Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
No Flies on S.F.'s New Composting Law
San Franciscans have six more weeks before they're required to toss their food scraps into green composting bins or face a fine - but apparently all the trash talk coming out of City Hall is already having an effect.
Pamela Mazzola, chef of Boulevard, puts food scraps placed inside corn-based bags into the green compost bin for pickup. (Photo: Brant Ward / The Chronicle)
Just a few months ago, the city Department of the Environment was doling out five to 10 green composting bins a day; now that number is up to 130. The amount of composted material coming out of San Francisco is up 15 percent over the past few months - now totaling 480 tons every day.
"There's a real sense of urgency now," said Jared Blumenfeld, director of the Environment Department. "We never heard from these folks and, suddenly, they're saying, 'How do you do it?' "
Each day, Blumenfeld's department sends five or six people schooled in composting to apartment buildings, homes and businesses to show people how to get started - and to help them find the space for another bin in this tightly packed city. In some particularly crowded neighborhoods like Chinatown, homeowners are already banding together to share a bin.
And eco-conscious tenants who were frustrated that their landlords didn't have composting bins on-site are now pointing to the law and getting their way, Blumenfeld said.
"It's definitely achieving the intended results - people want to make sure they're in compliance," he said of the legislation proposed by Mayor Gavin Newsom and passed by the Board of Supervisors in June.
Starting Oct. 21, every home and business in the city must have three separate color-coded bins for waste: black for trash, blue for recycling - and now green for composting. Failure to sort trash initially will result in several warnings, but ultimately could lead to fines of up to $1,000 in egregious cases.
The city's requirement - first of its kind in the nation - is part of a larger plan to have San Franciscans sending nothing to landfills or incinerators by 2020. City officials say the city currently diverts 72 percent of its waste.
San Franciscans' food scraps are trucked by the company Recology to Vacaville, where they're processed for 90 days. Then, the scraps are sold to farms, vineyards and golf courses around the region.
Kathleen Inman, owner of Olivet Grange Vineyard and Inman Family Wines in Sonoma County, said that lately she hasn't been able to buy all the composted material she needs because the facility can't produce it fast enough. She said she's excited that San Francisco will soon be producing more food scraps for her vines.
"When people come to my tasting room from San Francisco, I always ask them, 'Do you compost?' and if not, I tell them they need to," she said.
Some of San Francisco's most avid composters are restaurants. For 10 years, garbage collection companies have given price breaks to restaurants that compost. Now about 3,500 of the city's 4,200 restaurants are participating.
In a circle-of-life kind of way, Inman sells her wine to Charles Phan, owner of Slanted Door and other restaurants in the city. Phan has been composting for many years, and his restaurants' scraps may wind up fertilizing Inman's vines. Phan said his restaurants divert about 85 percent of their waste away from landfills.
Pamela Mazzola, chef at Boulevard, has been composting at her home for decades - and for several years at her restaurant. She said everyone "from the busboys up to the CEO" has been trained on sorting trash properly.
"I am the poster child for composting - that's the only time anyone ever calls me, to talk about compost or garbage," she said with a laugh.
Bob Shaffer, a composting consultant for Recology and a lifetime composter, said the city's "extreme step" is essential, even if people elsewhere in the country view it as one of those only-in-San Francisco laws.
"I really believe in this program so if they're out there on it, they're out there in the right area," he said.
- Posted in



20 Comments so far
Show AllI think this is great!!
Seattle has been doing this for residential waste since April and will eventually include businesses.
Many Seattle residents report downsizing to a 5 gallon garbage "can" that is not much larger than an orange crate. By putting food scraps, garden clippings, paper, cardboard,select plastics, glass and metals in the recycling containers, there isn't much left to go into the garbage.
That's right and all this makes people think about waste well before they are going to throw something out. If we all thought carefully about disposal when we are shopping to buy something, we could, by our purchasing power, convince vendors to use environmentally safe packaging.
If the manufacturer was financially responsible for the costs of the recycling, the use of recyclable materials and (reduction in packaging bulk) would skyrocket!
Wow! Talk about smart! Now if we could only talk everyone into doing the same thing...
Wonderful! Thank you San Fran!
look out for one another........ see ultimatecivics.com
It is great except that a lot of the composted stuff has poison chemicals from the vegetarian matter which wind up in your wine and garden food.
So the next step will be very difficult...akin to the current battle with the insurance corporations.
How to grow food without adding harmful pesticides.
There is no doubt in my mind that the human cancer rate is connected with the food we ingest.
