May, 05 2010, 02:31pm EDT
New EPA Testing Method Identifies Higher Coal Ash Threat; Must Drive Agency's Rulemaking
Arsenic, among others, leached at 1,800 times federal safe drinking water levels
WASHINGTON
A new testing method by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
reveals that pollutants such as arsenic, antimony, chromium and
selenium, can leach from coal ash at levels dozens and sometimes
hundreds of times greater than the federal drinking water standard. This
news comes on the heels of EPA's proposal to regulate coal ash, in
which the agency offered two options: a plan to regulate coal ash as
hazardous waste and another to regulate it as non-hazardous.
According to EPA's new testing data, cited in the agency's proposed
rule released yesterday, pollution from coal ash can shatter the
"hazardous waste" threshold, an important factor as the EPA is facing
pressure from industry to avoid defining coal ash as hazardous waste.
The new testing procedure emphasizes the need for the EPA to make the
right decision and choose the stronger of the two proposals for
federally enforceable coal ash safeguards that use the strongest limits
of the law to protect the communities living near coal ash sites.
In December 2009, the EPA produced a report examining the fate of
pollution captured in smokestacks at coal-fired power pants. The report
was quietly posted to the EPA's website, but offered groundbreaking
results. The EPA tested over 70 samples of ash and sludge from numerous
power plants. The results revealed the potential for some ashes and
sludges to release large concentrations of toxic chemicals. According to
new testing methods on coal ash applied by the EPA's Office of Research
and Development:
- Arsenic, a potent carcinogen, leached from one coal ash at 1,800
times the federal safe drinking water standard, more than 3 times the
threshold of hazardous waste and over 76 times the level of previous
leach tests; - Antimony, which causes heart, lung and stomach problems,
leached from a coal ash at 1,800 times the federal safe drinking water
standard and over 900 times the level of previous tests; - Chromium, which can cause cancer and stomach ailments, leached
from one coal ash at a level 73 times the federal safe drinking water
standard, over 1.5 times the hazardous waste threshold, and 124 times
the level of previous leach tests; and - Selenium, which causes circulatory problems in humans and is a
bioaccumulative toxin extremely deadly to fish, leached from one coal
ash at nearly 600 times the federal drinking water standard, 29 times
the hazardous waste threshold and nearly 66 times the level of previous
leach tests.
"The writing is on the wall, the floor, the ceiling, everywhere,"
said Lisa Evans, senior administrative counsel at Earthjustice. "Coal
ash pollution poses a significant threat to human health and our
environment. The EPA's new testing methods are much more precise and
clearly determine that arsenic, selenium and other pollutants from some
coal ashes pose a toxic threat to drinking water, fish and wildlife
populations, and our health."
Adding air pollution controls to existing power plants is shifting
toxic pollution from the smokestacks to the fly ash, FGD gypsum and
other air pollution control residues commonly referred to collectively
as "coal ash." Increased concentrations of toxic metals in coal ash
increases the potential for them to leach into water.
Read
an Earthjustice report summarizing the EPA's findings
"This new EPA report confirms just how significant the threat is to
aquatic life," said A. Dennis Lemly, Research Professor of Biology at
Wake Forest University. Dr. Lemly is an expert in aquatic toxicology of
selenium. "It shows that selenium quickly moves into water, often at
levels that are thousands of times greater than what is necessary to
poison fish. With this degree of contaminant mobility, concentration,
and toxicity, coal combustion waste, or coal ash, is an extremely
hazardous material."
These new testing methods show that arsenic can leach from coal ash
at 3 times, chromium can leach over 1.5 times, and selenium can leach at
29 times the threshold of what is considered hazardous waste. For
decades, the EPA, state agencies and industry relied on a 1990 leach
test, known as the Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure (TCLP),
which often failed to accurately predict levels of pollutants leaching
from coal ash. For years, the National Academy of Sciences and the EPA's
own Science Advisory Board questioned the reliance on such an
inaccurate testing method for coal ash and explicitly recommended that
EPA replace the old test. In 2006, the EPA itself acknowledged the need
for a more accurate and sensitive test and began using an alternate
framework. The new EPA proposed coal ash rule explicitly states that "a
considerable body of evidence has emerged indicating that the TCLP alone
is not a good predictor of the mobility of metals in CCRs under a
variety of different conditions."
