Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Tristan Anderson to Sue for Injury in Israel Protest
An Oakland man who was seriously wounded by a tear gas projectile fired by Israeli police during a West Bank protest will file suit despite a military report concluding that he was engaged in an "act of war," his lawyers said Sunday.
Ex-Cal tree-sitter hurt in West Bank protest Tristan Anderson (San Francisco Chronicle photo) The case of Tristan Anderson, who remains hospitalized with brain damage and a fractured skull six months after he was injured, may test Israel's efforts to shield itself from lawsuits for harm it causes during wartime, said attorney Michael Sfard.
Anderson's lawyers said Israel's Ministry of Defense has told them the demonstrators threw stones and other objects at police, who acted in self-defense.
The Ministry of Defense, Sfard said in an e-mail message, "is trying to apply the (act of war) doctrine to every (case of) damage caused in the occupied Palestinian territories by Israeli forces."
Anderson, 38, was among a group of about 400 Palestinian and international demonstrators who gathered March 13 in the town of Naalin, near the wall Israel is building along its border to keep Palestinians out.
The wall cuts off parts of the West Bank, including a portion of Naalin, and is the site of frequent protests.
Anderson was struck in the head by a tear gas canister fired from about 65 yards away by a border police officer, according to some fellow demonstrators. He had brain surgery at Tel Hashomer hospital in Tel Aviv and is no longer in critical condition, but is blind in his right eye, friends say.
His parents, Nancy and Michael Anderson of Grass Valley (Nevada County), report that he has regained consciousness and they are optimistic about his recovery, said Lea Tsemel, an Israeli civil rights lawyer who represents the family.
However, she said she believes Tristan Anderson will be permanently disabled.
Before going to Israel, Anderson was one of the tree-sitters who until last September occupied a grove next to UC Berkeley's Memorial Stadium in an unsuccessful bid to stop the university from clearing the trees to make room for an athletic center.
This summer, Anderson's lawyers received a letter from Israel's Ministry of Defense saying its preliminary investigation had cleared government forces of wrongdoing.
"The border police force was attacked massively by about 400 demonstrators who threw blocks, stones and gas rockets," the letter said, according to Tsemel's translation. "The police sincerely feared that they would be hurt. ... In these circumstances, we are talking about an act of war. Accordingly, the state is not responsible for any damages."
Tsemel said numerous witnesses contradict the ministry's report.
"He was demonstrating. He didn't have any weapon. He was a peacenik. ... Nothing was endangering the soldiers," the attorney said in a telephone interview from her home in Israel.
While some demonstrators have thrown stones at soldiers, Tsemel said, there was no evidence of any violent activity by Anderson.
Sfard, who also represents Anderson, said the Ministry of Defense was trying to extend the "act of war" defense from armed conflicts to police responses against civilian demonstrators.
Tsemel said Anderson and his family would file suit shortly in either Jerusalem or Tel Aviv. In addition to compensation, she said, "we want the army to investigate the event and bring to trial the border police person who shot at him and those who gave him the orders."



11 Comments so far
Show AllYes it was 'an act of war'. One side was reduced to throwing stones at best and the other side has nuclear weapons, White Phosphorus, and all the normal tools of weaponry that the US helps supply them with. Israel is not a democracy at all. It is a society totally based on the notion of racial and cultural superiority supposedly belonging strictly to the state-certified Jewish inhabitants.
I hope you aren't suggesting that Mr.Anderson was 'throwing stones' because he wasn't. There is a video that clearly shows that he and others were peacefully milling around after a PEACEFUL demonstration when out of nowhere came that nearly lethal blow that will disable him for the rest of his life. Tristan's presence there was an act of PEACE and an appeal to humanity and decency, not a provocation for continued violence.
No, that is not what I meant at all.
I thought as much but wanted to be sure.... thanks for clarifying.
"Earlier in the day at least 5 Palestinians, including a 3-year old child, were injured by settlers, who rampaged through Tel Rumeida hurling stones and bottles at local residents. Palestinian schoolchildren on their way home were also attacked. The IDF, which was intensively deployed in the area, did not intervene to stop the settlers."
http://www.amnestyusa.org/individuals-at-risk/holiday-card-action/tove-johannsson/page.do?id=1011298
The folks who bashed in the 19 year old Human Rights worker's face with impunity for defending Palestinian schoolchildren were chanting: "We killed Jesus, we'll kill you too!".
Israel is turning into a nation of abusive bullies. At some point they will be held accountable.
"is turning" Surely you jest! Israel has been a rogue nation for decades. Its brutality which matches and even surpasses that of the U.S. is now displayed everywhere, thanks to the current level of information and its dispersal outside the corporate media.
"the current level of information? Surely, you meant to say "disinformation" or "misinformation" - correct?
Much respect to Tristan for his bravery and service in resistance to fascism, militarism and apartheid.
And all my condolences to his friends and family.
Tristan, you are a hero to many of us, in your defense of the the most vulnerable and oppressed people in Palestine.
We all prey for your recovery.
Whenever I start feeling sorry for myself over the fact that I am a natural born American citizen hopelessly caught up in the rapacious capitalist juggernaut that has become the BANE of Planet Earth, I pause and realize that... that there but for fortune, I could have suffered the horrific and disgusting fate of being born a Sociopathic Psychotic Israeli Jew!
And all that will come out of the lawsuit is that some obscure agency somewhere will timidly ask Israel to investigate itself after which Israel will declare to have been acting in self-defense and proclaim to have the "most moral army" in the world amid screams of holocaust and anti-semitism. Nothing will change! Oh, yeah, and forever after, Tristan Anderson's family will have to live their lives looking over their shoulders, after all, let's not forget that this is the United States of Israel.