SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FREE NEWSLETTER

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FREE NEWSLETTER

Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.

* indicates required
5
#000000
#FFFFFF
Opinion
Climate
Economy
Politics
Rights & Justice
War & Peace
Stable genius still at work
Further

It's Fine: A Plumber and TV Has-Been Walked Into A Bar

Welcome to exceptional America's latest clusterfuck, wherein "the whole rust-bucket empire" is raining tech outages and other debacles and befuddled MAGA clowns and their imbecile rapist despot have no clue what broke the sky or anything else - maybe routers, switches, measles, Biden, Iran, Black people, trans people, copper wires, immigrants, the ICC, "extraordinary circumstances," or SI, aka Super Incompetence - but if you give them $50 billion they'll fix it. Or not.

Yes, Blue Wave, all good. But for now we are trapped in the apocalyptic timeline that occurs when too many racist, gullible, ill-informed dimwits elect a reality-show president who hires inept hacks who "say nice things about him on Fox News" and they all believe that whatever ensues - diarrhea lettuce, Tylenol autism, banks crashing, parking lot airports, drunken Nazis war crime-ing, pandering to dictators, and now "the week the machines quit" - is somebody else's problem. Add the advent of late-stage capitalism's newest brilliant idea - unregulated, potentially-humanity-destroying AI - and, Dr. Google reports, "The era of autonomous attacks has arrived."

First came last week's ground stop - over 6,000 flights scrapped, 10,000 delayed, 1.5 million travelers stranded, thousands stuck on runways eating pretzels for five hours - in a country that long ago took "one giant leap for mankind." After Trump got last year's big hideous bill passed and its $12.5 billion for "the most advanced air traffic control system on Earth - many decades (will) go by before this one gets obsolete" - we got a former plumber from Oklahoma with anger issues who voted against Biden's $10 billion FAA bill and a washed-up was MTV's The Real World: Boston trying to "explain" why the world's richest country's planes were all laid low.

Citing vague "extraordinary circumstances and safety," Transportation Guy Sean Duffy and Homeland Security Guy with two first names Markwayne Mullin - but no FAA guy - jabbered word salad about overloaded routers, faulty upgrades, copper wire swapped for fiber wire. They said "we're built to handle crises" and nobody was in danger but it was a miracle nobody died. They said it def wasn't the fault of their new $875 million AI system SMART overloading the old routers with data though AI is known for overloading old routers and besides the new system "isn't plugged in" - this from the wizards who named their brand new air traffic control system....Brand New Air Traffic Control System.

Duffy, in a Star Trekky outfit, declared, "This is an emergency. This is bipartisan. This is American." Also, "Trump is a builder, and he's going to deliver for the American people," a novel idea. He demanded $30 billion, then $50 billion to fix what's not yet diagnosed as cohorts spend billions on an illegal war and monstrous ballroom nobody wants. Response to why he's begging for money when his party runs everything: What network are you from? Why they're doing upgrades on a busy weekend: There will be a reevaluation of when we do the work. Could this be cyber warfare or other “nefarious” activity? "We don't believe so," but chainsaw-wielding DOGE fired everyone who looks for it so who knows.

Focusing on the important stuff, Mullin berated a reporter who used "AI" - "We call it SI around here" - before adding it wasn't an "SI attack," which is not a thing. He and Duffy contradicted each other, spilling the beans on what experts warn are the dangers of rushing to launch SMART without safety evaluations to avoid the kind of breakdown that just happened. On Sunday, Duffy went on all the TV news shows, hilariously denouncing "partisanship" while blaming "prior administrations" and ignoring Trump's prompt freezing of Biden's $25 billion to modernize the FAA. Still, he insisted, Trump "loves the airspace." Mullin chimed in, "This is what the leadership of President Trump looks like." LOL.

Many called bullshit; one report said of about 60 air traffic controllers interviewed, “None of them are buying what they said.” The head of the union representing over 11,000 FAA workers, who earlier charged DOGE with recklessly firing hundreds of essential workers, said they'd been replaced by contractors and weren’t involved in per-protocol upgrades or risk assessment. Dems want to investigate aviation "disarray," from the latest fiasco to chronic air-traffic controller shortages, communication breakdowns, where money's spent, and staff purges and funding cuts to cybersecurity and infrastructure Even MTG blasted the "shakedown for more money (as) the biggest fuck you to the American people."

