Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
West Urged to Write Off Haiti's $1bn Debt
Western governments have been urged to write off Haiti's international debts of nearly $1 billion (£620 million) after its prime minister said rebuilding the country could take a decade.
Jean-Max Bellerive told an emergency meeting of ministers in Montreal, including US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, that the "colossal" effort would take "at least five to 10 years".
He said: "The people of Haiti will need more and more and more in order to complete the reconstruction. What we're looking for is a long-term commitment. Haiti needs the massive support of its partners in the international community in the medium and long term."
Responding to criticism that the Haitian government had been almost invisible during relief efforts he said it was working in "precarious conditions".
"We are fully conscious that the prime responsibility for our future lies in the hands of the Haitian government and the Haitian people."
Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper said: "It was not an exaggeration to say that at least 10 years of hard work awaits the world in Haiti."
Officials from a dozen countries, the United Nations, the European Union and the International Monetary Fund attended the talks to discuss the aid effort and make initial rebuilding plans.
They looked at whether to relocate the capital Port-au-Prince away from its present site. Around 235,000 survivors have already fled the blighted city.
The Montreal talks were expected to lay the groundwork for a full-fledged donors conference in the coming weeks at which pledges of money for reconstruction will be made.
Diplomats raised the possibility of a rebuilding project similar to the Marshall Plan, the US-led postwar reconstruction of Europe, which would take many years.
Nearly two weeks after the worst recorded disaster in the Americas there was still confusion over the death toll. One Haitian minister said 90,000 bodies had been collected, another said 150,000. One third of the buildings in Port-au-Prince are destroyed and at least one million people are homeless.
Haiti was already the poorest country in the Western hemisphere and groups including Oxfam and The World Council of Churches called on ministers to immediately cancel its full $890 million (£550 million) international debt.
They also asked for delivery on the IMF's previous pledge to turn a $100 million (£62 million) interest-free loan to into a grant.
Oxfam International executive director Jeremy Hobbs said: "Expecting Haiti to repay billions of dollars as the country struggles to overcome one of the worst natural disasters in recent memory would be both cruel and unnecessary." Britain has already cancelled all debts owed to it by Haiti and called on all remaining creditors to do the same.
With the planting season just two weeks away Oxfam also called for support for Haiti's farmers to prevent a man-made food crisis. There were also calls for cash grants which would be used to pay earthquake survivors to clear up the rubble.
There has already been widespread criticism of the relief effort in Haitiwhich came under further attack from Italy's civil protection chief, Guido Bertolaso. Mr Bertolaso was acclaimed for his handling of the aftermath of last April's earthquake in L'Aquila, Italy.
In an extraordinary outburst in Port-au-Prince he called the US-led effort in Haiti a "pathetic" failure, saying it was too reliant on military personnel. The US has sent 20,000 troops and anchored a hospital ship offshore.
He said: "I think it has truly been a pathetic situation. It could have been run a lot better, "The Americans are extraordinary but when you are facing a situation in chaos they tend to confuse military intervention with emergency aid, which cannot be entrusted to the armed forces.
"It's a truly powerful show of force but it's completely out of touch with reality." Mr Bertolaso, who holds the rank of a government minister, also accused individual countries and aid agencies of conducting a "vanity show".
He said: "Unfortunately there's this need to make a 'bella figura' before the TV cameras rather than focus on what's under the debris." The Italian Government immediately distanced itself with a clearly embarrassed Franco Frattini, the foreign minister, saying: "The Italian government does not share these statements." Meanwhile, the UN and children's charities criticised plans by the US, Belgium, France, Germany, the Netherlands and Spain, to fast-track adoptionprocedures for taking orphans out of Haiti.
"We are very concerned that there are increasing reports that children are being picked up and trafficked out of the country," said UNICEF spokesman Kent Page, although he had no details of specific cases.
There was also disagreement over a plan by European countries to send 350 police officers to help with aid distribution as looting continued in Port-au-Prince.
Six countries - France, Italy, Spain, the Netherlands, Portugal and Romania - agreed to send officers but Britain opposed the idea, saying the US had enough troops there already.