We have a huge pile of free composted dirt at our local dump but I won't put it on my vegetable garden because I don't know what is in it.
But as usual...San Francisco is leading the way and deserves kudos!
Jeevee
Vert essential comment. Thank you, Lilsy, and all the best to you! DO KEEP GOING.
I asked myself the same question, and recalled what I'd recently heard about on NPR, namely - Green Chemistry. Is there a new world view out there?
Here are some links, for starters:
http://www.epa.gov/greenchemistry/
http://www.rsc.org/Publishing/Journals/gc/
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_chemistry
We live in the woods in a tree. We have a compost pile for vegetable scraps, and egg shells and such. That eventually gets mixed in with the dirt in our vegetable garden. We also have a composting toilet. That waste eventually gets mixed in with the dirt in our flower garden. It was suggested to me that a year is sufficient time for vegetable and human waste to be usable. Nothing is hurried. It takes time for it all to process. I had never thought of any of this until I moved into the woods. I missed out on the nature of all of this for most of my life. I am so grateful to be getting in to it now at 58. Good for San Francisco.
And good for you. I've often thought how much earth moving expense could be saved if a properly designed suspension system for a house was attached to four or more sturdy trees in a grove. As far as living in one tree as you do, it must have a large trunk. How many square feet do you have and how do you adjust to annual growth?
Actually, thank you for asking, it is figuratively a tree house, in that a three trunk tree enters the floor at about 10 feet off the ground, and nine large branches exit through the roof at about 10-12 feet above the floor. I was going to suspend it from the tree, but after seeing the different ways to accomplish it, decided to support it from poles (16) spread evenly across the floor joists. I used 4X4s and later doubled six of them to 4X8. There is approx 1 inch clearance around each trunk at floor level and approx 3-4 inches around each branch. This allows for movement in winds. The branches move quite a bit during strong winds, but have not touched the surrounding roof yet. We had an 80 mph gust a few months back and the house took a slight bump, but if I hadn't been expecting it, probably would not have noticed. There are approximately 700 square feet floor space in the house itself, and a approx 150 sq ft utility room below under one section. The house is hexagonal. I have a few pictures of it on myspace, stanfield-morris, particularly on page 2 of the pics. We have pretty much all the conveniences except a flush toilet. We have water service and electricity, and wood burning heat so far with electric backup. We got away without septic or sewer. We have gray water system (sink, shower, washer)and compost for everything else. Still need to make adjustments, but beginning the second year here.
Fantastic. The hexagonal shape must help direct the winds around the house. I hope it catches on. A neighborhood of houses in trees would be quite handsome and environmentally friendly. I live in a 12 X 70 on about 1/3 acre in Vermont.
What is strange is that the county in which I live seems to prefer a septic tank for garbage disposal waste and such to compost. I would think that natural disposal/recycling would be much preferred. I think it is better regulated to require a verified, inspected septic system rather than compost, where there is no record, no permit, and no legal standards or guidelines to enforce. I can understand, because I have a feeling that there are places out here in the area where raw sewage might be dumped. There is a dump station for RV's and such, where we dumped a 5 gallon sewage container while we lived in a tent when building the house. But, I think some just dump containers over embankments and let it seep into the ground which I think is very uncool. I would say those cases are few and far between, though, and I can't say for sure that it is done at all. I've just heard stories. I thought I'd throw that in since this article was on composting.
What if instead of composting, you throw leftover food out the window from your tree? That would feed bigger animals besides earthworms.
The earthworms love our compost piles. As far as bigger animals, they already treat themselves with cat food if we don't keep the utility room door shut. We have a "kitty" door in it. Raccoons and opossums and squirrels frequent our property, but our two dogs are VERY hazardous to the health of the Raccoons and Opossums. I quit trying to break up the carnage after becoming a casualty of one. The dogs don't know what is between their teeth when there is a frenzy going on. So let the furry creature beware!
I hope someone is checking the final output for toxic wastes, heavy metals etc.
It's only food scraps, not everything-organic-matter scraps.
fantastic, the USA is slowly catching up with "backwards" europe. National composting has been happening in Germany for at least ten years [the amount of time i lived there] and probably a lot longer. germany also has national mandatory recycling. trash pick up occurs only every two weeks and the size of the container is about 12 to 14 inches square and the same depth. you can have a bit larger container but at a huge increase in cost. the most interesting aspect of this is the difference in cultural thinking. the europeans saw this as a necessity while the americans see it as an inconvenience that will upset the money gods.