Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Skill Up, Party Down: Transition Towns in a Changing World
Transition Towns plan a gentle descent from oil dependence—and have a blast in the process.
Ciaran Mundy, a successful high-tech entrepreneur with a Ph.D. in soil ecology, started a website to update people on all the “terrible news about climate change.” But after a while, he felt it wasn’t working—that it would never work. “It took me years to realize there’s no point in putting up more facts and figures,” he says. “They just bounce off people.”
Then he stumbled across the Transition Town movement, which was just picking up steam in his city—Bristol, England. When Mundy attended a training session on Transition Towns, he found a group of people addressing the big problems of our time, and doing it with optimism and a sense of celebration.
The Transition movement is built around making the transition to a world after peak oil—the time when world oil production reaches an all-time high, then goes into irreversible decline. Oil prices will spike and the economy will stop growing, wreaking havoc in our society, which depends on petroleum for nearly everything, from growing food to maintaining economies. The Transition movement aims to prepare communities for peak oil—or climate change, or economic meltdown—by reclaiming lost skills, teaching new ones, and fostering local self-sufficiency.
The movement’s approach and attitude, as much as its goals, galvanized Mundy. “It’s not about being angsty, and doing worthy things. It’s about celebrating,” he says. “I like parties—I’m a bit of a party animal,” he adds with a grin. “So it’s perfect for me.”
Starting the Transition
Transition Towns started in 2005 as a community project led by Rob Hopkins, who was teaching permaculture in a rural Irish town called Kinsale. The year before, he and his class watched a new movie, The End of Suburbia, that said peak oil will completely transform our lives. “It greatly focused the mind and came as a great shock to everyone—myself included,” Hopkins writes in The Transition Handbook, the movement’s bible. He added a project to his course to imagine how Kinsale “might successfully make the transition to a lower-energy future.”
Hopkins moved to Totnes, a town in southwestern England, and launched the first official Transition Town. He rallied people to devise an “energy descent plan”— which has become the core of the Transition movement—for scaling back energy use, sourcing food and other goods closer to home, and otherwise aiming for local sustainability.
Hopkins’ Handbook argues that these steps are essential to avoid undermining the planet’s ability to support humanity, regardless of when the effects of peak oil kick in.
But these efforts could also strengthen communities and improve people’s daily lives. There’s no downside to eating fresher food, getting to know our neighbors, and avoiding maddening commutes. Those are all solid preparation for energy and food shortages, economic shocks, and climate tempests to come—and they may help us avoid such a bleak future.
Transition Bristol
Mundy’s party-loving enthusiasm seems infectious. Transition Montpelier, Mundy’s local group, has been in many ways the most successful in and around Bristol. Besides organizing street parties, they’re growing food in allotments—city-owned garden plots that people can sign up to use—and in planters they’re building along the streets. They’re assembling a buyer’s group to build their own renewable power mini-grid, getting solar panels for the neighborhood at a discount, and then divvying up the electricity. And they’re devising their own local currency for Bristol, to support local businesses and strengthen the whole local economy by keeping money circulating in the community.
It’s no surprise that, in 2007, Bristol became the first large city to start the Transition process—it was the 11th official Transition group—it’s regarded as one of the country’s greenest places. A progressive city near the ocean, its hills are dotted with pastel Victorians. In its neighborhoods, the main streets feature organic food shops and cafes serving fair trade coffees. The city council’s sustainability office is in a revamped, energy-efficient, former tobacco warehouse, and out front they have a model home that’s hyper-efficient.
More than a dozen Transition groups have sprung up in Bristol’s neighborhoods and surrounding villages, like Portishead and Clevedon. “Our approach [for] how to take Bristol through the Transition process … is to see the city as a network of villages,” says Transition Bristol’s official website. The approach seems to be taking off. Each neighborhood or village group has only a handful of core members, which makes meetings tractable and maintains a focus on a small part of the city that the members know well. A central group for Bristol, and another emerging for the wider area, are clearinghouses for experiences and coordinate efforts among smaller groups.
As of this writing, nearly 300 communities in more than a dozen countries have started their own Transition Town initiatives. The bulk are in the United Kingdom, the United States, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand, but groups are also springing up in Portugal, Italy, Japan, and Chile.
Many have come to Transition groups on a path similar to Mundy’s: They were worried about the environment and wanted to be sustainable, but they didn’t feel they were making much of a difference. Now, instead of worrying, they’re actually doing something.
