Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
You Say You Want a Revolution?
Detroit, the once-proud capital of industrialization is now the paragon of de-industrialization and urban decay.
General Motors' July 15 announcement that it will cut white-collar employment costs by 20 percent is just one more nail in the industrial coffin.
Actually, this job-cutting phenomenon isn't new. It's been going on since the 1960s when the car companies began automating blue-collar assembly line jobs. Since the 1980s they have been steadily chipping away at the white-collar jobs by offering middle managers early retirement buy-outs.
This is the next American revolution, said Dr. Grace Lee Boggs, 93, a long-time Detroit activist and a Bryn Mawr-educated philosopher.
"We are at a stage in human history that is as monumental as changing from a hunter/gatherer society to an agricultural society and from an agricultural society to and industrial society. Where we're headed now will be different because we have exhausted planetary space and human space for us to continue to look at things through the Cartesian measurement of material things."
In other words, a new epoch is emerging that emphasizes relationships and communities more than the accumulation of things -- and the counting of profits.
A trip to Greenfield Village and the Henry Ford Museum in Dearborn, a mere 30 minutes from downtown Detroit, illustrates how the nineteenth century Industrial Revolution grew into the twentieth century consumerist society, which was plush with inventions and conveniences that raised the living standards of middle class Americans. People could afford these products because so many of them left their farms and took higher-paying factory jobs in the cities. However, those good wages came at a price: people became mindless cogs in a giant machine, as Charlie Chaplin depicted in the film, "Modern Times."
Industrialization was a far cry from the first American Revolution of 1776, which was about people giving of themselves for the larger community, said Grace. That sentiment yielded to a European colonial mentality that justified taking natural resources from Africa, Asia and Latin America in order to manufacture products and sell them at huge profits.
"We need to face the way we used the world for our gains, pleasures, satisfactions," said Grace. "This is the way we evolve to a higher stage of humanity. And unless we want to live in terror for the rest of our lives, we need to change our view about acquiring things."
The industrial society also skirted social justice concerns by focusing on jobs and paychecks as a means of keeping the economy going and the people happy. It didn't face the fact that the workers were demeaned and deskilled or that some of the products they made (like military equipment) or some of the processes they used (which involved dangerous chemicals) could be harmful.
Actually, people have only had "jobs" for the past 100 years. These jobs had nothing to do with being productive, making products essential for living or deriving personal growth or the enjoyment of life. Jobs led people to believe that anything they did for pay was good -- no matter how destructive it was to the person, the community or the environment.
Now, in the twenty-first century after hundreds of thousands of jobs have been moved offshore and collapsed many local economies, Grace believes that the way has been cleared for the next American revolution, especially since a number of other factors make the need for change both obvious and necessary:
- Occupation of Iraq;
- Environmental degradation, species extinction and global warming;
- Polarization of the rich and poor in the United States and in the global North and South;
- Economic instability with trillions of dollars of debt, housing foreclosures and the loss of local small businesses and farms.
She said that the turning point occurred in 1999 when protesters' demonstrations effectively closed the World Trade Organization (WTO) meeting held in Seattle. A worldwide movement was kicked off to challenge the rapacious global economy that was shifting the labor market to the lowest bidder in a kind of race to the bottom.
"We usually think of revolution as violence," said Grace. "However, revolution is more about envisioning what is possible when it appears that things are changing." She believes that Detroit, in particular, is fertile ground for this next revolution because it is such a devastated city.
Detroit has 70,000 vacant lots where neighborhoods and commercial properties once stood. And although the city looks like it has been bombed, Grace sees a silver lining: the city no longer has to adhere to the usual capitalist mantra of growth and expansion because it is absolutely clear that the industrial system is finished. This fact allows citizens to respond by starting something new all over again.
Grace and her husband, Jimmy Boggs (now deceased), a 30-year Chrysler autoworker, and a host of their friends began articulating the next revolution in the 1980s. Their work eventually planted the seeds for "Detroit Summer" in 1992 where young and old would re-generate their neighborhoods by developing community gardens and producing public works of art.
