Palestinians children search through the rubble of their home a day after an operation by the Israeli Special Forces in the Nuseirat camp, in the central Gaza Strip on June 9, 2024, amid the ongoing conflict between Israel and the Palestinian Hamas militant group.
The Nuseirat Massacre Shows How Israel and the West Devalue Palestinian Lives
This Zionist view that mentally strips Palestinians of their humanity as a prelude to their physical extermination is a continuation of the colonial view of subjugated peoples.
On the morning of Saturday, June 8, the racist Zionist colonial army carried out horrific massacres in the central governorate, killing at least 274 Palestinian civilians, including women, children, and men.
Hours later, they announced that these massacres were a cover to free four Israeli captives in the Nuseirat camp.
At the time of the massacre, I was visiting the central governorate and heard Israeli bombing everywhere. F-16 fighter jets, Apache helicopters, artillery, and warships were all involved in the random bombing of civilian gatherings. People fled in all directions, not knowing where to go, as there is no safe place in Gaza.
Does the part of the world supporting the Zionist colonial regime truly believe in the value of human equality? Do they think that the lives of 40,000 Palestinians equal the lives of 120 Israeli hostages?
Many of those in the central governorate at that moment had recently fled Rafah after the occupation army dropped leaflets urging residents to evacuate.
As for northern Gaza, none of the displaced were permitted to return. Since the beginning of the war, the occupation army had separated it from the central region, with tanks in the Netzarim corridor—which cuts across Gaza—ready to kill anyone attempting to return.
The most significant observation about this massacre is that there was no operational necessity for it. The occupation army could have freed the captives with far fewer Palestinian casualties, with the basic principle that killing even one civilian is a crime that demands accountability.
Mass Civilian Casualties
That the Israeli military deliberately caused mass civilian casualties is reinforced by the fact that the relentless Israeli bombing targeted a wide area and locations far from the site of the operation.
For example, massacres were committed in Deir al-Balah, about 10 kilometers away, while the operation took place in the Nuseirat camp. This excessive killing of civilians without any "operational need" has only one explanation: the colonial Zionist state seizes any opportunity to shed the blood of as many Palestinians as possible.
It sees the killing of every additional Palestinian as a gain since its project is fundamentally based on the idea of ethnic cleansing. It wants to instill in the Palestinian consciousness that the cost of any attempt to rebel against the colonial project will be high.
Israel is not alone in devaluing Palestinian lives. The friendly governments of this colonial state, primarily the U.S. administration, adopt rhetoric that legitimizes the genocidal crimes committed by this colonial state.
Since the beginning of this genocidal war, Western officials have called for the release of Israeli hostages, implying that the only problem in Gaza is the hostages' detention.
Meanwhile, as calls continue for the release of about 120 Israeli captives from Gaza, Israel has killed nearly 40,000 Palestinians in eight months, the overwhelming majority of whom are civilians, including around 15,000 Palestinian children.
Does the part of the world supporting the Zionist colonial regime truly believe in the value of human equality? Do they think that the lives of 40,000 Palestinians equal the lives of 120 Israeli hostages?
Reality disproves this, showing that supporters of the racist colonial project believe in a hierarchy of human value, where the colonial state's citizens are considered more valuable and deserving of life than Palestinians.
An 'Ugly Heritage'
At the start of this war, the racist colonial state's Defense Minister Yoav Gallant described Palestinians as "human animals."
This description was not a momentary loss of temper but the most honest expression of the Zionist view of the Palestinian people. All of Israel's genocidal policies before and after October 7 confirm that they do not see Palestinians as humans deserving of life but as a threat that needs to be eliminated.
Israel is a reminder of this ugly heritage of the Western colonial project.
History helps us understand the present. This Zionist view that mentally strips Palestinians of their humanity as a prelude to their physical extermination is a continuation of the colonial view of subjugated peoples.
