Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
US State's 'Personhood' Law Would Hit Birth Control: Opponents
WASHINGTON - Pro-choice groups have warned that a law passed by legislators in the US state of North Dakota recognizing the "personhood" of a fetus would not only outlaw abortion but could also bar access to birth control.
Lawmakers in the North Dakota lower house voted 51 to 41 on Tuesday to pass the Personhood of Children Act, which confers the same basic rights on "all human beings from the beginning of their biological development, including the pre-born, partially born."
Pro-choice activist Lisa King holds a sign in front of the US Supreme Court on January 22, 2009 in Washington, DC. (AFP/Getty Images/File/Alex Wong) The bill is expected to go before the state senate in around two weeks.
If passed, it would be used to challenge the Supreme Court's 1973 Roe versus Wade decision that legalized abortion in the United States and gave the country some of the least restrictive abortion laws in the world, experts said.
Roe v Wade states that women in all 50 states have the absolute right to terminate a pregnancy during the first three months and a qualified right to do so up to six months.
By challenging Roe v Wade, pro-life activists aim to return the decision-making process on whether or not abortion is legal to the states, Brian Rooney of the Thomas More Law Center told AFP.
"The purpose of these laws is to challenge Roe v Wade. Once Roe v Wade is overturned, it doesn't mean abortion is illegal in all 50 states but it says that the states decide what to do with abortion," Rooney said.
In pressing for personhood laws to be passed by the states, pro-life advocates cite Supreme Court Justice Harry Blackmun, who drafted the Roe v Wade ruling, a morally and politically divisive issue in the United States since it was passed 36 years ago.
"Justice Blackmun said in the original Roe versus Wade decision that if personhood is ever established for the human being at the moment of his conception or creation, the Roe versus Wade decision would fall," Judie Brown, president of the pro-life American Life League said.
Republican state Representative Dan Ruby, who sponsored the North Dakota personhood act, said during the debate on the bill that its language was "what's required by Roe v Wade."
The 1973 Supreme Court decision "stipulated that before a challenge can be made, we have to identify when life begins, and that's what this does," he said.
But Tim Stanley, head of communications at the Planned Parenthood Federation of America branch representing North and South Dakota warned that the bill reached beyond a ban on abortion.
"The bill is written so broadly that it could easily impact other major life decisions in reproductive health care, including birth control and emergency contraception," said Stanley.
"It goes well beyond an abortion ban and well beyond what mainstream Americans and North Dakotans want," he told AFP.
Vicki Saporta, president of the National Abortion Federation, said: "While it is a direct challenge to Roe v Wade, we expect that the bill would not only ban abortion but could reach common forms of birth control as well."
Both pro-choice groups vowed to fight the bill, insisting it did not reflect the wishes of the US public.
"It's not a done-deal. We're hopeful we'll be able to make our case and stop this bill cold," Stanley said.
Saporta predicted the bill would be challenged in the courts if passed by the North Dakota senate and signed by the state governor.
And she said there was scant evidence that North Dakotans back the bill.
"There is no reason to believe that the population in North Dakota supports this legislation. If you look at South Dakota, where they tried twice to ban abortion in referenda, the voters of that state said 'no,'" Saporta said.
South Dakotans most recently rejected a proposed ban on abortion last year, the same year that voters in the state of Colorado roundly rejected a personhood law by three to one.
Surveys have shown that more Americans back a woman's right to choose whether or not to have an abortion than are pro-life, or against abortion.
But Brown, of the American Life League, hailed North Dakota for becoming the first state legislature to "act in a positive way" on a personhood law.
"As of today there are 19 states that have laws proposed, but no other state has got this far," she said.
- Posted in



11 Comments so far
Show AllThe definition of life, and the instant at which it begins, has eluded our best minds for thousands of years---and now a bunch of fundagelical pinheads in the North Dakota legislature have settled it?
Superstition as a basis for lawmaking is SO over. Didn't they get the memo?
Not another chorus of 'every sperm is sacred', please...
What's next for the anti-choice crowd if this sort of thing passes? Repealing the laws against rape? Hey, that rapist needs to spread his seed, and if he doesn't he's breaking the law about respecting a potential person...
They need these "Persons" to grow into adults so that they can go to Iraq and Pakistan and Iran to kill all the non persons there.
The first step in making women nothing more than baby factories again, and god help her if anything bad happens to that fertilized egg or fetus while it's in her body. Remember when they were demanding the records from doctors and clinics for every woman who'd had a miscarriage a few years back? Imagine how it'll be if these crazies have their way and actually get this law passed - a woman miscarries, or has an accident and loses the baby, etc., - she goes on trial for murder.
I think it's about time - before it's too late - for everyone with any sense left to start demanding proof.
If they make such an unproven assumption and are successful at creating a law based on that assumption, on something of this import, and end up controlling the lives of every living woman in the country by doing so, WHAT will their next assumption be??!
"Every sperm is sacred" - monty python's "the meaning of life"
Biblical law will demand the Semen Security Squads investigate every household's laundry -- sheets and handkerchiefs -- and all tissue wads for evidence of mass murder; that is, masturbation resulting in the loss of millions of potential fetuses.
"no gods, no masters" --m. sanger
Can we send the Semen Security Squads to investigate the Catholics, evangelicals, and fundamentalists first? That will keep them busy forever!
Ray Berthiaume
According to Catholic moral theology the fetus, while human, is not a PERSON until it is viable, i.e. can live outside the womb! Fools rush in where angels fear to tread.
Ray, this is not at all what i was told by a roman catholic, 'leftist' priest and theology professor last year. Living outside the womb is the jewish moral theology on the subject. That it can sustain as a separate entity.
Catholic theology says that even a zygote is a life that cannot be destroyed. In fact, a man cannot masturbate because that is a sin.
But actually, perhaps you are being very subtle and i am not understanding your comment.
People need to start pushing the idea that every fertilized egg created by in vitro fertilization would be considered a person under laws like this. Every facility that did not implant them all and left them frozen until they 'died' would be guilty of murder, and so would the parents. That would pit the anti-choice crowd against every couple that desperately wants a child, and would go far to stop this madness in its tracks.
Great comments, all!! The pope admonished nancy pelosi yesterday at the vatican. He said catholic politicians and legislators must tow the line on issues about women's bodies. So, they should be loyal to the church as opposed to their constituency....
It's the old pope versus king conundrum....
Dafoe
These holier than thou pro life/anti abortionists are adhering to the "thou shalt not kill" commandment when it comes to what a women has growing in her womb, once the babe is delivered its fair game for being killed by every means known, sent out to kill innocents for others and these same holy ones are not only silent about the commandment but are cheering the killers on, once born that commandment has more qualifications than carter has pills. How pathetic and downright evil. North Dakota has gone round the bend. Possibly one could divert the wall from the mexican border and put it around ND!