Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Wal-Mart Price Pressure Hurts China Workers: Report
BEIJING - Wal-Mart Stores Inc's demand for rock-bottom prices from suppliers in China means some of these companies are forcing their employees to work in sweatshop-like conditions, a new report said on Wednesday.
A shopper looks through clothing at a Wal-Mart store in Alexandria, Virginia November 12, 2009. (Reuters) China Labor Watch said Wal-Mart, which also operates more than 250 stores in China, is failing to pick up on such abuses when it carries out audits of certain suppliers, calling into doubt pledges to source ethically.
"As the world's largest retailer, Wal-Mart leverages its massive product orders to purchase goods at low prices, and workers suffer the financial burden," China Labor Watch, a New York-based rights group, said.
Wal-Mart said it launched an investigation into the five factories referenced in the report after learning of the allegations.
"We take reports like this very seriously, and we will take prompt remedial action if our investigations confirm any of the alleged findings," according to a statement from Wal-Mart spokesman Richard Coyle.
Wal-Mart, the world's largest retailer and with more than 60,000 suppliers worldwide, procures billions of dollars worth of goods directly from China every year.
The company said last year that it would enforce stricter quality and environmental standards for its army of Chinese suppliers.
But in some factories run by Wal-Mart suppliers, China Labor Watch found pay was withheld to workers who did not meet production targets, and employees who were given only poor quality food or accommodation.
In two of the factories, workers were banned from wearing gloves, lest it slowed production, the report said.
"Worst of all, two of the factories have rules forcing workers to lie to Wal-Mart auditors, forcing workers into silence as Wal-Mart turns a blind eye to sweatshop conditions," the report said.
While China Labor Watch noted that Wal-Mart had "responded enthusiastically" to help factories which do not meet standards, there had been no overall, systematic improvement.
"Wal-Mart has basic standards which it must implement," China Labor Watch said.
"It has the size and power to be an industry leader, and this will not come from Ethical Standards Program initiatives alone but also from major change to Wal-Mart's corporate practices, including increased investment in the audit system and careful review of purchasing practices," it added.
"The case of Wal-Mart, the world's largest retailer, shows that corporate codes of conduct and factory auditing are not enough by themselves to strengthen workers' rights if corporations are unwilling to pay the real price it costs to produce a product according to the standards in their codes."
(Reporting by Ben Blanchard and Emma Graham-Harrison; Additional reporting by Nicole Maestri in San Francisco; Editing by Alex Richardson, Bernard Orr)



10 Comments so far
Show AllWalmart will send a message to the Chinese govt. to SILENCE the reports coming out of the factories...they don't care about human-rights...all you have to do is to look at how they treat their employees in their stores to see how contemptuous they are towards American workers!!
The Chinese govt. will take care of the rest...human rights in China....R I G H T !!!!
duh!
How amazing, we have turned the whole comunist power of Red China into our own corporate slave colony, while insisting they carry our debt! We have got them to pay us to enslave them.....
It's a little like an S&M script,
Anyway it wont last, so ENJOY!
Low prices are to the consumer what candy is to the tooth.
Walmart has a dark side, a very big dark side. There are better ways to live that do not include giving them your money.
This is not new news, folks. I've seen lots of shows on the Wal-Mart situation, as well as other companies, over there. Maybe it's getting even worse now, but it is not new. Add to that the fact that Wal-Mart and Amazon are in a price war right now over books and CDs and such, and Borders and Barnes and Noble are in big, big trouble. One of them may not even make it through the holiday season -- this year's Circuit City, I guess. These big-box book sellers put the little guys out of business and now Wal-Mart and Amazon are putting their large competitors out of business. Race to the bottom? In every respect. And I believe that CDs and DVDs are also made in China now -- or at least my brother told me this last night.
The sad thing is that the stagnant wages in the U.S. have made Wal-Mart the phenom that it is, especially now that house-as-ATM and lack of credit has forced families to survive on what they make and it's not easy. Enter Wal-Mart. Wal-Mart is nothing to cheer about.
Getting high pay and cheap bargains is the only form of happiness most Americans are ever exposed to. Just a consummer driven brain-power dictatorship with everyone a blind slave to the next man more intelligent.
Even sadder than the PTSD returning soldiers deal with is this soul deadening consumerism that passes for happiness. Happiness is not even a component of this addiction, not remotely connected to it in any way. The lie that happiness can be bought by buying material goods is the greatest coup ever pulled off by Madison avenue. Its success is as phenomenal as it is tragic.
When the poor shopping addict feels the pain of emptiness most acutely, relief cannot wait for the time and effort it would take to read the great mystics of any religion. If drugs won't provide relief more shopping is the only alternative.
For anyone who is so addicted, a short cut to real food for the soul is THE PERENNIAL PHILOSOPHY BY Aldous Huxley. Unfortunately even this short cut requires the sick person to recognize her addiction and have a desperate desire to get well, but when a taste for the higher is found, any desire for the lower is either gone or is easily overcome.
Intelligence is not a requisite. Anyone who can read can learn to develop an intense longing for what has meaning and know getting and spending for what they are.
WAL-MART ---- INTELLIGENCE DICTATORSHIP
Have a ten year running battle with Wal-Mart, it started when I ran for Sheriff on a most liberal platform and was using the Wal-Mart parking lot for most of my campaigning. And now as I help to organize a Wal-Mart union.
Store manager harassment, threats to have their security haul me to jail, having the police hit me with illegal traffic tickets, banging on my home at 2 a.m. threatening to do me harm, goons threatening me as I walk the streets, and all in the name of good natured free market capitalism.
Surely they only thing that will make Wal-Mart honest is laws that give them no choice to be fair and honest.
Good laws would be welcome, but it sounds like work like your own is the heart of this. Anti-scabbing laws existed, and when Reagan entered office, he announced that these would not be enforced, and largely they were not.
We need to vote the goons out, red or blue, and certainly we need those laws, but none of this happens without union: union now, union tomorrow, and union purchases when we go to spend our wages.
As an old but too often ignored point, we might note the considerable synergy between the interest of Chinese workers and American worker and "Main Street" economy here. Buying from Walmart supports the oppression of Chinese workers that allows American companies to offshore jobs.
If workers understood what they pay for when they purchase, Wal-Mart would bust in a quarter.