Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Cash Costs of War: Antiwar Meeting Ready to Link Foreign Wars with US Economy Woes
ALBANY -- The Revolution will be televised -- or, rather, streaming live online.
Antiwar demonstrations in the Vietnam era were a regular feature of the nightly network news on NBC, CBS and ABC.
Today, protests against the war in Afghanistan are just as likely to be online as on TV, and in the form of damning documents or videos shown on WikiLeaks.
And lacking a Sarah Palin or Glenn Beck -- figures that have rallied the nation's Tea Party movement -- peace activists are taking a different tack. They are connecting the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and our sagging economy and poor jobs outlook.
"The message here is the war and jobs and the economy is the same issue," said Joe Seeman, a local MoveOn member and one of an estimated 600 people attending the United National Peace Conference finishing up today at the Crowne Plaza hotel.
Drawing a mix of peace and civil rights activists, socialists, and progressive union members, the conference aimed at developing a broad consensus on how to get the U.S. military out of the Middle East and other locations.
Attendees were also anxious to counter what they said was the media-driven perception that Americans are more Tea Partier than Peace Seeker.
In addition to debating, massaging and fine-tuning a roster of statements, manifestos and declarations, participants were looking toward next month. They plan to put on their own demonstrations to rebut a Glenn Beck rally planned for the Lincoln Memorial in Washington D.C. on Aug. 28 (the same date that Martin Luther King Jr. gave his "I have a dream" speech in 1963).
Pointing to polls showing the unpopularity of the Iraq and Afghan wars, these activists believe there is a vast untapped store of public sentiment against overseas military action.
What they need to do, participants said, was figure out how to best demonstrate that the money spent on military actions could be put to use in creating jobs at home.
"We have to make that connection," said Joe Lombardo, a Delmar activist who helped organize the convention.
"The Tea Party movement for all its complaints has no solution," contended Phil Wilayto, editor of the Virginia Defender, a Richmond based publication that focuses on civil rights, poverty and the anti-war movement. "We have a solution. Money for jobs not for wars."
While the bulk of participants seemed to be from the Northeast, some came from across the nation, including California and the Midwest as well as Virginia.
One of the speakers was Mike Alewitz, a muralist and associate art professor in Connecticut who was at Kent State when Ohio National Guard troops opened fired and killed four students 40 years ago.
Indeed, parts of the convention had what might be called an updated counter-culture feel with its roots in the '60s.
There were activists protesting U.S. involvement in Latin America and the Caribbean, including in Colombia and Haiti. There were booths for socialist/feminists, anti-imperialists, and communists.
There were Palestinian supporters calling for Israel to leave Gaza and the West Bank alone, and civil libertarians upset at what they termed government harassment of Muslims in the U.S.
The keynote address was delivered via videolink from M.I.T. by linguist and longtime foreign policy critic Noam Chonsky.
Cindy Sheehan, an anti-Iraq war activist came to the conference but had to leave as her daughter had just gone into labor, said Lombardo. U.S. Rep. Paul Tonko also addressed the group and labor activists from the SEIU-1199 health care workers also participated.
As for the televising, a Troy group, The Sanctuary for Independent Media was providing a live streamed video of the conference at http://mediasanctuary.tv/crows/.

55 Comments so far
Show AllWell... duh!
All the great empires went bankrupt from war. Even when concerned citizens pointed out how stupid continual war was, they were ignored in favor of the rich men who grew rich from war profiteering.
exactly.............well, duh, duh............
Time to repeal the law of war that prevents looting of conquered countries, and also that pesky idea that we shouldn't extort other peoples to pay for the wars we want to wage.
Think of how much money the usa could have made if they had done the smart thing and auctioned off the Iraqi museums to the highest bidders, why you might have a surplus instead of a massive debt right now.
And bring back slavery, sell off the conquered people into lifetime bondage. Think of the money that is just being pissed away by those 'Modern' thinkers.
Really now, Julius Caesar paid for his 'election' campaigns by enslaving and looting the Gauls. If it was good enough for July it should be good enough for us.