Meanwhile, Duffy claimed the stable genius was "fully engaged" during the days of travel mayhem. Translation: He was huddled in the Oval Office babbling about movies with Jon Voight. He was "having many meetings on many subjects," and posting 13 times about the golf course he wants to fix up so "all over the world it will be acclaimed as the Best Golf Course anywhere" in a D.C. where "the people are happy and safe again!" He was insisting, “I don’t take any responsibility” for breaking air travel and Duffy/Mullin "acted incredibly, everybody was safe, nobody was hurt, no crashes, no nothing." He was proclaiming, "We need Congress to give us the money, FAST!"

He was also crudely assailing Yamiche Alcindor, a black female NBC reporter, for asking why he spends so much time on absurd, obscene vanity projects when the airline system is crumbling. "Lookit the White House - it's flawless," he raged. "Listen to me. I know you don't see dirt (where) you come from," but they had 18 broken windows and plaster falling off and he had "a responsibility" to put it "in decent shape." When she asked why not fund infrastructure, the "president" who's grifted $62 million in Nvidia stock yelled she was "so pathetic." "This doesn't cost money. This is peanuts. And I pay for it," he shrieked "This is called talent. You don’t have talent." Nothing to see here.

Except everything is breaking, and neither he nor his bumblers have a clue what to do about it. We've seen a cascading catastrophe of high-profile tech and other failures that together expose the complexity, fragility, mystery of vast systems we depend on daily, and of the expertise we desperately need - and possibly lack - to keep them afloat. The day before the airlines broke, a global Microsoft outage disrupted email and other basic online tools in over 70 countries, plunging millions of businesses and people into "a virtual snow day." The fail led to one of the first iterations of corporate-speak pleading to, "Please be patient. We are working to resolve this as quickly as possible.”

Many more followed. On Monday, America's behemoth JPMorganChase, with 86 million customers, said its systems were down due to a software bug; they later said there was no evidence of "unusual malicious activity," other than, you know, capitalism. On Tuesday, brokerage firm Charles Schwab, with $13 trillion of other people’s money, greeted customers who might want some of it with an “Internal Server Error"; they later described a “webpage loading issue." MInutes later, Equinor, one of Europes largest oil and gas producers, said it was under cyberattack. Soon after, Apple Pay shut down across the U.S., taking iCloud, App Store, Apple Music et al with it; no explanation was offered.

There was another short-lived outage at United Airlines, with 416 delayed flights, and then another. The NSA issued a "code yellow" when a highly classified network used for internal national security communications went down after experiencing “temporary degradation” during a routine maintenance; they said the system is built with "multiple layers of redundancy" to keep basic operations running. Experts said without more data it's hard to know if any of these fails constitute a cyber attack, but so many major outages in mere days "look suspiciously like what we'd expect one to look like." The consensus: “There’s a lot of weird stuff going on." So sure, let's keep building data centers.

Not all the dystopian weirdness, of course, is technology-related. Thanks to Sec. Brainworm, measles is no longer deemed "eliminated" in America, which now feels so scary that half of Trump's high-end flunkies - Miller, Hegseth, Rubio, previously Noem and Bondi - are moving onto military bases, building their own Green Zones safely away from the people they're supposed to be serving. Online sages speculate the latest refugee from reality, $700-million Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, is running scared from struggling Americans wondering where all their money's gone; Hegseth's move is said to prove he's firing so many generals because they need the houses.

In fact, the supremely incompetent Hegseth can claim his own micro clusterfuck. The Pentagon just failed its ninth consecutive audit even while it asks Congress for a record, "gobsmacking" $1.5 trillion. He's being sued by Ecuadorian survivors of a boat strike; the U.S. Coast Guard, wearing camo on a boat, cuffed them at gunpoint. In a harrowing 60 Minutes interview, a survivor of the Iran drone attack on a U.S. base in Kuwait that killed six American soldiers charged higher-ups repeatedly ignored warnings the makeshift base - marked on a list of Iran's targets - was so unprotected it was like "a trailer park"; the survivor has filed a formal whistleblower complaint with Congress.