This effort further blossomed into forming a local agricultural network that is now impacting the city's food system by growing thousands of pounds of fresh, nutritious produce through organic agriculture techniques, finding alternative uses of blighted spaces, creating income generating activities, and diversifying crops and products for market.
Gardens are also affecting larger issues like reducing crime, cleaning up trash-strewn lots, connecting people to nature, nurturing leadership in citizens young and old and improving property values. What's more, gardens have rekindled people's hope in the future, a sentiment missing in Detroit since the "rebellion" of 1967.
This revolution urges citizens not to stand around and wait for leaders to initiate needed changes. Instead, individuals are learning that they can enlist others to help them rebuild their communities. Interestingly, it's the young who are especially stepping up to this challenge through local service programs, college projects, and the creation of small businesses and organizations.
"What we're witnessing is a national government that is incapable of solving the questions of our society and our world because politicians are so subject to lobbyists and corporations that fund their campaigns, that they can't do what needs to be done," said Grace.
She cited Paul Hawken's book, "Blessed Unrest," which discusses how small groups all over the world are rebuilding their communities from the ground up and changing the world because people are connecting to one another.
"We have the opportunity to take a great leap forward in these very challenging times," said Grace. "We need to change our institutions and ourselves. We need to seize opportunities. We need to launch our imaginations beyond the thinking of the past. We need to discern who we are and expand on our humanness and sacredness. That's how we change the world, which happens because WE will be the change."
Olga Bonfiglio, who grew up in Downriver Detroit and graduated from Wayne State University in Detroit, is now a professor at Kalamazoo College where she teaches a class in urban revitalization. Her website is www.OlgaBonfiglio.com and her e-mail address is olgabonfiglio@yahoo.com.



81 Comments so far
Show AllI am inspired by this article, and i hope others are too! keep the faith! light shines through darkness, not the other way around...
"And unless we want to live in terror for the rest of our lives, we need to change our view about acquiring things."
Visit - www.storyofstuff.com
AND STOP BUYING THE CRAP!! NOW!!
In this country, people complain about the mess but then just sit like lazy butt monkeys and watch American Idol. Even the gun toters act so stupid when they keep saying "We gotta collect more guns because when the fascists take over, we'll be ready !" Well guess what? The corporate fascists have already taken over right under their noses and as a matter of fact even with all their guns and ammo, they're POWERLESS because they keep waiting for a "revolution" to happen. The French and American Revolutions didn't happen like that. People got their asses out and fought for their critical needs. Unfortunately, too many blue-collared workers even in Detroit would much rather worry about their guns and bible than about their wage, healthcare benefits, and even their jobs and homes itself. The corporate elite LOVE this kind of dysfunctionality. A Revolution doesn't start with guns. It starts with thinking and then the guns will follow where they need be the case for the people against the elites.
More and more we come to realize that not only can the government not solve the huge problems we face, but government has become inseparable from these problems and we, the people, will have to solve all of this ourselves, or die trying. If we don't shrink from it, we'll be empowered to an extent we never imagined possible.
Only A Peaceful Revolution Can Change The World
"Based on?"
"Perpetual war + global warming = Doomsday."
"Revolution how?"
"We elect a president who's going to end the Iraq War, negotiate with Iran plus turning things around here at home."
"Failing in that?
"A mass uprising."
"Either way what sort of world?"
"It'll be up to us."
quite simply , where social progress is most vibrant is where the "government" fears the people, and social progress decays where the "people" fear the government.
Simplify
turn off your tv
don't buy items because of the "label" why advertise for Tommy or whomever for free?
buy local and only what you need
ride a bike if possible, get off the oil
things are gonna get real bad, real fast when everyone suddenly realizes you can't do much of ANYTHING, when the DRINKABLE WATER is all but gone.
if you think the "oil wars" are a horror wait till they start killing for water, after all you can't drink oil or cash.
be the change you wish to see in the world...