(don't even think of taking this statement seriously, unless you work for one of those rightwing 'think tanks' then go ahead and say what I just said. I dare you, I double dog dare you...)
if you haven't already, you would enjoy this:
http://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/sociopolitica/esp_sociopol_ironmountain0.htm
*
Foreword
*
Background Information
*
Statement by "John Doe"
*
The Report of the Special Study Group
*
Introduction
*
Section 1: Scope of the Study
Section 2: Disarmament and the Economy
Section 3: Disarmament Scenarios
Section 4: War and Peace as Social Systems
Section 5: The Functions of War
Section 6: Substitutes for the Functions of War
Section 7: Summary and Conclusions
Section 8: Recommendations
I read the forward, a bit fishy... No real names, and a dodgy idea that 'peace' would break out on a permanent basis.
The fake names don't bother me as much as the idea that anyone would believe that humans will give up on war to solve their 'issues'. It'd be nice if we could, but I'd sooner believe that I could buy the Brooklyn Bridge from a beggar than I'd believe that anyone actually took the premise seriously.
I do not know one person in the last 5yrs. from either side of the political spectrum that thinks we should be in either War . I don't think regular people still buy into fight them there, instead of here, anymore. The only people left liking the war are our Leaders, that continue to make Mad Money, killing people. May they all suffer from some horrible illness that no money can fix, and their families too....that is all we can do, curse them ,unless we decide it is worth going to the streets and telling those assholes over, and over again to get out of the war business ! I just don't see it though, nobody wants to get in trouble ( so they say)they can't miss work... they don't have gas to go protest. You should hear the excuses people give why not to get involved.
razormirror, who was it that said, "It is better to light a single candle, than to curse the darkness"?
That being said, i agree with you. Although i wouldn't want to put curses on them. Two wrongs and all that stuff......
This is one giant classroom we are in. And we are 'learning' the largest lessons. The human condition is the subject. And our perspectives have got to change or nothing creative will happen. That is one lesson i have already seen on the blackboard here.
Why is it that these are the people with the so called power? That is what i wonder. I think the definition of power needs to change. Creativity - that which is not predictable - is the ultimate power of all. Bringing something completely original into 'being'. Something inspirational is needed. And it won't be found in religions, that is for sure. And it won't be found in the same old political systems that have been around for hundreds of years. Obviously. Or it would be different by now.
If there isn't a deep psychological change within the masses....i think the writing is on the wall, not the blackboard.
As far as taking to the streets, we've said it all a million times on this very site. I have been in nyc and DC more time than i can count over the past ten years, beginning with the original invasion of Afghanistan. And i was there last march for the 'march', etc. It was pathetic. Sad, really.
peace,
rita
Empire_USA, sounds like the working outline for Orwell's *1984.*
Peace from a prole, Jack
We are funding 2 plus wars and 725 military bases around the world. YES drawing the connection between unemployment or home foreclosures or increased class sizes and military spending makes sense.
We are funding 2 plus wars and 725 military bases around the world. YES drawing the connection between unemployment or home foreclosures or increased class sizes and military spending makes sense.
He is also a Zionist who condones Israel's imprisonment and torturous treatment of the citizens of Gaza. In his mind, the billions we give to Israel for atrocities is money well spent.
I do not believe that a MoveOn member has any credibility on this issue as his organization has refused to come out in favor of immediate withdrawal of all troops from Afghanistan and Iraq [as well as civilian contractors] and also the dismantling of all U.S. military bases in those countries.
Hear, here! MoveOn lost me in '04 with their endorsement of such a pro-war loser as Kerry.
Well, that does make you a double loser for the year of 2004. But I guess you'll always have Paris: probably to yourself.
MoveOn - Daily Kos - stalking vampires in support of Democrats. They'll suck out your time and money, but when the '06 election gave Democrats control of the House and Senate, they'll tell you it isn't right to pressure Congress to withdraw from Iraq.
