Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Bank Looting Bonuses Reported--Will the SEC Awake from Its Slumber?
A short time ago, New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo released a report focusing on the bank bonuses paid out by the biggest banks in 2008, the same year they were bailed out by federal taxpayers. The report notes that in many instances the bank bonuses exceeded bank profits, the implication being that taxpayer dollars were being used to subsidize the salaries of the ace banking executives who created the financial crisis in the first place.
Highlights from the report No Rhyme or Reason: The Heads I Win, Tails You Lose Bank Bonus Culture include:
Two firms, Citigroup and Merrill Lynch, suffered massive losses of more than $27 billion at each firm. Nevertheless, Citigroup paid out $5.33 billion in bonuses, and Merrill paid $3.6 billion in bonuses. Together, they lost $54 billion, paid out nearly $9 billion in bonuses and then received TARP bailouts totaling $55 billion.
For three other firms—Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, and JPMorgan Chase—2008 bonus payments were substantially greater than the banks' net income. Goldman earned $2.3 billion, paid out $4.8 billion in bonuses, and received $10 billion in TARP funding. Morgan Stanley earned $1.7 billion, paid $4.475 billion in bonuses, and received $10 billion in TARP funding. JPMorgan Chase earned $5.6 billion, paid $8.69 billion in bonuses, and received $25 billion in TARP funding. Combined, these three firms earned $9.6 billion, paid bonuses of nearly $18 billion, and received TARP taxpayer funds worth $45 billion.
In sum, Mr. Cuomo wrote:
Thus, when the banks did well, their employees were paid well. When the banks did poorly, their employees were paid well. And when the banks did very poorly, they were bailed out by taxpayers and their employees were still paid well.
Why hasn’t anyone been prosecuted for looting the American taxpayer? Indeed, the number of prosecutions involving banking boondoggle is—dare I say it? Criminally small.
One "bonus bailout" did end up in court. You remember the brouhaha when it became known that Merrill Lynch (headed by John Thain of the million dollar bathroom remodel) paid out a $3.6 billion dollar bonus package to executives shortly after it had lost $27 billion and shortly before it was acquired by Bank of America (BoA)? Well, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) woke up from its decade-long snooze and decided to investigate the bonus bonanza. Eventually, it fined the company for not telling its shareholders about the package. All well and good, except it fined the company $33 million, which is less than 1% of the $3.6 billion looted from taxpayers.
Fortunately, a federal judge, Jed Rakoff, who was required to review the settlement, flatly refused to approve it. Judge Rakoff said that BoA and Merrill had "lied to their shareholders." He said that the $3.6 billion in bonuses paid by Merrill, as the ailing brokerage giant was taken over by the bank, was from "effectively from Uncle Sam." At least this judge is demanding more accountability. The next hearing on the issue will be on August 24th.
So, will SEC chair Mary Shapiro be handed a spine and a double expresso? Will Merrill’s John Thain and BoA’s Kenneth Lewis be cuffed? Stay tuned.
- Posted in

27 Comments so far
Show AllJust more details to add to the greatest felony ever perpetrated against the US citizenry and any citizenry for that matter.
Is it really a surprise that TARP funds are nothing more than a give away to fund the lavish life styles of the rich and shameless? Those who voted for TARP understood the quid pro quo all along. It provides for a sweet corporate job once the pond scum lose their election bids, a golden parachutte when the government gravy train runs out.
Yeah, the more things change, the more they stay the same.
The author asks, "Why hasn’t anyone been prosecuted for looting the American taxpayer? Indeed, the number of prosecutions involving banking boondoggle is—dare I say it? Criminally small."
Are you kidding? The question you ought to be asking is why do the Democrats and Obama allow it? (After all the Dems controll both houses and the Presidencey; what don't you understand about this?)
The answer is clear, they are all bought and paid for by the frigging banksters.
Wake up!
Even Barney Frank was quoted recently: "They own the place". A rare moment of candor
Right church; wrong preacher:
Sen. Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) has been battling the banks the last few weeks in an effort to get 60 votes lined up for bankruptcy reform. He's losing.
On Monday night in an interview with a radio host back home, he came to a stark conclusion: the banks own the Senate.
"And the banks -- hard to believe in a time when we're facing a banking crisis that many of the banks created -- are still the most powerful lobby on Capitol Hill. And they frankly own the place."