-gandhi
And if you go carrying pictures of Chairman McCain
Everything's just gonna stay the same
Don't you know it's gonna be
Fucked up
(with apologies to the great John Lennon)
Since 911 I have yet to see an american with the nuts to stand up and be that one person who makes change. Those so called elected people are puppets to the big corps and Israel. America was a great country at one time now it is just a 3 rd world country where torture and corruption are normal. The who system is wrong from top to bottom. I will wave next time I go to some other country for my vacation.
Barter is one answer.
"If we want to reap the harvest of peace and justice in the future, we will have to sow seeds of nonviolence, here and now, in the present. I believe that hope for the future depends on each of us taking nonviolence into our hearts and minds and developing new and imaginative structures which are nonviolent and life-giving for all. Some people will argue that this is too idealistic. I believe it is very realistic. I am convinced that humanity is fast evolving to this higher consciousness. For those who say it cannot be done, let us remember that humanity learned to abolish slavery. Our task now is no less than the abolition of violence and war ....We can rejoice and celebrate today because we are living in a miraculous time. Everything is changing and everything is possible."-Mairead Maguire, Noble Peace Prize Laurette
The 'prophet' Lennon said and sang:
"That what people call God is something in all of us. I believe that what Jesus and Mohammed and Buddha and all the rest said was right. It's just that the translations have gone wrong…Jesus was all right, but his disciples were thick and ordinary. It's them twisting it that ruins it for me...
"You're just left with yourself all the time, whatever you do anyway. You've got to get down to your own God in your own temple. It's all down to you, mate...All we are saying is give peace a chance...All you need is love...Imagine all the people living life in peace. You may say I'm a dreamer, but I'm not the only one. I hope someday you'll join us, and the world will be as one...Reality leaves a lot to the imagination....Number 9 Number 9 Number 9... I'm so very small."
"Let all who are small come in here...Wisdom has built her house; come eat her food and drink her wine and walk in the ways of understanding."-Proverbs 9
I'm so very small, so very small, already within the heart of every atom yet extend Beyond the Universe and connect every mother and child....Number 9 Number 9 Number 9...
http://www.wearewideawake.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=802&Itemid=197
We want a revolution and we need a revolution. But how? We need guns and gardens. We need hope and we need change. We have to stop the mentality of war and yet not give into acquiescence to the militarists and the nationalists. We have to defeat liberals of all types and work with the radicals to change the world.
Workers of the world unite!
Eileenfleming, and in the words of the great Jimi Hendrix, "When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace."
w
w
w
.
z
e
i
t
g
e
i
s
t
m
o
v
i
e
.
c
o
m
Any revolution won with a gun produces a system that must be defended with a gun. We've been down that road.
I try to be the change I want to see. My lifestyle is frugal and I like it that way.
The greatest lie of all is "If only I can get------I will be happy."
The belief in that lie has resulted in all the greed and corruption that grind the poor into the dust and give the illusion of accomplishment to the fruits of the lust for power and wealth.
All we have to do to defeat the system is to just stop. Maybe it won't be easy, but I promise it will be less difficult than chasing the wind.
"We have to defeat liberals of all types and work with the radicals to change the world."
The difference between a left wing conservative and a right wing conservative:
One will make you equally poor, the other will make you unequally poor.
Nietzsche,
Very well put.
I can't help but think that all the hand-wringing and exhortations to vote one way or the other is because most have never truly tried changing themselves. Being the change we want to see in the world is, and always has been, the only way to peaceful and lasting change. I have yet to find a hole in this logic, while others take us to disaster time and again.
Nietzsche-excellent post.
How about some posts on what each of us are doing to "change" and some ways that we are reaching out to others?
You can't be poor if you are grateful for what you have. In material goods it varies from person and from place to place but it is never very much.
