Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
- The Rise of the New Economy Movement
- Preying on Poverty: How Government and Corporations Use the Poor as Piggy Banks
- The Organic Watergate: Alarming Report Reveals USDA's Cozy Relationship with Corporate Agribusinesses in 'Organics'
- Updated: Under Pressure, TED Releases 'Income Inequality' Talk
- 'Biggest Act of Civil Disobedience in Canadian History'
Popular content
Today's Top News
Environmentalists Slam Bush 'Fox-in-Henhouse' Plan
WASHINGTON - A Bush administration plan to let U.S. agencies decide for themselves whether their actions put wildlife at risk is drawing fire from environmental groups, which say this is like letting a fox guard a henhouse.
This undated photo provided by the New Mexico Game and Fish Department shows a New Mexican meadow jumping mouse at a marsh near Espanola, N.M. The New Mexico meadow jumping mouse is among 13 species listed in petitions filed by WildEarth Guardians on Thursday, Oct. 9, 2008. The conservation group is seeking protections for the species under the Endangered Species Act.
(AP Photo/New Mexico Department of Game and Fish, Joan L. Morrison) The Interior Department, one of two federal agencies pushing for
this policy change, rejects the environmentalists' critique, saying the
new rule would cut bureaucratic red tape and free government scientists
for more important work.
But a coalition of conservation groups sees the move as an attempt to gut the Endangered Species Act.
"This is exactly the fox guarding the henhouse," Michael Daulton of the National Audubon Society said. "It's a scary proposition to think about agencies with no wildlife expertise at all making decisions about the fate of species, potentially leading to extinction."
The 35-year-old Endangered Species Act is meant to protect threatened wildlife by relying on the best available science, the environmentalists noted. Government scientists must now consult with agencies on projects that could put species at risk.
The rules change could take scientists out of the equation, the conservation coalition maintained.
Audubon, which aims to protect birds, was among more than 120 groups that joined to flood the Interior Department's Fish and Wildlife Service with 100,000 negative comments about the plan on Friday.
This flood of paper was timed to coincide with the end of an official "public comment" period on the proposed rule change, which ends on Tuesday. After that, it is unclear when or whether the rule will be adopted.
'HAIL MARY PASS'
"This proposed rule change is obviously a Hail Mary pass to industry friends in the final days of the Bush administration and it will fail," said Janette Brimmer, a lawyer with Earthjustice.
A Hail Mary pass is a desperate last-minute play in American football.
At the heart of the matter is the notion of dropping a requirement for U.S. agencies -- from the Transportation Department to the Army Corps of Engineers -- to consult with scientists before they take on projects that could threaten wildlife on the Endangered Species list.
As the Interior and Commerce departments wrote in their plan, released in mid-August with little fanfare: "We propose to add language that action agencies are not required to consult on those actions for which they determine their action will have 'no effect' on listed species or critical habitat."
These two agencies set a 30-day public comment period, which was extended for an additional 30 days. Conservation groups urged a 120-day period for comment from the public and Congress, and said comments should be allowed by fax and e-mail in addition to paper letters, the only form now accepted.
"The abbreviated timeline and restrictive commenting options raise serious concerns that the Department of the Interior is attempting to rewrite a bedrock environmental statute without allowing for anything approaching adequate public involvement," the environmental groups said in a letter to the Interior Department's Fish and Wildlife Service.
Chris Paolino, an Interior Department spokesman, said scientific consultation occurs in the planning phase of federal projects, and that these scientists do not simply "rubber stamp" government efforts.
The aim of the proposed rule change, Paolino said by telephone, "is to streamline the process a little bit, remove red tape where we can and remove the backlog of consultations that had developed over the last 30 years and allow for those projects where there's an accepted 'no negative impact' to an endangered species to move forward."
The Bush administration has been widely criticized for its record on endangered species. Since President George W. Bush took office in 2001, 58 species have been added to the list, compared with 522 during the eight years of the Clinton administration and 231 in the four-year presidency of George H.W. Bush, the current president's father.
Editing by Eric Walsh.

4 Comments so far
Show All"Fox guarding the henhouse" is an unfortunate expression since it demonizes foxes.
The expression originates from the fact that wild animals engage in predatory activity which comes as a surprise to humans who choose to have livestock agriculture.
A fox decimating chickens in a henhouse isnt the problem-foxes do what they always do-the problem comes from humans who put chickens in such an unnatural environment. Foxes have to be carnivorous-humans do not. We dont need eggs, if we did, vegans wouldnt exist. Paul McCartney would be a figment of our imaginations.
Same with weasals--another creature which is used in insults-along with wolves-because of their success in defying human desires.
very true..........but we vegans are in the minority........and what is that old phrase? majority rules. so there's no hope for the poor animals.
It seems every "fast track" or "enabling deregulation", and even projects with initial good intentions such as globalization, over the last 20 years have come around to bite us on the behind.
Make up a problem, blame it on someone, change the regulations or start a war, and companies well represented by lobbyists rake in the cash at the expense of whatever was in their way. Make it stop, Mr. Obama.
Get these government haters out of the government !!