The EPA's new test method provides a more accurate assessment of the
potential of toxic chemicals to leach from the waste, showing that coal
ash pollution is an obvious threat to drinking water and in some cases,
far exceeds the thresholds for hazardous waste.
"Sound science should inform decision making," said Mary Fox, PhD,
MPH, Assistant Professor at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public
Health. "Reliable scientific testing methods ensure the most accurate
data are available to regulators when they set protective standards. The
EPA's new testing methods clearly show the threat coal ash poses to
drinking water supplies and the communities that rely on them. These
findings provide critical information for establishing coal ash waste
management strategies that protect water supplies."
"The new leaching data is cited in EPA's proposed rule, and this
should end, once and for all, the reliance on a test that has no
scientific basis." Evans said. "The utility industry and coal ash reuse
industries argue that coal ash is not hazardous waste, relying on
obsolete testing methods that are nearly 20 years old. But there is new
science now being used by the EPA that shows unequivocally that some
ashes and sludges behave just like hazardous waste."
Earthjustice is a non-profit public interest law firm dedicated to protecting the magnificent places, natural resources, and wildlife of this earth, and to defending the right of all people to a healthy environment. We bring about far-reaching change by enforcing and strengthening environmental laws on behalf of hundreds of organizations, coalitions and communities.
800-584-6460LATEST NEWS
'Shameful': Columbia Greenlights Police Crackdown on Anti-War Encampment
Even after dozens of students were arrested, hundreds "rushed to take the place of their classmates" and continued the protest.
Apr 18, 2024
The arrests of dozens of Columbia University and Barnard College students on Thursday "galvanized" other supporters of Palestinian rights on the campuses, as hundreds of students occupied the school's western lawn after New York City police filled at least two buses with protesters who had been detained for setting up an encampment.
"Disclose, divest, we will not stop, we will not rest," chanted hundreds of students as they marched around the area where organizers had set up a tent encampment early Wednesday morning.
Columbia President Minouche Shafik informed the campus community on Thursday that she had authorized the police to clear the encampment.
As it has been in the past, the school has become a center of anti-war protests—and crackdowns by school officials and the police—since Israel began its bombardment of Gaza in October.
Pro-Palestinian students and alumni have demanded that Columbia divest from companies that profit from Israel's apartheid policies in the occupied Palestinian territories and cancel its dual degree program with Tel Aviv University.
In response to pro-Palestinian demonstrations, Columbia in November suspended the campus chapters of Jewish Voice for Peace and Students for Justice in Palestine—an action that pushed the New York Civil Liberties Union and Palestine Legal to file a lawsuit on behalf of the students last month.
On Thursday, police and Columbia employees took down about 50 tents that had been up for more than a day and disposed of them in trash cans and alleyways—but The New York Times reported later that "demonstrators repitched a couple of tents, and ... recovered the main signage from the encampment as well," while hundreds of students were "still gathered and chanting on the south side of the grass."
The arrests came a day after Shafik testified before the U.S. House Committee on Education and the Workforce about antisemitism on campus.
U.S. Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.), whose daughter, Isra Hirsi, was among the Barnard students who were suspended on Thursday for participating in the encampment protest, questioned Shafik about whether antisemitic protests have actually taken place at Columbia, prompting the president to say there have not.
"There has been a rise in targeting and harassment against anti-war protesters, because it's been pro-war and anti-war protesters is what it seems, like, correct?" asked Omar.
"Correct," replied Shafik.
On Thursday, Omar posted on social media two images of protesters at Columbia: one from the encampment this week, and one from 1968, when students protested the U.S. war in Vietnam.
