Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Making a 'Sacred Zone' in Appalachia
It's not enough to stop mountaintop removal coal mining. The goal is to build a new Appalachia.
When people get caught up with that which is right and they are willing to sacrifice for it, there is no stopping point short of victory.
--Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., 3 April 1968
It is April 4, 2009, as I write. A year ago, a handful of community residents gathered on a mountain here in Fayette County, West Virginia, to pray for a mountain that has stood sentinel over our homes for generations. We prayed because, like so many other mountains in Appalachia, it, and we, are under attack.
That attack is prosecuted is by a coal company willing to sacrifice us for a load of coal. A day more than forty-one years ago, Dr. King said, "It's all right to talk about the new Jerusalem, but one day, God's preacher must talk about the new New York, the new Atlanta, the new Philadelphia, the new Los Angeles, the new Memphis, Tennessee. This is what we have to do."
In the last speech of his life, made in Memphis at the confluence of civil rights and labor rights, Dr. King staked out new ground that took his movement beyond the struggle for basic civil rights. He said he had been to the mountaintop; that he had looked over Jordan.
The New York Times recently described mountaintop removal as "Appalachia's Agony." Understanding the destruction that comes when mountaintops are sliced away to get to the coal below is important. But I believe Dr. King would have called us to talk about a New Appalachia.
We must begin the building of the New Appalachia while we still have mountaintops worth climbing.
On that April morning of last year, we were surrounded by employees of the coal company. They had come to demand the sacrifice already under way be completed - the sacrifice of our community to Mammon. They swore. They cursed. They screamed at the priest as he tried to deliver his sermon on the flank of that hill. Determined, they shut down our public prayer and the sacrifice of Gauley Mountain continues to this day, as it does on mountains across Appalachia.
As the mining continues, our homes rock from blasting. Toxins leach into our water. We see the end of our community coming, as so many other Appalachian communities have seen the end of theirs. The sacrifice continues, as it continues all over central Appalachia, from Gauley Mountain to Cherry Pond Mountain, Kayford Mountain and five hundred others. The smoke of the sacrifice is sharp with the sting of blasted ammonium nitrate, diesel fuel, and silica, but to the distant agent of Mountain Removal, Appalachian peoples' sacrifice has the sweet smell of success: "There is no god but Coal, and Mountain Removal is its Profit."
Long in the making and long in the tireless efforts of coalfield natives like Larry Gibson, Judy Bonds, and Maria Gunnoe, a light is finally shining on the dirty secret Coal has kept hidden in the deep folds of Appalachia's ancient mountains. Millions now know what is being done to their fellow Americans in the name of "energy." They know that Mountain Removal is a scourge not just upon Appalachia, but upon the nation and the world. Millions of people across America and around the world are demanding an end to the nightmare. Some are asking even deeper questions about how we heal an Appalachia that is seeing the end of the coal reserves.
Chief among those visionaries is Van Jones. Twice recently I have heard Mr. Jones address large groups of people, sharing his vision. Van Jones founded Green For All. He describes an environmental movement that includes social and economic justice in the bargain.
Jones said something that spoke loudly to me: "We're going to turn Appalachia from a Sacrifice Zone to a Sacred Zone."
Ever since then, I've considered what that means. Truly, Appalachia has been a "Sacrifice Zone." Our lives, our homes, our health and our future have all been sacrificed on Coal's altar. Thousands upon thousands of miners have died in the mines and outside of them. They have died for want of basic safety measures and for want of basic human rights. They have died from disease. They have died from slate falls, explosions and gunshots. They have died from flooding. The widows of the nearly 500 miners killed at Monongah in 1907 received as little as forty dollars to support them and their children the rest of their days. Even our graves get no respect from the Mountain Removers, as our cemeteries are pushed over the hill and into the valleys.
Appalachia is a Sacrifice Zone and the ashes lay on the altar everywhere we look.