A refusal to have more is all the revolution we need. Nothing else is necessary to win, and to protect ourselves we need only learn to protect our frugality.
This is a good article as far as it goes. But Ms. Bonfiglio seems to be struggling over terrain that has been very well covered and examined by earlier philosophers of political economy from the present back into the mid-19th century.
Ms. Bonifiglio, please read a little Marx, or at least get a subscription to the Monthly Review.
"In other words, a new epoch is emerging that emphasizes relationships and communities more than the
accumulation of things " .......thanks olga, this says it all
"A refusal to have more is all the revolution we need."
This is fine, and I try to live simply also. But, you need to be careful here. Would you tell that to a starving Dalit in India, a slum dweller in Sao Paulo, Bogotá or Caracas, or even the USAns I encounter on a late 86B bus to Homewood/Brushton?
If you asked them if the bourgeois in the developed world being well-of was a cause of their impoverishment, I don't think they would make the connection. They would blame economic system. And, if, for argument, the well-off did chose voluntary poverty, but with no other changes to the economic system itself, it would only make things even worse for the global poor as the owners of capital slashed wages and employment and raw commodity prices in a desperate grab at a shrinking pie!
It's an old saying but a true saying - The problem is the system! No voluntary frugality or do-goodism will change the system
Hi Ted, Waking up is a slow process for some people.
I saw a multi billionaire on TV being asked if he wanted to make another billion before he died.
He said "Oh yes, I want to go to the moon some day, look back at the Earth, and say 'That's part of my portfolio'".
There will always be people like that. When enough of us demonstrate a better way, more people will pay attention to us.
"WASHINGTON (AFP) - US President George W. Bush assured Americans Saturday that the battered US economy will "pull through" despite continuing housing woes and a spike in inflation."
Yes George, I'm sure that the American economy will be just fine as soon as you pay off the national debt.
I don't care about changing the present system. The present system has to be replaced, one person at a time.
I would never lecture anybody who has less than they need to be satisfied with what they have.
Every person must decide for herself how much is enough. If the millionaire insists he needs more, it's ok by me as long as his having more does not mean some already poor person must have less.
This is not about do-goodism. If you are not distracted with material trash (i.e. more than you need) you will have time to discover what is important.
What is important is different for different people but every person who thinks it is more stuff will be disappointed.
George is a good example of how useful wealth can be to a fool.
When hearing people talk about consumerism and the gotta have it attitude I think of my grandparents. They lived through the depression and the lessons they gleaned from that stayed with them for the rest of their lives. They didn't go out and get new clothes to keep up with fashion. They repaired what they had.
They saved change and every so often put that in savings. Drives out into the country were a luxury that they partook of sparingly. To them it was a waste of gas. Grandmother made everything from scratch using produce bought from a local farmer. She always swore it tasted better than store bought.
Though it seems unreasonably austere for today's America, it must have something to it.....they lived happy and debt free.
Well said Truth.
I grew up in Simcoe , Ont. Canada , about 200kms east of Detroit and I know that the long hot summers would produce a plethora of tomatoes , potatoes ... You can grow a lot of vegetables on cleaned-up and tilled 70,000 vacant lots.
A similar idea has taken off in Havana , Cuba where even patio flowerpots are planted with vegetables consumable either by the occupant or sold locally.
A good resource DVD mentioned several times on CD is "The Power of Community:How Cubans Survived Peak Oil". This documentary probably is using many of the same strategies and techniques as "Detroit Summer" in its urban-gardening endeavour
Congratulations to the advocates of Detroit Summer
Neitzsche,
You seem to be inflicted with the Ayn Rand/Thatcher/Reagan/Friedman disease, the idea that "there is no such thing as society" only atomistic individuals making individual decisions.
But in reality, there IS a system and a society, so replacing a system "one person at a time" cannot work, because individual decisions, the types of decisions that can be made, and their outcomes, and even a persons fundamental views of "how the world works", are made under the environment and constraints of the system itself.
