Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
If You’re a ‘Little Guy,’ a Contract Means Nothing
Wth due deference to George Orwell, all contracts are equal. But some contracts are more equal than others.
Contracts entered into by the hotshots at American International Group for $165 million in bonuses, signed just months before their web of financial cunning unraveled, are inviolate. Contracts entered into by shop-floor workers at auto plants must be renegotiated, so that the taxpayers who bail out the industry don't coddle supposedly overpaid union members.
Contracts that secured "retention" bonuses for the same wizards who engineered the flimsy financial products that helped bring down the world economy went to 73 individuals who received $1 million or more-with the top honcho getting $6.4 million. Contracts that secured retiree health benefits for autoworkers with creation of a special trust are being rewritten so that carmakers can use their own cut-rate stocks, not cash, to help fund their obligation to elderly people who once worked on assembly lines.
Contracts that were crafted at AIG early in 2008-a few months before taxpayers sent their first installment of bailout money to the insatiable insurance giant-must stand. The deals guaranteed that some bonus recipients would lock in as much money as they had received in 2007, before the company's downward spiral.
Contracts agreed to by the United Auto Workers in 2007 trimmed wages and created the controversial trust for retiree health benefits that allowed the automakers to effectively remove some costs of the promised benefits from their own balance sheets. That contract does not stand.
As just renegotiated by Ford-which didn't take federal bailout money-and the UAW, workers gave up cost-of-living adjustments, two years of "bonuses" they'd been promised instead of wage hikes, vacation days, break time and other benefits. Rules are to be changed so that workers can stay on the job more than eight hours in variable shifts, without being paid overtime.
UAW President Ron Gettelfinger told Congress in December that workers and retirees both were ready "to make further sacrifices" to ensure the industry's viability in the wake of the credit crisis-a crisis caused in part by AIG's exotic financial instruments. "We are willing to do our part," Gettelfinger told the Senate Banking Committee.
AIG chief Edward Liddy told a House subcommittee Wednesday that though he runs a company now 80 percent owned by the taxpayers, it still must operate as a business that takes account of the "cold realities" of competition for customers, revenue and, yes, employees. Because of this and "certain legal obligations," the big bonus payouts went into the pockets of some of the people who messed up the credit markets so badly that average Americans now have trouble getting car loans and auto dealers struggle to keep operating.
AIG has thus far received $170 billion in taxpayer money. General Motors, the car company considered to be in the deepest trouble, got $13.4 billion. GM is currently in negotiations with the UAW that are likely to result in more concessions from the union.
Larry Summers, the chief White House economic adviser, said on Sunday that AIG's bonuses had to go through because "there are contracts. The government cannot just abrogate contracts." Summers made the comments to ABC News three days after President Barack Obama learned of the bonus payments but uttered not a word publicly about them.
Now the White House and Congress are ablaze with indignation and vow to try to recoup every penny.
New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo, quicker and more sure-footed than the lethargic Obama administration, got an accounting of how the millions were doled out. It shows, among other things, that 11 of those who received "retention" bonuses of $1 million or more-including an employee who pocketed $4.6 million-no longer work at the firm. The top seven bonus recipients received more than $4 million each.
The top-tier wage for production workers at UAW plants is about $28 an hour. New hires are paid $14 an hour.
Cuomo conveyed the preliminary results of his AIG probe in a letter to Barney Frank, chairman of the House Financial Services Committee. "Something is deeply wrong with this outcome," Cuomo wrote.
Something, indeed.

12 Comments so far
Show AllSometimes I think I am reading the script to "History of the World" as directed by Mel Brooks.
The double standards, the favoritism shown to the rich and powerful so overt it is mind boggling and Congress and the Politicians only react when public opinion says they must.
Again as I and others pointed out, this clearly a smokescreen. While paying the bonuses of 165 million wrong at every level, all it does is detract public opinion from the TRILLIONS of taxpayer dollars being shifted to the Financial Industry and the wealthy.
This 165 million might be "paid back" and public outrage soothed, but those other trillions of dollars will NOT be coming back.
it will be another "Mission Accomplished".
Imagine what all this money could have done for the People. New and decent schools. New & improved train/rail systems. Infrastructure fixes for our national parks. Instead, it goes to keep the powerful in power after their massive failures. God, the money they have stolen (and continue to print for themselves. Its incredible. Its unbelievable.
We have nothing and no way to stop them. A complicit president and congress, and a media that is only concerned about drawing eyes and selling ads.
