Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

A woman signs an 'eviction notice' for President Donald Trump hanging on the security fence that surrounds the White House November 8, 2020 in Washington, D.C. (Photo: Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)

A woman signs an 'eviction notice' for President Donald Trump hanging on the security fence that surrounds the White House November 8, 2020 in Washington, D.C. (Photo: Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)

Federal Judge Rejects Attempt by Wisconsin Trump Allies to Overturn Biden Win

Their argument, said the judge, "lies somewhere between a willful misreading of the Constitution and fantasy."

A federal judge on Monday delivered yet another defeat to President Donald Trump and his supporters in their ongoing efforts to overturn President-elect Joe Biden's November electoral victory, which is expected to be certified by Congress in a joint session scheduled for Wednesday.

"Courts are not instruments through which parties engage in such gamesmanship or symbolic political gestures."
—Judge James E. Boasberg

The lawsuit (pdf) was filed last month in U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia by the right-wing Wisconsin Voters Alliance. Other plaintiffs included GOP Wisconsin lawmakers as well as groups and voters from Arizona, Georgia, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin—all of which Biden won.

The suit against Vice President Mike Pence in his official capacity as president of the Senate, both houses of Congress, the Electoral College, and leaders from the five states sought a "constitutionally compliant process for state-by-state post-election certification of presidential votes and presidential electors."

The Trump allies argued that Pence and Congress shouldn't be allowed to consider states' electoral votes "unless their respective state legislatures have voted affirmatively in a post-election vote to certify presidential votes and their presidential electors for the current and future presidential elections."

District Court Judge James E. Boasberg wrote in his seven-page opinion (pdf) Monday that the suit was filed on behalf of plaintiffs without standing and, at least regarding some defendants, in the wrong court. He added, "It would be risible were its target not so grave: the undermining of a democratic election for president of the United States."

"Even if the the court had subject-matter and personal jurisdiction, it still could not rule in plaintiffs' favor because their central contention is flat-out wrong," explained judge, tearing apart the Trump allies' claims about Article II of the Constitution.

"Plaintiffs somehow interpret this straightforward passage to mean that state legislatures alone must certify presidential votes and presidential electors after each election, and that governors or other entities have no constitutionally permitted role," the judge wrote, adding that this "is not at all what Article II says."

Noting that each of the five battleground states in question has passed constitutionally sound statutes "directing how votes are to be certified and electors selected," Boasberg concluded that "plaintiffs' theory that all of these laws are unconstitutional and that the court should instead require state legislatures themselves to certify every presidential election lies somewhere between a willful misreading of the Constitution and fantasy."

"It is not a stretch to find a serious lack of good faith here," wrote the judge. "Yet even that may be letting plaintiffs off the hook too lightly. Their failure to make any effort to serve or formally notify any defendant—even after reminder by the court in its minute order—renders it difficult to believe that the suit is meant seriously."

"Courts are not instruments through which parties engage in such gamesmanship or symbolic political gestures," added Boasberg, threatening a possible referral to a committee that could sanction the Trump allies' counsel.

The judge was appointed to the district court in D.C. by former President Barack Obama. He was previously appointed by former President George W. Bush to serve as an associate judge of the Superior Court of the District of Columbia.

Boasberg's decision comes after a federal appeals court on Saturday dismissed a suit by Rep. Louie Gohmert (R-Texas) and other Republicans that sought to empower Pence to interfere in the Electoral College vote count and overturn Biden's win.

Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) led another group of Republicans who announced Saturday that they will join Sen. Josh Hawley (R-Mo.)—and more than 100 GOP House members—in contesting the presidential election results during the Wednesday session, which provoked accusations of "sedition."

Trump, meanwhile, pressured Georgia's GOP Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger on Saturday to "find" enough votes to overturn Biden's win. Leaked audio of the hourlong call drew demands for a criminal probe of the president and others.

Continued outrage over Trump's attempted election interference in Georgia comes just a day before a pair of runoff races in the state will determine which party controls the Senate. With a Democratic majority in the House, the outcomes of those elections are expected to dramatically impact Biden's ability to implement his agenda.


Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
We need your help.

Support progressive journalism.

Common Dreams is not your average news site. We don't survive on clicks or advertising dollars. We rely entirely on your support. And without it, our independent progressive journalism simply wouldn’t exist. Every gift of every amount matters.

Join the fight and support our common dreams today.

'Sorely Disappointed' by Court Ruling, Pipeline Foes Demand Biden 'Act Immediately to Stop Line 3'

"Every day President Biden refuses to stop the Line 3 pipeline is a slap in the face to environmental justice communities and a renewed breaking of his promises on climate and Indigenous rights."

Brett Wilkins, staff writer ·


300+ Progressive Groups Urge Corporations to Ditch ALEC for Pushing Voter Suppression Bills

"If corporations really believe in protecting our democracy and the right to vote, they must end their affiliation with ALEC," said one advocate.

Kenny Stancil, staff writer ·


Reality Winner's Release From Federal Prison Met With Calls for Full Pardon for the NSA Whistleblower

Winner will serve the rest of her five-year sentence under the supervision of a halfway house.

Julia Conley, staff writer ·


Analysis Highlights Biden Proposal to End $84 Billion Gift to Big Oil Buried in Trump Tax Scam

"We can stop this insane corporate welfare and use it to pay for a renewable energy future."

Andrea Germanos, staff writer ·


Intent on Appeasing Manchin, US Blocks G7 Progress on Phasing Out Coal

"Once again Joe Manchin is casting a heavy shadow."

Julia Conley, staff writer ·