EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Body Bags Reveal Fate of Soldiers Who Refused to Fire on Their Own People
A brutal picture of the start of Libya's uprising is beginning to emerge.
The bodies were in dark green shrouds lying on the concrete floor of the morgue, 10 prisoners shot and then set on fire as the security forces of Colonel Muammar Gaddafi unleashed a last round of vengeful violence before being forced to flee.
Bags apparently containing the bodies of soldiers killed by Gaddafi loyalists after defecting (Osama Mohammed) The dead men are said to have been soldiers who had refused to open fire on those marching against the regime. They had been disarmed and beaten up by their comrades before being incarcerated in an underground cell in al-Katiba, the main military encampment in Benghazi.
The account of the last days of the inmates came from a Libyan army officer who subsequently surrendered to the rebels and changed sides. He was able to provide names of some of those killed, all local men, but bereaved relations had not been able to identify the charred remains.
Mohammed el-Targi, in charge of processing fatalities at al-Jala hospital, said: "Normally there are some parts of bodies in cases of burnings which shows who the person was, but there was very little left in these cases. We had wives, parents, children of these poor men come here and they were all crying. One mother said that although she could not identify her own boy, all of those killed are her sons now."
Yesterday, after days of cold rain and stormy winds, Libya's second city woke up to bright sunshine and warmth. Shops and businesses opened after the impromptu holiday which accompanied the revolution as people began to go about their daily lives once more.
Despite this return to a sort of normality, dark secrets of the brutalities at the time of the uprising have started to emerge. The burnt bodies at the morgue were a pitiful sight. "They were shaheeds [martyrs]. They sacrificed themselves rather than harm their own people," said Fateh Elami, the duty manager at the hospital. "We should put up a memorial to them."
But the violence has not been one-way. There were also the bodies of three "mercenaries" from sub-Saharan Africa used by the regime against the demonstrators. Their bodies, with deep wounds to the head and torso, lay beside that of a Libyan soldier. These, too, said Mr Elami, will remain unclaimed.
The al-Jala was the busiest hospital during the first few days of intense strife in Libya's second city, and many of the wounded from those days are at the wards. Najla Farkash is one of the medical staff who worked almost around the clock in this period. One day, she was treating a long line of injured people when the next patient wheeled into her path prompted a gasp. It was her 27-year-old brother Amraja. He had been shot in the head.
"I had cried a little when some young boys were brought in for treatment badly hurt," Ms Farkash, a 29-year-old clinical assistant, said, shaking her head. "But when it is someone from your own family, it is very, very hard."
Amraja Farkash had been on his way to the funeral of two of his cousins, killed by the security forces in the first days of the protests the week before last, when he was shot. He is now paralysed down the left-hand side of the body and his working life as a driver is over.
"I supported the revolution but I was not even taking part in any marches when they shot me, I was going to bury my cousins. Why should they do this?" he asked. "I do not know who shot me, it may have been a mercenary, it may have been a Libyan. But I know it was my own government that did this. If I could go and fight now, I would. I feel very angry."
Fawzia Radiki, in an adjoining ward, wanted to show what had been done to her husband, Ibrahim, after he was seized by the police while taking part in a rally outside the Khadija. He had his arm and several ribs broken during a beating with metal-tipped staves and was shot in the back as he ran away. As he lay on the ground a policeman kicked him repeatedly in the face, breaking his jaw.
"What is the outside world doing about all this?" Mrs Radiki demanded. "They go on about rights, but they are allowing Gaddafi to do all this to people who cannot defend themselves."
Meanwhile, Mohammed Saad, sitting on the edge of his bed, recalled a time when he had a plush army job at al-Katiba, a time when he scarcely imagined he would be ordered to turn on his own family. Yesterday, Mr Saad, 23, winced as he removed his cardigan to expose the gunshot wound that nearly killed him. He was shot after refusing to fire his gun when protesters overran the military compound, the culmination of a defining battle in the fall of Benghazi to anti-regime forces. "The last thing I remember is an officer putting his gun to my chest, and shouting: 'Go and shoot! Go and shoot!'" Mr Saad recalled, describing how hours later he woke up in a Benghazi hospital.
Soldiers retreated to al-Katiba after the protests that broke out on 15 February turned violent when loyalist troops fired on the demonstrators, killing dozens. Heavily outgunned residents then staged a three-day battle for control of the barracks, the turning point coming when one protester packed his car with explosives and rammed it into the walls of the base.
The fall of the military base was a crucial victory for the revolutionary forces, sweeping away Libyan leader Colonel Gaddafi's control in the east of the country, and bringing his 42-year rule to the brink of collapse. "You know what al-Katiba meant?" said Mohammed Hussein, a doctor. "It was a terrifying seat of power. It was a signal to everyone who drives by to say, 'Here we are'."