Mary Harris Jones taught working people how to stand up for themselves as she witnessed coal company brutality in the heart of West Virginia's coalfield conflicts. Mother Jones saw the sacrifices and promised, "When I get to heaven, I will tell God Almighty about West Virginia." Kathryn Hoffman, a neighbor of mine, recently put a fine point on these well-known words. "I think Mother Jones must've gone to hell," she said in a meeting with the West Virginia Department of Environmental Protection, "because nothing here has changed."
The very economy of the region, and particularly West Virginia, is held captive by a coal industry that wants to keep other business out to maintain the region and this state as its personal fiefdom. Poverty has been the handmaiden of the coal industry. The West Virginia counties that produce the most coal are the same counties that have the most grinding levels of poverty. It's no coincidence. Our landscapes are dotted with ghost towns, left in the wake of coal companies on the "bust" side of the boom-and-bust cycle of the "free" market's ups and downs.
How then, do we create that Sacred Zone? It starts, as it must, with the end of Mountain Removal. That is the sine qua non of any attempt. Ending Mountain Removal, in turn, means people losing the jobs they've had doing that work. Mountain Removal workers are constantly told that "environmentalists want to take away your jobs." Mountain Removal workers have been so emotionally abused by their employers over the years (remember: the vast majority of them don't have the protection of a union) that they have been conditioned to believe that they lack the skills to work in an economy not predicated on the ruin of everything around them. This is one of the most hateful lies in the whole process, alongside the cynical insistence that Coal is all that West Virginia has.
The jobs question has been answered. The Coal River Wind Project proposes an industrial wind farm on Coal River Mountain, a series of peaks suited to capturing winds of sufficient force for industrial electrical generation. This community-led project envisions a wind farm that provides more jobs in perpetuity than the Mountain Removal job that is now slated to destroy Coal River Mountain. Its revenues would outpace the tax revenues from coal. Its jobs are the equal to those who are hired to demolish the mountain. The Coal River Wind Project is a lamp to Appalachia in Mountain Removal's endless night. It refutes Big Coal's insulting premise that Appalachian people are good for nothing more than destroying their own homes and communities.
Since last year's financial collapse and government bailout, we've grown accustomed to monumental dollar figures. The word "trillion" is losing its meaning. For the New Appalachia, however, we don't need that much.
The coal industry estimates there are fewer than 5,000 people employed removing West Virginia's mountains. Let's assume that they earn $70,000 each, or a total of $350 million a year. That's tiny by comparison to what we've already thrown down rat holes like AIG. West Virginia's cut of the "stimulus" has been figured at $1.8 billion.
How long would it take to get a green economy started and self-sustaining in Appalachia? Five years? Ten? Five years of retraining and guaranteed income replacement for Mountain Removers would cost $1.75 billion. That's less than the amount of money being thrown away on the "clean coal" boondoggle. Even ten years of income replacement is a bargain at $3.5 billion.
Is long-suffering Appalachia worth as little as even one percent of what the rest of the nation is getting? If we aren't, then we will know that we are less-than-American in the eyes of our government and fellow citizens.
Part of making Appalachia a "Sacred Zone" lies in making Appalachia whole. That would require us to fix the land that has already been stripped. We can keep people working by doing the reclamation work the scofflaw coal companies evade once they've extracted the coal and the profit from these hills.
In the meantime, while we're putting Mountain Removal's wrongs to right, we can be installing the components of the new, green economy in Appalachia. Solar panel factories, lithium battery factories, and wind turbine factories in the heart of Appalachia will put miners and others to work on good, stable jobs. Tax incentives and public spending can green low income homes. The AFL-CIO has recently initiated a Green Workplace Certificate program at its National Labor College. These skills could be taught at our local community colleges. Imagine the potential for change such a program presents for the rank and file of the building trades. I can see homes on hillsides and in hollers where solar panels and ridgeline wind turbines generate ample electricity to meet every need.