Pete is such an arrogant putz he stepped up to cheerlead Marco Rubio when he defended the killings in the Caribbean, ripped a "fake" ICC for claiming they violate international law, and charged - exquisite pot/kettle - the Court has appointed themselves "judge, jury and executioner (who) supersede the laws of sovereign states." Hegseth's bombast: "Stop quoting laws to MEN WITH SWORDS." Iran's Foreign Minister's masterful response: "That quote was uttered by a Roman general whose final campaign ended in crushing defeat...He was beheaded after fleeing the battlefield. A better maxim: 'Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.'"

Cue a cartoon president, now cavorting with autocrats in Asia, who "reviewed a week in which Americans couldn’t fly, bank, email or pay for groceries with their phones, and concluded that stuff happens." Asked about the outages at Chase et al, the jerk who said only he could keep America safe said, "It's going to be very much under control." Asked if he's concerned about these rippling calamities, he said, "No. It's life. When you're big and powerful and have all the money, things like this happen. It's fine." Even Fox' Jesse Watters is perturbed by the "eerie" series of glitches: “The government’s telling us everything’s fine. It doesn’t seem like it...There needs to be a plan."

Alas, if we're facing Armageddon, it's with MAGA clowns in charge. Vonnegut-esque Markwayne Mullin, whose reviews to date range from "an idiot" to “a gym teacher subbing in for health class," insists, "The homeland is very secure." He also said of outages whose causes remain unknown, "I can tell you with complete certainty we are not under attack." He later amended his certainty to 98% after talking to a guy who's "very smart with tech" who said "it's the SI because these programs aren't designed to work as fast as SI (and) it causes a system to be overran." He also ungrammatically defended taking a government plane to Louisiana amidst airline turmoil to watch a football game with, “We would have never went if the airways weren’t open." Sigh.

His reality-TV bestie Sean Duffy, meanwhile, was silent for hours after an Amtrak train from D.C. to New York struck and killed a man in Maryland, train service around D.C. was halted, and thousands more travelers were again left stranded, this time in a station Duffy earlier insisted putting under his own department's control to "help make this city safe and beautiful." On Fox, he again blamed Biden for the airline bedlam, specifically his focus on woke issues like the name cockpit; he made the same claim after a 2025 plane crash in DC killed 67 people. JD also went on Fox to blame the airline mess on Dems and - more pot/kettle! - their "ridiculous obsession with men in women's sports."

The common cause of so much havoc, writes Jonathan Larsen, is in large part unbridled capitalism, which exists to make money, not safeguard us. "A lot of the systems that are failing are bad systems," he notes, including unbridled capitalism's "life in the name of economic growth." "If our systems are falling to their knees, that poses risks, but it’s also an opportunity to choose what stands up," he writes. "On Election Day, thousands of systems of human organizing beat the system (of) oligarchs spending millions...one sign of a growing hunger for, and power of, human-based systems." On Tuesday, FEMA aired an Emergency Alert System warning: "It is only a test." Frazzled America: "We don't trust you."

- YouTube www.youtube.com

SEE ALL
Senate Minority Leader Schumer Talks To Reporters At The US Capitol
News

Schumer Faces Fresh Call to Step Aside Over Latest Vote With GOP on Polluter-Friendly Permitting Bill

An environmental advocate is calling for Sen. Chuck Schumer to step down as Senate Democratic leader after he supported a permitting reform bill that critics say will empower polluters by weakening environmental regulations.

Schumer (D-NY), the Senate minority leader, was one of 14 Democrats who voted Wednesday to advance the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA), which cleared a procedural vote 65-31.

The bill would speed up the permitting process for energy and infrastructure projects by limiting environmental reviews and restricting the ability to challenge permitting decisions in court.

Democratic supporters of the bill celebrate it as a way to speed up the approval of clean energy infrastructure and drive down energy costs, pointing to projections that it will result in modest emissions reductions. But environmental groups warn the bill will also clear the way for much faster approval of fossil fuel infrastructure and artificial intelligence data centers, exposing communities on the front lines to the harms of industrial pollution.