· Yr Obd't Servant
Do we have a reason to believe that SEC is asleep and not complicit?
I was thinking the same. To me, the SEC is just another puppet for the financial hucksters just like the DEA and FDA are corporate puppets for Big Pharma.
Remembering the energy crisis in California some years back (that I said from the beginning was a well-orchestrated inside job for conservative political purposes), and looking at the banking situation now, it's easy to compare the two and see what the game plan is. The writing was on the wall in regard to the GOP remaining in power, and as they're so good at doing with their big think tanks, they came up with the grand scheme of tanking the economy and holding it down in order to finally do away with the liberal party, hopefully forever. I'd even lay odds on the all the smaller banks that are failing around the country are like the judicial purge; getting rid of the liberal ones and the conservative ones that refused to go along with the plan.
A woman in Spokane, WA, a caller on C-SPAN this morning, hit the nail on the head. She basically said the banks are conservative, and they're doing exactly what all the conservatives have been doing, which is everything in their power to bring Obama down. Their actions with the bonuses, the withholding of loans, and everything else they've done since the bailout makes this pretty clear.
found one..CBS news..
california energy crisis..gonzalas on tape, laughing..
here it is..
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2005/02/03/eveningnews/main671618.shtml
The wholescale looting of public (taxpayers') money through the TARP fund defies all belief!!!
And no one in either the Bush or Obama administration has ever offered any rational "rhyme or reason" why it should have taken place.
NO business (bank or other) is ever too big to fail! And now, to add insult to injury to the American public, we read about the unbelievable bonuses that are currently being paid out to the "looters" who are responsible for the failure of the businesses to begin with.
If this isn't proof positive that our degenerate government (both Republican and Democrat) hasn't completely failed in its fiscal responsibility to the American people, I can't think of anything that would be. It's as though these criminal bankers are robbing us blind in broad daylight as we are forced to just stand by and watch!!!! What a slap in the face!!!!
What's wrong with this picture???
The "United States of America" can no longer be called by that name and has become the laughing stock of the world! A government "of the people, by the people, and for the people" no longer exists in America. Abraham Lincoln is weeping in his grave!
Bottari sez: "So, will SEC chair Mary Shapiro be handed a spine and a double expresso?"
***
More likely she will be handed a bottle of Sominex and a large bag of cash fluffed into a comfy pillow.
Exactly, she is a big fan of derivatives and de-regulation. Another fox guarding the henhouse; just like they like it. Bottari is either irrationally optimistic, or naive.
Actually you have to look what happened before she stepped in the picture..
12/31/08: "Top Accountant leaving SEC"
washington
Susan Markel, Chief Accountant in the agencys division of enforcement, is taking a job in the corporate investigations practice of AlixPartners LLP, a turnaround consulting firm.
Actually you have to look what happened before she stepped in the picture..
12/31/08: "Top Accountant leaving SEC"
washington
Susan Markel, Chief Accountant in the agencys division of enforcement, is taking a job in the corporate investigations practice of AlixPartners LLP, a turnaround consulting firm.
Yes, but how does that mitigate my claim?
"Why hasn’t anyone been prosecuted for looting the American taxpayer?"
Because legislative bills and statutes, whether constitutional or NOT, are written to protect these effing criminals at the expense of taxpayers.
In fact, if you look at the term "EMBEZZLEMENT" in Barron's Law Dictionary (1984), it says "embezzlement is often associated with bank employees, public officials, or officers of organizations"......
"The American people’s ignorance, stupidity, and disinterest in the governance of this nation have allowed an oligopoly of politicians, bankers, and powerful corporations to seize control of the country and loot its riches for their personal gain." -J. Quinn
for you Gail, you asked why no one has been prosecuted? here is just one for you, and there is so much more, its tons of cases:
http://www.truthout.org/article/logjam-war-contractor-fraud-suits
follow the money:
Thanks for the link. Great article!
Do you think it's fair to say that the DOJ will go to any length to cover the asses of the Pentagon and "violence for profit" businesses?
Here's another good article on the topic:
http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.
php?context=va&aid=14672
Lloyd Blankfein, Capo di Tutti Capi of Goldman Sachs, is reported to "look like shit", so worried is he about the reporting of Goldman Sachs upcoming bonuses. He looked like shit long before that.