- Posted in

33 Comments so far
Show AllELECTIONS NOW ---- ANYTHING ELSE IS ANARCHY
How capitalism prospers best is to allow those most intelligent in managing capital to rule business, and to have government in full submission to business. Which is in effect, and in actuality, unregulated anarchy as in Empire USA. Such is what has happened in Haiti since our US Marines did their first coup in 1915.
So the only salvation for Haiti is to end the rich nobility anarchy, which is of course is an open and fair election. which of course President Aristide would again win by 92% of the vote.
Don't you think it might be a little bit of a problem to hold elections now? They haven't even overcome the problems of food distribution or shelter for those without houses.
(1) Over 90% of everyone in Haiti are starving, just sitting around doing nothing but starving. Plenty of free time to get the election done.
(2) It would be quick employment for several thousand.
(3) Six rich families have owned most all the land in Haiti for over 50 years, and a fair election would instantly convert Haiti from a rich nobility anarchy into social democracy.
(4) Otherwise we have 30,000 foreign troops killing off starving Haitians by the thousands.
(5) "Disaster capitalism" in reverse, the "Shock Doctrine" turned against itself.
(6) Get the Haitian to do it without government approval, get President Aristide back in power and watch the fur fly.
"get President Aristide back in power and watch the fur fly."
Google "Hillary Haiti" to get some nice pix of that Clinton tribe member shaking hands with those six families who own Haiti. These pix were taken shortly after the US/France/Canada governments kidnapped the socialist president because he wanted to double the minimum wage to an unacceptably high 40 cents per hour, and to increase government pork on socialist white elephants like education and health care.
Luckily, Hillary worked for Wal-mart (as a queen-ant) so she really appreciates the value of 22 cent an hour laborers.
It's a shame this kind of imposed salary doesn't leave much for homebuilding or social programs of any kind. But we can all thank Hillary for the cheap baseballs at Wal-mart.
John Ellis
First, there aren't any foreign troops killing of Haitains nor are there going to be.
As to 1,2 and 3 I'm sure you are right. But you can hardly get trucks up the road to deliver food and from what I hear (and this is just hearsay) the civil authority is fairly disorganized and the police force is in tatters. Remember Astride disolved the Army and set up the police force. And they lost most of their offices and a lot of policemen in the quake.
My point is who is going to set up the erlection? Us, Americans? Hell no! The French? Double Hell NO!! No outside power should arrange an election. Haitaians should do it. I just don't see how they can at the moment.
Would not Astride have to be elected again? He served out his original term of office.
Well since they need to "rebuild the country" you can tell straight off that there's something fishy about this deal.
The entire country of Haiti wasn't destroyed/damaged by the earthquake. The city of Port Au Prince was though. Did he seriously mean to imply that the city is the entire country?
Does any natural disaster in your country an excuse to write off all your debt? How big of a disaster does it need to be?
Sorry Haiti about your earthquake, but $0 should be written off of your national debt. Pay it back.
TheLorax
Though I agree, you shouldn't write off the debt, what would be wrong with a moratorium? Interest free for say 10 years? That would allow them to regain their feet and hopefully establish political stability.
I agree. There is no reason for them to pay any more than what they borrowed.
TheLorax
Though any debt from the French should be forgiven right away. They owe Haiti money, not the other way around. When I went back and looked at what happened over the years since their revolution (not slave revolt) France owes Haiti big time.
Frankly the idea that ex-slaves were required to pay their ex-masters for their freedom is repugnant.
"Frankly the idea that ex-slaves were required to pay their ex-masters for their freedom is repugnant."
What about the idea that the common people have to pay back the debts that their Western-imposed dictators borrowed from the West? Does this seem any fairer to you?
Who did you have in mind? Not Papa Doc or Baby Doc as they were certainly not Western imposed. Astride? Do you believe because the US negotiated his return and put him back in power to serve out the rest of his elected term he was a Western im posed dictator?
1915? Clarify please. If any loans were taken out by Western-imposed dictators then I'd say no. It is no more fair that the theft by France. Who are you talking about?