That’s how it worked for Bill Roberts, a music teacher who’s turned his whole backyard into a garden. He started a Transition initiative in his village, Long Ashton, on the outskirts of Bristol. “I thought for years of joining my local Greenpeace or Friends of the Earth, but I never did,” Roberts says. Those organizations, he says, are “really top-down.”
But Transition is “bottom-up,” Roberts says. For him, that makes all the difference, putting “the importance and power of it at the community level.” When he first heard about Transition Towns, he “found it very inspiring—that to be green, we could actually have a better life.”
A local book publisher is letting the Long Ashton group use a piece of land to start a community vegetable garden. When they wanted to break the sod, a Conservative Party district councilor brought his draft horses and plowed the plot. It was tough work, even for the stout horses, but now Transition Long Ashton is planting crops and building a chicken coop.
Although these neighbors put in a lot of effort to create this garden, they enjoyed it, Roberts says. It’s the same feeling that reeled him in to the Transition movement in the first place. “It’s not that you give something,” he says. “It’s that you’re coming together and you get something.”
Reskilling
Besides growing food, they’re also gaining skills—often from their neighbors, who turn out to be resident experts. Take Deryll Hibbitt of Long Ashton. She’s always gardened—at 74, she’s been growing food longer than many of her neighbors have been alive. Hibbitt was one of 23 people who showed up for the first Transition meeting in Long Ashton. Before the meeting, she’d never heard of Transition. But she soon joined up and started a “grow it” group—“a meeting place for people interested in growing food,” she says, “where they share problems and knowledge in a very informal way.”
Along with gardening, members of Transition Long Ashton are acquiring other skills that a few generations ago would have been part of common knowledge. It’s all part of what the Transition movement calls “reskilling.”
In Long Ashton, those pitching in with the community garden are also trying their hand at keeping chickens and pigs, and learning from their neighbors how to build fences to keep them in. They’re learning how to preserve food as jams, by canning, and through lactic acid fermentation—the way that sauerkraut is made. “The networking through the Transition group has supported many of us in being adventurous with these things,” Roberts says.
“Reskilling” can also mean learning new technologies. For Richard Hancock, an auditor for the health service, learning how to track his energy use has paid dividends. He joined Transition Hotwell and Cliftonwood, in his part of Bristol, and through them joined a Carbon Reduction Action Group—“like Weight Watchers for your carbon footprint,” as he puts it. The numbers were surprising, he says. “When I looked at mine, my gas bill was the biggest part of my footprint—even when I was flying around.”
Other members helped him pick out a new, far more efficient, gas boiler for his house, and figure out how best to install it. “Working out how to vent a new gas boiler would be difficult without expert advice,” because of convoluted regulations, Hancock says.
To help people get tips and clues on how to improve their homes’ energy efficiency, Transition Montpelier teamed up with the local authority and the Energy Saving Trust to train several people to do “energy audits.” In the autumn, they’re launching another program, called Green Open Doors, to give people a chance, Mundy says, “to learn from a neighbor about domestic energy saving and generation” in typical homes.
The Peak Oil Frame
Transition Town members didn’t invent most of the ideas they’re using, like local currencies and, of course, gardening or making jam. But they have brought these strands of local sustainability together using the theme of peak oil.
“What’s fantastic about Transition is the frame of peak oil,” says Joy Carey, a Bristol-based food researcher, who worked for years for the Soil Association, the U.K.’s largest organic food certification group. “Peak oil focuses people’s minds. Before, having a sustainable food system seemed like the right thing to do—but that was it. Suddenly there was a whole other reason to take it seriously.”
Transition members have been crucial in helping Bristol and other cities imagine life after peak oil. Last year, when Bristol’s city council commissioned a report on how the city might cope with peak oil, they tapped Simone Osborne—a member of Transition BS3, named after the group’s postcode. “This was a major, major report,” says Steve Marriott, city council sustainability manager. “It made senior people all across the city sit up. We’ve re-engaged a whole tier of decision makers that weren’t on board before.” The “most dramatic response,” he says, is that the local branch of the National Health Service pledged to cut its greenhouse gas emissions. It is looking into the vulnerability of health care to peak oil and climate change, with efforts headed up by Dr. Angela Raffle, a public health consultant and member of Transition Bristol.
Tapping the Power of Community
Transition groups have had a lot to learn about the best role they can play in Bristol, says Claire Milne, who is a coordinator both for citywide and national Transition efforts. “What’s coming through really clearly is that its role is to act as a platform, to bring together all the amazing things that are already happening, and then allow them to work together more strategically.” Or, as Mundy puts it, its major strength is in “joining up the dots.”