Mr Saad was one of a privileged few to obtain a posting at al-Katiba, which meant instant privileges and better wages. But he never thought his loyalty would be tested. When fighting first broke out between protesters and government forces, he and his colleagues were put on standby, ordered to shoot anyone who attempted to enter. It was only when his father finally reached him that he understood that the protesters were ordinary people from the city.
"My father called me to come home, and then said, 'Even if you [think you are going to] die, don't shoot.' He told me: 'I am one of the protesters,'" Mr Saad said. "I felt frozen. I had this image that if I fired, I would shoot my father."
Mr Saad was not the only one to feel conflicted. He claims that several of his older army colleagues were ordered to change into plain clothes and drive out in unmarked cars and shoot anybody they saw. About 20 of them refused, and were executed, he claimed.
More than a week since the fighting stopped, hundreds still flock to al-Katiba to glimpse the remnants of the regime. Few Libyans have ever seen inside the dreaded compound, yet now they wander freely through the burnt-out and ransacked buildings. In the dungeon where the soldiers were killed and burned, a large concrete box with thin shafts of daylight coming from half a dozen narrow windows now draws a steady stream of visitors. Mariam Fatrusi, who had arrived with her sister to have a look, had decided, however, that it was a mistake to have come. "It is an evil place, I can feel very bad things were done here," she said. "They should seal it up."
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

24 Comments so far
Show AllThis may very well be a true account. However, I am immediately reminded of the story about Kuwaiti babies who were pulled from their incubators by marauding Iraqi forces, which turned out to be a complete hoax. That story was used to incite hatred two decades ago in the lead up to an invasion. I am so skeptical about what is going on and/or reported in Libya. The white gloved approach taken by the international community toward a despot like Mubarak, with a long history of torturing his people, is obviously out the window when dealing with Gadhafi. Why is this? How is it that the uprising in Libya is well armed? This is not an uprising of thousands of labour organizers or educated people in the streets. This looks more to me like some sort of CIA operation.
Either way this plays out, it is the fruit of a foreign policy which valued "stability" over human rights. Your skepticism is well deserved, as history shows the long trail of covert meddling in internal politics of other nations, be it elections (Yeltsin in Russia, Nicaragua, etc.) ) , in opposition uprisings be it Eastern Europe or Latin America, or the support of repressive governments all over the globe. With the I believe genuine uprisings in Tunisia and Egypt, the shocking events (as in Shock Doctrine) can open the door to exploit this situation with purposeful interference from outside. I want to believe a democratic autonomy can evolve in these nations, but I am also fearful for their future.
Why not simply fear for your own, Joe? I'm so enjoying this thread; aren't we an interesting little group!
Love, Liz
Regardless of who these men are, what country they are from, they are a Mother's child. May God/Allah have mercy on them all.
I would expect such articles to be published in the Washington Post, New York Times or some other horrible conservative rag...not Common Dream. Shame on you for publishing this crap. It reminds me of all the articles about the weapons of mass destruction hidden in Iraq...pure govermental propoganda.
I agree with you 100%.
This sounds like the story of Saddam Hussein gassing his own people, etc., typical US propaganda to justify yet another illegal invasion for oil.
Gaddafi has been a Washington puppet all along and the only reason he's all of a sudden a villain again is that he's lost control of population. Time for Washington to replace the dictator.
More American and British hypocrisy and opportunism.
Gadhafi was/is not a US puppet; he was part of the revolutionary 60s.
Wake up, that was some 50 years ago, the Gaddafi of today has nothing to do with the Gaddafi of the revolutionary 60s. Here, learn something, from a WSWS article:
"The United States made a major political and financial investment in the cultivation of friendly relations with Gaddafi, regarding his sudden rapprochement with Washington and US foreign policy after 2003 as a major strategic gain. Hillary Clinton recently feted one of Gaddafi’s sons in Washington and appointed the founding chairman of the US-Libya Business Association to be the State Department’s coordinator for international energy affairs.
Gaddafi’s son visited the United States in 2009. Secretary of State Clinton ensured he was made suitably welcome.
If these powers are now lining up to return to Libya as the supposed patrons of the opposition forces that have seized control of much of the country, they are being driven by the very same appetites for profit and plunder."
Same old story. In Panama when going after Noriega. Footage was shown of his ransacked residence showing pornographic materials, sex toys etc. This was all over the US State Department News Agencies(USSDNA) aka news for days ala NYT, Tom Brokaw(NBC), Bernard Shaw(CNN), Peter Jennings(ABC)and CBS until someone noticed the same footage had been shown several years before when the game was against Allende in Chile. A whole book of examples can be written on this sort of practice.
