Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Raising the Dead: Memorial Day Activists Jailed in Protest to Stop 998 Coal Sludge Deaths
In three separate direct actions in the West Virginia coalfields on Saturday, nonviolent protesters launched the new phase of Operation Appalachian Spring, a growing national campaign to stop mountaintop removal mining and raise awareness of the catastrophic potential of government regulated blasting near a precarious coal sludge impoundment.
"The toxic lake at Brushy Fork dam sits atop a honeycomb of abandoned underground mines,"said Chuck Nelson, from Raleigh County, W.Va. "Massey wants to blast within 100 feet of that dam. The company's own filings with the state Department of Environmental Protection project a minimum death toll of 998 should the seven-billion-gallon dam break. EPA should override the DEP and revoke this blasting permit for the safety of the community." Nelson did not participate in the civil disobedience actions.
The nearby Shumate Dam sits a few football fields atop the Marsh Fork elementary school.
In a telling if not bizarre twist of violations and governmental priorities, Mountain Justice activists who floated a "West Virginia Says No More Toxic Sludge" banner atop the toxic multi-billion gallon Brushy Fork slurry impoundment were arrested for "littering."
Still unable to make bail, nine of the 17 arrested protesters are being held on trespassing charges at the Southern Regional Jail in Beckley, West Virginia. In an extraordinary move to crack down on the protesters, nine violators were given a cash bail of $2000 a piece, which, according to the organizers, prohibits a bail bondsman deposit and requires full payment.
Donations for the activists' emergency bail fund can be made at a paypal link at: www.mountainjustice.org
Facing a daily assault of over 3 million pounds of ammonium nitrate/fuel oil explosives detonated at mountaintop removal sites in Appalachia, Coal River Valley residents joined with Mountain Justice and Climate Ground Zero activists at the entrance of Massey Energy's Marfork mining complex in Pettus, West Virginia on Saturday, May 23rd. According to the Sludge Watch Collection, seven people approached the entrance to the dam facility and the Whitesville detachment of the West Virginia State Police asked them to leave. When the seven refused, the state police arrested them.
The police refused to arrest 94-year-old former Congressman Ken Hechler, D-W.Va, who first held congressional hearings on the egregious impact of mountaintop removal in 1971. (A follow-up interview with Hechler, who led a national campaign for the abolition of strip-mining in the 1960s and 1970s, will be released later this week.)
Thirty-eight years after Hechler's first hearings on mountaintop removal, scores of Appalachian communities have been flooded, depopulated, subjected to a boom-bust single economy of outside coal companies, and contaminated by toxic strip-mining operations; over 500 American mountains have been blown to bits, an estimated 1,300 miles of streams have been jammed with waste, and over a million acres of deciduous hardwoods forests in America's oldest and most diverse mountain range have been wiped out.
Picketers placed 1,000 pairs of shoes to the site to represent the number of people killed if the Brushy Fork Slurry Impoundment were to burst. According to the protestors, Massey Energy's own filings with the W.Va. Department of Environmental Protection noted the 998 potential deaths as the minimum number in the case of a catastrophic breach of the earthen dam.
A Massey subsidiary in eastern Kentucky was responsible for the largest coal slurry spill in the eastern US--until last December's TVA coal ash pond disaster--leaking over 300 million gallons of toxic sludge into the area's waterways and aquifers in 2000. That disaster "impacted more than 100 miles of stream beds and associated flood plains downstream," and also covered backyards and farmland in coal slurry, according to a 2001 EPA's task force report.
"I fear for my friends and all the people living below this coal sludge dam," said Gary Anderson, who lives on the mountain near the site. "Blasting beside the dam, over underground mines, could decimate the valley for miles. The 'experts' said that the Buffalo Creek sludge dam was safe, but it failed. They said that the TVA sludge dam was safe, but it failed. Massey is setting up an even greater catastrophe here."
In a related action, six Mountain Justice activists locked themselves to mountaintop removal equipment on the nearby Kayford mine site owned by Patriot Mining Company with a banner: "Never again!" The protesters were cited for trespassing and released.
Here's a clip from that action:
- Posted in


12 Comments so far
Show AllAttention: Sarcasm
That was a 'disclaimer', got it? Announcing sarcasm ahead.