Mundy may be a party animal, and Transition Montpelier’s street parties may be a blast—but they also have a purpose. “Working together in community is something that we have focused on, whether through organizing street parties, film nights, growing groups, street art, home energy audits, or transport groups,” Mundy says.
The real power of the movement is its focus on building community, Mundy says. “You can have lots of people who understand how to do stuff—gardening, home energy saving, bicycle repairs, and so on. But the magic lies in helping communities get together and work together in communicating, celebrating, and spreading those skills.” In an age of mass media, individualism, and consumerism, he says, these community-building skills have withered—but we need them urgently now. “I feel this is the primary part of reskilling,” Mundy says. “I can’t stress this enough.”
These efforts—planting gardens, putting energy descent plans into place, building community—may not be enough to avert the catastrophic change that many see coming. “Transition is a social experiment on a massive scale,” says a banner on the Transition Network website. “We truly don’t know if this will work.” But, crucially, the movement’s principles and attitudes have galvanized people, getting them out into their communities and their gardens. What started as a school project in Kinsale is now a worldwide experiment that’s truly putting the idea of local resilience to the test.



17 Comments so far
Show AllCapitalism, (everyone a competitor), has destroyed the family, community, and national units. This is a great start in the right (left) direction.
Truly revelatory. But what we are seeing, of course, is simply a knockdown of the industrialized (over-industrialized?) First World to the kind of society that most of the world lives in, indeed the kind of society that existed in the First World before oil and cheap energy came along. These folks look like they're onto something good, don't they? Where do I sign up?
"These folks look like they're onto something good, don't they? Where do I sign up?"
I'm glad you asked.
Go to http://www.meetup.com and enter "transitions towns" in the Topic window. Find one near you or start one and join us!
I second this suggestion!
The whole point of this movement is it is truly a bottom-up movement: But with some high-powered real-people thinking behind it.
Also check out the US site:
http://www.transitionus.org
Exiting gradually and in orderly fashion out of industrial society is the only sane road, if humankind is to survive with any decency (as opposed to surviving in a life that is short, nasty, and brutal).
Excellent solution. We need to start doing this in California.
I applaud the Transition Towners for doing something instead of nothing. But I'm concerned about the tone and ideology that seem to prevail in the movement.
First, I don't think all the talk of "fun" and "partying" is appropriate, even if meant as an antidote to constantly depressing news. People by the billions are suffering at this very moment, in so many ways, due to global overshoot. When relatively affluent First Worlders hobby around with recreating a bucolic past, and talk about the fun they have doing it, I can't help but see this as more of a smug withdrawal than a genuine engagement with the mess we're in.
Second, while it is indisputably true that the current iteration of industrial civilization is on its last legs, that does not automatically mean that a pastoral, idealized repeat of the 19th century is just around the corner. Such a notion is ideology, not prophecy.
Rather, we should expect a long phase of "scarcity industrialism" to come next, with authoritarian government, increased warfare, and tighter centralized control becoming the norm (more so than today, that is).
I believe we need to prepare for a future that will be very uncertain and unpredictable, very uncomfortable, and very trying. I'm not sure the Transition Town movement has the right paradigm to survive, let alone thrive, in such an environment.
"First, I don't think all the talk of "fun" and "partying" is appropriate, even if meant as an antidote to constantly depressing news. People by the billions are suffering at this very moment..."
Wow, you wouldnt last very long on any activist project.
Indeed, I haven't, despite many tries. From what I've seen, the ease and comfort of First World living undermines most activists' ability to truly "get" the profound depth of our predicament. I'm not saying I have the answers, or that we should all embrace a life of ascetic deprivation. But I am saying that we should be conscious of what we take for granted, and try our best to not let it get in the way of intellectual and spiritual honesty.
As someone who has been participating in Transition Town activities locally, as someone who sees value in what these folks are doing- I still couldn't agree with you more. Typical of nearly all Yes! articles I've ever come across, this one largely glosses over the larger implications of the problems at hand in favor of the kind of "optimism and celebration" that apparently characterizes this movement in the comfy suburbs near Bristol.