We know from the history of Western colonialism how European invaders exterminated tens of millions of Native Americans and killed tens of millions more Africans when they brought them through long journeys of torture and humiliation across the ocean.
Those who survived were enslaved. We also know how colonial powers exterminated tens of millions in Africa and Asia and looted their wealth during the colonial era.
Israel is a reminder of this ugly heritage of the Western colonial project. No state or politician can claim to believe in human values while supporting this genocidal colonial state at the same time.
Belief in the principles of equality, justice, and dignity for all humans necessarily requires opposing this ugly colonial system and fighting for a world that believes in the right to life and dignity for every human being, regardless of race, religion, or colour.
Urgent. It's never been this bad.
Dear Common Dreams reader, It’s been nearly 30 years since I co-founded Common Dreams with my late wife, Lina Newhouser. We had the radical notion that journalism should serve the public good, not corporate profits. It was clear to us from the outset what it would take to build such a project. No paid advertisements. No corporate sponsors. No millionaire publisher telling us what to think or do. Many people said we wouldn't last a year, but we proved those doubters wrong. Together with a tremendous team of journalists and dedicated staff, we built an independent media outlet free from the constraints of profits and corporate control. Our mission from the outset was simple. To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. Building Common Dreams was not easy. Our survival was never guaranteed. When you take on the most powerful forces—Wall Street greed, fossil fuel industry destruction, Big Tech lobbyists, and uber-rich oligarchs who have spent billions upon billions rigging the economy and democracy in their favor—the only bulwark you have is supporters who believe in your work. But here’s the urgent message from me today. It’s never been this bad out there. And it’s never been this hard to keep us going. At the very moment Common Dreams is most needed and doing some of its best and most important work, the threats we face are intensifying. Right now, with just two days to go in our Spring Campaign, we're falling short of our make-or-break goal. When everyone does the little they can afford, we are strong. But if that support retreats or dries up, so do we. Can you make a gift right now to make sure Common Dreams not only survives but thrives? There is no backup plan or rainy day fund. There is only you. —Craig Brown, Co-founder |
On the morning of Saturday, June 8, the racist Zionist colonial army carried out horrific massacres in the central governorate, killing at least 274 Palestinian civilians, including women, children, and men.
Hours later, they announced that these massacres were a cover to free four Israeli captives in the Nuseirat camp.
At the time of the massacre, I was visiting the central governorate and heard Israeli bombing everywhere. F-16 fighter jets, Apache helicopters, artillery, and warships were all involved in the random bombing of civilian gatherings. People fled in all directions, not knowing where to go, as there is no safe place in Gaza.
Does the part of the world supporting the Zionist colonial regime truly believe in the value of human equality? Do they think that the lives of 40,000 Palestinians equal the lives of 120 Israeli hostages?
Many of those in the central governorate at that moment had recently fled Rafah after the occupation army dropped leaflets urging residents to evacuate.
As for northern Gaza, none of the displaced were permitted to return. Since the beginning of the war, the occupation army had separated it from the central region, with tanks in the Netzarim corridor—which cuts across Gaza—ready to kill anyone attempting to return.
The most significant observation about this massacre is that there was no operational necessity for it. The occupation army could have freed the captives with far fewer Palestinian casualties, with the basic principle that killing even one civilian is a crime that demands accountability.
Mass Civilian Casualties
That the Israeli military deliberately caused mass civilian casualties is reinforced by the fact that the relentless Israeli bombing targeted a wide area and locations far from the site of the operation.
For example, massacres were committed in Deir al-Balah, about 10 kilometers away, while the operation took place in the Nuseirat camp. This excessive killing of civilians without any "operational need" has only one explanation: the colonial Zionist state seizes any opportunity to shed the blood of as many Palestinians as possible.
It sees the killing of every additional Palestinian as a gain since its project is fundamentally based on the idea of ethnic cleansing. It wants to instill in the Palestinian consciousness that the cost of any attempt to rebel against the colonial project will be high.