Throw in the Post, Times, Nation, MSNBC - there job is to make sure progressives are channeled and neutered.
You left out the Class War on the U.S.: Wall Street, War Profiteers, Big Oil, Big Pharma, "Health" Insurance, Agribusiness, Big Chemicals, Chamber of Commerce, and their obedient servants in the White House, Congress, on the Supreme Court, and in state governments, all intent on destroying the U.S. working and middle classes so all of us will be their 21st century serfs and our young will be brainwashed in test-driven charter schools or forced by the "poverty draft" to enlist in the Empire's "voluntary" military so they can "be all that the Empire needs them to be".
I'd say a big problem is the "I've just finished my daily double shift cleaning your bed pans, wet nursing your children, preparing your food and now you want me to transfer three busses over to the voting site..." form of democracy.
Will this attempt at a movement ever grow legs and get any traction? What can we reasonably expect if it's to be directed in any way by MoveOn? Surely they're still convinced Obama is the great progressive savior we've been waiting for, and Democratic Party is vastly different from the fascist Republicans. How soon will this "movement" devolve into just another effort to keep Democrats in office and elect more of them?
So the Albany Times Union reports on the United National Peace Conference, but will we hear a word about it anywhere on corporate media, which totally dominates the media spotlight? Not bloody likely. They barely bothered reporting more than a few words about all the protesting leading up to the Iraq invasion/occupation and they'll treat this the same way. Tea Parties are big news, Glenn Beck and Sarah Palin's daily idiocies receive constant coverage, as if they're the leaders they pretend to be, representing the views America wants and needs.
"It's the media, stupid" should be the slogan of this movement, if it ever does get anywhere, which it really can't because it's the fucking media that will prevent that from happening by rigorously ignoring it. We've been waiting for 12 years for the sacred Internet to be the medium triggering revolution, and it ain't happening. It's just been a place for messaging back and forth, leading to . . . more and more messaging.
We presently have about 700 military bases spread throughout the world and an annual defense budget of $895 billion.
Those statistics could wake-up the dead.
Five more troops "dead!" in this illegal and deadly Middle East war of aggression and hegemony. Just so dam sad!
I thought our troops were suppose to be coming home? Wasn’t that part of the campaign rhetoric? These five troops are, and not the way their grieving loved ones had planned.
"The military did not say precisely where the incidents occurred?"
http://www.cnn.com/2010/WORLD/asiapcf/07/24/afghanistan.us.troops.killed/index.html?section=cnn_latest
We're never leaving the Middle East unless "the people" decide they've had "ENOUGH!" The keyboard cowboys and girls decide to turn off their puters and assemble at least "five to ten million strong" for a "P E A C E F U L !" protest, and perhaps send a message to our so called leaders, that "we've had enough" of this deadly and costly empire building. It is time to begin rebuilding "AMERICA!" Does anyone remember that place? Or was it all just a dream.
Considering that unprecedented numbers of people took to the streets in peaceful protests prior to the Iraq War, and yet we still bombed the country back to the stone age, I don't hold out a lot of hope that P E A C E F U L protests will derail the imperialist empire.
That being said, I still continue to participate in peaceful protests whenever the opportunity presents itself. In fact, last April 15th, myself and a handful of other anti-war activists co-opted the Tea Party rally with signs against the wars and US Militarism. We were able to steal the thunder of the Tea Partiers by getting equal news coverage on both the local TV news and the newspaper even though there were about 7 of us and over 1000 Tea Partiers. Callers to a local right week talk radio show complained that we got too much coverage.
I think the Ant-War movement needs to take over the Tea Parties and drowned out there incoherent message with one of Anti-War. Swell the ranks of the Tea Party with messages of Peace and Justice. Steal their news coverage. If the news covers a Tea Party, the majority of the people there will have anti war signs. That is my hope and from this article, it seems others have this idea by having a counter Glenn Beck rally.