Jim Walsh, the policy director at Food & Water Watch, said, "Sen. Schumer’s alignment with Republicans over a majority of his own Democratic caucus in voting to advance this terrible pro-polluter, pro-data center permitting bill is all the reason needed to demand that Schumer step down as leader of the Senate Democrats."

“Sadly, Schumer has failed to learn the primary lesson from last week’s midterm elections—that Americans are fed up with unchecked aggression from Big Tech and the out-of-control construction of AI data centers,” Walsh said. In virtually every local election in which data centers were on the ballot, voters opted to reject them in their communities.

“Time and again throughout this Congress, Schumer has supported the status quo. But the American people are loudly demanding real change," Walsh added. "Schumer must step down from party leadership for good."

Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.), who is challenging Schumer in the race for Senate majority leader, voted against the bill on Wednesday.

Like many Democrats who supported the legislation, Schumer framed his vote as a response to Americans’ concerns about high energy costs, an issue that helped fuel historic wins for the party nationwide.

“Americans are paying too much for energy, and we need to do something about it," Schumer said in a statement earlier this month. "For too long, our broken permitting system has held back cleaner, cheaper energy; driven up costs; and delayed good-paying jobs."

Erik Schlenker-Goodrich, executive director of the Western Environmental Law Center, has pushed back against this framing.

"This bill is being deceptively pushed as an ‘affordability’ bill when those benefits are at best meager, speculative, and won’t be felt for more than a decade while the harms to the people and places we love will start the moment this abomination of a bill is signed into law," he said.

According to an analysis by the Rhodium Group published earlier this month, BAAJA would reduce annual household electricity bills by just $41 to $66 by 2035, equivalent to about $3.42 to $5.50 per month.

Columbia University's Center on Global Energy Policy has projected that electricity costs may actually increase for Americans in the short term because construction costs could be passed along to consumers before savings are realized.

Meanwhile, many of the environmental effects from increased fossil fuel use and data center construction, such as water and air pollution, could be felt much sooner. Public health groups, including the American Public Health Association, have warned that BAAJA could increase rates of asthma, cardiovascular disease, certain cancers, and premature births by increasing exposure to polluting infrastructure.

"BAAJA may give us savings of a mere $15 a month in 15 years, while exponentially increasing asthma and cancer-causing pollution in our neighborhoods," said Mar Zepeda Salazar, legislative director at Climate Justice Alliance. "This is the ‘affordability win’ we are supposed to be grateful for?"

Though it appears on track to pass in the Senate, the bill has yet to get through the House of Representatives, where House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY), who is expected to become speaker in January, has raised some objections to its provisions on environmental protections and tribal sovereignty. If Congress doesn’t pass the bill before the new Congress begins in January, its backers would have to start over under Democratic majorities.

"The House has an opportunity now to acknowledge the clear will of the American people and rein in Big Tech’s data center attack," Walsh said. "It must start by rejecting this terrible pro-polluter, anti-environment permitting bill, and in so doing, demonstrate what political courage and common sense look like.”

SEE ALL
Epstein & Trump At Mar-A-Lago
News

Leak Reveals Deutsche Bank’s 'Bad Behavior'—Including Nearly $600 Million of Epstein-Linked Payments

A group of whistleblowers has released more than 15 million internal documents from Deutsche Bank that reveal what the Financial Times described in a Tuesday social media post as "bad behavior, systemic failures, and incompetence."

In a video summarizing the documents' most important revelations, Financial Times investigative reporter Dan McCrum said they expose the German bank's "hidden losses, secret payments to a Qatari, and money laundering at an industrial scale."


A Tuesday Financial Times report zeroed in on the bank's role in financing Jeffrey Epstein, as leaked records reveal the bank processed nearly $600 million of payments related to the late financier and convicted sex offender.

Specifically, the records show that internal regulators at the bank filed suspicious activity reports on $582 million worth of Epstein-related money transfers, including "payments to women, suspected misuse of charitable donations, and transfers from wealthy individuals such as Apollo Global Management co-founder Leon Black and hedge fund billionaire Glenn Dubin."

Although a report released in August by the office of US Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) accused Deutsche Bank of ignoring "massive withdrawals of cash for questionable purposes from Epstein's accounts," the leaked internal documents show that transfers enabled by the bank were far larger than previously known.

