SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FREE NEWSLETTER
Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.
5
#000000
#FFFFFF
To donate by check, phone, or other method, see our More Ways to Give page.
Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.
Ken Bossong 301-270-6477 x.11
In a group letter sent to President Obama, members of his Administration, and all the Members of the U.S. Congress, 142 organizations and businesses wrote that the Japanese nuclear accident is a tragic reminder that it is long past the time to end U.S. reliance on nuclear power.
The groups argued that nuclear plants can never be designed to withstand all potential "acts of God," all instances of "human error," all types of "mechanical malfunction," and all forms of "terrorist attack."
In a group letter sent to President Obama, members of his Administration, and all the Members of the U.S. Congress, 142 organizations and businesses wrote that the Japanese nuclear accident is a tragic reminder that it is long past the time to end U.S. reliance on nuclear power.
The groups argued that nuclear plants can never be designed to withstand all potential "acts of God," all instances of "human error," all types of "mechanical malfunction," and all forms of "terrorist attack."
Moreover, the still unfolding nuclear disaster in Japan once again underscores that there is no such thing as "safe" or "clean" or "cheap" nuclear power.
Consequently, no new reactors should be built in the Untied States and existing nuclear reactors should be phased out as rapidly as possible. Instead, national energy policy and funding should be refocused on greatly improved energy efficiency and the rapid deployment of renewable energy sources which are far cleaner, safer, and cheaper than nuclear power.
The text of the letter and list of signers follows.
# # # # # # #
March 23, 2011
President Barack Obama
Secretary of Energy Steven Chu
U.S. Senator Harry Reid
U.S. Senator Mitch McConnell
U.S. Representative John Boehner
U.S. Representative Nancy Pelosi
Members, U.S. Congress
Dear Sir/Madam:
We, the 142 undersigned safe energy advocates, have been speaking out about the risks and dangers posed by nuclear power for years - for many of us, since before the 1986 Chornobyl and 1979 Three Mile Island accidents as well as the hundreds of other radioactive releases, unplanned shut-downs, and other mishaps that have continuously plagued both the U.S. and the international nuclear industries since their founding.
While nuclear power's unacceptable safety, environmental, public health, economic, and national security risks should have been self-evident long before now, the latest unfolding nuclear disaster in Japan once again underscores the following:
Nuclear plants can never be designed to withstand all potential "acts of God."
Nuclear plants can never be designed to withstand all instances of "human error."
Nuclear plants can never be designed to withstand all types of "mechanical malfunction."
Nuclear plants can never be designed to withstand all forms of "terrorist attack."
There is no such thing as "safe" nuclear power.
There is no such thing as "clean" nuclear power.
There is no such thing as "cheap" nuclear power.
Consequently, the Price-Anderson cap on liability in the event of an accident should be repealed, all proposed governmental financial and regulatory incentives for new nuclear plant construction - including loan guarantees, accelerated licensing, and inclusion in a "clean energy standard" - should be rejected, and no new reactors should be built.
Existing nuclear reactors should be phased out as rapidly as possible, beginning with the oldest and/or most unsafe, and no presently-licensed reactors should have their operating lives extended.
Safety standards for existing reactors should be substantially tightened while they continue to operate and federal nuclear funding should be redirected to the orderly phase-out of those reactors as well as the safe decommissioning of closed reactors and disposal of radioactive waste.
National energy policy and funding should be refocused on greatly improved energy efficiency and the rapid deployment of renewable energy sources which are far cleaner, safer, and cheaper than nuclear power.
Sincerely,
Michael Closson, Executive Director
Acterra: Action for a Healthy Planet
Palo Alto, CA
Aur J. Beck, Chief Tech
Advanced Energy Solutions
Pomona, IL
Lesley Weinstock, Coordinator
Agua es Vida Action Team
Albuquerque, NM
Rochelle Becker, Executive Director
Alliance for Nuclear Responsibility
San Luis Obispo, CA
Laura Filbert Zacher, CEO
ARE Systems, LLC
St. Louis, MO
Thea Paneth, Secretary
Arlington United for Justice with Peace
Arlington, MA
Mari Rose Taruc, State Organizing Director
Asian Pacific Environmental Network
Oakland, CA
Lara Morrison, Board Member
Beverly-Vermont Community Land Trust
Los Angeles, CA
Kay Martin, Vice President
BioEnergy Producers Association
Gualala, CA
Kay Firor, President
Blue Mountain Solar, Inc.
