
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FREE NEWSLETTER
Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.
5
#000000
#FFFFFF
To donate by check, phone, or other method, see our More Ways to Give page.

Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.
"We are running out of road, and the latest text shows just how far governments have allowed fossil fuel interests to steer the negotiations off course," said one campaigner.
As the United Nations Climate Change Conference in Antalya, Türkiye entered overtime on Friday, advocates of heeding scientists' calls to rapidly phase out planet-heating fossil fuels intensified pressure on governments to end the trend of previous summits and wrap up COP31 with a truly ambitious agreement.
Reuters reported from the summit that Ralph Regenvanu—climate minister of Vanuatu, a South Pacific island nation that faces rising seas and worsening storms—warned, "We can see where it's going, and it's not going to be a high-ambition text."
The latest cover decision draft, released Thursday, the eve of when the conference was supposed to conclude, cut language on the "transition away from fossil fuels," and instead calls for a "transition towards low greenhouse gas emissions and climate-resilient development." It also eliminated a reference to the $120 billion needed for climate finance for the Global South by 2035.
"I'm struggling to find the words for the sadness, heartbreak, and disbelief I feel watching what is unfolding at COP31. How is this possible?" said Kumi Naidoo, president of the Fossil Fuel Non-Proliferation Treaty Initiative and founding chair of Africans Rising for Justice, Peace, and Dignity.
"What breaks my heart is that we know what is at stake," he stressed. "People are losing their homes, their livelihoods, and their lives. Communities are struggling to hold on to places that have sustained their cultures for generations. Entire countries are fighting for their survival."
Naidoo declared: "Imagine Alcoholics Anonymous spending 30 years negotiating and producing a statement that never mentions alcohol. Now imagine the alcohol industry turning up as the largest delegation and helping shape the outcome."
Texas Tech University professor Katharine Hayhoe similarly said, "A climate deal that leaves out fossil fuels is like a plan to quit smoking that never mentions cigarettes."
Some government representatives at the summit are also frustrated. UN News reported Friday that "led by France and Panama, ministers and representatives from across the world including Belgium, Côte d'Ivoire, Finland, Greece, Guatemala, Spain, Sweden and Vanuatu, joined forces to demand stronger climate action."
That coalition of countries' six priorities for a COP31 agreement are:
Separately, in a letter obtained by Politico, the European Union warned that COP31 is at risk of turning into a "fossil fuel summit," and the latest draft text would be "perceived as a retreat from previous commitments, and as disproportionately accommodating the interests of continued fossil fuel production and consumption."
The 27-member bloc's climate commissioner, Wopke Hoekstra, and Ireland's climate minister, Darragh O'Brien, wrote that "the EU must be clear that it cannot join consensus on a package that would represent a substantive step backwards for global climate action."
Laurie van der Burg, global public finance lead at the advocacy group Oil Change International, responded that "the EU is trying to shift blame onto others and it is deeply hypocritical. While we welcome calls to reaffirm the commitment to transition away from fossil fuels, the EU did not show the leadership needed to deliver it. At the beginning of COP31, it signaled it was prepared to drop the renewables ask from the electrification target and it has failed to put forward an EU fossil fuel transition roadmap."
"Even worse, the EU blocked progress on the public finance, adaptation, and just transition that developing countries urgently need," she noted. "These are not side issues. They are essential to making a fair fossil fuel phaseout possible and protecting communities from climate disasters. The EU came to COP31 with a hardline position on finance showing no willingness to be constructive. The EU is cowardly trying to deceive and frame the outcome of this COP, but it's obvious: the EU is pointing fingers at others while refusing to show any leadership itself."
Oil Change has also sounded the alarm about the inclusion of language on carbon capture and storage (CCS) and carbon removal in the draft, with global policy lead Romain Ioualalen declaring that "governments must stop treating the cover decision text like a fossil fuel executive's wish list. We are running out of road, and the latest text shows just how far governments have allowed fossil fuel interests to steer the negotiations off course."
"An outcome that should fast-track a fair and funded transition away from fossil fuels instead opens the door to more fossil gas, and gives dangerous credibility to disproven technologies like CCS that will trap us in our dependence on the volatile fossil fuel economy," he added. "These CCS paragraphs are a real and immediate danger to the energy transition and need to be removed. This isn't a pathway out of the crisis. It's a license to prolong it. Governments have a last chance to turn this around."
Fanny Petitbon, policy analyst at the group 350.org, similarly said that "carbon capture is the biggest scam in the era of overshoot, and our leaders could be very much falling for it. Taken together, these paragraphs would lock in decades more fossil fuel use and pull money and attention away from the solutions that already work: renewables, efficiency and a just transition away from fossil fuels. We cannot let unproven technologies distract from what science demands: a fast, fair and full phaseout of fossil fuels."
Recent studies have found that temporarily surpassing the Paris Agreement's 1.5°C threshold for temperature rise this century, relative to preindustrial levels, is now inevitable, and the world is headed for "an irrecoverable overshoot" of that target unless governments "rapidly reduce emissions to limit both the magnitude and duration."
There have been various positive developments at the summit in Antalya, from the Ministerial Declaration on Accelerating Action on Super Pollutants and the launch of the Global SF6 Pledge, to $30 million in new investments in the Global Fund for Coral Reefs, but activists like Fenton Lutunatabua, 350.org's Pacific and Caribbean lead, remain worried about the final deal.