Epstein was far from the only infamous Deutsche Bank client, and Le Monde on Tuesday published an investigation into the bank's long financial relationship with President Donald Trump.

According to Le Monde, the leaked documents "provide for the first time direct evidence of suspicious transactions connecting companies owned by Trump" and a notorious Azerbaijani money laundering operation, which "was used throughout the 2010s to buy political influence and siphon off public funds for the benefit of Azerbaijan's elite."

The records reveal a number of suspicious transactions related to a Trump luxury hotel project in the Azerbaijani capital of Baku in the spring of 2015, just weeks before the real estate mogul and reality TV star would announce his first presidential campaign.

Le Monde singled out records showing attempts by entities at the heart of the "Azerbaijani Laundromat" to wire precisely $141,261.82 to DT Marks Baku LLC, a Delaware based firm responsible for collecting Trump licensing fees, in April 2015.

Le Monde explained that seeing "the same sum bouncing between four different bank accounts in just two weeks, with three different explanations" is "typical of how money-laundering operations function."

"By multiplying transfers and altering payment descriptions," Le Monde reported, "those behind the transactions obscure the financial chain and make tracing the origin of the funds nearly impossible. The complexity blurs the link between the often illicit origin of the money and its final beneficiary."

The New York Times reported on Tuesday that the internal Deutsche Bank records show the institution also blew off multiple internal warnings and continued financing oligarchs with ties to Russian President Vladimir Putin.

At least two divisions within the bank warned about the risks of continuing to do business with Russian billionaire Oleg Deripaska, as an internal report documented the many allegations against him, including money laundering, tax evasion, ties to organized crime, and using the legal system to "bully his competitors."

Despite this, the bank continued maintaining its relationship with Deripaska, whom it describe in an internal memo as "a reputable businessman and well-established business partner with a significant pipeline of further transactions."

Deutsche Bank finally broke off its ties to Russian oligarchs after Putin invaded Ukraine in 2022, but the Times noted it only did so after its competitors announced plans to exit the Russian market.

SEE ALL
Chuck Schumer and Sheldon Whitehouse
News

15 Senate Democrats Help Republicans Pass 'Giant Giveaway to Big Tech and Polluters'

The Republican-controlled US Senate, with the support of more than a dozen Democrats, passed a hotly contested bill that would weaken the Clean Water Act, the Endangered Species Act, and other key environmental laws to accelerate approval and development of energy projects, including climate-wrecking gas pipelines and data centers.

The final vote on the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) was 62-33, with nearly every Republican and 15 Democrats supporting passage. The 15 members of the Senate Democratic caucus who voted for the bill were Chris Coons (Del.), John Fetterman (Pa.), Ruben Gallego (Ariz.), Martin Heinrich (NM), John Hickenlooper (Colo.), Angus King (Maine), Amy Klobuchar (Minn.), Gary Peters (Mich.), Jack Reed (RI), Jacky Rosen (Nev.), Brian Schatz (Hawaii), Chuck Schumer (NY), Elissa Slotkin (Mich.), Mark Warner (Va.), and Sheldon Whitehouse (RI).

The legislation passed without ever facing a hearing in the Senate, a fact that Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.)—an outspoken opponent of the bill—called "pretty damn outrageous and offensive."

If passed by the House and signed into law by President Donald Trump—whose White House has backed the measure—BAAJA would limit the authority of federal courts to block energy projects due to violations of environmental protection laws. The measure would also exempt pipeline expansions from National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) review, potentially bar future administrations from rolling back previously approved projects, and restrict states' and tribes' ability to block projects under the Clean Water Act.

The legislation was endorsed by the American Petroleum Institute, the largest fossil fuel industry lobbying organization in the US. The group applauded Thursday's vote as "a major breakthrough on historic permitting reforms" and praised the legislation's lead sponsors, including Whitehouse and Sen. Mike Lee (R-Utah).

Environmental organizations expressed support for some elements of the legislation, such as provisions that would speed up transmission and grid modernization. But the good provisions don't outweigh the destructive ones, green groups said, arguing the bill's benefits are heavily tilted toward fossil fuel projects—and would likely be further tilted in that direction by the Big Oil-friendly Trump administration.