When the Haitian slaves rebelled against the French, Frech made Haitians pay reparations for the loss of the slaves. US of course supported the French since US had slaves then.
As Slavoj Zizek cites from Hallward's 'Damning the Flood':
"Only in Haiti was the declaration of human freedom universally consistent. Only in Haiti was this declaration sustained at all cost, in direct opposition to the social order and economic logic of the day." For this reason,"there is no single event in the whole of modern history whose implications were more threatening to the dominant global order of things."
US's greatest fear is that the Haitian Revolution of 1804 would reverberate again not just in Haiti but all over the world. That is why US occupied Haiti, why Dubalier was put in power, and why Aristide was sent into exile.
The irony is that the two countries that US fear the most are the two small island nations directly south of US, Cuba and Haiti.
What a completely shitty attitude. You do know that a large portion of that debt is because the French made them pay reparations after the Haitians overthrew them and removed themselves from SLAVERY, right? It took them until 1949 to have paid off HALF of it.
The IMF and it's cronies are the single most disgusting group of people in the world. They go around "loaning" countries money that they KNOW they will never be able to pay back, and then they impose all sorts of anti human, seriously oppressive rules and regulations on those countries, removing even that country's right to rule it's own people.
No doubt you consider yourself a "good Christian". Ever hear of the idea of FORGIVENESS? Christ was really big on it. And while you're at it, look at the concept of Jubilee. It is a biblical idea that every 7 years, your debts are forgiven. Horrible, isn't it, that people should be given a second chance. Haiti has NEVER been given a FIRST chance.
And for the record, the previous head of United Health made $1.6 BILLION during his tenure there. ONE person made more than the entire debt of the country of Haiti, and you can't find it in your heart to forgive a debt that you aren't even involved with.
Once again, the love of money rules all. DISGUSTING.
Well first off if I ever became a Christian I'd do the world a favor by finding the tallest building I could and jumping off of it.
I'm not supporting moneylenders but greedy moneylenders aren't the focus here. Haiti borrowed money. If you don't enfore them paying it back it starts a chain reaction (global) so nobody has to pay back any debt. This would include legitimate lenders and business loans. You can't just wave a wand and eliminate an entire nations debt just because of a natural disaster. If you did you would break into the "we had a flood" and "there was a tornado" to even "it rained really hard". Debt must be repaid. Unscrupulous lenders should be prosecuted and their interest eliminated but the money they borrowed should be repaid.
I has nothing to do with greed. It has to do with ethics.
There are several countries that have had their debt forgiven, and the world keeps going on just like it always has. There's no rush of countries that don't put their debt above their people's welfare, no panic at the IMF. A country has to nearly disintegrate from inside before debt forgiveness happens, but it does happen.
If a dictator of a country makes a deal with the IMF and that person is overthrown, the deal is with HIM and shouldn't be on the backs of people making less than a quarter an hour. In this case it's almost like making a deal with someone's jailer and when the jailer leaves the job, making the prisoner pay that debt. The people of Haiti are not free to do anything but die early, either from lack of food, shelter, or from natural disaster. They are as much political prisoners as anyone in any jail around the world.
What do you call it when an entire country is held hostage? Business as usual in a world run by big money.
WJM
"There are several countries that have had their debt forgiven, and the world keeps going on just like it always has"
When you think about that , you have a strong point.
"They go around "loaning" countries money that they KNOW they will never be able to pay back"
It's much more corrupt than that.
The IMF loans Western-backed dictators scads of money, which is then wasted, and then it is the common people who end up paying all that huckster money back.
The IMF are more like organized crime than they are like a development agency.
Actually they paid the damn French off in 1947 in full, including interest.
Do you believe the Chinese should forgive our debt simply because we are having a hard time? Should anyone's debt be forgiven because they borrowed more than they could pay. Obviously your heart is in the right place and your description of the IMF is correct.
Love of money has nothing to do with this. If you borrow from others, you have to pay it back. Its a simple concept. Predatory and criminal lending like the French reparations is quite another matter.
"the previous head of United Health made $1.6 BILLION during his tenure there"
I'd be happy to discuss a retroactive tax paid directly to Haiti from his salary.