"For the Pacific, 1.5°C is the last line of defense," Lutunatabua said. "The latest COP31 cover decision has eliminated all mention of the transition away from fossil fuels. These may just be words to you, but to us they represent the line between survival and extinction. The Pacific cannot be remembered as what the world allowed to disappear. This is a final call on world leaders to save their COP31 legacy: Secure an outcome aligned with 1.5°C, set the roadmaps for a fossil fuel phaseout, and fund our futures. For us, this is nonnegotiable."
“The only ones who would benefit from BAAJA are industry executives.”
Fossil fuels industry watchdog Oil Change International on Thursday criticized a bipartisan permitting reform bill for failing address the climate crisis or stop what it described as "skyrocketing" energy costs for consumers.
Citing data fromRhodium Group, which recently studied the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 (BAAJA), Oil Change found that even with the bill’s passage, electricity prices are still projected to increase by around 8% by 2040.
While this is a smaller increase than the 13% hike over the same period absent the BAAJA's passage, the group nonetheless found that "the bill’s savings are overshadowed by the increases."
"For example, according to Rhodium, in the Mid Emissions Scenario with BAAJA, the bill is seen to shave $50 off the average annual bill, or just over $4 a month," Oil Change explained. "But our calculation shows the average annual bill in 2040 would still be over $157 higher than in 2025, or over $13 a month. Households that are already struggling to afford to keep their electricity on today will not see relief from rising energy bills under BAAJA."
The group also cited a number of other factors contributing to higher energy prices that aren't addressed in the bill, including "rising electricity demand from data centers, extreme climate events spiking energy costs in winter, wildfires and storms repeatedly destroying infrastructure that needs to be rebuilt, excessive utility profits, and overdependence on increasingly expensive fossil gas."
The bottom line, wrote Oil Change, is the BAAJA "does not address affordability or the climate crisis," but is instead "a massive gift to the Trump administration, Big Oil, and Big Tech."
Oil Change's analysis earned an endorsement from fellow environmental watchdog Food and Water Watch.
"The only ones who would benefit from BAAJA are industry executives," the group wrote in a social media post.
The Senate is expected to hold a final vote on BAAJA in the coming days. If it passes, the bill would go to the Republican-controlled US House of Representatives, which has a narrow window to act on it before Democrats take over both chambers of Congress in January.
US Sen. Ron Wyden's amendment comes amid a reported push by the US Department of the Interior to identify federal lands that can be used for data centers.
US Sen. Ron Wyden on Thursday slammed Republicans for blocking a vote on his amendment to a bipartisan permitting reform bill that would bar the construction of data centers on public lands.
According to a Thursday report in The Hill, Wyden (D-Ore.) has been holding up votes on the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 (BAAJA), which has been criticized by environmental groups as a giveaway to the fossil fuels industry, because his data center amendment is not currently up for consideration.
In a Thursday social media post, Wyden explained his rationale for holding up the legislation.
"Republicans are blocking a vote on my amendment to ban data centers on public lands," Wyden wrote, adding that BAAJA achieves Sen. Mike Lee’s (R-Utah) "fever dream of giving away your public lands to tech giants."
Wyden proposed his amendment weeks after The Washington Sun reported that the US Department of the Interior, under the leadership of Secretary Doug Burgum, has pushed the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) to “identify public land ripe for data center development,” and provide lists to department leadership.
Earlier this month, ProPublica reported that Burgum stands to personally profit from data center construction on public lands, as he has anywhere between $18.1 million and $64.4 million invested in artificial intelligence companies.
Environmental advocacy organization Earthjustice recently highlighted provisions in BAAJA that it said would open up public lands for data center development in an action alert.
"Buried within more than 400 pages of dense legislative text," Earthjustice wrote, "the Senate permitting bill includes provisions that would put public lands on the chopping block, enable fast delivery of gas to fuel the artificial intelligence data center build-out, threaten historic and cultural sites, give handouts to oil and gas companies, lock in deep-sea mining for years to come, and codify illegal permits."
Environmental groups aren't the only ones rallying opposition to building data centers on federal lands.
As Washington State Standard reported on Tuesday, a coalition of veterans groups called Veterans for Public Lands called for the halt of data centers built on public lands.
“These are our lands,” Gregg Bafundo, a senior adviser of the coalition and former ranger of the Okanogan Wenatchee National Forest, told Washington State Standard. "If the government’s going to do anything with these, they have to ask the permission of the American people. And right now, the American people don’t want data centers on our public lands."
One expert said the analysis makes clear that the war-related crisis "has irrevocably changed the global energy system, adding to the many reasons why countries would benefit from a rapid transition to clean energy."
High-polluting countries like the US are continuing to push for oil and gas extraction, but despite the unwavering commitment of leaders like President Donald Trump to fossil fuels, a report released Thursday by the International Energy Agency says that Trump's own war on Iran made "vulnerabilities in traditional fossil fuel supply systems" clearer than ever.
“I don’t see any credible pathway for the energy world to return to the way it was before,” said Fatih Birol, the IEA's executive director, as the Paris-based agency released its "World Energy Outlook 2026."
The vulnerability that is inherent in countries' fossil fuel dependence became impossible to ignore this year as Iran swiftly retaliated against Trump and Israeli President Benjamin Netanyahu after they launched the war. Iranian officials effectively closed the Strait of Hormuz, which about 20% of the world's oil supply passes through, and sent energy prices skyrocketing.
"The world has been through several major oil supply shocks since 1970," said the agency. "The current crisis is by far the largest."
The IEA coordinated the release of 400 million barrels of crude oil in an attempt to stabilize energy markets, but Birol said a "range of energy futures" are likely to emerge from the upheaval, which “delivered a huge shock to the system."
Mohamed Adow, director of Power Shift Africa, told The Associated Press that "this crisis has exposed the price of fossil fuel dependence. It’s crazy that a conflict thousands of miles away can send energy bills soaring at home.”