"Senators who voted for this bill should be ashamed," said Erich Pica, president of Friends of the Earth US. "Just weeks after Americans made clear they are tired of politicians putting corporate profits ahead of people, the Senate approved a giant giveaway to Big Tech and polluters. Calling this a bipartisan compromise doesn't change what it is: a reckless attack on our clean air, clean water, wildlife, public lands, oceans, and communities."

"It's bad enough that Republicans wanted to gut our environmental laws," Pica added. "It's unconscionable that Democrats helped them do it."

Some Democrats who supported advancing the bill in previous procedural votes switched their votes to no on final passage, including Sen. Andy Kim (NJ). In a statement posted to social media, Kim said he "voted earlier in the process to allow a debate and amendment process that could improve the bill before final passage."

"Unfortunately those improvements, which would rein in the worst impulses of the Trump administration, were not made, and the potential consequences for New Jersey are unacceptable," said Kim.

BAAJA's opponents called on the House, which will be narrowly controlled by Republicans until January, to reject the legislation.

"This bill identified the wrong problems and has therefore arrived at the wrong solutions," said David Watkins, director of federal government relations for the Climate and Energy Programs at the Union of Concerned Scientists. "The Clean Water Act isn’t the problem—the fossil fuel industry and their enablers in the Trump administration are responsible for throttling renewable energy deployment across the United States."

“The Senate’s bill is totally out of step with the message of the midterm elections. Policymakers must move on from the status quo driving high energy bills and record fossil fuel profits," Watkins added. "The House should reject BAAJA and negotiate a better bill in the new Congress in January, one that protects our environment, includes meaningful input from communities burdened by fossil fuel pollution, and makes cheaper and cleaner renewable energy more accessible to everyone."

SEE ALL
BANGLADESH-MYANMAR-ROHINGYA-ICJ-COURT-GENOCIDE
News

Myanmar Government Guilty of Genocide, International Court of Justice Says in Historic Ruling

In a historic ruling, the International Court of Justice on Thursday found Myanmar's government responsible for committing genocide against the Rohingya Muslim minority during its brutal military campaign in 2017.

It is the first time in the ICJ's 80-year history that it has found a state responsible for committing genocide under the 1948 Genocide Convention, with the court ruling in a 9-6 vote that "the only reasonable inference that can explain Myanmar’s actions is an intention to destroy a substantial part" of the Rohingya population.

ICJ President Yuji Iwasawa said the court found that during Myanmar's military campaign that began in northern Rakhine State in August 2017, "security forces killed thousands of Rohingya civilians, perpetrated widespread acts of sexual violence, as well as acts of extreme violence against children, and attacked fleeing Rohingya as they sought to flee in large numbers.”

In the case brought by the West African nation of The Gambia, the court found that the evidence supported UN investigators’ estimate that at least 10,000 Rohingya were killed, including women and children. It also showed soldiers committed widespread rape and sexual violence. The ICJ additionally found that Rohingya villages were systematically burned and destroyed while neighboring villages belonging to other ethnic groups were spared. In all, more than 700,000 Rohingya were forced to flee into neighboring Bangladesh.

The court ordered Myanmar to investigate, prosecute, and punish suspects, and enact laws implementing the Genocide Convention to prevent future violations. It also ordered the country to facilitate the voluntary return of displaced Rohingya, help locate missing people, return or replace lost or damaged property, provide rehabilitation for victims, and ensure protection against discrimination. Myanmar must also compensate the Rohingya for harm done with an amount to be determined later, the ICJ said.

The ruling was celebrated by human rights advocates. Amnesty International’s Secretary General Agnes Callamard called it "a historic and authoritative recognition of the atrocities committed against the Rohingya and a rare moment of justice for survivors, victims and their families."

She said the ruling "must serve as a wake-up call to the international community" and "must not simply be ignored," especially since those who committed the atrocities are still in positions of power.

“The man who oversaw a campaign of crimes against humanity and other crimes under international law against the Rohingya, the former head of the armed forces, Senior General Min Aung Hlaing, is now Myanmar’s president following engineered elections," she said. "Governments should not welcome him on the international stage, especially as grave violations continue unchecked inside Myanmar. Instead, they should stop any transfer of all weapons, security and surveillance equipment, and military and security assistance to Myanmar."