Cove, OR
Sandra Gavutis, Executive Director
C-10 Research & Education Foundation
Newburyport, MA
Laurent Meillon, Director
Capitol Solar Energy LLC
Denver, CO
Elizabeth C. Battocletti, President
The Carmel Group, LLC
Reston, VA
Gwen Ingram, Vice President
The Carrie Dickerson Foundation
Tulsa, OK
Don Timmerman, Roberta Thurstin Timmerman
Casa Maria Catholic Worker Community
Milwaukee, WI
Kieran Suckling
Center for Biological Diversity
Washington, DC
Andy Kimbrell, Executive Director
Center for Food Safety
Lenny Siegel, Executive Director
Center for Public Environmental Oversight
Mountain View, CA
Lucy Law Webster, Executive Director
Center for War/Peace Studies
New York, NY
David Hughes, Executive Director
Citizen Power
Pittsburgh, PA
Deb Katz
Citizens Awareness Network
Shelburne, MA
Janet Greenwald, Co-coordinator
Citizens for Alternatives to Radioactive Dumping
Albuquerque, NM
Caroline Snyder
Citizens for Sludge-Free Land
North Sandwich, NH
Robert Singleton, Nuclear Issues Chair
Citizens Organized to Defend Austin
Austin, TX
Charlie Higley, Executive Director
Citizens Utility Board of Wisconsin
Madison, WI
Pam Solo, President
(Co-convener, TheCLEAN.org)
The Civil Society Institute
Newton, MA
Norm Cohen
Coalition for Peace and Justice
Linwood, NJ
Cristina Castro, Coordinator
CODEPINK NYC
New York, NY
Medea Benjamin, Co-Founder
CODEPINK Women for Peace
Washington, DC
Bill Gallegos, Executive Director
Communities for a Better Environment
Huntington Park & Oakland, CA
Tam Hunt, J.D., President,
Community Renewable Solutions LLC
Santa Barbara, CA
John Calandrelli, Chapter Program Director
Connecticut Chapter of Sierra Club
Hartford, CT
Nancy Burton, Director
Connecticut Coalition Against Millstone
Redding, CT
Luke Lundemo, Director
Conscious Living Project
Jackson, MS
Lois Arkin, Executive Director
CRSP Institute for Urban Ecovillages
Los Angeles, CA
Stephen M. Brittle, President
Don't Waste Arizona, Inc.
Phoenix, AZ
Kathryn Barnes, Board of Directors
Don't Waste Michigan - Sherwood Chapter
Sherwood, MI
Lois Barber, Co-founder & Executive Director
EarthAction & 2020 Action
Amherst, MA
Jane E. Magers, Coordinator
Earth Care, Inc
Des Moines, IA
Chris Trepal, Executive Director
Earth Day Coalition
Cleveland, OH
Al Fritsch, SJ
Earth Healing
Ravenna, KY
Lester R. Brown
Earth Policy Institute
Washington, DC
Jim Bell, Director
Ecological Life Systems Inst. Inc.
San Diego, CA
Mahlon Aldridge, Vice President
Ecology Action
Santa Cruz, CA
Cara L. Campbell, Chair
Ecology Party of Florida
Ft. Lauderdale, FL
Dan Stafford, Organizing Director
Environmental Action
Denver, CO
William Snape
Environmental Law Program
American University Law School
Washington, DC
Lillian K. Light, President
Environmental Priorities Network
Manhattan Beach, CA
Don Ogden, Producer
The Enviro Show-WXOJ-LP & WMCB
Florence, MA
Jennifer Barker
EORenew/SolWest Fair
Canyon City, OR
Ben Mancini, President
EV Solar Products, Inc.