“With the world on the brink of breaching 1.5°C of global warming and climate impacts rapidly worsening, world leaders must drastically change course and help secure a healthier, safer world powered by clean, affordable energy for all.”
The war will likely ultimately lead to countries reducing their dependence on the Strait of Hormuz, the IEA forecast, estimating that the 20 million barrels of oil per day that passed through the waterway could be reduced to 8.5 million by 2030 and under 2 million by 2035.
Meanwhile, renewable energy sources, especially solar power, as well as nuclear power, are set to be the “biggest beneficiaries” as governments rethink their energy supply.
The IEA report emphasizes that consumers are already responding to the oil and gas shock of 2026 by turning to electric vehicles and solar panels.
The report was released as leaders assembled in Antalya, Türkiye head into their final days of negotiations at the United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP31), with the latest draft of an agreement leaving advocates dismayed by failing to include a call for a transition away from fossil fuels—even though both the economic realities described in the IEA report and the worsening climate emergency demand such a transition.
“The IEA’s latest report makes clear that the fossil energy crisis unleashed by the US-Israel war on Iran has irrevocably changed the global energy system, adding to the many reasons why countries would benefit from a rapid transition to clean energy and electrification," said Rachel Cleetus, climate program director at the Union of Concerned Scientists. “The future of the energy system and our climate are inextricably intertwined. World leaders at COP31 must stand up to fossil fuel enablers and commit to a fast, fair transition away from all fossil fuels to renewable energy, and ramping up energy efficiency."
“The Trump administration’s attacks on clean energy policies and boosting of fossil fuels is only serving the interests of large fossil fuel polluters who are raking in billions in profits while people struggle to afford basic necessities. It’s time for the newly elected Congress to reverse the harms, keep the administration in check, and hold fossil fuel companies accountable for the damages they are causing," added Cleetus. “With the world on the brink of breaching 1.5°C of global warming and climate impacts rapidly worsening, world leaders must drastically change course and help secure a healthier, safer world powered by clean, affordable energy for all.”
The term "fossil fuels" did not appear in the draft, released one day before the conference is set to close.
The latest draft of the cover decision released Thursday at the United Nations Climate Change Conference in Antalya, Türkiye asserts that negotiators aim to keep the goal of limiting planetary heating to 1.5°C "within reach."
Less clear is how leaders plan to do that, considering all mentions of transitioning away from fossil fuel energy—and even the term "fossil fuels"—were eliminated from the draft that was published with one day to go until the summit's close.
Language regarding the “transition away from fossil fuels," which scientists and energy experts have long agreed is imperative in order to limit the global temperature rise to 1.5°C above preindustrial temperatures, had been included in the 18-page draft that was released Monday.
In the document released Thursday, negotiators instead pledged a “transition towards low greenhouse gas emissions and climate-resilient development," and called for "concrete solutions to accelerate" that less ambitious transition.
They wrote that the goal of keeping "1.5° within reach" and limiting the overshoot remained, "recognizing that countries will take different pathways and solutions."
The draft did not appear compatible with multiple reports that have been released by United Nations agencies in recent weeks, warning that countries must take action to rapidly reduce fossil fuel emissions in order to have any hope of ensuring an overshoot of the 1.5°C threshold—now considered to be inevitable—is only temporary.
Climate Action Tracker released an analysis last week emphasizing that "a transition away from fossil fuels" is a key lever "that could cut emissions at the speed and urgency needed to follow" a pathway aligned with the Paris Agreement of 2015, which identified and secured commitments regarding the 1.5°C threshold.
Advocates were dismayed not only by the absence of any mention of fossil fuels, but also by the inclusion of carbon capture and storage (CCS) "and other unscientific and costly carbon removal technologies," which experts warn would undermine the energy transition.
Jasper Inventor, who has led Greenpeace's delegation at COP31, told The Guardian that the new draft "dangerously adds the option of a carbon capture and storage target to the mix" in a move that was "profoundly unacceptable."
“The [United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change] process has never had such a target and anything that provides a way for the fossil fuel industry to keep polluting the climate would be a profound backwards step at a time when climate impacts are rapidly worsening," Inventor said.
At last year's summit in Belém, Brazil, more than 500 lobbyists promoting carbon capture, which has been called "a lifeline for fossil fuels," gained access to the negotiations, and Romain Ioualalen, global policy lead at Oil Change International, said the text released Thursday once again had "the fingerprints of fossil fuel interests all over it."
"Governments have managed to remove almost everything that would actually signal countries are serious about phasing out fossil fuels," said Ioualalen. "Instead they’re playing sycophant to the fossil fuel industry, leaving the door wide open for failed technologies like CCS and more fossil gas. The crucial call to accelerate the transition away from fossil fuels is so diluted it might as well be absent."
Advocates also noted that the new text proposed a launch of an “Antalya-to-Addis Ababa Roadmap on Adaptation and Resilience Finance” initiative—a reference to next year's conference in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia—but no longer mentioned the figure of $120 billion needed for climate finance for the Global South by 2035—"the bare minimum rich countries should have committed to in Antalya," according to 350.org.
Andreas Sieber, head of political strategy for 350.org, said the conference is "on the brink of an outrageous and utterly embarrassing lack of leadership by the COP31 presidencies," held this year by Türkiye and Australia. "Rich countries’ failure on finance is a historic disgrace. They expect developing countries to shoulder the costs of a global transition while refusing to provide the means to deliver it. This is not a failure of technical negotiations. It is a shameless abdication of political responsibility. If this is where COP31 lands, history will remember it as a summit where those entrusted with leadership chose the comfort of inaction over the courage to confront reality.”