For example, here in the US, can I, as an individual go to a doctor and demand free medical care financed by my taxes? No, because the system doesn't allow it, no matter how much gumption I have as an individual. Do I have an individual choice over the wages and conditions I work in my job? Would even my boss, or the boss over him? No! The capitalist system severely constrains this choice for everyone.
Or say, black people start moving into my neighborhood whites move out, and the market value of my house starts declining. I may personally have the most anti-racist convictions in the world, and be a black person myself! But could I do anything at all to stop the decline in the value of my house? No. This is because racism is not a property of individuals, it is a property of a SOCIETY.
the author's position is essentially that of John Ludd. the idea that mankind has exhausted the earth's resources has been popping since we got here.
Actually I see Neitzsche as far divorced from Rand/Thatcher/Reagan and instead describing what is referred to as Gnosticism.
Which is we have to each find the joys in our own lives, and learn to love ourselves in order to understand that we are all really one.
And we have to want the best for everyone else and share in their joy as well.
Thank you GwNorth. I see I have been understood.
NIETZSCHE/GW NORTH: I'm with you two on this one. Amen! There's nothing like knowing you already have what you need and honoring that, plus respecting the (spiritual) source from which it came.
I remember when I was living below the poverty line, in a rough marriage and had just had a baby. I was craving vegetables to make soup but had no way to get to the supermarket, nor the energy to do so. I went downstairs to check my mail around 1 PM and lo and behold, the box was full of vegetables. A friend was leaving on a trip and figured I could use the produce that would otherwise go bad in her absence. I have seen THIS type of thing so often. I believe that when we live from the heart, and respond to our own instinct for generous impulses acted upon, when WE have a need, something numinous finds a way to have it answered. Note I said need. Even Mick Jagger understood, "You can't always get what you WANT, but if you try some time, you just might find, you GET WHAT YOU NEED."
As for the 3rd world, the IMPRINT of poverty along with its ACTUAl experience is so severe, that the belief systems, not to mention the infrastructure that would support OTHER need to be reshaped. I wish we Americans could send all the clothing we don't use, the furniture we're inclined to toss, etc TO THEM. The idea of fashion is absurd as it makes a lot of people toss perfectly good clothing because it's no longer "in." Talk about a non-conservation model unworthy of following! I wear the same dresses now I wore 25 years ago... bottom line is, if you wait long enough and retain your same size, the fashions come back around again!
The material world is merely a manifestation of the spiritual world. We are here to learn from it and grow as individuals.
it my belief that all humans are entitled to food, clothing and shelter, the bare necessities , so that all have the opportunity to grow spiritually and as communities.
The problem is that as inviduals too many think that self improvement and growth comes from acquiring material things in an ever greater abundance. Just as those without anything, who struggle hand to mouth just to fill their bellies have little opportunity to grow spiritually, those focused on the material world forgo that opportunity as well as their entire lifetime consumed in the pursuit of material wealth.
Which is ultimately meaningless.
I am not talking about religions here. I have little use for organized religion.
We should wish neither poverty or great wealth on ourselves . We should seek out that which makes us happiest and learn that life and awareness is a precious gift, wherever it came from.
The revolution we need to have, is inside ourselves. We need no need of guns and violence to achieve such.
PK
>>If those that hold there must be a physical basis for everything hold that these mystical views are nonsense , we may ask: What , then, is the physical basis of nonsense?....Arthur Eddington
The American Revolution was not about "...people giving of themselves for the larger community." It was about taxes. A revolution will not be effective until you starve the King of his tax base.
Insurgency comes from the poor. Oppression comes from the top. Revolution - this comes from the middle. Remember that. Find ways to starve the King (like buying less gasoline - 18.4 cents tax per gallon).
