March, 23 2010, 05:22pm EDT
Senator Graham Proposes Indefinite Detention Legislation To White House
WASHINGTON
Senator
Lindsey Graham (R-SC) has presented legislation to the White House
regarding future handling of terrorism suspects, according to a report
in the Washington Post today. Senior White House officials reportedly
have begun circulating a summary of the draft legislation to some
members of Congress. Graham has reportedly outlined new
procedures for habeas corpus claims and a new indefinite detention
authority. The American Civil Liberties Union believes that detaining
individuals indefinitely without charging them with a crime or
providing them a meaningful opportunity to challenge their detention is
un-American and violates our commitment to due process and the rule of
law.
Senator Graham has
also been urging the Obama administration to use the discredited
military commissions for the trials of 9/11 suspects despite Attorney
General Eric Holder's announcement in November that the Justice
Department would be using federal criminal courts for these
prosecutions. Since 9/11, there have been over 300 successfully
completed terrorism-related trials in federal court. The military
commissions have completed only three terrorism-related cases, with two
of three convicted defendants having served relatively short sentences
they have already completed.
also been urging the Obama administration to use the discredited
military commissions for the trials of 9/11 suspects despite Attorney
General Eric Holder's announcement in November that the Justice
Department would be using federal criminal courts for these
prosecutions. Since 9/11, there have been over 300 successfully
completed terrorism-related trials in federal court. The military
commissions have completed only three terrorism-related cases, with two
of three convicted defendants having served relatively short sentences
they have already completed.
The ACLU believes the
military commissions, despite some improvements through legislation,
remain unworkable and should be shut down for good. President Obama has
reportedly not yet reached a decision on where to hold the 9/11 trials.
military commissions, despite some improvements through legislation,
remain unworkable and should be shut down for good. President Obama has
reportedly not yet reached a decision on where to hold the 9/11 trials.
The following can be attributed to Laura W. Murphy, Director of the ACLU Washington Legislative Office:
"Despite
pressure from Senator Graham, the Obama administration should not enact
any policies that allow for the indefinite detention of individuals -
potentially for a lifetime - without providing due process and a
meaningful opportunity to challenge the detention. Indefinite detention
without charge or trial flies in the face of American values and
violates this country's commitment to the rule of law. The assumption
that sacrificing our principles will make us safe is not only false; it
is dangerous. If Senator Graham's legislation is introduced, Congress
must stand strong and uphold our most cherished values, not cement into
law policies that rival the worst of the Bush administration's legacy.
Even during years immediately following 9/11, Congress never took the
unprecedented step of passing an indefinite detention statute. Now that
there is a president and Congress who have stated a commitment to the
rule of law, it would be a terrible irony to have this kind of
legislation seriously considered. We urge both the White House and
Congress to reject any indefinite detention proposal."
pressure from Senator Graham, the Obama administration should not enact
any policies that allow for the indefinite detention of individuals -
potentially for a lifetime - without providing due process and a
meaningful opportunity to challenge the detention. Indefinite detention
without charge or trial flies in the face of American values and
violates this country's commitment to the rule of law. The assumption
that sacrificing our principles will make us safe is not only false; it
is dangerous. If Senator Graham's legislation is introduced, Congress
must stand strong and uphold our most cherished values, not cement into
law policies that rival the worst of the Bush administration's legacy.
Even during years immediately following 9/11, Congress never took the
unprecedented step of passing an indefinite detention statute. Now that
there is a president and Congress who have stated a commitment to the
rule of law, it would be a terrible irony to have this kind of
legislation seriously considered. We urge both the White House and
Congress to reject any indefinite detention proposal."
The following can be attributed to Jameel Jaffer, Director of the ACLU National Security Project:
"The Obama administration should not
use the discredited military commissions system for the most important
terrorism trials in American history. The federal criminal justice
system has experienced judges, experienced prosecutors, a track record
that includes hundreds of successful terrorism prosecutions and
procedural rules that have been tested and refined over two centuries.