A target of ensuring that 35% of energy is derived from electricity by 2035 remained in the draft on Thursday, but was listed as a "voluntary" option countries can take "in accordance with their national circumstances and development priorities."
Rukiya Khamis, East Africa lead for 350.org, said that "electrification that masquerades as green yet opens the door to more fossil fuel use is not what we came here for."
"Africa needs to electrify with renewables to keep people safe, lower bills, and create green jobs and industries," said Khamis. "We cannot build this future on crumbs thrown by rich polluting nations. Governments are spending around $1 trillion on fossil fuel subsidies. But at COP31 they have only pledged $50 million for adaptation, and the draft text delays agreeing on a baseline for tripling adaptation finance with yet another process. If that isn’t fixed, Ethiopia will be left to clean up the mess that rich nations, particularly European nations, made in Antalya by blocking climate finance."
"Developing countries and frontline communities don’t need another process, they need the money," Khamis added. "COP31 must set the baseline now and get it delivered. Anything less is a cruel injustice and an insult we will not accept.”
The draft was released a day after Juan Carlos Navarro, Panama's environment minister, warned that negotiators at the meeting were "being held hostage by the petroleum mafia" and had been "stricken by Stockholm disease."
"We are being held hostage by the petroleum mafia," says @juancanavarro. https://t.co/CEgPrdCy3k
— Fossil Fuel Treaty Initiative (@fossiltreaty) November 18, 2026
"They are so smart that they have convinced us that they are actually doing this for our own good," said Navarro. "They destroy our planet for our own good. They destroy nature to help us... We must look forward, tell the truth, and act with urgency in our own national interest."
Navarro, leading Panama's delegation, wrote a letter Thursday to the COP31 presidencies saying the country would block any outcome of the talks that does not meet its demands. The final agreement out of the meeting must be unanimous.
"While we listen to endless oratory, the planet is being destroyed," said Navarro, who has pushed for a cap on oil production. "Outside this room and this conference, the world needs and expects radical change from us, and we are not delivering it... Accordingly, I inform you that Panama will not join any consensus, and will formally object in the closing plenaries, to the adoption of any decision that does not lead to an outcome satisfactory to our principles and our values.”
“Panama will not lend its name to an outcome that continues to ignore and attempts to excuse each nation’s individual responsibility," he added, "and by so doing prolongs and worsens the crisis."
The rapid data center build-out represents the "nail in the coffin for the planet’s life support systems," said one expert.
With the US and China turning to fossil fuels to power the data centers that the countries are pushing to rapidly build, the International Energy Agency said in its annual World Energy Outlook on Thursday that planet-heating emissions from the facilities are projected to rise by 70% by 2030.
The two countries are not alone in pushing for the expansion of massive data centers, which require large amounts of energy to operate and cool continuously running servers.
But the IEA noted that in the European Union, developers are expected to use renewable energy for about 70% of their data center needs by 2030. In Canada, the agency identified plans for 11 gigawatts of gas generation to power data centers over the next four years, and in the rest of the world, developers are expected to use gas plants for their energy needs with a combined capacity of just 4 gigawatts.
Developers in the US, meanwhile, currently have plans for about 180 gigawatts of new gas-fired plants to power their data centers, and the country is expected to rely on gas for about 60% of its electricity needs for the facilities.
In China, about half of data centers' electricity will come from coal-fired plants by the end of the decade.
The IEA's report was released a day after 14 Democrats in the US Congress joined Republicans in advancing the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA), a key permitting reform bill that would speed up fossil fuel projects and artificial intelligence data centers by limiting environmental reviews.
Christopher Wright, a professor at the University of Sydney and author of Organizing Responses to Climate Change, said the IEA report showed that the rapid data center build-out represents the "nail in the coffin for the planet’s life support systems."
The report was released as world leaders continued negotiations at the United Nations Climate Change Conference in Antalya, Türkiye, where campaigners, scientists, and policymakers have demanded a final agreement that includes concrete commitments to phase out the emissions that are projected to explode due to data centers.
The Climate Action Tracker said last week that without decisive action to slash fossil fuel emissions, the planet is headed for an "irrevocable overshoot" of the 1.5°C limit set by the Paris climate agreement in 2015. UN agencies have also warned in recent weeks that avoiding at least a temporary overshoot of the threshold is no longer possible, and drawing down fossil fuel emissions is now needed to ensure the breach is only temporary.
Following the disruption to world energy markets by the Iran War started by Israel and the US earlier this year, IEA executive director Fatih Birol said Thursday that he does not "see any credible pathway for the energy world to return to the way it was before."
Policy decisions, suggested the IEA, including those regarding how to power artificial intelligence and data centers, will determine the world's energy and climate future.
"Schumer’s alignment with Republicans... in voting to advance this terrible pro-polluter, pro-data center permitting bill is all the reason needed to demand that Schumer step down as leader."
An environmental advocate is calling for Sen. Chuck Schumer to step down as Senate Democratic leader after he supported a permitting reform bill that critics say will empower polluters by weakening environmental regulations.
Schumer (D-NY), the Senate minority leader, was one of 14 Democrats who voted Wednesday to advance the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA), which cleared a procedural vote 65-31.
The bill would speed up the permitting process for energy and infrastructure projects by limiting environmental reviews and restricting the ability to challenge permitting decisions in court.