Maria Elena Vignoli, senior international justice counsel at Human Rights Watch, said that in addition to being a "long-awaited recognition of the suffering the Rohingya have endured from Myanmar’s military," it also "provides a significant precedent for victims of genocide, and other grave crimes, across the world in their own quest for justice.”

Nimer Sultany, a law professor at the University of London's School of Oriental and African Studies, said the ruling had massive implications for the December 2023 genocide case brought before the ICJ against Israel over its military campaign in Gaza.

"The court's application of the law to the facts in Myanmar makes it highly likely it will reach a similar conclusion in the case of Israel, given the scale of its crimes in Gaza," he said, adding that the ruling "breathes new life into the Genocide Convention."

Amid systematic attacks against international law led by the Trump administration, which has waged war on institutions such as the International Criminal Court (ICC), Antonio Guterres, the United Nations secretary-general, said the ruling against Myanmar "is a demonstration of international justice & a reaffirmation that impunity for such horrific acts must not stand."

While the ICJ's rulings are legally binding, it has no independent means of compelling Myanmar to comply.

University of Manitoba law professor and genocide scholar Kjell Anderson argued that while the ruling "will not immediately change the situation on the ground," it may help to "mobilize attention and support for the Rohingya."

"This should also help to create some moral clarity for states in the region—like Malaysia, Thailand, India, and China—that are cozying up to the Myanmar government, and, in some cases, sending Rohingya back into a tremendously dangerous situation."

Anderson shared a message he received from a Rohingya friend living in the Kutupalong camp in Bangladesh.

"Today is a deeply emotional and historic day for the Rohingya," they said. "After everything our people have endured, this moment gives us renewed hope for justice, dignity, and a better future and return to the homeland."

SEE ALL
Protest held outside New York Times building over the paper's coverage of Iran
News

Iran Slams 'Baseless' US Media Speculation on Dirty Bomb Plot, Dual-Use Dams

Iranian officials on Tuesday condemned speculative reporting by CNN that Tehran is plotting a chemical or "dirty bomb" attack on Washington, DC, and by The New York Times that Iran may be building dams to supply underground missile sites with water, while critics noted the US corporate media's history of amplifying unsubstantiated claims to manufacture consent for war.

Iran's United Nations Mission in New York said on social media that "the recent preposterous allegations published by The New York Times concerning Iran’s dams, alongside CNN’s fabricated narrative about an alleged 'dirty bomb,' are part of a calculated disinformation campaign designed to manufacture pretexts for further aggression and war crimes."

The mission told CNN that "Iran considers the use of chemical weapons under any circumstances to be wholly illegitimate," remarks that came from the representative of a country that suffered frequent chemical attacks by US-backed Iraqi forces that killed and wounded hundreds of thousands of Iranian soldiers and civilians in the 1980s.

Iranian Foreign Minister Seyed Abbas Araghchi also took to social media, writing: "In the past 72 hours, pro-Israel media have 'reported' that Iran is supposedly plotting to use chemical weapons in DC while building missile bases under dams. RUBBISH."

"Spare us the Iraq War-style propaganda, especially with Israeli fingerprints all over it," Araghchi added. "Nobody is buying it."

Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesperson Esmaeil Baqaei accused "those who initiated the aggression against Iran" of "now seeking to lay the media groundwork for their sinister designs by manufacturing and disseminating baseless allegations, including the recent claims published by The New York Times and the fabricated media narrative surrounding an alleged 'dirty bomb' propagated by CNN."

"Step by step, they are attempting to manufacture a veneer of legitimacy for further aggression and atrocities," he added.

Iranian Parliamentary Speaker Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf also responded to the Times article on social media.

"Cool," he wrote. "New rule: Any dam, port, or power plant near a US or Israeli base is dual-use. We’ll apply your logic consistently and even-handedly."

The Times article—written by Sanam Mahoozi, a London-based Iranian journalist, and Erika Solomon, the newspaper's bureau chief in Iran and Iraq—acknowledges in its third paragraph that "any connection" between Iran's missile program and its "ambitious, decades-old initiative to develop water infrastructure remains speculative."

"No conclusive evidence—but questions worth asking," Mohoozi wrote in a social media post promoting the piece.