Chino Valley, AZ
Judi Poulson, Chair
Fairmont, Minnesota USA Peace Group
Fairmont, MN
Linda S. Ochs, Director
Finger Lakes Citizens for the Environment
Waterloo, NY
Dan Brook, Ph.D.
Food for Thought---and Action
San Jose, CA
Jon Blickenstaff, Treasurer
Footprints for Peace
Cincinnati, OH
Nick Mann, Legislative Program Assistant-Environment
Friends Committee on National Legislation
Washington, DC
Richard V. Sidy, President
Gardens for Humanity
Sedona, AZ
Amanda Hill-Attkisson, Managing Director
Georgia Women's Action for New Directions
Atlanta, GA
Peter Meisen, President
Global Energy Network Institute
San Diego, CA
Bruce K. Gagnon, Coordinator
Global Network Against Weapons & Nuclear Power in Space
Brunswick, ME
Casey Coates Danson, President
Global Possibilities
Los Angeles, CA
Barbara Harris
Granny Peace Brigade NY
New York, NY
Vicky Steinitz
Greater Boston United for Justice with Peace Coalition
Boston, MA
Alisa Gravitz, Executive Director
Green America
Washington, DC
Jennifer Olaranna Viereck, Executive Director
HOME: Healing Ourselves & Mother Earth
N. Bennington, VT
Bonnie A. New, MD MPH; Director
Health Professionals for Clean Air
Houston, TX
Dr. Kathleen Sullivan, Program Director
Hibakusha Stories
New York, NY
David Morris, Vice President
Institute for Local Self-Reliance
Minneapolis, MN
Jaydee Hanson, Policy Director
International Center for Technology Assessment
Washington, DC
Victor Menotti, Executive Director
International Forum on Globalization
San Francisco, CA
Christian May, Founder
iSupportSolar
Frederick, MD
Daniel Ziskin, PhD; President
Jews Of The Earth
Boulder, CO
Andy McDonald, Director
Kentucky Solar Partnership
Appalachia - Science in the Public Interest
Frankfurt, KY
Kay Tiffany, Steering Committee
Lexington Global Warming Action Coalition
Lexington, MA
Paul Gallimore, Director
Long Branch Environmental Education Center
Leicester, NC
Greg Mello
Los Alamos Study Group
Albuquerque, NM
Claudine Cremer, Owner
Meadow Cove Farm
Weaverville, NC
Linda Belgrave, Secretary
Miami for Peace & Justice
Coral Gables, FL
Barbara Jennings, CSJ, Coordinator
Midwest Coalition for Responsible Investment
St. Louis, MO
Mark Haim, Chair
Missourians for Safe Energy
Columbia, MO
Judy Treichel, Executive Director
Nevada Nuclear Waste Task Force
Las Vegas, NV
Lilia Diaz, Outreach Director
New Energy Economy
Santa Fe, NM
Penelope McMullen, SL
New Mexico Justice and Peace Coordinator
Loretto Community
Santa Fe, NM
Carolyn Treadway
No New Nukes
Normal, IL
Wells Eddleman, Staff Scientist
North Carolina Citizens Research Group
Durham, NC
Larry Bell, President
North East Arizona Energy Services Company
Concho, AZ
Barbara Haack, Member
North Shore Coalition for Peace and Justice
Ipswich, MA
David Borris, President
North Suburban Peace Initiative and Chicago Area Peace Action
Evanston, IL
Nina Bell, J.D., Executive Director
Northwest Environmental Advocates
Portland, OR
Alice Slater, NY Director
Nuclear Age Peace Foundation
New York, NY
David Krieger, President
Nuclear Age Peace Foundation
Santa Barbara, CA
Wendy Oser, Director
Nuclear Guardianship Project
Berkeley, CA
Jack & Felice Cohen-Joppa, editors
The Nuclear Resister
Tucson, AZ
Arn Specter, Editor
The Nuclear Review
Philadelphia, PA
Glenn Carroll, Coordinator
Nuclear Watch South
Atlanta, GA
Chris Daum, President
Oasis Montana Inc. Renewable Energy Supply & Design
Stevensville, MT
Philip Tymon, Administrative Director
Occidental Arts and Ecology Center
Occidental, CA
Patricia A. Marida, Chair-Nuclear Issues Committee
Ohio Sierra Club
Columbus, OH
Dave Robinson, Executive Director
Pax Christi USA
Washington, DC
Judi Friedman, Chair
PACE (People's Action for Clean Energy, Inc.)