Democratic supporters of the bill celebrate it as a way to speed up the approval of clean energy infrastructure and drive down energy costs, pointing to projections that it will result in modest emissions reductions. But environmental groups warn the bill will also clear the way for much faster approval of fossil fuel infrastructure and artificial intelligence data centers, exposing communities on the front lines to the harms of industrial pollution.
Jim Walsh, the policy director at Food & Water Watch, said, "Sen. Schumer’s alignment with Republicans over a majority of his own Democratic caucus in voting to advance this terrible pro-polluter, pro-data center permitting bill is all the reason needed to demand that Schumer step down as leader of the Senate Democrats."
“Sadly, Schumer has failed to learn the primary lesson from last week’s midterm elections—that Americans are fed up with unchecked aggression from Big Tech and the out-of-control construction of AI data centers,” Walsh said. In virtually every local election in which data centers were on the ballot, voters opted to reject them in their communities.
“Time and again throughout this Congress, Schumer has supported the status quo. But the American people are loudly demanding real change," Walsh added. "Schumer must step down from party leadership for good."
Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.), who is challenging Schumer in the race for Senate majority leader, voted against the bill on Wednesday.
Like many Democrats who supported the legislation, Schumer framed his vote as a response to Americans’ concerns about high energy costs, an issue that helped fuel historic wins for the party nationwide.
“Americans are paying too much for energy, and we need to do something about it," Schumer said in a statement earlier this month. "For too long, our broken permitting system has held back cleaner, cheaper energy; driven up costs; and delayed good-paying jobs."
Erik Schlenker-Goodrich, executive director of the Western Environmental Law Center, has pushed back against this framing.
"This bill is being deceptively pushed as an ‘affordability’ bill when those benefits are at best meager, speculative, and won’t be felt for more than a decade while the harms to the people and places we love will start the moment this abomination of a bill is signed into law," he said.
According to an analysis by the Rhodium Group published earlier this month, BAAJA would reduce annual household electricity bills by just $41 to $66 by 2035, equivalent to about $3.42 to $5.50 per month.
Columbia University's Center on Global Energy Policy has projected that electricity costs may actually increase for Americans in the short term because construction costs could be passed along to consumers before savings are realized.
Meanwhile, many of the environmental effects from increased fossil fuel use and data center construction, such as water and air pollution, could be felt much sooner. Public health groups, including the American Public Health Association, have warned that BAAJA could increase rates of asthma, cardiovascular disease, certain cancers, and premature births by increasing exposure to polluting infrastructure.
"BAAJA may give us savings of a mere $15 a month in 15 years, while exponentially increasing asthma and cancer-causing pollution in our neighborhoods," said Mar Zepeda Salazar, legislative director at Climate Justice Alliance. "This is the ‘affordability win’ we are supposed to be grateful for?"
Though it appears on track to pass in the Senate, the bill has yet to get through the House of Representatives, where House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY), who is expected to become speaker in January, has raised some objections to its provisions on environmental protections and tribal sovereignty. If Congress doesn’t pass the bill before the new Congress begins in January, its backers would have to start over under Democratic majorities.
"The House has an opportunity now to acknowledge the clear will of the American people and rein in Big Tech’s data center attack," Walsh said. "It must start by rejecting this terrible pro-polluter, anti-environment permitting bill, and in so doing, demonstrate what political courage and common sense look like.”
"These shared lands should not be sacrificed to an unprecedented wave of industrial development without a national conversation about whether that development belongs there in the first place."
As the Trump administration and members of Congress on both sides of the aisle push to speed up data center development—against the wishes of the vast majority of Americans, according to recent polling—a coalition of more than 100 conservation and advocacy groups urged two top administration officials on Wednesday to impose an immediate moratorium on the facilities on public lands, arguing that "fundamental threshold issues" must be resolved before such development.
According to US Bureau of Land Management (BLM) records, at least 17 data center campuses and 13 related infrastructure projects—including transmission lines and access roads—have been proposed across more than 24,000 acres of federal land in Arizona, Idaho, Nevada, Oregon, Utah, and Wyoming.
Those projects have been proposed without determining "whether this new industrial use is legally authorized on public lands and, even if it is, whether large-scale data centers are an appropriate use of America’s public lands," wrote the coalition of 115 groups to Interior Secretary Doug Burgum and Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins on Wednesday.
"There is no comprehensive federal policy addressing these questions, no meaningful public process examining the consequences of this new use, and no adequate framework for addressing enormous demands on water and energy, impacts to wildlife and cultural resources, or effects on tribal nations and nearby communities," added the groups, including Defenders of Wildlife, the Sierra Club, Montana Conservation Voters, and Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility (PEER).
The letter follows recent reporting by ProPublica that showed Burgum has up to $64 million invested in artificial intelligence companies, many of which are pushing for the expansion of data centers to power their technology, while hundreds of President Donald Trump's political appointees also have significant financial ties to the industry.
More than 320 officials appointed by Trump have ties to Google parent company Alphabet, which plans to spend nearly $200 billion this year on the data center build-out. More than 240 of them have investments or other financial ties to Meta Platforms, which is also developing data centers.
“The Trump administration is treating America’s public lands like a line item in their own investment portfolio, and conflicted Data Center Doug Burgum, who has tens of millions invested in the speculative AI data center build-out, is leading the charge," said Jayson O'Neill, a spokesperson for Save Our Parks. "This administration and Burgum will continue to use their power to give away our public lands to AI data center developers unless Congress steps in to block it.”
The coalition called a moratorium on data centers on public lands "the minimum responsible step."
"It would give tribal nations, communities, lawmakers, and the public an opportunity to understand what is being proposed and to weigh in on whether commercial data centers are compatible with public land laws, purposes, and values. It would also allow for full examination of environmental impacts, cumulative demands on water and energy, and the consequences of transforming shared public lands into industrial sites."