I agree with all above!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This is a fundamental question...and i can not find solace in either answer bantered about here...Jesus himself...taught about "salvation" within the system of the Roman empire..but at the same time encouraged radicalism in his turn the other cheek, if a man asks your coat give to him your cloak etc...these were all radical proposals against the "system" as referenced in a CD article a couple years ago...But he also taught about inner peace....Somewhere among all his teachings I'm sure is the solace I seek (since it seems he was balancing the peace of the inner person while battling within an empire situation)...but I haven't found it yet... And on the other hand...ask yourself whether the slaves in antebellum America should have/could have just "become the change they wished to see in the world?" and for those who found peace within the system... I think we call those people "Uncle Tom's" now...The globalization system has made us all "slaves" of a sort....We can in NO WAY become independent, self sufficient or free...within the current system...YEs we can live by our own moral code...but step even a little out of line and you risk it all...
jimbob...you should read Thom Hartmann's book..Unequal Protection The Rise of Corporate Dominance and the Theft of Human Rights...In it he does a good summary of what the American Revolution was really about...and my takeaway was that it wasn't about taxes per se...but about priveledge for the East India Tea Company (a corporation who had a privledged relationship with Britain and who paid NO import taxes or tariffs on business to America) while taxing small American businesses and goods...hence the impetus for the "Boston Tea Party"...The AMercian revolution wasn't about taxation without representation...it was about the outrage of corporate privledge...how far we've come eh?
This has been one of the best discussions I have seen on CD for a while. Thank you all!
Some here seem to be pretty organized in their vision of how we can change the world to be a better place. Some seem to think that we have to change the "system" before anything can really be accomplished. Me, I haven't really thought it out that well. I just know that the only thing I have control over is my own actions. And there are certain things that I have done in the past that I don't think contributed very much to the sustainability of the planet. So I have changed many of those things.
Yes, life is much simpler now. I have a lot less stuff. And sometimes just getting by is a challenge. But I have to say that I am a lot happier. I am more connected to my neighbors and my community. For me, being interdependent is very rewarding on a number of levels. It really is true that what goes around comes around.
I don't know....I have this theory that everyone is either a "feeder" or an "eater". I happen to be a feeder. It gives me great pleasure to feed others. Literally. I'm not sure why. It just seems to be something innate. And because this is how I receive joy, I have to find the "eaters" to feed. And those eaters sure like to connect with us feeders too. I really like this sort of interdependence. It's a simple way of defining community I guess.
good luck - oh, they've stood up, but the people didn't back them up. There is NOTHING a single individual can do to change the course this country is on. And when those brave souls do stand up, we all sit and watch as the corporate media and "opinion shapers" rip them to shreds. So many (more than any other time in history I would say) have stood up: Dennis Kucinich, Ralph Nader, Cynthia McKinney, Cindy Sheehan, Joe Wilson, Scott Ritter, Richard Clarke, the retired Generals, the diplomats, the whistleblowers, the celebrities and all the others who have put their careers/reputations/lives on the line to speak truth to power -- but no one has their backs.
It is a fundamental flaw of American culture -- we have no understanding of solidarity, the essential ingredient in the notion of "we the people" in a democratic society.
thinkingmom
as the pace of change increases - and it is increasing - desperation, confusion, panic and resignation all seem to compete for our attention. the codes of conduct and life principles that have guided us along the way seem to be so much "hot air," seemingly contributing more to problems than solutions. but in a way, it has always been thus. during the hundreds of years of slavery, individuals must have wrestled with perceptions of safety and risk as they contemplated resistance. it took as much courage to "wait for the right time" as it did to commit to openly making a break - lives were in the balance all along the way.
as much as it is tempting to see only the immediate crises in our lives, this is about much more than our own personal stories. for those who have children, who work especially hard at helping them prepare for some kind of future, there is really no other option besides taking the long view - the revolution may or may not happen tomarrow, next week, next year. but there is an equivalent uprising, and it is always happening inside us. if we have the courage to look deeply without falling into despair, without needing to see profound change immediately, we will survive, we will grow, we will assist in a broader transformation and our children and theirs will live to fight their own battles.