Canton, CT
Aviv Goldsmith, President
Precursor Systems, Inc.
Spotsylvania, VA
Launce Rake, Communications Director
Progressive Leadership Alliance of Nevada
Carson City/Las Vegas/Reno, Nevada
Elizabeth O'Nan, Director
Protect All Children's Environment
Marion, NC
Joy Blackwood
Public Health Educator
Landover, MD
Anne Mitchell, General Secretary
Quaker Earthcare Witness
Burlington, VT
Tor Allen, Executive Director
The Rahus Institute
Sebastopol, CA
Michael Welch, volunteer
Redwood Alliance
Arcata, CA
Tena Willemsma
Religious Leaders for Coalfield Justice
Winchester, VA
Quintin Bullis, GC-Sales/Installer Solar Energy Systems
Renaissance Developers
Tunnel, NY
Ron Leonard, Founder
RenewableEnergyCoalition.org
Woodstock, NY
Gordian Raacke, Executive Director
Renewable Energy Long Island
East Hampton, NY
Andreas Karelas, Executive Director
RE-volv
San Francisco, CA
Peggy Kurtz, Co-coordinator
Rockland Sierra Club
Nyack, NY
Russell Lowes, Research Director
Tucson, AZ
Clare Ritchie, Chairperson
Salem Peace Committee
Salem, MA
Elaine Holder, President
San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace
Mothers for Peace Action Committee
San Luis Obispo, CA
David Brown Kinloch, President
Shaker Landing Hydro Associates, Inc.
Louisville, KY
Rabbi Arthur Waskow, Director
The Shalom Center
Philadelphia, PA
Dennis R. Winters, Chair
Sierra Club - Pennsylvania Chapter
Philadelphia, PA
Mark Dickson, Owner
Simple Power, LLC (Renewable Energy Design and Installation)
Stevensville, MT
Sr. Ellen Orf, CPPS; Leadership Team member
Sisters of the Most Precious Blood
O'Fallon, MO
Diana Oleskevich CSJA, Justice Coordinator
Sisters of St. Joseph of Carondelet, St. Louis Province
St. Louis, MO
Scott Sklar, President
The Stella Group, Ltd.
Arlington, VA
Stuart Magruder, AIA, LEED, Principal
Studio Nova A Architects, Inc.
Los Angeles, CA
Erika Schneider, Outreach Coordinator
Sundance Power Systems
Weaverville, NC
Ken Bossong, Executive Director
SUN DAY Campaign
Takoma Park, MD
John F Neville, President
Sustainable Arizona
(statewide), AZ
Rona Fried, CEO
SustainableBusiness.com
Huntington Station, NY
Ron Hubert, President
Sustainable Economic Development Initiative of Northern Arizona
(Managing Director - Hozho International)
Flagstaff, AZ
Karen Hadden, Executive Director
Sustainable Energy & Economic Development (SEED) Coalition
Austin, TX
Melissa Everett, Ph.D., Executive Director
Sustainable Hudson Valley
Kingston, NY
Charles Jansen, Initiating Group Member
Transition Asheville
Asheville, NC
H. Patricia Hynes, Chair - Board
Traprock Center for Peace and Justice
Greenfield, MA
Chuck Learned, Director
Tri Local Returns
Madison, WI
Marylia Kelley, Executive Director
Tri-Valley CAREs
Livermore, CA
Dr. Brian Moench, President
Utah Physicians for a Healthy Environment
Salt Lake City, UT
Dr. Don Richardson
Western NC Physicians For Social Responsibility
Brevard, NC
Chris Herman, Owner
Winter Sun Design
(Interim President - Edmonds Community Solar Cooperative)
Edmonds, WA
Diane Farsetta, PhD, Executive Director
Wisconsin Network for Peace and Justice
Madison, WI
Virginia Pratt, Chair
Women's International League for Peace and Freedom
Boston, MA
Suzanne Maxx, Founder/President/Ex.Dir.