Public support for data centers has plummeted amid reporting on their massive consumption of energy and water and their contributions to climate pollution.
Last week, the Interior Department released a five-year plan that includes potentially selling off public lands—a proposal, O'Neill told ProPublica on Tuesday, to "sell off what’s left to AI data center developers and [Burgum's] extractive resource buddies.”
According to More Than Just Parks, projects already proposed for public lands include:
A dozen Democrats in Congress are pushing to limit or ban data centers on or near public lands, according to reporting by ProPublica on Tuesday, with some citing the reports on Trump administration officials' ties to the AI industry.
Rep. Rashida Tlaib (D-Mich.) told the outlet she would "continue building the coalition" for the No AI Data Centers on Federal Lands Act, which she introduced in July in the Republican-controlled Congress. Democrats are set to take control of the US House of Representatives and the Senate in January.
“The American people expect public lands to be managed for the benefit of everyone, not a handful of corporations," said Jose Witt, Nevada state director for the Wilderness Society. "These are the places we hike, hunt, and connect with the natural world, yet the administration is poised to dramatically reshape how public lands are used to benefit big tech and the data center industry. The recent election made clear that Americans want a check on data center development, and we urge the administration and Congress to pause data center construction on public lands so we can fully assess the impacts and give the public a real say.”
The coalition wrote to Burgum and Rollins two days after 21 members of the Democratic caucus in the Senate voted to end debate on the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, which would speed up the federal permitting process for data centers and fossil fuel projects. Advocates have warned that the bill's changes to federal law would open up public lands for the facilities.
"America’s public lands belong to all of us," reads the Wednesday letter. "They provide places to hunt, fish, hike, camp, and connect with nature; protect clean water, wildlife habitat, cultural resources, and landscapes important to tribal nations; and preserve opportunities and experiences that cannot simply be recreated once they are lost. These shared lands should not be sacrificed to an unprecedented wave of industrial development without a national conversation about whether that development belongs there in the first place."
Large companies have rolled back efforts to protect the public as the federal government has "largely abandoned chemical safety as a priority," the report notes.
This year's Retailer Report Card, released on Wednesday by the research and advocacy group Toxic-Free Future, notes that consumers today are especially reliant on the corporate accountability efforts of large companies when it comes to staying safe from toxic materials in products they buy, as the Trump administration has "largely abandoned chemical safety as a priority."
Unfortunately for millions of families who shop and eat at major stores and restaurants like Walmart, Trader Joe's, and McDonald's, the report finds that nearly half of the companies included in the analysis are backsliding in efforts to remove toxic chemicals and plastics from their products and packaging.
Twenty-two of the 45 retailers saw their scores decline by at least two percentage points, as TFF rated them on whether they have a corporate safer chemicals policy, their transparency regarding ingredients, their bans on toxic chemicals and plastics, and whether they offer products that are Safer Choice Certified by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).
Walmart and Whole Foods saw the greatest declines in their grades, with both plummeting by at least 20 percentage points and earning "C" grades.
Whole Foods, which is owned by Amazon, has a list of banned or restricted substances—and widely publicizes its restricted components and ingredients on its shopping bags—but did not report progress on its goal of reducing its chemical footprint by 30% by 2025, in time for the Retailer Report Card's release. It also has not supported governmental policies to eliminate or reduce chemicals or plastics of high concern.
Walmart previously led the way in calculating and reporting its chemical footprint, said TFF, "but this year, while it released data about the percentage reduction of its chemical footprint for formulated products, it offered reduced transparency about the gross amount of toxic chemicals in these products."
“After a decade of growing retailer action, this backsliding should be a wake-up call,” said Cheri Peele, a co-author of the report and director of government and market policy at TFF. "Protecting people’s health must remain a priority.”
While significant backsliding was evident at companies like Whole Foods, Walmart, and retailers that dropped by 10 or more percentage points, including Amazon, Dick's Sporting Goods, and Walgreens, Peele emphasized that "companies know how to make products safer, and this year’s leaders show that progress is possible."
Apple, IKEA, Target, and Sephora, which all received "A" or "A-" grades, were credited with adopting comprehensive safer chemicals policies that apply to their products, manufacturing, private-label, and brand-name items.
IKEA also had the distinction of being one of the most improved retailers, jumping 11 percentage points. The furniture and home goods store "has made significant progress over many years in restricting chemicals and plastics of high concern including formaldehyde, PVC [polyvinyl chloride], PFAS [per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances], BPA [bisphenol A], and expanded polystyrene in a number of products."
In 2025, the company also introduced a total ban on PFAS—which are also called "forever chemicals" and have been linked to multiple cancers, reproductive harms, and other health problems—in all of its large materials. The policy came a year before President Donald Trump's EPA proposed rolling back limits on PFAS in drinking water.
Dollar Tree was the most improved store, increasing its score by 16 points after strengthening its reporting requirements, expanding its restricted substance list, and requiring private-label suppliers to use safer alternatives to restricted chemicals.
“Families shouldn’t have to choose between what they can afford and their health,” said José Bravo, national coordinator of the Campaign for Healthier Solutions. “It’s encouraging to see Dollar Tree restrict more harmful chemicals and require more transparency and accountability from suppliers at a time when other retailers are backsliding. Dollar stores tend to operate in communities that are overburdened by pollution and other stressors on health. Even small improvements to dollar store chemical policies make a real difference.”