Okay here it comes:
(the sarcasm)
'What's a few coal niggers, Biggers?'
(that was sarcasm)
Now, all you fuckin' word-phobes, make sure you petition for my arrest and removal for uttering such a phrase, even in sarcasm. How dare I? NO EXCUSE! Just like no excuse for not wearing a seat belt, or some other vile misconduct.
For this is Amerika. And we depend on our words for the sacred illusion of freedom.
THE ILLUSION.
OF.
FREEDOM.
IS.
SACRED.
Dumb-asses!!
Can't talk without profanity?
nope.
quite the mess us dumb asses have gotten ourselves into... and are making.
Whoever you are, coldponder, I don't blame you as much as some others.
Thanks for your comment.
Look what Senator Byrd and your beloved Bomber do to their very own fellow countrypeople and country.
Sick, Sick Greedy Politicians !!!!!!!!!!
I believe there is a pre existing derogatory term ---- it is Coal Cracker.
Coal crackers. You're a pretty educated, alert fellow there glenn ford. That's a compliment, to you, despite any disagreements we may have.
Niggers rhymes with Biggers and I was just fucking teed off. Apparently, though to some, less is More.
Whatever.
Just so it is made clear, most of the the coal waste that is going into the Brushy Fork and Shumate impoundments is from underground mines. The surface mining in the adjoining area is a separate issue.
Also, there is no evidence that fine coal refuse is "toxic".
As I've written before, the real issue is aesthetic - surface mines and coal waste piles or dams are UGLY. It is a shame that we can't oppose them on this basis - as they could in Europe - instead of shaky science.
The dams themselves are engineered structures, designed and certified by licensed engineers, and should be no more prone to failure than any other large dam. Emergency action plans are prepared for all dams which loss of life is likely if they were to fail. If I lived downstream of a coal waste dam, I'd have a household evacuation plan ready if I lived there, but I'd have one if I was on the flood plain downstream of any other kind of dam.
Now, the big caveat. I did say the Brushy Fork dam "should" be no more prone to failure. However, I happen to be familiar with the engineer that is doing the ongoing design of Brushy Fork, and, like so many low-ball type engineering consultants, I am not very impressed with his level of expertise and professionalism. On top of this, the quality-control of the placement of the supposedly compacted coarse refuse that forms the dam is not anything like a real large dam would be.
Unfortunately, there is nothing solid enough for me or some of other concerned colleagues to go to their state board and challenge the engineer's license. US-style capitalism has forced many consulting civil engineers to compete on the basis of price rather than technical merit, and while this goes against the engineering cannon of ethics, no state board has been able to challenge it. The bottom line - these coal waste imprisonments don't get anything like the level of engineering budgets and therefore engineering attention that a comparable large reservoir produced by governmental enity would get.
I is a quiet secret among engineers that the technical competence of average practicing civil engineers in the USA is poor compared to Europe.
The best solution I can think of would be for the State of West Virginia to budget a few million dollars and impanel some real geotechnical experts from academia to do a completely independent program of exploration drilling, testing and review of the dams.
If fine coal refuse is as fine as sawdust then it is a hazzard because Osha considers the much less toxic sawdust to be a hazzard.
The Dams are not just an "aesthetic" problem because they do fail and create huge decades long disasters. Dumping extremely toxic Mercury etc.
It was environmental issues at the power plants that drove the development of coal washing plants and the production of the slurry waste.
But to be clear, I'd rather not see coal used for power generation at all.
I hate to tell all of you this but as long as there is no proven replacement for fossil fuels, we will be anticipated these coal sludge messes for decades to come until Peak Coal hits hard though that would come after Peak Oil and Peak Gas. There are plenty of alternative energy sources in addition to solar, wind, tidal, geothermal, and biofuels such as switchgrass that are also environmentally friendly but the poor inventors such as myself have been forced to give up my creations to the energy giants buying our patents lest we face disruption charges. The protesters might want to talk to us inventors and protest the giant energy corps crushing new inventions.
I followed the Fuel Cell development at a N.Y. plant, but when the were about to sell units to the Public for homepower generation G.E. bought all the franchises worldwide ( except for Mich.) thus no home fuell cell units on the market.