After the Iraq invasion the sleeping world discovered that Saddam Hussein's foreign minister Naji Sabri was a CIA spy. I wonder the same when I hear the Libyan foreign minister do his song and dance on CNN. If Libya's resources has to be western managed, it is wise to start by exploiting the historic tensions between the Arabs and Magrebs(berbers) in Libya. If the west wants to start helping Arabs the can start in Gaza, the biggest open space prison in the world. Or in the Congo.............
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/middleeast/iraq/1513685/CIA-recruited-Saddams-foreign-minister-to-spy-on-Iraqi-regime.html)
Yes you can fool all the people all the time. The tail end of the "bell curve" is considered statistically insignificant. Noise.
The extermination of the Native Americans, Colonization, Slavery etc took hold by the west among other things exploiting and fomenting dissent among native people to introduce and make permanent their hold on foreign resources. As long as the seemingly natural human conditions of internecine tensions exist. The devil will always find work.
Meanwhile nothing has changed in Egypt or Tunisia. Last time I checked Lieberman and McCain where in Egypt last week laying ground work. Superficial change, fundamental sameness. The people marched to the wrong palace, the match should have been to the embassies were the rules are formulated in secret. Now we all must be entertained with what Mubarak did or what money he stole.
It is of interest to even see so called progressive like DemocracyNow and others on CD covering or commenting the Libyan situation with little context. If Amy is presumably not that ignorant? Why the pretense of ignorance? All she needs to do is look at east Timor , which she talks about a lot, for parallels.
No, comrade. You will not be entertained at all.
Elisabet,
Are you trying to be funny or what? You are, definitely , not funny!
No, I'm definitely not trying to be funny. I was being picky. Sorry about that.
I wonder if Gaddafi has hired Blackwater yet.
They will kill anyone for enough money. It's what we do!!!
I've seen body bags before. The bags above have no bodies in them, even "charred" ones. Skeletons don't disintegrate that easily. Those could only be bodies if they were totally dismembered, and the parts divided between bags.
May you all rest in peace!
Brings to mind King Mongkut's song, "A Puzzlement," in "The King and I"
http://www.stlyrics.com/lyrics/thekingandi/apuzzlement.htm
"Shall I join with other nations in alliance?
If allies are weak, am I not best alone?
If allies are strong with power to protect me,
Might they not protect me out of all I own?
Is a danger to be trusting one another,
One will seldom want to do what other wishes;
But unless someday somebody trust somebody
There'll be nothing left on earth excepting fishes!"
That seems to be the way we're headed, doesn't it.
“God grant, that not only the Love of Liberty,
but a thorough Knowledge of the Rights of Man,
may pervade all the Nations of the Earth,
so that a Philosopher may set his Foot
anywhere on its Surface, and say,
‘This is my Country.’”
Benjamin Franklin
4 December, 1789
There was a time in this country when the majority could think objectively and critically. Unfortunately, the polarity has switched. The poor little sobbing wretch telling the Renfield Class in D.C. about the babies? Turns out she was the daughter of the Kuwait ambassador. Also, the reason Iraq invaded was Kuwait had been caught stealing oil from Iraq and refused to stop, (must have taken classes on thet from the U.S. of Israel). Getting back on topic, don't make the mistake of assuming, (if or when it comes down to it), "our boys" won't mow fellow citizens down. They've done it many times before, with great relish actually. Ludlow massacre they burned women and children alive in their tents for the marrano Rockefeller....did it several times in Virginia....seems the miners wanted fair pay, fewer hours, (we work 40 plus a week here....32 hours a week is the norm in Western Europe and BASE vacation time of 5 weeks a year), oh they also took offense in being paid in "company scrip". that way, the poor corporation got it back by forcing the men to buy from company stores at company PRICES....slick huh? Well, they've been whittling away at the labor laws folks before us DIED for...and I guess they feel they've immasculated the public enough to finally just DO it w/o any fear of repercussions.
NUKE EM!!!!!
Murdered by US protected mercenaries using US supplied weapons?
Really, in all the images from Libya, did you see any US manufactured weapons? I only saw AK-47 rifles, T-55, T-72 tanks and French built jets.
At some point people will have to decide which side they think the US supports in Libya. It's kinda funny to read some posts and articles, and see the squirming of some "progressive" authors. It's kinda hard for them to face the fact that the beloved socialist revolutionary Gadhafi does not wanna give up his reign over Libya, preferring instead to kill his own people. Last couple of week have been pretty entertaining.
I wish there was an Internet in 1989 to have read the comments about the fall of the Berlin wall and the liberation of Eastern Europe from the communist oppression.
It's clear what Libyans want, that the US STAYS THE FUCK OUT.
They have enough to deal with right now, a US puppet dictator and his goons, without also having to worry about American drones, F16s and nuclear carriers.
The US only interest in the region is the Libyan oil, nothing else. Stay the fuck out.
There is a lot of oil in Libya and the CIA always goes where the oil is. They are laying the groundwork for a democratization invasion, that way Obama can rack up another war.