"War = Debt". I took that sign in huge letters to a local Tea Party rally. A couple of people looked askance for my hijacking their carefully controlled message, but in general most Tea Partiers understood how it was gospel truth.
While I appreciate that these people are trying to link the tailspin economy to the wars as a means of ending those wars I can only ask..
Will the time come when the sight of a Child in some foreign land born with no limbs or eyes due to the weapons used against her village, or the sight of a child with all limbs blown off, or a childs body cut in half by a "Precision Guided Munituion" be enough for the masses to rally to call an end to war and the war machine?
Why must it always be how does the war impact me?
Every dollar spent on foreign wars is a dollar that is not invested here at home. All through the Bush years there was no reinvestment in America. Our infrastructure was not maintained. No new infrastructure was built. Few tax dollars were invested in the American people.
We spend more than the rest of the world combined on defense. We spend this money annually and have been for years. We are living the greatest military buildup in world history. We call it defense spending. That is Orwellian doublespeak. Such large sums spent year after year can not honestly be called defensive. What we spend in relation to what all the other countries on the planet spend makes our spending offensive by definition.
It is offensive spending and not defense spending. Let's call a spade a spade. The Spanish Armada was built to be used. Why have we built the greatest war machine in world history? What is the endgame? Let's start calling the DOD the DOO - the Department of Offense.
or they could just revert to the original: Dept. of War.
Personally I call it the DO2D, the Department of Death and Destruction.
Obama is a bigger war criminal than Bush. Obama has escalated our use of evil robotic drone murder machines in Afghanistan and Pakistan. These same drones are soon going to be flying along the Texas/Mexico border and the Arizona/Mexico border. Armed? Soon to be hovering around your house. Drone America marches on... Welcome to Obamadroneland...
And Obama made a "surprise" video appearance at the Netroots convention in Las Vegas and activists to ask for support of his escalating robotic drone murder wars on Afghanis and Pakistanis. Two corporatist imperialist Royalist War Parties to choose from in the 21st century after we sat by dumbfounded as five Supreme fascists staged their coup on 12-12-00 and gave us the very sore loser Bush in the White House for eight years...
Governments and nations act like fearful crowds in panic while the sane individual would not make war on rivals.
Let's Enjoy our short time in the universe, its later than you think.
Doesn't look like the Internets are as fast as we originally had hoped they'd be...
All that money this country has pissed away on making and sustaining war since 9/11 could've created quite a Utopia (such as our ancestors had hoped for when they first came to this country) for its' 300,000,000+ inhabitants.
The U.S. Military Industrial Complex has proven itself to be nothing but a Make Work Program for those desperate, uneducated and a-moral enough to depend on perpetual government welfare to feed and cloth their families!
I'm sure many fine things were done at this gathering, but as long as these folks continue to exclude and marginalize the 9/11 truth movement they are going to keep missing the picture. They think they're aware of how deep government deception runs, but, alas, they're not.
There are some who would argue that it are only the wars - and the paranoid "security" scam - which are keeping the economy going.
They would be wrong.
Prosperity has been curtailed to lure the unemployed (and unemployable) into the recruiting offices.
For "Homeland", read "Fodderland".
Let's give special thanks to the US mainstream media for this disinformation about how this gang used to be so "pwogressive."
AD
Let's give special thanks to the US mainstream media for this disinformation about how this gang used to be so "pwogressive."
AD
Thank You Rick for the review of the meeting.And Cindy congratulations on a new grandchild wow
War =endless profits /peace priceless
peace kg
All wars fail at the end.
Anti-war folks like me are very bright but it doesn't take a rock scientist to figure this out.
Both Iraq and Afghanistan were fought so 0,001% or less of the American population could become even more insanely wealthier than they were before 911.