New York City Council member Tiffany Cabán was among those who condemned the university's crackdown on the protests on Thursday.
"Suspending and arresting Columbia/Barnard student activists and disbanding student organizations—including Jewish students and organizations—doesn't combat antisemitism or increase safety," said Cabán. "All it does is punish and intimidate those who believe in human rights for Palestinians. Shameful."
Keep ReadingShow Less
'The Pressure Is Working': Biden Weighs Climate Emergency Declaration
Campaigners urged the president to "keep listening to the millions of young, people of color, and working-class voters who are demanding climate policy that meets the moment."
Apr 18, 2024
The youth-led Sunrise Movement on Thursday celebrated Bloombergreporting that "White House officials have renewed discussions about potentially declaring a national climate emergency."
The Wednesday revelation came just two days after six young activists were arrested outside Vice President Kamala Harris' Los Angeles, California home to increase pressure on the Biden administration to make such a declaration, which would unlock various federal powers to combat the fossil fuel-driven global crisis.
According to Bloomberg:
Top advisers to President Joe Biden have recently resumed talks about the merits of such a move, which could be used to curtail crude exports, suspend offshore drilling, and curb greenhouse gas emissions, according to people familiar with the matter who asked not to be named because a final decision has not been made.
White House advisers are divided over the idea of declaring a climate emergency, with some saying it wouldn't provide Biden with enough newfound authority to make substantial changes, the people said. Others, however, argue such an announcement would galvanize climate-minded voters.
"The pressure is working. Let's keep it up," Sunrise said on social media, highlighting some of what Biden—who claimed last year that "practically speaking," he had already declared a national climate emergency—could do with a real declaration.
Sunrise wasn't alone in welcoming the news. The Center for Popular Democracy (CPD) Action said that "we've BEEN calling for a climate emergency!! Now, the White House is considering declaring one."
The group urged Biden to "keep listening to the millions of young, people of color, and working-class voters who are demanding climate policy that meets the moment."
As Biden and Harris have campaigned for reelection in November—when they are expected to face former Republican President Donald Trump, whose plan for the planet is "drill, baby, drill"—the Democrats have faced intense pressure from campaigners including members of CPD and Sunrise to step up their climate actions.
"I'm on the frontlines raising my voice for my Black and Latine families and friends, because I know that we deserve to have affordable housing and healthcare, we deserve an administration who will fight for us, but instead of declaring a climate emergency, we are seeing Biden and Harris expand oil and gas production to record levels," 18-year-old Ariela Lara, who was arrested at Harris' house, said Monday.
Climate campaigners have praised the Biden administration for parts of the Inflation Reduction Act and a recent pause on liquefied natural gas exports but blasted the president for skipping last year's United Nations summit, continuing fossil fuel lease sales, and enabling the Mountain Valley Pipeline, Willow oil project, and construction of the nation's largest offshore oil terminal.
Keep ReadingShow Less
Blinken Hasn't Ended Aid for Israeli Military Units Tied to Killings, Rapes
"Blinken continues a very long American tradition of very selective enforcement of human rights laws," said one critic.
Apr 18, 2024
Amid global condemnation of Israel's assault on the Gaza Strip and the Biden administration's complicity, ProPublicarevealed Wednesday that U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken has for months ignored staff recommendations to cut off American aid to Israeli military and police units accused of human rights violations including killings and rapes.
"The incidents under review mostly took place in the West Bank and occurred before Hamas' October 7 attack on Israel," which was the catalyst for the current Israeli escalation in Gaza, reported ProPublica's Brett Murphy. "They include reports of extrajudicial killings by the Israeli Border Police; an incident in which a battalion gagged, handcuffed, and left an elderly Palestinian American man for dead; and an allegation that interrogators tortured and raped a teenager who had been accused of throwing rocks and Molotov cocktails."