If all the nations involved would be willing to cancel Haiti's debt, I'd certainly vote for that. But they aren't.
Write off the debt.
How much debt did Chrysler, GM, etc, etc. walk away from last year?
to whom were the loans made? mostly to the Duvallier clan and since they kept most of it for themselves they should pay it back.
at what interest rate are these loans compounded? I'll bet they've payed the loans back 5 times over.
they've payed enough.
None of those corporations should have been bailed out. When you make poor business decisions in a Capitalist society guess what happens....you go out of business!
The fact that they walked away from debt is an internal political affair and not an International event.
Haiti, like all nations, should return any money it borrowed. It has been suggested that interest be eliminated from their loan and I agree with that. Excluding all debt isn't a good idea.
I have already written a strong letter of recommendation to my Florida governor requesting that Haitian immigrants be given the same treatment as Cuban immigrants. It is totally inexcusable and disrespectful to have a double standard on border patrol where Cubans on the one hand are given blanket legal status whereas Haitians even with all valid proof are harassed or deported back. Racism is alive in Florida !
I hope it gets there faster than the aid workers he promised. His countries economic sitiuation appears serious, where is he going to get the money? The Chinese are a good bet. They keep giving our government bucks and our debt is certainly bigger than theirs
Well, the fact that Venezuela sits on top of the world's largest oil reserves, I'd say they are probably set for a while. I doubt they will have to go to China to get money. It's only countries like ours, who intentionally kill off their own manufacturing sector for the cheap buck (and get tax breaks and cuts for doing so), who have to go to China for money.
WJM
You certainly have a point about us "who intentionally kill off their own manufacturing sector for the cheap buck (and get tax breaks and cuts for doing so), who have to go to China for money."
Ain't corporate America great?????
Venezuela does indeed sit on the oil reserves you mention, but she is in a lot of trouble in a number of ways. By not investing in new plants to produce energy they are looking at real problems with electrical power due to the drought. Despite the recovery in oil prices, the Venezuelan economy is deep in recession and continues to sink even as the rest of Latin America is recovering. Inflation is already in double digits and rising.
Sounds like us doesn't it?
Two points. How many trillion$ did the US government give the Bankster$ to pay their bad gambling debts, no questions asked? How many of them posted the highest profits they'd ever made as soon as they got it?
Aristide was very much like Chile's Allende. He was giving the people of Haiti their dignity back. He was raising their standard of living and had started providing modern homes to replace the shanty towns. He wanted to raise the minimum wage from twenty-three cents per hour to two dollars. Naturally, he had to go. The US government replaced him with yet another butcher willing to enslave his people and garner the kickbacks and international loans for his own use.
The killings have gone on, with UN backing, ever since.
Most of that billion in debt is in the pocket of the Duvaliers, Tortue, and other exploiters of their people, for providing a guaranteed labor pool for the Cartels, of undernourished serfs working long hours for pennies, trying to survive.
It has become the American Way. Wait until you see the fate of the American (United States) working class after the Corporations have taken the last of our accumulated wealth, as they have taken our power.
You had better look to France, not the US for Haiti's problems. The idea of giving all other countries a free pass...is passe.
Haiti needs to declare Chapter 11, the debtors get nothing, reorganize and issue new reconstruction bonds. Its the corporate way!
And the free pass for the Banksters, is that passe, too?
minitrue
"And the free pass for the Banksters, is that passe, too?"
It most assuredly is NOT!
After reading Bill Quigley's article (http://www.commondreams.org/view/2010/01/17-6), it seems to me that we the USA, owes Haiti much more than $1bn. We should repay them for all of the inhuman things which we put the Haitians through over the years ~ we call ourselves Christians, but in reality we are first class hypocrites ~ and we will pay one way or another. What comes around goes around!
I was digging around in the web this evening and found this headline-
Collapsed CARIBBEAN MARKET Sat On Huge Cache of COCAINE and DRUG MONEY. Owners Block Rescue Attempts. Many Died In Direct Result.
http://www.haitian-truth.org/
I looked a bit more into the site, and there is a TON of information there that you all will find a very interesting read.