It had nothing to do with War on Terror, but War of Terrah. Borat was right after all :)
It’s a beginning, a good attempt, but breaking the Obama spell, the hallucinogen in the White House, will not be easy if future attendances remain at 600, most of the nation is still asleep while the busy bees are gathering more power and momentum, the visibility of this movement remains low, whether they tell the truth or not. Noam Chomsky made pre-recorded comments for the United National Peace Conference and what he said doesn’t make me feel hopeful -- any real change for America would mean blood on the streets; a velvet revolution seems unlikely.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GcIVNzcMucU&feature=player_embedded
Someone here at CD said we have 700 military bases spread around the world but it’s actually more than 1000. I live near the site of a new war garrison being built in Europe (with a mission to support the wars in Iraq, Afghanistan, and soon Iran) you can tell by the construction (I have been documenting this with photographs), the renovations at the older base nearby, its soldiers quarters built with stone and marble, an entire micro-America community costing hundreds of millions; the Americans are here to stay for a generation. Soldiers and their families keep to themselves, do all their shopping inside their Little America because they know the sight of an “ugly” American causes anger in the local population. They know they are hated. Not far, in the hills, the U.S. army stores munitions, along with toxic chemicals that have been leaking into the water supply for the last twenty years and causing abnormal amounts of cancer in young and old.
The link between war and the economy is evident even here in this corner of Europe. The local economy benefits little since most of the money goes into the deep pockets of contractors and politicians. The protests of one hundred thousand here did little to change the course of events. I hope the United National Peace Conference movement has better luck.
President Obama wants to cut all federal agencies across the board by 5%. Why? It's because there's no more money to be borrowed, children.
All 50 states have crushing deficits except maybe possibly North Dakota. Why? It's because the federal government has shifted its debt problems on someone else, so you'll blame the states, not the feds. The states in turn are usually shifting the deficits onto the backs of the townships, counties and cities. A shocking number of towns have no library anymore, or they have no police or fire department in a few cases. If you need help call the county police or the state police.
The best way to finance police departments is more traffic tickets. Have you noticed that the main purpose of the police is more and more to collect money from half of us?
If I were a Tea Party protester I would kick and scream and hold my breath until the government acted right. Hey, good luck with that.
The rest of us need to face the reality that the Iraq/Afghanistan war has easily set us back 5 or 6 trillion, and 5% interest on 5 trillion is an extra quarter trillion a year that our government doesn't have. We have collectively been robbed of our life savings in order to protect the profits of some internationally owned corporations. Now the money's gone. If we're lucky we can find a profiteering Bernie Madoff to put into jail and sell his assets, but those assets will not be anywhere near one penny on the dollar.
Other trillions have been spent so that we can give many, many millions of civilians and their grandchildren cancer someday with our H-bomb collection and with our delivery systems. Now doesn't this nuclear war killing capability make you feel all Godly and moral, all warm and fuzzy about what you've accomplished with your money, rather than providing for your own kids, or providing a real life for all those Haitian civilians?
I thought the Cold War ended around 1990. What have we defended ourselves against for 20 years? The Martians?
I think that a few wealthy Republican crooks are deathly afraid that when the rest of us don't have any money for international debt service, we're going to come to them and drill, baby, drill. Well, they might have a point. Where else in the USA are we going to find any more oil?
Progressive movements can get things done, but they have to recognize they may have to go about it in an unconventional way here. Let's allow that we may have to posthaste get moving to supporting a progressives and peaceniks for Powell. We have to recognize that now that the GOP national chairman has called out the current president on war in Afghanistan a black Dwight D Eisenhower in the form of Colin Powell might well be just what the doctor ordered to bring sanity back to both domestic and foreign policy. It worked in 1952 with Ike when the McCarthy era was in full stride, thus how dare we not allow for such an unorthodox strategy today. Let's remember that I F Stone in the 1950s once came out with the slogan "Vote Ike for Peace" and definitely meant it. Who could more easily tell the war mongers to stick it than Powell or tell the gang on Wall Street to bring their green under control or else? Who could more easily put through a national income policy which Gerald Ford advocated in his day as president but likely failed to get it by being tainted with the Watergate brush cutting down so drastically on his popularity?