World Team Now
Malibu, CA
Nathalie Worthington, Owner
Worthington Studios
St. Petersburg, FL
One analyst said the Nexstar-Tegna merger was "yet another threat to our democracy, with fewer media companies controlling what gets reported on and how."
Free press advocates warned Thursday that the Federal Communications Commission’s decision to greenlight Nexstar’s takeover of Tegna further imperils US democracy by accelerating the consolidation of broadcast media and extending the reach of right-wing propaganda.
According to The New York Times, the $6.2 billion deal will form a conglomerate that will "oversee 265 television stations in 44 states and Washington, reaching about 80% of US households," making it by far the largest owner of local TV news in the country. Nexstar is headed by megamillionaire Perry Sook.
Commissioner Anna Gomez, the lone Democrat currently serving on the FCC, accused her colleagues of rushing approval of the Nexstar-Tegna merger while keeping the general public completely in the dark.
"This merger was approved behind closed doors with no open process, no full commission vote, and no transparency for the consumers and communities who will bear the consequences," said Gomez, who added that the entire process was "meant to avoid public scrutiny."
Several critics echoed Gomez's concerns in denouncing approval of the merger.
Matt Wood, general counsel and vice president of policy at Free Press, accused the FCC of ignoring its own rules limiting broadcast TV station ownership to create a right-wing propaganda machine aimed at pushing the agenda of President Donald Trump and his allies.
"This deal would create a massive broadcast conglomerate willing to put the political agenda of Donald Trump over the needs of the communities local television serves," said Wood. "[FCC Chairman Brendan] Carr and his allies in Nexstar’s executive suites have put up a smokescreen of rhetoric designed to dupe people into believing that these national conglomerates are truly local stations."
John Bergmayer, legal director at Public Knowledge, described the FCC's merger approval as "a betrayal of the agency’s legal obligations and the public it is supposed to serve." He predicted the deal would have a devastating impact on the quality of local TV news.
“In every market where Nexstar already operates multiple stations, it has consolidated news operations, merged newsrooms, and cut staff," Bergmayer said. "Nexstar’s CEO told investors the company analyzed the overlap markets ‘line by line, person by person’ to determine where to make cuts. Fewer owners means fewer reporters, fewer editorial voices, and fewer checks on local power."
Bergmayer added that the merger is "yet another threat to our democracy, with fewer media companies controlling what gets reported on and how."
Jeff Jarvis, professor emeritus at the CUNY Graduate School of Journalism, warned that the merger is part of "the creation of state media" under the Trump administration, and described it as "even more dangerous than Ellison Inc.," a reference to the proposed mega-merger between Paramount Skydance—a company controlled by the son of billionaire Trump donor Larry Ellison—and Warner Bros. Discovery.
Even with FCC approval, Nexstar's acquisition of Tegna is not yet a done deal, as eight state attorneys general this week filed an antitrust lawsuit to block the merger.
California Attorney General Rob Bonta, one of the state AGs involved in the lawsuit, described the Nexstar-Tegna deal as "illegal, plain and simple."
"When broadcast media is owned by a handful of companies, we get fewer voices, less competition," said Bonta, "and communities lose the critical check on power that local journalism delivers."
"Trump doesn't need Israel's permission to end this war," said one observer. "The longer he waits, the more Americans pay."
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Thursday that "there has to be a ground component" to the war on Iran as a new survey of US voters showed just 7% support for a large-scale invasion involving American forces.
"It is often said that you can't win, you can't do revolutions from the air. That is true," Netanyahu told reporters during a press conference in Jerusalem. "You can do a lot of things from the air... but there has to be a ground component, as well. There are many possibilities for this ground component. And I take the liberty of not sharing with you all of those possibilities."
Netanyahu's insistence on the necessity of ground operations in Iran came as US President Donald Trump declared to reporters in the White House on Thursday, "I'm not putting troops anywhere."
"If I were," he added, "I certainly wouldn't tell you."