To displace this system for a military commissions system that does not
have rules, that is certain to result in further delay, that has
resulted in only three convictions over eight years and that is viewed
as illegitimate by much of the rest of the world, would be deeply
irresponsible. Attorney General Holder's decision to use federal
criminal courts was the right decision for national security and the
right decision for the rule of law. The Obama administration should
reaffirm the decision, not reverse it."
More information about why terrorism suspects should be tried in civilian courts is available online at: www.aclu.org/national-security/terrorism-cases-should-be-tried-federal-court
The American Civil Liberties Union was founded in 1920 and is our nation's guardian of liberty. The ACLU works in the courts, legislatures and communities to defend and preserve the individual rights and liberties guaranteed to all people in this country by the Constitution and laws of the United States.
(212) 549-2666LATEST NEWS
30th Strike in Trump's High-Seas Kill Spree Claims 2 More Lives
At least 107 people have been killed in US bombings of boats that the Trump administration claims—without evidence—were involved in narco-trafficking in the Caribbean Sea and Pacific Ocean.
Dec 29, 2025
The US military said Monday that two alleged drug smugglers were killed in the bombing of another boat in the eastern Pacific Ocean, but—as has been the case throughout 30 such strikes—offered no verifiable evidence to support its claim.
US Southern Command (SOUTHCOM) said on X that, on orders from Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, "Joint Task Force Southern Spear conducted a lethal kinetic strike on a vessel operated by Designated Terrorist Organizations in international waters."
"Intelligence confirmed the vessel was transiting along known narco-trafficking routes in the eastern Pacific and was engaged in narco-trafficking operations," SOUTHCOM added. "Two male narco-terrorists were killed. No US military forces were harmed."
According to the Trump administration's figures, at least 107 people have been killed in 30 boat strikes since early September. The administration has tried to justify the strikes to Congress by claiming that the US is in an “armed conflict” with drug cartels, while legal scholars and Democratic US lawmakers counter that the bombings are likely war crimes.
War powers resolutions aimed at reining in President Donald Trump’s ability to extrajudicially execute alleged drug traffickers in or near Venezuela failed to pass the Senate in October and the House earlier this month.
Monday's strike came amid Trump's escalating aggression against Venezuela, including the deployment of warships and thousands of US troops to the region, authorization of covert CIA operations targeting the country's socialist government, and threats to launch ground attacks.
Trump claimed Monday without providing evidence that US forces destroyed a "big facility" in an unspecified country where narco-traffickers' "ships come from."
Keep ReadingShow Less
Trump Bemoans Not Winning Nobel Peace Prize During Netanyahu Hot Mic
The self-described "most anti-war president in history" has ordered the bombing of at least nine nations—more than any US leader in history—and has been indispensable to Israel's genocide in Gaza.
Dec 29, 2025
President Donald Trump—who has bombed more countries than any US leader in history—once again lamented what he considers his snub for the Nobel Peace Prize during a Monday meeting with fugitive Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
In an apparent hot mic moment, Trump, seemingly unaware that there were reporters in the room, speaks to Netanyahu and other Israeli and US officials gathered at the president's Mar-a-Lago club in Florida about the "35 years of fighting" between two unspecified countries that he "stopped."
"Do I get credit for it? No," Trump says, adding before being interrupted by Netanyahu, "They gave the Nob..."
As something of a consolation prize, Netanyahu said Monday that he's awarding Trump with the Israel Prize, that nation's highest cultural honor. Trump will be the first foreign leader to receive the award.
Football's global governing body also gave Trump its inaugural—and widely derided—FIFA Peace Prize earlier this month in recognition of the administration's role in brokering an end to international conflicts.
"I did eight of them," Trump said during the hot mic—likely referring to the number of wars he falsely claims to have ended—before seeming to notice the journalists and changing the subject.
Trump ranting to Netanyahu on a hot mic: "Do I get credit for it? No. They gave the Nob-- I did 8 of them. How about India and Pakistan? So I did 8 of them. And then I'll tell you the rest of it."