Basically, they take our money and use it to fuck us over, most of the time.
there are many that are coming to a way of life through concise thought and an understanding that we all... people and nature are interconnected through the energy that i personally believe is what sparked all life... and though this may sound like I'm starting to skip into spiritual/religious realms... nonetheless we cannot escape the reality that beneath our consciousness resides a force of life that we can intellectually ignore all we want to.... or classify it in acceptable religious beliefs.... but its there and its making its presence known and felt in spades!
if you pay attention to nature... if things get too out of whack... nature... will right things... sometimes through incredible acts of impersonal violence...
and we as ppl have in an incredibly arrogant way overstepped our welcome with nature... we dont take anything in the natural world into account when we look at wars and leaders that have lost their perspective... this too has been a balance out of sorts that needs to be put back into place...
we've been a credit society for some time now... and its been a fantasy of a moneyed life... but it's a false one.. and the time is here that we're being asked to pay our past due bill...
we've assigned so much value to the possession of things... and many ppl have begun to believe this fantasy and made their reality and if you try to tell them otherwise... if you try to shake them of their fantasy.... things get ugly for us ppl that dont have a voice in a system that values money... power... position and greed above all...
so the question many wonder... is how will we as a race survive a transition that is inevitable if we're to survive in this great plane of existence...
do we cleave to the examples laid out by mother nature and do so with violence in an attempt to restore order and balance... well yeah... we can go that route... and then what?
if the meek inherit the earth... just how meek will they remain... because if we fight this "revolution" of bringing ppl in the fantasy realm of the haves and have nots back to reality in a violent manner... we're just repeating many pages of history...
and if we do so peacefully... are we going to be subjected to a financial tantrum from those that have realized that more and more ppl dont want to play the game by their rules anymore...
whenever one of my children display their displeasure over a decision that i've made that directly impacts them... with a tantrum... i would simply ignore them and wait for it to pass and once they realized that they couldnt get their way thru this method... they'd stop that particular form of behavior...but they wouldnt give up their need to get what they wanted because its a part of human nature! so they'll test the limits in other ways....
is this what we can expect from those in power that want to keep it and keep the status quo regardless of how much the rest of us say we want things to be different?
if we simply... one at time... or groups at a time.... ignore their rules and play by our own that will bring us back to connection with the energies of the earth and leave us living healthier lives... in all areas of importance... physically... spiritually and emotionally... will they just leave us alone and find some other way to play with power?
or while we're trying to adjust to living a life of true harmony and bliss and not one that we've been programmed to believe is the only way to live .... the american dream ... striving to have it all... will they take our inattention as weakness and take us over completely.... finally stripping us of all remaining rights that we believe are inherent with being higher sentient beings?
will they enslaves us if too many ppl buck the system they've put in place?
so then that leaves us to two options... take our chances and simply ignore them... live our lives by encouraging the growth local communities and economies and hope that they just leave us be?
or do we have to fight them off... drive them away and THEN live life this way? (when have you seen anyone in power give that up peacefully?)
we've had thousands of years of conditioning that there is no way to be any other way....
even though we could probably exist for a time... side by side... those that want to live in a modern world and have and take all that they can without any regard to the planet beneath them... and those that want to work on smaller scales?
or would the struggle to take more then whats their fair due start all over again?
personally i think that we wont be able to escape a violent clash as these two diverse ways of thinking cannot coexist in the same space... and the energy that we're connected to thru all living life is tired of being ignored...
when you put pressure on both ends of the stick... eventually it will break.... think we're starting to witness some stress cracks... what happens from here will be for the history books to decide…
Sorry to rain on anyone's parade but until you NAME the culprits and TARGET them for action, you're pi**ing in the wind. The culprits are the ELITES and the action is to STARVE THEM.