There is a vision. There is a dream. We need the minds and hands to make that dream concrete. We need economists and accountants and finance specialists to make this dream reality. We need labor organizers to speak directly to the people who will build with their own hands the economy of the New Appalachia. We need musicians, painters, writers, photographers and poets to carry our sacred heritage into the coming century. We need agriculturalists and biologists to rethink how we use this precious, well-watered soil.
We have an opportunity to re-imagine Appalachian life and culture, to take the best of our past and reinterpret it for the coming centuries. From music, to visual art, to written and spoken words to the very nature of how our communities exist civicly, how they exist socially, we have here, now, a chance to make Appalachian culture in our own image, and of our own spirit. We have a chance to define what "community" means in the Digital Age.
I am an Appalachian. Generations of my kin have lived in this region. My wife and I are helping to raise members of the next two generations of Appalachian children. We have a vested interest in the New Appalachia. The long history of deprivation in this region has made Appalachian folk some of the most hardworking, inventive, creative people in the country. Our music circles the planet. Our lore is the lore of a nation. Our homespun wisdom bears truths that have withstood the test of time. Generations of Appalachian folk have survived in nigh unsurvivable circumstances. We have made a virtue of making bricks without straw. Imagine what we could build with even a little bit of straw! Those new bricks, strong with the sacred energy of community, will be the foundation of the New Appalachia, and our anguished sacrifices will finally give way to victory.
- Posted in



16 Comments so far
Show AllBob, Mother earth is rallying for this endeavor to take off. The ideas are sound, futuristic, doable, and hopefully inevitable. Fighting big coal is a monumental task. They know they are in their last days....and they will continue to rape Mother earth till they can no longer get away with it. We all need to stop them. We need to look with new eyes at what Mammon has wrought on our beautiful blue planet. We need to realize that the Great Earth Mother is indeed sacred...all her mountains, valleys, rivers, streams, deserts....everything. Words for all to live by: First, do no harm.
Beautiful article! Appalachian children are truly children of the Mother. She has given you the task of witnessing to the world the difference between earths children and earths destroyers. Dare I say....the true definition of Good and Evil.
As long as we have Appalachia's in our country, those that worry so much about other folks or foreign nationals problems are rather childish and naive.
"The very economy of the region, and particularly West Virginia, is held captive by a coal industry that wants to keep other business out to maintain the region and this state as its personal fiefdom. Poverty has been the handmaiden of the coal industry. The West Virginia counties that produce the most coal are the same counties that have the most grinding levels of poverty. It's no coincidence."
They couldn't keep them out without the help of the big banks and the federal givernment and the betrayal of their fellow Mountaineers by state and local officials on the take.
There has to be a special level of Hell for these bastards.
q
"There has to be a special level of Hell for these bastards."
let's hope it has lots of coal!
"There is no god but Coal, and Mountain Removal is its Profit."
Best quote on coal, ever.
It is hard for me to understand our President. This is a relatively inexpensive fix, both politically and financially. I am most disappointed that a man of such reputed integrity would not rectify this problem. With all due respect to Sen. Byrd, coal is not and cannot be the answer. We, especially the people of West Virginia, have sacrificed too much already.
"How then, do we create that Sacred Zone? It starts, as it must, with the end of Mountain Removal."
A Sacred Zone is a brilliant concept. They are absolutely what needs to happen -- everywhere. Recognizing the Earth as a great, contiguous blessing that we've all been gifted, is key to the survival of our species. Gratitude for the gift is a necessary component for proper stewardship of it.
I believe that the process for ending Mountain Top removal begins with the immediate devaluation of coal. Recognizing the true value of coal as nil, in the context of cheap, available regionally distributed alternative fuel sources, will stop the extraction of coal. Proportionate respect for true costs and dangers of extractive resource economics means eliminating those industries that potentiate extinction. If there were available alternatives to coal, people wouldn't mine it. The fact is there is an alternative to coal that has been suppressed for so long, that people no longer even consider it an option: Industrial hemp -- How bad do things have to get before all solutions are considered?
Hemp agriculture is critical to producing abundant organic biofuels AND highly nutritious food -- FROM THE SAME HARVEST! People who criticize biofuels because they are concerned about food security would be reminded about hemp.