In my opinion, The Cult of Positive Thinking is a psychological disease that is doing nearly as much damage to our ability to evolve, change, repair the damage done and restore the planet to a state where it can sustain 6 billion or more people as the damage done by the Myth of Individual Freedom. The Cult of Positive thinking allows us to gloss over all the really thorny and intractable issues so that we can focus on the ones that don't make us uncomfortable, and ultimately don't avert or even significantly blunt the impacts of the multiple existential crises facing humanity. As a Peace Corps volunteer I saw people living in levels of squalor, poverty, and insecurity that would surely send most of the readers of Yes! to the ashram to decompress for a week. What these people fail to understand is that we do live in a world of our own making, but wrapping yourself in a protective bubble of positive thoughts doesn't make the world a better place for anyone but you.
But hey, at least we enjoy ourselves right? Isn't that what activism is really all about?
At the risk of sounding like a moldy old Marxist fig, for this movement -- which I support, by all means! -- to succeed in the long run, its participants and proponents need to start seriously thinking about the capitalist/non-capitalist dyad, in addition to the global/local one. The problem with a lot of "appropriate technology"/"small is beautiful" environmental movements is that they focus almost entirely on technique and scale questions, while overlooking the issue of class relations -- who produces the surplus, who appropriates it, and who decides when/where/how it is to be invested. They haven't been forced to come to grips with this issue (and other "thorny and intractable" ones you allude to) because they still exist on the (well-off) margins of affluent capitalist societies and don't yet pose a major threat to the big blocs of capital or the capitalist state. And perhaps the greater danger in the short run is that the transition towns will be benignly absorbed by the "greening" (imagined or real) of the capitalist state. We already see evidence of that in this article, with no critical comment whatsoever. I'm sure that in part this is because the social base for this movement at present is (mostly) disenchanted members of the professional middle stratum, who by upbringing, experience, and habit have never been forced to come to grips with directly confronting capitalist class and capitalist state power.
well said. i was thinking the same.
what i am curious about is their decision making process. how is power relationships dealt with? do they use a consensus model or do they vote?
ultimately, these questions are crucial to issues of participatory democracy. and if they aren't dealt with, the worst type of corrupt localism can destroy this movement.
when the economy collapses and the state can't pay for it's enforcement arm, self-defense will be an issue as well.
but i am really excited about this movement. it has important elements of direct action, decentralized democracy, local currencies and autonomy. one area i think it could probably use some help with is building a strong infrastructure for network solidarity.
If you could give your preconceived notions a rest, you would see that many of us feel the same as you, yet we allow our imaginations to work out the details with the help of others.
I see absolutely no reason to flagellate ourselves and live in sack cloths because of the state of the world or the fact that we live in the First World. We all take the situation of the world very seriously, and yes, we even allow ourselves to have fun (though, believe me, many of our get-togethers are no parties).
If you're looking for a movement that answers all questions and bridges all gaps, let me save you the effort - stop now. Transition Towns (and its sister org., Permaculture) are made up of people who are coming together to mutually find solutions to seemingly intractable problems. We do not have the answers and we are not perfect, but we are real. And, we could use all the help we can get.
Finally, I sense a misapplication of meaning in your last sentence. Questioning and working things out together IS spiritual honesty, which is attainable through the very act of opening ourselves up to the realization that we don't have the answers and that we need others to help us find them. This should not be confused with spiritual _purity_, which is ultimately unattainable and is usually just a means of running away from the questions. I know, I used to hold out for purity.
Great idea! I recently added a series of photos on my Facebook account of all the ways that my wife and I are bring green and using less energy here at home. I'm going to add a link to this story.
I think Rod Hopkins has 6 children!?!
Don't transition to my town you population bomber.
Bong Hits 4 Jesus Brigade
The first Green elected to Parliament in Gr. Britain is from Bristol Beach, presumably part of Bristol. So Transition has political implications, too.
Our maiden attempt at a garden last year
. . Was fervid but unscientific,
Some plantings maliciously failed to appear
. . While others were grossly prolific.
Our string beans and lettuce and radishes grew
. . With vigor and speed quite incredible.
But anything somewhat exotic or new
. . Displayed not a sprig that was edible.
Our garden is gone, we have sodded the space
. . And our zeal for the project is sodden.
The insects and weeds may take over the place
. . Unfettered, unsprayed and untrodden.
This year there's no lopsided harvest to reap.
. . We're humbled but not inconsolable.
The produce we buy is a long way from cheap
. . But the intake is sweetly controllable.
Poem by Irene Warsaw, published in her delightful
anthology: "Warily We Roll Along," The Golden
Quill Press, 1979.