Recycle1: 'How about some posts on what each of us are doing to "change" and some ways that we are reaching out to others?'
We're doing all kinds of things to become independent from the elites to make the elites irrelevant. We're growing our own food, walking, riding the bus instead of driving, etc.
USAn: 'replacing a system "one person at a time" cannot work'
When the people stop going to Walmart, one person at a time, eventually Walmart will go away. When the people stop paying wartaxes, one person at a time, eventually the Pentagon will go away.
When the people break out of the capitalist indoctrination they will envision the new system and build it.
thinkingmom: 'We can in NO WAY become independent, self sufficient or free…within the current system…'
Sure we can and we are. We don't need 90% of the capitalist warez. Self-sufficiency is a wonderful universe of possibilities and alternatives. You will see when you get rid of the internal obstacles - then you can get rid of the external obstacles. The power is in the hands of the people, always.
Holy synchronicities, Batman! I was thinking of Grace Lee Boggs just yesterday. I saw her on Democracy Now! back in January http://www.democracynow.org/2008/1/22/ive_never_had_this_much_hope.
This is how white I am: I had never heard of her. Now I'm glad you have reminded me of her. Thanks for the great article. As a Zen poet and student of comparative mythology, I bow in your general direction (forwarding service requested).
Did you see Francis Moore Lappé's interview with Amy Goodman? http://www.democracynow.org/2008/7/9/as_global_food_crisis_tops_g8
And for that shift in frame, I humbly recommend my own site:
http://zelikowednomore.blogspot.com/
She, too, speaks with eloquent paassion about the need for a "shift in frame."
When does one know when one has grown spiritually? Isn't spirituality an ego self-serving substitute for materialism masked over as being more of the same mentality of accumulation? We decide what we want to accumulate or not. Unfortunately, there is as much spiritual accumulation going on as there is material accumulation. Both create diversions from human being (versus human doing). Living simply so others may simply live applies to both material and spiritual accumulation.
And if you go carrying pictures of Chairman Obama
Everything's just gonna stay the same
Don't you know it's gonna be
Fucked up
(with apologies to the great John Lennon)
Most people on these boards severely underestimate and slander the American citizens.
If you actually talked to Americans, instead of just bitching about how they should be more like you, you'd realize that most Americans know things are as screwed up as we do.
What they don't have is a way to change things. So, they just get along as best they can. And sure, they watch American idol to take their minds off of it.
But, what you will see is that if you offer them a way to change things, they'll turn off American idol and come join you.
This is the lesson of both the fall of the Soviet Union and the Obama campaign. The Soviet Union went from looking like a police state that had things tightly under control to a collapse with millions of people in the streets causing and celebrating that collapse in just a handful of years. The key is that when people realized they could change things, they came out into the streets and did just that.
The is also the lesson of the Obama campaign. A party hack politician in his personal grab for power goes around chanting meaningless matras of 'change'. His pollsters tell him that 'change' polls well, so he sees how many times he can shove the word into each speech. The people react and come to him in the millions.
Of course, they are all fooled. This is not real change, and they'll quickly go back to American idol as they realize this. But the key is in noticing how they reacted.
Offer them real change, and they'll come out in the millions.
The key is to do all the hard work before then. To slowly build the movement to the point where someday it can look like a tsunami. We have to do all the hard work to build the movement, put out ideas, and slowly get more people thinking out way. We need to do that to someday get to the point where the people as a mass can see it as a means of really getting some changes made around here. Then be ready for a heck of a ride when it all breaks lose, because its going to happen fast and probably surprise most of the people who've been dreaming about it when it comes.
"Revolution - this comes from the middle. Remember that. Find ways to starve the King (like buying less gasoline - 18.4 cents tax per gallon)."
Great point, jimbob. I would extend that to buying less of what supports the current system and more of what supports a system we would like to see: local farmers and foods, local artisans, local small businesses which sell locally made products. Of course, as a whole, it is necessary to just consume less.