The report's "Hall of Shame," including 16 retailers that earned failing grades, was rife with companies that have failed to "take any steps toward reducing toxic chemicals." Ahold Delhaize—which owns major grocery chains including Hannaford, Food Lion, and Stop & Shop—Publix, Alberstons, and Trader Joe's were among the stores in the Hall of Shame.
While 22 retailers (44%) reported progress by phasing out PFAS in food packaging and textiles, bisphenols in receipt paper, and/or PVC in packaging, this was "a considerable reduction from 34 retailers (68%) reporting similar progress in 2024."
The report also found "insufficient" progress in ingredient transparency, with 21 companies (42%) failing to ask their suppliers for the chemical content of their products.
"This is an improvement from 2024, when 54% did not ask suppliers for chemical content," reads the report, while adding: "Retailers can’t manage chemicals they do not know are in their products."
The report notes that governmental policies have been shown to improve retailers' safety protocols.
"Before Washington state’s ban on toxic bisphenols in receipts took effect in January 2026, several retailers including Best Buy, Costco, CVS Health, REI, Target, TJX, Walgreens, Whole Foods Market, and others had already begun eliminating toxic bisphenols from receipts nationwide, demonstrating that safer alternatives were possible," reads the report. "Washington state’s ban was followed by California passing a similar law in September 2026, showing how retailer action and strong state policies can build on each other to drive safer practices across the marketplace."
Sarah Doll, national director of the environmental health alliance Safer States, said that "strong state policies that put health first, together with retailer action, help drive safer products across the marketplace."
“Families deserve the same protections wherever they shop," said Doll. "Retailers should build on this progress, not move backward.”
"It has never been clearer that agrochemical corporations have too much influence in government, and that unchecked pesticide use has created an urgent public health crisis."
The Take Down Pesticides coalition announced on Monday is calling for a global "agricultural shift away from petroleum-derived pesticides and towards proven organic and agroecological alternatives," with a particular focus on paraquat, a weedkiller "already banned in over 70 countries and linked to Parkinson's disease, thyroid cancer, and neurological harm to children."
The coalition—which includes Alianza Nacional de Campesinas, Coming Clean, Pesticide Action & Agroecology Network (PAN), and dozens of other organizations—wants policymakers worldwide to crack down on pesticides, but its first public statement highlights actions under US President Donald Trump, who has repeatedly betrayed his campaign promise to "Make America Healthy Again."
"This year, the Supreme Court sided with multibillion-dollar pesticide companies over people who have been harmed by their products," the groups said. "The Environmental Protection Agency continues to greenlight pesticides linked to cancer, Parkinson's disease, birth defects, and neurological harm to children. The US president has attempted to intervene in markets and boost the production of a pesticide linked to cancer, at the bidding of the company who makes it. And Congress has slashed food assistance for needy families, while incentivizing even more pesticide use."
"It has never been clearer that agrochemical corporations have too much influence in government, and that unchecked pesticide use has created an urgent public health crisis," the coalition continued, highlighting the heightened risks for farmers and farmworkers as well as public demand for outlawing dangerous pesticides. "States are starting to take back power, and protect their own residents from pesticides. More than 13 states have introduced legislation to ban or restrict paraquat, a toxic weedkiller that has shortened too many lives. One of those states, Vermont, became the first to ban it."
While recognizing that "banning one pesticide is not enough to protect the health of the farmworkers, farmers, and rural communities regularly exposed to multiple pesticides," the coalition explained that "ending paraquat use is an opportunity for farmers to get off the pesticide treadmill, and adopt organic and agroecological practices, instead of reaching for a replacement herbicide. Banning paraquat would send a powerful signal that agriculture cannot continue as usual."
PAN organizing lead Cristobal Lagunas said that "through our work, we meet people and hear stories of farmers and farmworkers who have been harmed by pesticides. People who sprayed pesticides for years and later developed cancer, Parkinson's, or other chronic conditions, people who were exposed while pregnant and whose children suffered developmental and neurological harm, and people who live near farms and experienced pesticide drift and are now afraid of what the future holds."
"Unfortunately these are not rare exceptions; these are regular occurrences in a system designed to take advantage of our most vulnerable communities," Lagunas stressed. "Our food system has let science, regulation, and compassion fall behind corporate profit. It’s time to foster a food system built on justice, transparency, and resiliency."
Hormis Bedolla, initiative coordinator for pesticides and environmental justice at Alianza Nacional de Campesinas, declared: "Pesticides are not combating insects and pests... They are poisoning and killing us. The idea of creating perfect fruit is not worth our health nor our lives."
Launched during the latest United Nations Climate Change Conference, the coalition also highlighted that "virtually all synthetic pesticides are derived from fossil fuels, and are manufactured in polluting facilities that harm community health. Fossil fuel-based pesticides contribute to the climate crisis—and should not be falsely marketed as a sustainability tool. Pesticides strip the soil of nutrients, reduce biological diversity, and inhibit soils from sequestering carbon."
The groups argued that "organic and agroecological practices of controlling weeds and other pests can be scaled up and widely adopted, if we have the political will to invest in them. We call on the public to continue to demand affordable food free from pesticides. We call on state lawmakers to prohibit paraquat and other toxic pesticides."
With Democrats set to take control of the US Senate and House of Representatives in January, after decisive wins against Trump's party in the midterms, "we call on members of Congress to resist agrochemical lobbying, reject campaign contributions from pesticide companies, and prioritize people’s health over corporate profits," the coalition continued.
"We call on state and local policymakers to prohibit the use of synthetic pesticides on lands that they manage," it added. "And we call on farmers to stand up to agrochemical companies, and demand federal, state, and local support for adopting organic and agroecological growing practices. Together, we can take down pesticides."
