June, 28 2012, 08:27am EDT
Bahrain: Free Injured Protesters for Urgent Medical Care
Rescind Their Military Court Convictions
WASHINGTON
Bahraini authorities should quash the sentences of two protesters unfairly convicted by military courts for participating in pro-democracy demonstrations in February and March 2011, Human Rights Watch said today. Both men are in need of urgent medical treatment due to the long-term effects of injuries from security forces' gunfire during the demonstrations. Their families say they have been denied the medical care they need.
Both of the men, Jaffar Salman Maki and Mohamed Ali, were convicted on charges of "illegal gathering," which appear to violate their right to freedom of assembly, Human Rights Watch said. They did not have access to lawyers during their trials in a military court. A court of cassation is scheduled to review Maki's conviction on June 28, 2012.
"The least authorities could do is void the convictions of these two Bahraini men who were tried and sentenced without lawyers by military courts," said Sarah Leah Whitson, Middle East director at Human Right Watch. "These young men have already paid a heavy personal price, and deserve an end to this nightmare."
In June 2011, military courts sentenced Maki to two years in prison and Ali to three years for participating in "illegal gatherings and rioting." Both were injured by police gunfire during the demonstrations, though Maki denies that he was a demonstrator and both men have denied any acts of "rioting."
King Hamad bin Isa Al Khalifa established military courts in March 2011 to prosecute people who had participated in the pro-democracy protests. These courts continued operating until early October.
Neither of the two men had lawyers at their trial, family members told Human Rights Watch, and court records reviewed by Human Rights Watch make no mention of lawyers appearing to represent the men. A military appeals court reduced Ali's sentence to two years, but a civilian court upheld Maki's sentence.
Maki, 33, was injured on the face and chest by police gunfire on March 15 near his home in Sitra as he was returning from his work as a cleaning supervisor, his family told Human Rights Watch. They said that on the day he was shot, he was transferred from Sitra hospital to the Salmaniya Medical Complex, where doctors removed about 80 pellets from his face and chest and police later arrested him. On March 19 military prosecutors charged him with participating in an "illegal gathering and rioting."
According to the prosecutor's court filings, after interrogation, the military investigator determined that Maki was "a rioter" and said that he had confessed to participating in rioting. At his trial, Maki denied all of the charges against him. The special military court sentenced him on June 23, 2011.
A member of Maki's family who didn't want to be identified told Human Rights Watch that authorities only allowed them to visit Maki on July 11, 2011, for the first time after his arrest.
"He has lost vision in his left eye and can't see well in his right eye either," the family member told Human Rights Watch. The family member also said that doctors who initially treated Maki have said that he can regain his vision if he gets proper medical care, which the family members said he is not receiving in detention.
Ali, 23, was injured by the Bahrain Defense Forces during a demonstration near the Pearl Roundabout in Manama on February 18, 2011, his family told Human Rights Watch. Medical reports reviewed by Human Rights Watch indicate that he was hit by a bullet on the left side of his chest and was in state of "shock and very pale" when he arrived at Salmaniya. Due to severe internal bleeding, doctors removed three liters of blood from his chest and performed a number of emergency surgeries.
The hospital arranged a medical trip to France for him. However King Hamad declared a state of emergency on the date of his scheduled trip, on March 15, 2011, as a result of which he could not travel. On March 16 security forces took over the medical center and expelled family members attending Ali, his brother Hussain Ali told Human Rights Watch.
The family briefly saw Ali when doctors conducted another emergency operation on March 28, 2011, Hussain Ali said. Ali was interrogated at al-Naim police station in Manama on April 8, and denied the charges of "illegal gathering and rioting," court documents show. On May 31 Ali appeared in a military court without a defense lawyer. "We tried to find a lawyer but we couldn't because of the short notice, and the lawyers we contacted had many cases at that time," his brother said.
At the second session of his trial on June 7, 2011, the military court sentenced him to three years in prison. The family then hired a lawyer, who appealed the ruling. In June 2011 the military appeals court reduced the verdict to two years but rejected his appeal for temporary release to get medical treatment.
Hussain Ali told Human Rights Watch that his brother needs urgent medical care. "He has pain and inflammation in his chest," Hussain Ali said. "Whenever he is in pain, they take him to a doctor who gives him painkillers, but he has not been seen by a specialist."
Hussain said that authorities have not set a civilian judicial review of Ali's conviction.
The royally appointed Bahrain Independent Commission of Inquiry (BICI) in November 2011 called for civilian judicial review of military court verdicts and for voiding the convictions of people convicted for peacefully exercising their rights to free expression and peaceful assembly. However the review process has resulted in the release of just a few people.
Human Rights Watch called on Bahrain authorities to urgently review the military court verdicts of Maki and Ali, as well as all other Bahrainis sentenced by military courts, and to overturn any convictions for participating in peaceful protests. According to opposition activists, hundreds of people are in prison serving military court sentences.