Israel is not alone in devaluing Palestinian lives. The friendly governments of this colonial state, primarily the U.S. administration, adopt rhetoric that legitimizes the genocidal crimes committed by this colonial state.
Since the beginning of this genocidal war, Western officials have called for the release of Israeli hostages, implying that the only problem in Gaza is the hostages' detention.
Meanwhile, as calls continue for the release of about 120 Israeli captives from Gaza, Israel has killed nearly 40,000 Palestinians in eight months, the overwhelming majority of whom are civilians, including around 15,000 Palestinian children.
Does the part of the world supporting the Zionist colonial regime truly believe in the value of human equality? Do they think that the lives of 40,000 Palestinians equal the lives of 120 Israeli hostages?
Reality disproves this, showing that supporters of the racist colonial project believe in a hierarchy of human value, where the colonial state's citizens are considered more valuable and deserving of life than Palestinians.
An 'Ugly Heritage'
At the start of this war, the racist colonial state's Defense Minister Yoav Gallant described Palestinians as "human animals."
This description was not a momentary loss of temper but the most honest expression of the Zionist view of the Palestinian people. All of Israel's genocidal policies before and after October 7 confirm that they do not see Palestinians as humans deserving of life but as a threat that needs to be eliminated.
Israel is a reminder of this ugly heritage of the Western colonial project.
History helps us understand the present. This Zionist view that mentally strips Palestinians of their humanity as a prelude to their physical extermination is a continuation of the colonial view of subjugated peoples.
We know from the history of Western colonialism how European invaders exterminated tens of millions of Native Americans and killed tens of millions more Africans when they brought them through long journeys of torture and humiliation across the ocean.
Those who survived were enslaved. We also know how colonial powers exterminated tens of millions in Africa and Asia and looted their wealth during the colonial era.
Israel is a reminder of this ugly heritage of the Western colonial project. No state or politician can claim to believe in human values while supporting this genocidal colonial state at the same time.
Belief in the principles of equality, justice, and dignity for all humans necessarily requires opposing this ugly colonial system and fighting for a world that believes in the right to life and dignity for every human being, regardless of race, religion, or colour.
- 'Nowhere Safe in Gaza' as Evidence of Israeli War Crimes Mounts ›
- Children Among Dozens Killed in 'Appalling' Israeli Attack on UNRWA School ›
- Rejecting the Manufactured Case for Genocide in Gaza ›
- The Task of Freeing Palestine Is the Task of Freeing Ourselves ›
- 'Horrific Massacre': IDF Kills 200+ Palestinians Rescuing 4 Hostages ›
- Opinion | How Many More Massacres Must We Palestinians Endure Here in Gaza? | Common Dreams ›
- Opinion | Nuseirat, Like Gaza, Is a Representation of a Culture That Cannot Be Broken | Common Dreams ›
- Opinion | A Year Into Israel’s Genocide, the Fight for Life and Dignity in Gaza Continues | Common Dreams ›
On the morning of Saturday, June 8, the racist Zionist colonial army carried out horrific massacres in the central governorate, killing at least 274 Palestinian civilians, including women, children, and men.
Hours later, they announced that these massacres were a cover to free four Israeli captives in the Nuseirat camp.
At the time of the massacre, I was visiting the central governorate and heard Israeli bombing everywhere. F-16 fighter jets, Apache helicopters, artillery, and warships were all involved in the random bombing of civilian gatherings. People fled in all directions, not knowing where to go, as there is no safe place in Gaza.
Does the part of the world supporting the Zionist colonial regime truly believe in the value of human equality? Do they think that the lives of 40,000 Palestinians equal the lives of 120 Israeli hostages?
Many of those in the central governorate at that moment had recently fled Rafah after the occupation army dropped leaflets urging residents to evacuate.
As for northern Gaza, none of the displaced were permitted to return. Since the beginning of the war, the occupation army had separated it from the central region, with tanks in the Netzarim corridor—which cuts across Gaza—ready to kill anyone attempting to return.