Seeds for protein-rich food and stalks for biomass ethanol, cellulosic hydrogen, pyrolytic charcoal fuels, grown organically, sustainably, with multiple agronomic benefits. All that needs to change is our spiritual regard and essential respect for the world's most useful and nutritionally complete agricultural resource.
What used to be considered "environmental externalities," dismissed as unquantifiable and therefore not counted at all, are coming to be recognized as critical components of a very delicate system upon which all life depends. Quality of life, an unpolluted environment, the value of peace all matter in ways that ultimately determine the existence of the human economics that fails to take them into account.
Time is the limiting factor in the equation of survival. Every springtime that passes is gone forever.
Unless We the People reclaim the ancient relationship of respect and gratitude that has existed between religion and agriculture, our spiritual bankruptcy will prove a greater threat than economic insolvency.
Sioux Rose
PROJECT PEACE: Excellent post, although your use of "religion" in your concluding paragraph elicits a number of not entirely savory possibilities.
Imagine how forlorn and destitute human kind would be,
if love's search for abundant riches within each of us required :
… the ripping apart of hallowed structure,
demolition of nature's pristine order,
turning everything upside-down
and inside-out ?
¿ Who could or would rape and leave barren the lavish cradle of our own existence,
our Earth Mother's inviolable bones ?
Only the insane and rabid ruin strewn filled illusion of scarce separateness,
could ever allow such abuse of who we cannot but love forever.
¿ Our Mother, and source and connection of us all -- how could we forsake you,
merely for crass profit and expediency ?
Namaste
Beautiful prose.Luminous,Homo Sapiens ,not so wise,is digging for riches without!
peace
Sioux Rose
LUMINOUS: Beautiful post. You are a remarkable combination of poet and mechanical engineer, in other words a patient & evolved OLD soul. Thanks for your colorful and always interesting posts.
when I was in 9th grade I wrote a poem where the last line is:
Money loses value when worth itself is lost. (The proof of that pudding is stronger today than was the case in my teen years.)
Projectpeace-I watched a documentary called "Hillbilly:The Real Story" on the History Channel not long ago, and one segment showed how much marijuana was seized and destroyed by law enforcement in the Appalachias. It also talked about how much money marijuana pumped into the local economy. Could legalizing hemp and ending the drug war be part of the solution?
Live like the Tribes used to live in this land & there might not even be close to anywhere near the problems as there are now?
Life is good. What an experience! It's always best to forgive
The monster is a special organism with two separate, co-dependent halves. The elite half of the monster gathers the funny money from the banksters, builds the giant machines, hires the workers, plunders the land, generates the electricity and sells the people energy-consumptive appliances, all at carefully set prices to ensure the market succeeds.
The other half of the monster is the people themselves. As Mr. Kincaid says, the people are proud folk with their lore and all. They know how to do certain things to get by. But they have this co-dependent relationship with the other half of the monster, and they readily adopt the appliances, get hooked on the electricity, and the jobs, and get all tangled up and conflicted in their role as half of the monster.
Best stop doing that and start building self-reliant local communities. When Mr. Kincaid started talking about his lore, I wanted to read something more along the lines of documentation on the industry standards in the cottage industries in his area, the non-trade-secrets, the shared info, documented how-to, to serve Appalachia and everywhere else. Get to work, people!
Mountaintop removal for coal is pretty much a metaphor for everything that the US has come to represent. "Toxic Assets." Dump 'em on the Common(er)s.
-30-
The people who lived on this continent before Europeans arrived believed in and practiced a deep spirituality- they knew that Mother Earth, every part of her, is sacred. All the other living things, the rivers and streams. And the mountains.
They had no use for the angry sky god the europeans tried to sell them.
This country acts like it has lost its soul, if it ever had one. I do believe we would be a lot better, and happier, if we could learn the ways and spirituality of the Native Americans who lived in peace and harmony with Mother Earth for ten thousand years before the europeans came.