"Capo di Tutti Capi" that's brilliant! Even humor aside, it is not far from the truth. Our financial and political system is run by a bunch of mafia gangsters and banksters. Even an obscenely expensive suit and cosmetic surgery can't make some look any better.
Hey, Obama bailed out capitalism, that disgusting system of the last 500 years, and some of you still like him. What? You didn't think bankers would (because they're the source, the foundation of capitalism) engorge themselves at our expense?
Bottari: "will SEC chair Mary Shapiro be handed a spine and a double expresso? Will Merrill’s John Thain and BoA’s Kenneth Lewis be cuffed?"
I wouldn't hold my breath. The banksters may have paid themselves billions in bonuses with taxpayer funds, but that left billions more with which to corrupt Congress.
In a cosmic sense, what does it mean that the taxpayer is footing the bill for his own subversion? Is this the sound of one hand clapping?
this is the story came out last year...
its about time somebody found something wrong with it:
http://rawstory.com/news/2008/Bush_Administration_created_executive_pay_loophole_1215.html
you mean it took them THAT LONG to wake up??
Good grief...they should be fired,
somebody is not doing their jobs.
ohh
ya..
I got one more for you..
12/31/08:
"Top Accountant Leaving SEC"
washington/AP
Susan Markel chief Accountant leaving for the private sector, taking a job in the corporate investigations practice of AlixPartners LLP, a turnaround consulting firm.
Sioux Rose
UBREW: It's like a Mel Brooks story-line crossed with Mafioso characters. In other words, it would be funny if it were not so traggic. Basic scenario is that hard working people who can barely (if so) meet their mortgages, rising insurance and related costs, are footing the bill for the so-called "talent" at all these brokerage and banking firms who have effectively turned our entire economy into a betting-casino. "Bailed out" they continue throwing money at one another, and having been given the funds that BELONG TO THE PEOPLE, they then proceed to RENT back to us, what is OURS, at usurous interest rates, and STILL lose money (of course the fact that the dam remains open, as seen in the lack of will to reinstate the Glass-Steagall rules of play plays a significant role). Therefore they will inevitably come back to the "negotiating table" to ask for more funds.
Bills are printed and passed out, more and more inane priorities are trumped as opposed to genuine efforts aimed at fixing the system, supplying jobs, greening the nation's infrastructure, balancing the salary scales... and the net result will become an insidious inflation. In my lifetime there has never been such naked corruption in the light of day. Persons so willing to reward members of their own club while undeserved pain is delivered upon so many others.
I truly believe we are at the end of an age, a cycle that spanned 2200 years. And to the extent Earth is a school house, current events represent our final exams. Those who are putting their fingers into the cookie jar, stuffing their faces when their brothers and sisters are literally starving, are receiving the F grade. Those who humbly manage to share and retain their spiritual integrity (basic decency) in the face of so much graft, senseless violence, and corruption, will get more than a passing grade. It's helpful to think LONG term right now... we are spirits that take on bodies for the purposes of learning, and the ante has been upped on the process of demonstrating what has been learned or otherwise. In some ways those who are expressing the most evident of the "7 deadly sins" are to be pitied, for they are setting forth their own legacy into future lives and times. Karma as universal law is inviolate, and will not be mocked.
IT'S THE JEWS!!!! So I was chatting with an old guy outside the laundromat yesterday evening and he was telling me how the world works with the bankers setting up a whole fake economy and then when it collapse stealing all our money, and how the government officials are in on it too, and how capitalism is the worst system in history. He said people in Cuba might not have money but they are happier than us. And then finally he said but you know who it is really is, the worst culprit behind it all, THE JEWS!!!!! And you know, historically all this sort of banker hatred, is often also Jew hatred and I wonder if there's still some of that around today or if it is just a few old guys like this one. There's a lot of righteous hatred of Israel and bankers among "liberals" and maybe there's some unspoken antisemitism.
Wow, what deep and insightful analysis, quite impressive.
I reckon if we criticize Obama we are all racist slavemongers eh?
If we criticize US foreign policy we are traitors, and self-hating Americans?
How intelligent
Will Mary Shapiro grow a pair? Not likely. But where is the public outrage as the oligarchs systematically drain us? Oligarchs? That sounds like Russia. Is that where were headed. Doh!
Just stumbled across this in the early am....f'n fantastic stuff... thanks to all. too bad the politicians can't read any more than their bank account statements.