What to do. What to do.
A political solution is looking less and less likely. Individuals will have to decide what steps they are willing to take in the absence of one.
SO WHAT? A million here or there is gum money... a crummy condo, a warhol silkscreen..
WE ARE TALKING THOUSANDS OF BILLIONS! Where did the TRILLIONS go??
This million dollar rip off is SMALL POTATOES.. who is the big dude?? Follow the money.
WE ALL KNOW WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THIS SITUATION.
WE ARE.
Speaking of contracts and little guys, take a look at the current job market. More young people are working in temporary contracts than they are in full time positions. And even then not all contracts are kept. There are no benefits and nothing's secure. How are they supposed to even live paycheck to paycheck or even get married and spend quality time together? Maybe I'm getting too old and sometimes sick but I'm afraid that our young will be living on "fixed" contracts and living broken family lives at this rate. May God have mercy on their souls.
Excellent points JWVerez. Sadly, even the supposedly progressive and liberal blogosphere have only kept up with the corporate fall that they've actually forgotten the little guy. With all the mainly negative rant going on here, I've for the most part given up posting. Ironically, CD puts me through that retarded turing machine since its rather buggy "spam filter" misidentifies my honest and thoughtful posts as "spam". If anyone wants to laugh or viciously attack me for it, go right ahead. I'm not responding to your negativity.
Nebraska Nathan1 finds that "Ironically, CD puts me through that retarded turing machine since its rather buggy 'spam filter' misidentifies my honest and thoughtful posts as 'spam'."
I've noticed that I'm hit with the spam filter only when I try to embed an HTML link in my post.
Also, is it just me or has the "Comment Viewing Options" feature broken down? I can no longer re-set the order and number of comments. I e-mailed the website about his, with no perceptible effect.
What's going on here?
"current job market"?! Listen up son, it's been that way for us lower classers since the 1980's! I can't remember the last job in two decades where I had a contract let alone things like sick pay, health insurance, less than a 60 hour work week, mostly on a volunteer basis.
Countrywide already took my piece of shit overpriced condo (I wanted a house but didn't have a million dollars for one), I still got no job, no disability even though I walk with a cane at age 42 and my landlord wants to raise my rent.
Yay, America.
Sir, I'm already aware of that. In fact, after barely surviving after losing my limbs in Vietnam, I was still struggling through most of the 1980s just to get anywhere at employment. I'm in my 60s but I feel very sad for you to be walking in a cane at such a young age of 42.
There is a lot of scribbling lately decrying the AIG compensations. These pieces are worse than useless because they distract people into bickering about pseudo plans, which in reality are nothing but chaotic bungling, bungling which would be quite amusing were it not dragging us down the road to financial ruin. And with this financial ruin will come the political ruin and destruction of our society. NO JOKE, FOLKS!
AIG and all the other institutions which are unable to meet their financial obligations must be put through bankruptcy reorganization, along with the federal government and the governments of states like California. Basically, we have to (1) identify and protect the useful functions provided by these institutions and (2) help them meet their valid obligations to creditors in the degree compatible with (1). Any approach to the current financial crisis which does not include this process is destructive. Public officials who waffle on this do so because they fear a real exposure of our financial situation and of the people who created the mess. Both groups -- the public officials and their financier owners -- are the mortal enemies of the American people.
While I agree with your latter points, there was no 'bungling" as you pointed out. This was a calculated attack on the financial stability of this country by the ruling class. It has only one purpose, to bankrupt the coutry while emptying the treasury into the pockets of the connected.
Summers and Geithner have a lot to answer for. IN fact they ought to be fired immediately without pay. Why not? They make the lowers endure that kind of craptasm all the time. Blowback's a bitch.
Meanwhile, for such a smart guy, Mr. Obama ain't winning no spellin' bees backing his piss-poor whiz kid picks. If he was really smart he'd cut those bullies loose tomorrow.
I'm kind of enjoying this exposing the rich kidz stuff.... it's finally getting out there in the public discourse. Hell, even a month ago people still called me crazy for saying things like I've said about the owning class. I feel vindicated.
Now if I could just get a job and get paid.... I owe the city and an HOA and student loans because the rich kidz don't let poor people discharge those in bankruptcy. See when a lower gets ripped off or screws something up, they come after us with bats and guns and lawyers and take everything away from us. But when a rich boy does it... we bail 'em out.
Somethin' don't smell right and it' aint' Denmark....