Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Cakewalk? Libya's Future Far from Guaranteed
WASHINGTON -- Muammar Gaddafi seems all but done for as rebel forces snatch the capital from under his nose. The scenes in Tripoli are redolent of the April 2003 morning when a US-led invasion force entered Baghdad - the invasion was to be a ''cakewalk'' and the troops would be coming home in a matter of months.
People celebrate Sunday's news of uprising in Tripoli against Gaddafi's regime. The Libyan intervention has been different - and harder. While Baghdad fell in a few weeks, it took months of aerial bombardment by NATO air forces to clear the way for Libya's rebels - but the rebels entered Tripoli on their own, rather than on the heels of a foreign invasion force.
Because of Iraq and Afghanistan, Washington and the rest of the allied capitals, including Canberra, have been reluctant to be seen to be planning to ''manage'' the new Libya. On Sunday a senior American military officer shared his concerns with The New York Times: "There [is] no clear plan for a political succession or for maintaining security in the country. The [African and Arab] leaders I have talked to do not have a clear understanding how this will play out."
The rebel National Transitional Council, recognized by 32 countries, has undertaken to reissue their greenhorn fighters with a booklet on the finer points of human rights and laws of war.
The Americans disposed of the security forces in Iraq, but the transitional council says it plans to retain parts of the Libyan security machine. However, the rebels will want to run the show.
And even the transitional council remains an unknown quantity.
The murder of its military commander, Abdel Fatah Younis, remains unexplained, as does the dissolution this month of the rebel cabinet - and the failure to appoint a new one.
In a part of the world in which power brokers have mastered the art of telling the West what it wants to hear while getting on with their local agendas, it remains to be seen if signs of what has been read as evidence of common sense, democratic instinct, idealism and decency are to be deployed on behalf of all Libyans - or competing tribal blocks relishing a first opportunity in decades to test their relative strength.
Rebel forces in the western city of Misrata, Libya's third-biggest, have gone out of their way to register their contempt for the transitional council with foreign reporters, insisting that they refuse to take instructions from Benghazi.
And it is the rebels in the west of the country - from Misrata through to the Nafusa Mountains - who made the tactical gains that forced Gaddafi to his knees. If the rebel officers and politicians from the country's west get to Tripoli before the Benghazi caravan, the international community could find itself dealing with a very different transitional leadership. Shashank Joshi, of the Royal United Services Institute in London, wrote at the weekend: "It is naive to imagine that long-simmering tribal grievances … will not prove incredibly divisive. The Warfalla, Tarhuna, Magarha and Warshafana tribes have all made enemies, but their real or imagined mistreatment by the transitional council during a post-conflict period would be highly destabilizing."
And what do the rebels inherit after 40-plus years of Gaddafi's iron fist? A shell of a country bereft of credible institutions and any sense of a civil society. And the transition plans devised by the council to quiet international anxiety? "Hogwash," says a foreign diplomat now in Libya.
NATO said last night it was ready to help build the new Libya - "a state based on freedom, not fear; democracy, not dictatorship; the will of the many, not the whims of the few."
That's all well and good, but we have yet to see what the Libyans want - or what their new leaders will allow them to have.



46 Comments so far
Show AllCan anyone believe what the corrupt government of the United States says---you know, the "official story". You all know the old story on how to tell if a politician is lying, don't you? His lips are moving. Check out what Obumer says. Are his lips moving?
Under Gadhafi the oil belongs to the people of the nation and funds were used for education, health care, homes for the people and a massive water project to turn the dry land green. Libya has the highest standard of living of any nation in Africa. You wait and see what will happen if the people who can't drive out the foreign invaders. Take a look at Afghanistan and Iraq for the future of Libya. And that is our future too. The bastards that rule this nation don't care about you or your family. You are not in the club. You don't count.
If you heard the 'news' on TV you must face the fact that you are being lied to and washed over with high priced propaganda. Remember, if a politician's lips are moving, he/she is lying.
Oh, and BTW, we have just assured the creation of hundreds more freedom figh... I mean 'terrists(tm)' for the US to continue it's obscene levels of Murder Machine, I mean 'Defence Department' spending...
But certainly not bereft of oil and a huge underground aquifer, both ripe for the picking by multinational corporations. And don't expect credible institutions and a sense of a civil society any time soon, as those things tend to get in the way of resource exploitation (plunder) and financial aid (loan sharking) by banks and corporations.
very nice turn of phrase.
right up there with drinking the "kool-ade"
even better.
This is premature triumphalism - another wishful, needlessly self-contratulatory, "mission accomplished" moment, what with the arch evil doer of the month (Muammar Gaddafi) "all but done for as rebel forces snatch the capital" indeed.
Is this situation really all that different? Assuming Gaddafi does fall from power, was NATO's military intervention in Libya actually harder than the US-led invasion and occupation of Iraq?
As I recall it, there was no actual Iraqi "rebel" force in the field when the shock & awe aerial campaign of 2003 was followed up by the ground troop blitzkrieg up the turnpike from Kuwait City to Baghdad. That iconic photo of the Saddam statute toppling amidst a jubilant crowd, complete with a momentary US flag snippet for the stateside evening news, turned out to be a staged photo op. For some reason, the footage on ABC and NBC last night from Tripoli gave me a sense of deja vu.
The moment of truth at any cakewalk takes place shortly after the music stops.
p>Bill from Saginaw
FASCISM!! F*CK YEAH!!!
my thoughts exactly.
Who needs leaders when all Libyans can lead?
Direct democracy