"All of the government's nice talk means nothing while men like Maki and Ali languish in jail - not only after unfair trials, but without the medical care they need," Whitson said. "If the government wants Bahrainis to believe it cares about justice, it can start by dropping all charges based on peaceful protest and ensure that anyone convicted for protesting gets the medical care they require."
Human Rights Watch is one of the world's leading independent organizations dedicated to defending and protecting human rights. By focusing international attention where human rights are violated, we give voice to the oppressed and hold oppressors accountable for their crimes. Our rigorous, objective investigations and strategic, targeted advocacy build intense pressure for action and raise the cost of human rights abuse. For 30 years, Human Rights Watch has worked tenaciously to lay the legal and moral groundwork for deep-rooted change and has fought to bring greater justice and security to people around the world.
LATEST NEWS
UN Chief Warns of Israel's Syria Invasion and Land Seizures
United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres stressed the "urgent need" for Israel to "de-escalate violence on all fronts."
Dec 12, 2024
United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres said Thursday that he is "deeply concerned" by Israel's "recent and extensive violations of Syria's sovereignty and territorial integrity," including a ground invasion and airstrikes carried out by the Israel Defense Forces in the war-torn Mideastern nation.
Guterres "is particularly concerned over the hundreds of Israeli airstrikes on several locations in Syria" and has stressed the "urgent need to de-escalate violence on all fronts throughout the country," said U.N. spokesperson Stephane Dujarric.
Israel claims its invasion and bombardment of Syria—which come as the United States and Turkey have also violated Syrian sovereignty with air and ground attacks—are meant to create a security buffer along the countries' shared border in the wake of last week's fall of former Syrian President Bashar al-Assad and amid the IDF's ongoing assault on Gaza, which has killed or wounded more than 162,000 Palestinians and is the subject of an International Court of Justice genocide case.
While Israel argues that its invasion of Syria does not violate a 1974 armistice agreement between the two countries because the Assad dynasty no longer rules the neighboring nation, Dujarric said Guterres maintains that Israel must uphold its obligations under the deal, "including by ending all unauthorized presence in the area of separation and refraining from any action that would undermine the cease-fire and stability in Golan."
Israel conquered the western two-thirds of the Golan Heights in 1967 and has illegally occupied it ever since, annexing the seized lands in 1981.
Other countries including France, Russia, and Saudi Arabia have criticized Israel's invasion, while the United States defended the move.
"The Syrian army abandoned its positions in the area... which potentially creates a vacuum that could have been filled by terrorist organizations," U.S. State Department spokesperson Matthew Miller said at a press briefing earlier this week. "Israel has said that these actions are temporary to defend its borders. These are not permanent actions... We support all sides upholding the 1974 disengagement agreement."
Keep ReadingShow Less
Sanders Says 'Political Movement,' Not Murder, Is the Path to Medicare for All
"Killing people is not the way we're going to reform our healthcare system," he said. "The way we're going to reform our healthcare system is having people come together."
Dec 12, 2024
Addressing the assassination of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson and conversations it has sparked about the country's for-profit system, longtime Medicare for All advocate Sen. Bernie Sanders on Wednesday condemned the murder and stressed that getting to universal coverage will require a movement challenging corporate money in politics.
"Look, when we talk about the healthcare crisis, in my view, and I think the view of a majority of Americans, the current system is broken, it is dysfunctional, it is cruel, and it is wildly inefficient—far too expensive," said Sanders (I-Vt.), whose position is backed up by various polls.
"The reason we have not joined virtually every other major country on Earth in guaranteeing healthcare to all people as a human right is the political power and financial power of the insurance industry and drug companies," he told Jacobin. "It will take a political revolution in this country to get Congress to say, 'You know what, we're here to represent ordinary people, to provide quality care to ordinary people as a human right,' and not to worry about the profits of insurance and drug companies."
Asked about Thompson's alleged killer—26-year-old Luigi Mangione, whose reported manifesto railed against the nation's expensive healthcare system and low life expectancy—Sanders said: "You don't kill people. It's abhorrent. I condemn it wholeheartedly. It was a terrible act. But what it did show online is that many, many people are furious at the health insurance companies who make huge profits denying them and their families the healthcare that they desperately need."
"What you're seeing, the outpouring of anger at the insurance companies, is a reflection of how people feel about the current healthcare system."
"What you're seeing, the outpouring of anger at the insurance companies, is a reflection of how people feel about the current healthcare system," he continued, noting the tens of thousands of Americans who die each year because they can't get to a doctor.
"Killing people is not the way we're going to reform our healthcare system," Sanders added. "The way we're going to reform our healthcare system is having people come together and understanding that it is the right of every American to be able to walk into a doctor's office when they need to and not have to take out their wallet."