[image or embed]
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar.com) December 29, 2025 at 10:57 AM
Trump did nine of them—as in the number of countries he's bombed, breaking former President Barack Obama's record of seven. Over the course of his two terms, Trump has ordered the bombing of Afghanistan, Iran, Iraq, Libya, Nigeria, Pakistan, Somalia, Syria, and Yemen, as well as boats allegedly transporting drugs in the Caribbean Sea and Pacific Ocean.
Thousands of civilians have been killed or wounded during these campaigns, according to experts.
Trump has recently deployed warships and thousands of US troops near Venezuela, which could become the next country attacked by a the self-described "the most anti-war president in history."
The US president has also backed Israel's genocidal war on Gaza, which has left more than 250,000 Palestinians dead, maimed, or missing, and around 2 million others forcibly displaced, starved, or sickened. Israel's conduct in the war is the subject of an ongoing International Court of Justice genocide case filed by South Africa.
Meanwhile, Netanyahu and his former defense minister Yoav Gallant are wanted by the International Criminal Court for alleged war crimes and crimes against humanity in Gaza, including murder and forced starvation.
“He is a wartime prime minister. He’s done a phenomenal job," Trump said while standing with Netanyahu later on Monday. "He’s taken Israel through a very dangerous period of trauma."
He is also accused of prolonging the Gaza war to forestall a reckoning in his domestic corruption trial, in which Trump has intervened by requesting a pardon.
“Israel, with other people, might not exist right now," Trump added. "If you had the wrong prime minister, Israel right now would not exist.”
Keep ReadingShow Less
New State Laws Aim to Protect Environment, Consumers as Trump Wages All-Out War on Climate
"The gridlock and partisanship we see in Washington, DC can be dispiriting. But history shows that states can build momentum that eventually leads to change at the federal level."
Dec 29, 2025
Even as President Donald Trump and his administration have been ripping up environmental and consumer protection regulations, a number of state laws are set to take effect next year that could at least mitigate some of the damage.
A Monday statement from Environment America and the Public Interest Network highlighted a number of new laws aimed at curbing corporate polluters and enhancing consumer welfare.
First, the groups highlighted "Right to Repair" laws set to take effect in Washington, Nevada, Oregon, and Colorado, which give people the right to repair their own appliances and electronics without burdensome costs or barriers.
The groups lavished particular praise on Colorado's "Right to Repair" laws that they said provide "the broadest repair protections in the country," with new regulations that will give businesses in the state "access to what they and independent repair providers need to fix their electronics themselves."
Illinois, meanwhile, will fully phase out the sale of fluorescent lightbulbs, which will be replaced by energy-efficient LED bulbs. The groups estimate that eliminating the fluorescent bulbs will collectively save Illinois households more than $1.5 billion on their utility bills by 2050, while also reducing energy waste and mercury pollution.
Illinois also drew praise for enacting a ban on polystyrene foam foodware that will take effect on January 1.
The groups also highlighted the work being done in Oregon to protect consumers with legislation mandating price transparency to eliminate surprise junk fees on purchases; prohibiting ambulance companies from socking out-of-network patients with massive fees for rides to nearby hospitals; and placing new restrictions on the ability of medical debt to negatively impact a person's credit score.
California also got a mention in the groups' release for closing a loophole that allowed supermarkets to continue using plastic bags and for creating a new privacy tool for consumers allowing them to request that online data brokers delete all of the personal information they have gathered on them over the years.
Emily Rusch, vice president and senior director of state offices for the Public Interest Network, contrasted the action being taken in the states to protect consumers and the environment with a lack of action being done at the federal level.
"The gridlock and partisanship we see in Washington, DC can be dispiriting," said Rusch. "But history shows that states can build momentum that eventually leads to change at the federal level. As we build on this progress in 2026, we look forward to working with anyone—Republican, Democrat, or independent—with whom we can find common ground."
Keep ReadingShow Less
Most Popular