The most significant observation about this massacre is that there was no operational necessity for it. The occupation army could have freed the captives with far fewer Palestinian casualties, with the basic principle that killing even one civilian is a crime that demands accountability.
Mass Civilian Casualties
That the Israeli military deliberately caused mass civilian casualties is reinforced by the fact that the relentless Israeli bombing targeted a wide area and locations far from the site of the operation.
For example, massacres were committed in Deir al-Balah, about 10 kilometers away, while the operation took place in the Nuseirat camp. This excessive killing of civilians without any "operational need" has only one explanation: the colonial Zionist state seizes any opportunity to shed the blood of as many Palestinians as possible.
It sees the killing of every additional Palestinian as a gain since its project is fundamentally based on the idea of ethnic cleansing. It wants to instill in the Palestinian consciousness that the cost of any attempt to rebel against the colonial project will be high.
Israel is not alone in devaluing Palestinian lives. The friendly governments of this colonial state, primarily the U.S. administration, adopt rhetoric that legitimizes the genocidal crimes committed by this colonial state.
Since the beginning of this genocidal war, Western officials have called for the release of Israeli hostages, implying that the only problem in Gaza is the hostages' detention.
Meanwhile, as calls continue for the release of about 120 Israeli captives from Gaza, Israel has killed nearly 40,000 Palestinians in eight months, the overwhelming majority of whom are civilians, including around 15,000 Palestinian children.
Does the part of the world supporting the Zionist colonial regime truly believe in the value of human equality? Do they think that the lives of 40,000 Palestinians equal the lives of 120 Israeli hostages?
Reality disproves this, showing that supporters of the racist colonial project believe in a hierarchy of human value, where the colonial state's citizens are considered more valuable and deserving of life than Palestinians.
An 'Ugly Heritage'
At the start of this war, the racist colonial state's Defense Minister Yoav Gallant described Palestinians as "human animals."
This description was not a momentary loss of temper but the most honest expression of the Zionist view of the Palestinian people. All of Israel's genocidal policies before and after October 7 confirm that they do not see Palestinians as humans deserving of life but as a threat that needs to be eliminated.
Israel is a reminder of this ugly heritage of the Western colonial project.
History helps us understand the present. This Zionist view that mentally strips Palestinians of their humanity as a prelude to their physical extermination is a continuation of the colonial view of subjugated peoples.
We know from the history of Western colonialism how European invaders exterminated tens of millions of Native Americans and killed tens of millions more Africans when they brought them through long journeys of torture and humiliation across the ocean.
Those who survived were enslaved. We also know how colonial powers exterminated tens of millions in Africa and Asia and looted their wealth during the colonial era.
Israel is a reminder of this ugly heritage of the Western colonial project. No state or politician can claim to believe in human values while supporting this genocidal colonial state at the same time.
Belief in the principles of equality, justice, and dignity for all humans necessarily requires opposing this ugly colonial system and fighting for a world that believes in the right to life and dignity for every human being, regardless of race, religion, or colour.
- 'Nowhere Safe in Gaza' as Evidence of Israeli War Crimes Mounts ›
- Children Among Dozens Killed in 'Appalling' Israeli Attack on UNRWA School ›
- Rejecting the Manufactured Case for Genocide in Gaza ›
- The Task of Freeing Palestine Is the Task of Freeing Ourselves ›
- 'Horrific Massacre': IDF Kills 200+ Palestinians Rescuing 4 Hostages ›
- Opinion | How Many More Massacres Must We Palestinians Endure Here in Gaza? | Common Dreams ›
- Opinion | Nuseirat, Like Gaza, Is a Representation of a Culture That Cannot Be Broken | Common Dreams ›
- Opinion | A Year Into Israel’s Genocide, the Fight for Life and Dignity in Gaza Continues | Common Dreams ›