Skip to main content

Why are the billionaires always laughing?

Because they know the corporate media will never call bullshit on their bullshit.

Why are the billionaires laughing?

It’s easy to laugh when the corporate press treats you as a glorious success instead of the epitome of a broken social order. Billionaires laugh because they know the corporate media prefers to fawn over them rather than hold them to account.

Today, we ask you to support our nonprofit, independent journalism because we are not impressed by billionaires flying into space, their corporations despoiling our health and planet, or their vast fortunes safely concealed in tax havens across the globe. We are not laughing.

We are hard at work producing journalism for the common good. With our Fall Campaign underway, please support this mission today. We cannot do it without you.

Support Our Work -- Join the small group of generous readers who donate, keeping Common Dreams free for millions of people each year. Every donation—large or small—helps us bring you the news that matters.

Screen shot from the new film "Snowden," featuring actor Joseph Gordon-Levitt as Edward Snowden and Shailene Woodley as the whistleblower's influential girlfriend Lindsay Mills.

Human Element Makes Oliver Stone’s ‘Snowden’ Quite Captivating

Kevin Gosztola

 by Shadowproof

Every whistleblower undergoes some kind of transformation that pushes them to the point where they make the pivotal decision to challenge power. Oliver Stone’s film about National Security Agency whistleblower Edward Snowden portrays how he went from a person reluctant to question the government to a person who believed it was virtuous to challenge abuses of government power.

“Snowden” unfolds in the Mira Hong Kong Hotel, where Snowden (Joseph Gordon-Levitt) met with journalists Laura Poitras (Melissa Leo) and Glenn Greenwald (Zachary Quinto). The script intermittently flashes back to periods of Snowden’s life, from his time in a military boot camp to his time working for the CIA in Geneva to when he worked at an NSA facility in Oahu, Hawaii.

Gordon-Levitt nails the intonation of Snowden’s voice. Shailene Woodley is fabulous as his girlfriend, Lindsay Mills, and the choice to make much of the film revolve around Snowden’s relationship with Mills positively elevates the film to a fairly compelling love story. In fact, the way the story is told suggests Snowden’s views on questioning the government changed from post-9/11 flag-waving nationalism the more his romance with Mills blossomed, especially since she was against the Iraq War and other acts of President George W. Bush’s administration.

Jesselyn Radack, a whistleblower attorney who has represented Snowden, told Shadowproof, “I found the depiction of Ed to be very fair and balanced. There are so many caricatures of him, as well as a tendency to see him in binary terms: hero versus villain. This humanizes him as the multi-faceted, thoughtful individual he is.”

“Oliver Stone met with Snowden in Russia at least half a dozen times over a period of years,” according to Radack. She recognized that those meetings could be intense on a “multiplicity of different levels,” and “Stone and Snowden are also both very cerebral, sensitive, thoughtful, and self-aware,” and those meetings informed the film.

NSA whistleblower Thomas Drake, who was a technical consultant for the film, also found Stone captured Snowden well by showing the character and not some caricature.

“The human element is very much on the screen,” Drake contended. “I believe that makes the movie. I don’t think it would be the same without the relationship, and it wasn’t a passing relationship. It was a deep relationship, and of course, they discover each other online.”

Mills holds a mirror up to Snowden, Drake added. She forces him to reconcile with American exceptionalism, that license to do whatever is necessary to “prosecute the global war on terrorism” no matter the collateral damage. “That is the beauty of Lindsay, and Lindsay [keeps] checking him in that regard.”

There are few family scenes in the film. According to Radack, “I understand there are strong privacy considerations for that, but I think, for example, that the fact that there’s a strong military and government tradition in his family and background is very interesting. He doesn’t come from a family of former hippies.”

Hank Forrester (Nicolas Cage) and Corbin O’Brien (Rhys Ifans), two composite characters in the film, are vehicles for injecting some key ideas about security into the film. Forrester is a former intelligence official, who Snowden crosses paths with during his CIA training. The character has a background in the analog era of surveillance. O’Brien is a superior to Snowden. He acts like a mentor and tries to indoctrinate Snowden and pull him deeper into the security state because Snowden is very skilled at developing surveillance programs.

Drake said the Forrester character was a combination of whistleblowers like Bill Binney and himself, as well as other former intelligence officials. Corbin was developed to represent American exceptionalism or the imperial mindset. As Drake noted, the character says secrecy protects security, and security is victory. “That’s an empire line.”

