Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

"The political terrain these writers describe is barely recognizable even though they speak of events that occurred just last year," Gallagher writes. (Photo: DonkeyHotey/Flickr/cc)

Move to the Center! And Then? Move to the Center!

A recent New York Times op-ed argues that Democrats should continue pursuing corporate centrism, despite all of the evidence that it has been a disastrous failure

Tom Gallagher

Whatever else you might want to say about the corporate types who dominate the Democratic Party, you’ve got to give some of them an “A” for audacity.

The latest to register for top scores are Mark Penn and Andrew Stein who have raised the cry, “Back to the Center, Democrats” in a New York Times op-ed piece. Now, in case any of you have forgotten, Bernie Sanders did not actually win the Democratic nomination.

It was the centrist Hillary Clinton who did; the Clinton who lost to the most unpopular major party presidential candidate since the start of polling on such things; the Clinton that the establishment Democrats stuck with despite virtually every poll saying that Sanders ran stronger against Donald Trump than she did.

Given that Penn’s byline says that he “served as pollster and senior adviser to Bill and Hillary Clinton from 1995 to 2008,” you’d figure he might remember that, but apparently not.

In fact, Hillary Clinton appears nowhere in the these two gentlemen’s telling of the story of what has led to the decline of the Democratic Party in recent years. They tell us that “Democrats lost over 1,000 legislative seats across the country and control of both houses of Congress during the Obama years.”

Why was that?

Well, it appears that one of the problems is that “Candidates inspired by Senator Bernie Sanders, Senator Elizabeth Warren and a host of well-funded groups have embraced sharply leftist ideas.”

The fact is, of course, that any candidates inspired by the above mentioned Senators have attempted to stem the previous years’ decline of the Democratic Party dominated by precisely the“centrist” views the authors are promoting. 

Indeed, the political terrain these writers describe is barely recognizable even though they speak of events that occurred just last year. For instance, they decry the Democrats’ “loss of support among working-class voters, who feel abandoned by the party’s shift away from moderate positions on trade.”

From this, you’d never know that the presidential candidate whose name is apparently not to be mentioned is generally thought to have lost working class support to Trump precisely because of her “moderate,” establishment, pro-NAFTA position on trade which these gentleman embrace. 

They assert, reasonably enough, that in healthcare the Democrats “have a coherent message about protecting the working poor from losing coverage,” and yet, just like the 2016 Democratic standard bearer, they have nothing to say about adopting a plan that would actually offer the type of universal coverage that every other industrialized country already has.

And they argue that somehow the left is apparently responsible for the fact that “in special elections for Congress this year,” Democrats “failed to take back any seats held by Republicans”—even when the candidates were centrists like Georgia Democrat Jon Ossoff, who also declined to support a single-payer, universal health insurance program. 

It’s a truism that the publication of op-ed pieces in newspapers like the New York Times has more to do with the details contained in the authors’ bylines than in the quality of the ideas in the text above. Which makes one think that the editors involved might take a deeper look into the authors’ bonafides.

So far as Penn goes, the Times editors are probably not terribly off—his resume also includes work for former U.K. Prime Minister Tony Blair, the British equivalent of Bill Clinton, former right wing Israeli Prime Minister Menachim Begin, and a stint as a Microsoft executive—pretty much what you might expect from a corporate Democrat arguing a “centrist” line.

Stein’s credentials seem a bit shakier, though. Identified as “a former Manhattan borough president and New York City Council president,” he also once (unsuccessfully) sought the support of the Republican and Conservative Parties to challenge David Dinkins, a Democratic Mayor of New York City. Subsequently he pled guilty to lying about his involvement with Ken Starr, who did time for his role as a Ponzi scheme financial advisor to the stars. 

Still, none of that would matter for much, if the authors had any kind of coherent message, but given that they are arguing a typical centrist corporate Democrat line while using a variety of pseudo-proletarian covers—opposing "[i]dentity politics, class warfare and big government," that is never really a possibility. Perhaps they figure that this matters for little these days, given that the current state of White House politics is such that truth, honesty and consistency count for little. Let’s hope that they are wrong.

Certainly we Sanders Democrats, who supported a candidate who actually argued the pro-working class views which these confused-at-best writers claim to espouse, think that they are profoundly wrong.

Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
Tom Gallagher

Tom Gallagher

Tom Gallagher is a former Massachusetts State Representative and the author of 'The Primary Route: How the 99% Take On the Military Industrial Complex.' He lives in San Francisco.

This is the world we live in. This is the world we cover.

Because of people like you, another world is possible. There are many battles to be won, but we will battle them together—all of us. Common Dreams is not your normal news site. We don't survive on clicks. We don't want advertising dollars. We want the world to be a better place. But we can't do it alone. It doesn't work that way. We need you. If you can help today—because every gift of every size matters—please do. Without Your Support We Simply Don't Exist.

Patient Group Targets Pair of Democrats for 'Selling Us Out to Drug Companies'

"It makes me so angry that members of Congress are choosing Big Pharma over patients. It's unforgivable."

Jake Johnson ·

Judge Blocks Biden From Continuing 'Inhumane' Trump Policy to Deport Families

"This is not the end of the battle against this practice," said one rights group, "but it is a major step to ensure that the U.S. welcomes these asylum-seeking families—as we should."

Jessica Corbett ·

400+ Economists Press Congress to Permanently Expand Child Tax Credit

Such an expansion would "dramatically reduce childhood poverty in the United States," they said.

Andrea Germanos ·

Biden Admin. Sued for Letting Big Oil Harass 'Imperiled' Polar Bears

"We're hopeful the court will overturn this dangerous rule that puts polar bears in the crosshairs."

Jessica Corbett ·

'Cruel and Callous': Biden Slammed for Resuming Deportations to Battered Haiti

"Hours after the 7.2 magnitude earthquake, President Joe Biden released a statement saying that the United States was a 'friend' of Haiti. A 'friend' does not continuously inflict pain on another friend," said Guerline Jozef of the Haitian Bridge Alliance.

Kenny Stancil ·

Support our work.

We are independent, non-profit, advertising-free and 100% reader supported.

Subscribe to our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values.
Direct to your inbox.

Subscribe to our Newsletter.

Common Dreams, Inc. Founded 1997. Registered 501(c3) Non-Profit | Privacy Policy
Common Dreams Logo