Other coalition members include Friends of the Earth US, Earthjustice, and the Center for Food Safety—whose legislative and policy coordinator, Reagan Ferris, noted that the group has long "championed the rights of farmworkers, consumers, endangered species, and the planet by challenging government policies permitting the overuse of toxic pesticides."
"Pesticides are a poisonous false promise that harm people, contaminate our food, and irreparably pollute the water, soil, and air," Ferris said. "A new agriculture for the 21st century is not only possible, but essential, to ensure a regenerative, healthful food system."
"We are going backwards toward the goal of controlling CO2 emissions," said the author of a new study accounting for the electricity use and emissions of over 400 US data centers.
Just over 400 artificial intelligence data centers emitted as much climate pollution as Denmark does in a year, according to Harvard research published in Nature Sustainability on Monday.
The study found that a total of 403 hyperscale data centers released 28.3 million tons of carbon dioxide between May 2024 and April 2025, up to triple earlier estimates. And that number is likely to increase further as the rapid build-out continues.
"We are going backwards toward the goal of controlling CO2 emissions," Francesca Dominici, the study's senior author and Clarence James Gamble professor of biostatistics, population, and data science and director of the Harvard Data Science Initiative, told The Associated Press.
"What we're seeing is already striking, but it's only a snapshot of a rapidly expanding industry."
The researchers also looked at the overall electricity use of the data centers and found it was between 68 and 99 terawatt-hours, with higher estimates rivaling the annual electricity use of Michigan. All told, the centers accounted for 1.8% of US electricity consumption.
“We’re talking about just 403 facilities consuming approximately 82 terawatt-hours of electricity in a single year—approaching the annual electricity consumption of an entire mid-sized American state, including its homes, businesses, and industries,” lead author Gianluca Guidi, a postdoctoral fellow in the Harvard Department of Biostatistics, told Gizmodo.
The numbers, while high, are "nowhere near" the true greenhouse gas emissions of the industry, as Emily Atkin noted in Heated. The study did not count every data center active during the study period, did not look at the contribution of off-grid power plants like those used by Elon Musk's controversial Colossus data center in Memphis, and did not consider the climate pollution of refrigerants used to cool the centers.
The researchers also acknowledge that the build-out has only increased since the study period ended.
"What we're seeing is already striking, but it's only a snapshot of a rapidly expanding industry," Guidi said in a statement. "The data center boom hasn't slowed down since our study period ended in April 2025. New facilities have been built, existing campuses have expanded, and demand for AI computing continues to grow. That means the electricity use and carbon footprint we're reporting could already be substantially larger now in 2026."
This makes their findings all the more urgent for policymakers to consider.
“We already have over a thousand hyperscale facilities operating and another 2,000 planned,” Guidi told Gizmodo. “So, the data starts to raise a red flag about where we’re going, and whether we’re building these AI data centers in the most responsible way we can.”
The authors are also concerned about the impact of the data centers' fossil fuel use on public health. The researchers found that 54% of the data centers they studied were powered by fossil fuels, with 38% of them powered by gas and 15% by coal, but they were not able to dive into what that means for US residents' health and well-being.
"Quantifying health impacts is an important next step," Dominici said in a statement. "First, carbon dioxide drives climate change, which affects health through heatwaves, wildfire smoke, flooding, and other pathways."
Dominic continued:
Second, the fossil fuel power plants in the regional electricity systems associated with this demand also release other pollutants, such as fine particulate matter, nitrogen oxides, and sulfur dioxide, that are directly linked to heart and lung disease and premature death. So when data centers draw heavily on fossil fuel power, the people living near and downwind of those power plants may bear health costs, even if they're far from the data center itself.
The study authors also noted a lack of transparency and reliable information about data centers.
"Perhaps what surprised me most throughout the research was how little independently verified information is publicly available about infrastructure that’s already consuming electricity on this scale," Guidi told Gizmodo.
Atkin noted that the lack of transparency had made the researchers' task more difficult, and provided an opening for the new democratically controlled Congress to take action in January:
It’s supremely messed up that scientists have to work this hard just to get a partial picture of how much an immensely powerful, fast-growing industry is heating the planet we all have to live on—especially when voters just made it clear they want the industry reined in.
The public deserves to know exactly how many of these facilities exist, and how much they are polluting, so they can decide whether it’s worth trading the planet’s health for toothbrushes that tell us if we’re doing it right.
Come January, Democrats can show voters they were listening by making tech companies publish the data scientists actually need to figure out how many hyperscale data centers are running and how much they pollute. My bet is that once scientists get the full numbers, we’ll need a bigger country than Denmark for the comparison.
The research comes amid a nationwide backlash against the proliferation of AI data centers, with voters approving 43 of 44 anti-data center measures on the ballot in the midterm elections.
It also builds on growing evidence that the data center build-out is a worrying new contribution to the climate crisis. A Sierra Club analysis warned that the use of fossil fuels to power data centers could increase power sector emissions by 42% by 2030. Another study concluded that artificial intelligence is boosting climate emissions in another way: by helping facilitate the extraction and production of fossil fuels.
"With each passing day we’re learning more and more about the enormous greenhouse gas emissions and climate warming impacts that the AI data center industry is dumping on our planet," Seth Gladstone, the director of media and public relations for Food & Water Watch, told Common Dreams. "This comes on top of the skyrocketing electric bills and water security threats this industry brings wherever it lands. Now more than ever, we need Congress to act and pass a national moratorium on all new hyperscale data center construction, before it’s too late to halt Big Tech’s assault on our communities."
Update: This piece has been updated to include a quote from Seth Gladstone of Food & Water Watch.