One scene that really sticks out in the film for Drake involves O’Brien addressing the New York Times story, which revealed the Bush administration’s warrantless wiretapping program in 2005. It reflects the lie that the U.S. is a nation of laws. In reality, there are two governments, “a shadow government and normative state,” and the rules are militarized. The battlefield is global, and the purpose of any program or policy, which may undermine the rule of law, can be justified by a kind of “linear logical madness.” So, Fourth Amendment or privacy concerns are not permitted to overshadow the pursuit of security.

Drake’s act of whistleblowing and the zeal in which the U.S. government pursued him with Espionage Act charges features prominently in the film. Snowden grapples with how the government is trying to silence Drake, Binney, and other whistleblowers. It forms part of the inspiration for Snowden to flee the country instead of going through internal channels to expose wrongdoing.

“One thing I was worried about—I was worried it would get too in the weeds technically, and this was part of my role, ensuring that it didn’t get buried by the technology,” Drake shared. The real focus was on the change that occurred in Snowden, his personal transformation.

Stone was “hungry for detail.” He tried to absorb everything he possibly could, according to Drake. Like, “What was the context? What was it like to work there? What was the culture like? What are the buildings like? What was the place like? The people you reported to?”

It all could have become too dense, but fortunately, the details never suffocate the profound relationship between Snowden and Mills brought to life by Gordon-Levitt and Woodley. What Drake calls a “seductive world” pulls on him, and the “Siren call of secrecy and security” is powerful. She wants him to leave, but he cannot just leave.

“I was willing to go to prison, even if I lost my family,” Drake recalled. Likewise, the film shows Snowden willing to sacrifice all those years he spent with someone whom he cares about deeply.

The story of the journalists, who wrote Pulitzer Prize-winning stories on documents from Snowden, plays a small role in the film. Leo and Quinto give decent performances, but they aren’t given much opportunity to showcase their abilities to become these characters. The audience never really is offered a chance to get into what they were going through. (Perhaps, that is because we already have Laura Poitras’ Oscar-winning documentary, “Citizenfour,” and Stone did not want to replicate too many scenes from that film.)

Asked about how the film may further contribute to the shift in public opinion toward Snowden, from vilification to broad support, Radack responded, “I always have said that Snowden’s trajectory is a marathon, not a sprint. I hope it won’t take decades to resolve, but if you look at the path of someone like Pentagon Papers whistleblower Daniel Ellsberg, it took 40 years for him to go from a ‘traitor’ to a ‘hero.'”

Copyright FDL Media Group © 2019, All Rights Reserved.
Kevin Gosztola

Kevin Gosztola

Kevin Gosztola is managing editor of Shadowproof Press. He publishes the Dissenter Newsletter at Substack and hosts "The Dissenter Weekly" show, which covers whistleblower stories. He also produces and co-hosts the weekly podcast, Unauthorized Disclosure

This is the world we live in. This is the world we cover.

Because of people like you, another world is possible. There are many battles to be won, but we will battle them together—all of us. Common Dreams is not your normal news site. We don't survive on clicks. We don't want advertising dollars. We want the world to be a better place. But we can't do it alone. It doesn't work that way. We need you. If you can help today—because every gift of every size matters—please do. Without Your Support We Simply Don't Exist.

'When We Organize, We Win': Ocasio-Cortez Joins India Walton at Rally in Buffalo

The two progressives joined striking hospital workers on the picket line at Mercy Hospital after the early voting rally.

Julia Conley ·

Fatal Film Set Shooting Followed Outcry by Union Crew Members Over Safety Protocols

"When union members walk off a set about safety concerns, maybe 'hiring scabs' isn’t the solution you think it is."

Julia Conley ·

New Whistleblower Sparks Calls to 'Crack Down on Facebook and All Big Tech Companies'

Hours after another ex-employee filed a formal complaint, reporting broke on internal documents that show the tech giant's failure to address concerns about content related to the 2020 U.S. election.

Jessica Corbett ·

'Catastrophic and Irreparable Harm' to Wolves Averted as Wisconsin Judge Cancels Hunt

"We are heartened by this rare instance of reason and democracy prevailing in state wolf policy," said one conservation expert.

Brett Wilkins ·

West Virginia Constituents Decry 'Immorality' of Joe Manchin

"West Virginia has been locked into an economy that forces workers into low-wage jobs with no hope for advancement, and after decades of this our hope is dwindling," said one West Virginian. "The cuts that Sen. Manchin has negotiated into the agenda hurt our state."

Julia Conley ·

Support our work.

We are independent, non-profit, advertising-free and 100% reader supported.

Subscribe to our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values.
Direct to your inbox.

Subscribe to our Newsletter.

Common Dreams, Inc. Founded 1997. Registered 501(c3) Non-Profit | Privacy Policy
Common Dreams Logo