AD
Any in depth appraisal of the character and actions of General Powell soon makes obvious the self serving nature of this man. In military parlance Powell is referred to as a "water walker",and anyone who has served should understand the reference. He tried to bury the facts about My Lai while adjutant to the joint chiefs and his pre-invasion speech before the UN regarding Iraq ended any questions about his honesty, as he has none:
Mother Jones article
http://tinyurl.com/23c5k62
The U.N. Deception: What Exactly Colin Powell Knew Five Years Ago, and What He Told the World
— By Jonathan Schwarz
| Tue Feb. 5, 2008 1:10 AM PST
Colin Powell presented the case against Iraq to the UN Security Council five years ago today, on February 5, 2003.
As much criticism as Powell has received for this—he calls it "painful" and something that will "always be a part of my record"—it hasn't been close to what's justified. Powell was far more than just horribly mistaken: the evidence is conclusive that he fabricated evidence and ignored repeated warnings that what he was saying was false.
Unfortunately, Congress has never investigated Powell's use of the intelligence he was given. Even so, what's already in the public record is extremely damning. So while the corporate media has never taken a close look at this record, anyone can go through Powell's presentation line by line to examine the chasm between what he knew, and what he told the world. As you see below, there's quite a lot to say about it.
Powell's speech can be found on the State Department website here. All other sources are linked below.
Huh? Does Powell know he's being called to represent a peace movement? I think not...do some research on the man before you volunteer him (though your sentiment is appreciated)
John Lennon - Power To The People ... one more time!!!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wos-dDxpJlQ
This would help too ...
Give Peace A Chance - John Lennon
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I-NRriHlLUk&feature=related
Good choices, dorky! May as well go for the trifecta:
War - Edwin Starr
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_d8C4AIFgUg
___________________________
I didn't catch up to "War" until years after it was released; it's the equivalent of lapidary, unassailable "gospel truth" to me.
And then there's Buffy Sainte-Marie's transcendent "Universal Soldier", and quite a few others I'm too lazy to list.
This Sunday's New York Times has a fairly well written piece describing the huge costs that the conflicts in Afghanistan and Iraq which have cost Americans a startling $1 trillion. The Times notes that this breaks down to $1.1 million a year per soldier who is stationed in Afghanistan and Iraq while $67,000 per year was spent on soldiers during World War II and $132,000 in Vietnam.
The Times closed out its piece by stating that the United States has been "at war for 47 of its 230 years, or 20 percent of its history." But by putting forth this claim the Times totally ignores the fact that since 1947 to the present the CIA has been involved in many covert wars against many Third World countries in order to prop up the authoritarian governments of those countries. Someone should send the editors of that paper a copy of William Blum's Killing Hope which methodically breaks down these many covert and illicit actions that were undertaken by the CIA.
My former HS students had the perfect solution for unemployment: "Join the military." Why create jobs, and especially work towards developing universal health care (not profit-based, employment-based) when such things will make military service less attractive?
Very interesting article and very interesting comments. However if I might add a couple of things; The first casualty of war is truth, that said it may be years before we know the real figures if then. Enough prominate figures in Europian government have exposed the lies that were used to get the US and UK into war with Iraq. This is not new news, with a little searching on the net you can easily find references. But so far no accountability to Americans (the US has made no assertions), or the people of Iraq. These wars stopped being the right thing to do before they began. We Americans are wallowing in corruption, and most definately not serving our best interests. We should pull the plug and bring our troops home.
More positive news on the Hinzman case in Canada where an appeals court ruled in favor of Hinzman sending the refugee claim back to the Immigration board for another review.
The Court has ruled the Immigration board MUST consider "Concientous objector Status" which is did not do in its initial ruling. These means are current deportation orders on hold until the case reviewed.
With that the Conservative party has introduced a bill that would severely limit the number of appeals that could be filed by war resitors that have fled to Canada.
The NDP has introduced another bill which calls for all deportation orders against war resistors to hbe halted.
http://rabble.ca/news/2010/07/american-war-resister-win-another-victory-federal-court
Connecting the dots--it's about time!