A Reuters/Ipsos poll released Thursday found that just 7% of US voters support the idea of a large-scale ground invasion of Iran—but 65% of Americans believe that Trump will order such an operation anyway.
Just 34% of US voters would support "deploying a small number of special forces troops" to Iran, the survey found, while 55% said they would oppose the use of any ground troops.
The survey came days after Reuters reported that the Trump administration is "considering deploying thousands of US troops to reinforce its operation in the Middle East, as the US military prepares for possible next steps in its campaign against Iran."
The Pentagon's push for $200 billion in supplemental funding from the US Congress, which did not authorize the Iran war, amplified concerns that the Trump administration is gearing up for a prolonged conflict that could involve American troops on the ground, despite Trump's repeated public insistence that the war will be over "very soon."
Both US and Israeli intelligence agencies have reportedly assessed that Iran's regime is not on the verge of collapse after nearly three weeks of relentless bombing.
"Western officials and analysts who study Iran said they see little near-term prospect of a 'regime change' end to the 47-year-old Islamic republic or the rise of a more democratic government," The Washington Post reported earlier this week. "The latter is a goal cited by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and sometimes by President Donald Trump, who has said he’ll know the war is over 'when I feel it in my bones.'"
Raed Jarrar, advocacy director at the pro-democracy group DAWN, said Thursday that "the United States and Israel are not fighting the same war," pointing to recent Israeli strikes on Iranian energy infrastructure. The strikes drew a public rebuke from Trump, who is facing soaring gas prices at home due to the illegal war he launched in partnership with Netanyahu.
"Trump wants a quick exit. Netanyahu wants to permanently destroy Iran as a regional power," said Shakir. "There is an exit. Trump doesn't need Israel's permission to end this war. He's done it before in Yemen. The longer he waits, the more Americans pay."
Trita Parsi, executive vice president of the Quincy Institute for Responsible Statecraft, warned Thursday that Trump may be running out of time to "convincingly declare victory and provide himself a face-saving exit."
"Israel will do all it can to sabotage any such off-ramp, including killing Iranian's negotiators," Parsi wrote. "But it will become increasingly clear—if it hasn't already—to Trump that all his escalatory options only deepen the lose-lose situation he has put himself in."
"That's why Trump should never have listened to Netanyahu in the first place," he added.
"People can't afford childcare," said Sen. Bernie Sanders. "And this guy, in addition to giving tax breaks to billionaires, now wants to spend another $200 billion on a war that should never have been fought."
US Sen. Bernie Sanders said Thursday that it is absurd for the Trump administration to demand another $200 billion from Congress for an illegal war on Iran after lawmakers already approved $1 trillion in military spending for the year—and while millions of people across the nation are struggling to afford basic necessities.
"You got people all over this country, 20% of households, spending 50% of their income on housing," Sanders (I-Vt.) said in an appearance on MS NOW. "People can't afford healthcare. People can't afford childcare. And this guy, in addition to giving tax breaks to billionaires, now wants to spend another $200 billion on a war that should never have been fought."
The senator's remarks came as President Donald Trump, who has not yet formally requested the funds from Congress, suggested another $200 billion would be a "small price to pay" as the US-Israeli war on Iran heads toward its fourth week with no end in sight.
"I think the Trump people are in a bit of panic," Sanders said Thursday. "They're losing ground. Gas prices are soaring. There is massive discontent against this war. It's got to end, and we've got to make sure that Trump is neutered in 2026."
With the Trump administration considering a plan to deploy thousands of additional troops to the Middle East amid widespread fears of a ground invasion of Iran—which would explode the price tag of an already costly war—the National Priorities Project (NPP) released an analysis highlighting where the $200 billion requested by the Pentagon could be better spent.
The group estimated that $200 billion would be enough for all of the following this year:
"Pete Hegseth would rather the US bomb Iranian families than feed American families," wrote NPP's Lindsay Koshgarian, referring to the Pentagon secretary. "We should remember the lies that led us into war in Iraq a generation ago. That war ultimately cost nearly $3 trillion. We must not go down that path again. Our tax dollars should be helping struggling Americans, not feeding new forever wars."