"The way we're going to bring about the kind of fundamental changes we need in healthcare is, in fact, by a political movement which understands the government has got to represent all of us, not just the 1%," the senator told Jacobin.
The 83-year-old Vermonter, who was just reelected to what he says is likely his last six-year term, is an Independent but caucuses with Democrats and sought their presidential nomination in 2016 and 2020. He has urged the Democratic Party to recognize why some working-class voters have abandoned it since Republicans won the White House and both chambers of Congress last month. A refusal to take on insurance and drug companies and overhaul the healthcare system, he argues, is one reason.
Sanders—one of the few members of Congress who regularly talks about Medicare for All—isn't alone in suggesting that unsympathetic responses to Thompson's murder can be explained by a privatized healthcare system that fails so many people.
In addition to highlighting Sanders' interview on social media, Congressman Ro Khanna (D-Calif.) pointed out to Business Insider on Wednesday that "you've got thousands of people that are sharing their stories of frustration" in the wake of Thompson's death.
Khanna—a co-sponsor of the Medicare for All Act, led in the House of Representatives by Congressional Progressive Caucus Chair Pramila Jayapal (D-Wash.)—made the case that you can recognize those stories without accepting the assassination.
"You condemn the murder of an insurance executive who was a father of two kids," he said. "At the same time, you say there's obviously an outpouring behavior of people whose claims are being denied, and we need to reform the system."
Two other Medicare for All advocates, Reps. Maxwell Frost (D-Fla.) and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.), also made clear to Business Insider that they oppose Thompson's murder but understand some of the responses to it.
"Of course, we don't want to see the chaos that vigilantism presents," said Ocasio-Cortez. "We also don't want to see the extreme suffering that millions of Americans confront when your life changes overnight from a horrific diagnosis, and people are led to just some of the worst, not just health events, but the worst financial events of their and their family's lives."
Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.)—a co-sponsor of Sanders' Medicare for All Act—similarly toldHuffPost in a Tuesday interview, "The visceral response from people across this country who feel cheated, ripped off, and threatened by the vile practices of their insurance companies should be a warning to everyone in the healthcare system."
"Violence is never the answer, but people can be pushed only so far," she continued. "This is a warning that if you push people hard enough, they lose faith in the ability of their government to make change, lose faith in the ability of the people who are providing the healthcare to make change, and start to take matters into their own hands in ways that will ultimately be a threat to everyone."
After facing some criticism for those comments, Warren added Wednesday: "Violence is never the answer. Period... I should have been much clearer that there is never a justification for murder."
Keep ReadingShow Less
Reports Target Israeli Army for 'Unprecedented Massacre' of Gaza Journalists
"In Gaza, the scale of the tragedy is incomprehensible," wrote Thibaut Bruttin, director general of Reporters Without Borders.
Dec 12, 2024
Reports released this week from two organizations that advocate for journalists underscore just how deadly Gaza has become for media workers.
Reporters Without Borders' (RSF) 2024 roundup, which was published Thursday, found that at least 54 journalists were killed on the job or in connection with their work this year, and 18 of them were killed by Israeli armed forces (16 in Palestine, and two in Lebanon).
The organization has also filed four complaints with the International Criminal Court "for war crimes committed by the Israeli army against journalists," according to the roundup, which includes stats from January 1 through December 1.
"In Gaza, the scale of the tragedy is incomprehensible," wrote Thibaut Bruttin, director general of RSF, in the introduction to the report. Since October 2023, 145 journalists have been killed in Gaza, "including at least 35 who were very likely targeted or killed while working."
Bruttin added that "many of these reporters were clearly identifiable as journalists and protected by this status, yet they were shot or killed in Israeli strikes that blatantly disregarded international law. This was compounded by a deliberate media blackout and a block on foreign journalists entering the strip."
When counting the number of journalists killed by the Israeli army since October 2023 in both Gaza and Lebanon, the tally comes to 155—"an unprecedented massacre," according to the roundup.
Multiple journalists were also killed in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Mexico, Sudan, Myanmar, Colombia, and Ukraine, according to the report, and hundreds more were detained and are now behind bars in countries including Israel, China, and Russia.
Meanwhile, in a statement released Thursday, the International Federation of Journalists (IFJ) announced that at least 139 Palestinian journalists and media workers have been killed since the war in Gaza began in 2023, and in a statement released Wednesday, IFJ announced that 104 journalists had perished worldwide this year (which includes deaths from January 1 through December 10). IFJ's number for all of 2024 appears to be higher than RSF because RSF is only counting deaths that occurred "on the job or in connection with their work."
IFJ lists out each of the slain journalists in its 139 count, which includes the journalist Hamza Al-Dahdouh, the son of Al Jazeera's Gaza bureau chief, Wael Al-Dahdouh, who was killed with journalist Mustafa Thuraya when Israeli forces targeted their car while they were in northern Rafah in January 2024.
Keep ReadingShow Less
Most Popular