CNN's "exclusive" article cites seven unnamed US officials who claim American intelligence agencies believe Iran is developing plans to potentially target senior Trump administration officials in Washington with a radioactive or chemical weapon.

The report describes the alleged planning as an effort by Tehran to give itself options, rather than evidence of an imminent attack.

As US corporate media outlets amplified the speculative reports, the White House itself appeared to undercut the alarmist framing, with spokesperson Lauren Bis tsaying Monday that "at this time, there are no credible threats to the homeland.”

Experts on the subjects covered in the CNN and Times articles joined critics and analysts of the corporate media in condemning the pieces.

Kaveh Madani, director of the United Nations University's Institute for Water, Environment, and Health in Canada, told Al Jazeera, “I’m one of the people quoted in the [Times] article, but my comments had nothing to do with dams or missiles!”

"Speculation is not evidence. Spatial proximity is not causality," Madani said on social media. "Even those who attacked Iran have not made such claims linking dams to missiles!"

"This reductionist, sensational narrative is irresponsible journalism with potentially dangerous consequences for civilian water infrastructure," he added. "The New York Times should know better."

"I’m one of the people quoted in the article, but my comments had nothing to do with dams or missiles!”

Addressing Mahoozi, Pakistani journalist Mahlia S. Lone said: "You are advocating for war crimes to be committed. This is not journalism."

Samira Moyheddin, founder of the independent digital journalism outlet On The Line Media, also replied to Mahoozi, saying, "This is shameful journalism and you know it."

Lebanese-American journalist and political analyst Rami Khouri called the Times article troubling, arguing that it reflected the complicity of US mainstream media in American and Israeli military aggression, as during the Iraq War and the ongoing Israeli genocide in Gaza.

"The telltale sign of noncredible wobbly journalism is when conditional words like 'speculative', 'suggestive', 'may have developed', 'may shed light', 'suspect', and 'long-term riddle' occur more often than any definitive, evidence-based facts," Khouri told Al Jazeera.

"Another sad day for US mainstream journalism," he added.

At the independent progressive news site Truthout, editor-in-chief Negin Owliaei said on Bluesky that the Times story "broke" her, with its "pure speculation about whether dams in Iran are powering missile cities with absolutely no evidence, proof, or logical explanation."

Owliaei added that she was "actually shocked it got published, even in the Judith Miller outlet."

Dubbed "woman of mass destruction" by Times colleague Maureen Dowd, an opponent of both the Iraq and Iran wars, Miller and other US journalists infamously regurgitated Bush administration lies about Iraq's nonexistent weapons of mass destruction in the run-up to the illegal war that killed hundreds of thousands of people and wrecked much of the country.

Miller subsequently resigned in disgrace, and Times editors later published an extraordinary mea culpa, but by that time, Iraqi casualties numbered tens of thousands killed or wounded, and those of US-led coalition troops in the thousands.

Laila Al-Arian, executive producer of Al Jazeera’s “Fault Lines,” said Monday that the CNN dirty bomb article is "giving Iraq WMDs reporting.”

New York Times spokesperson Nicole Taylor defended the newspaper's reporting on Iran's dam program, saying that the article "accurately cited research and analysis by seven international experts," and "provided readers with a deeper understanding of Iranian infrastructure investment and the effects of US and Israeli attacks on civilians."

"Framing the independent reporting as a pretext for violence is dangerous," Taylor added.

As for CNN—which had not yet publicly commented on the dirty bomb piece—its own employees have alleged a pro-Israel editorial bias in coverage of the Gaza genocide, which one staffer called "journalistic malpractice."

Trump has demonstrated that he does not need much pretext to wage his illegal war of choice on Iran and bomb civilian infrastructure, including oil facilities, power plants, water reservoirs, bridges, hospitals, and other sites—including an elementary school where 156 students and staff were massacred on the first day of the war.

However, the CNN and Times articles come amid fears of renewed US-Israeli attacks on civilian targets in Iran, and Trump responded directly to the reports during a Tuesday press conference in which he was asked whether there was any imminent threat from Tehran.

"Well, if there is, they will pay a price the likes of which no country has ever paid before," Trump said. "I hope it's not, but... we take it very seriously because they happen to be crazy."

SEE ALL