Murphy obtained government documents and emails and spoke with current and former U.S. State Department officials, who said the recommendations from the Israel Leahy Vetting Forum—named for former Sen. Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.), who authored laws restricting aid to human rights abuses—were sent to Blinken in December and "they've been sitting in his briefcase since then."
While U.S. President Joe Biden has gradually increased his criticism of Israeli forces killing civilians in Gaza, "multiple State Department officials who have worked on Israeli relations said that Blinken's inaction has undermined Biden's public criticism, sending a message to the Israelis that the administration was not willing to take serious steps," Murphy wrote.
The Israeli government did not respond to the reporter's request for comment, but a U.S. State Department spokesperson did. "This process is one that demands a careful and full review," the American representative said, "and the department undergoes a fact-specific investigation applying the same standards and procedures regardless of the country in question."
Global critics have long accused the U.S. government of giving Israel special treatment while Israeli officials and troops subject Palestinians to apartheid, ethnic cleansing, occupation, settler colonization, and now "plausibly" genocide, according to the International Court of Justice. Since October, the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) have killed at least 33,970 people in Gaza.
The reporting sparked a fresh wave of outrage. The U.S. Campaign for Palestinian Rights declared that "this is how Antony Blinken will go down in history: for enabling Israel to commit the gravest of war crimes with U.S. tax dollars."
Alex Kingsbury, a member of The New York Times editorial board, noted that "Blinken continues a very long American tradition of very selective enforcement of human rights laws," while Brandon Friedman, a former Obama administration official, said that "this would be a career ender for a normal Cabinet secretary under normal circumstances."
Democracy for the Arab World Now "submitted Leahy sanctions requests for two of the Israeli units that Antony Blinken has putzed and punted on, in breach of U.S. law, despite clear evidence of despicable abuses—[including] torture, executions, and even murder of an American," according to executive director Sarah Leah Whitson. "But Antony Blinken insists on special privileges and exemptions for Israel, refusing to hold it accountable, U.S. law be damned."
@StateDept In 2023, we documented Israel counter-terrorism YAMAM unit\u2019s abuses, including two extrajudicial killings & two indiscriminate and reckless killings, including of a child in Jenin in March 2023, constituting gross violations of human rights under Leahy Law & war crimes under Rome\u2026— (@)
The Council on American-Islamic Relations' Robert S. McCaw said in a statement that "despite these internal report State Department reports detailing egregious human rights abuses by the Israeli government, including allegations of rape and torturing children in the West Bank, Secretary Blinken has ignored his own staff and continued to greenlight weapon shipments to the responsible Israeli military and police units."
"The glaring disconnect between the gravity of the accusations and his refusal to act on them is deeply disturbing," McCaw added. "Secretary Blinken must halt any further weapons transfers that the Israeli government will use to commit more human rights violations."
Human rights attorney Qasim Rashid pointed out that in contrast with how the Biden administration has treated Israel, the U.S. government pulled funding from the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East—as Palestinians in Gaza starve to death—over the "mere allegation" that a small number of staff were involved with Hamas.
"If we had been applying Leahy effectively in Israel like we do in other countries, maybe you wouldn't have the IDF filming TikToks of their war crimes now because we have contributed to a culture of impunity," Josh Paul, a former director in the State Department's Bureau of Political-Military Affairs and a member of the forum who resigned in protest in October, told Murphy.
Another State Department official, Annelle Sheline, stepped down late last month as a foreign affairs officer at the Office of Near Eastern Affairs in the Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor. She said that with the U.S. government continuing to arm Israel as it devastates Gaza, "trying to advocate for human rights just became impossible."
Sheline's resignation came just days after the Biden administration accepted Israeli government assurances that its use of U.S.-supplied weapons complies with international law—which human rights advocates and officials worldwide, including some congressional Democrats, have challenged over the past few weeks.
Over two dozen Democrats wrote Wednesday to Blinken and two other top officials that "we remain concerned by the stark differences and gaps in the statements being made by the State Department and White House on how Israel has not been found to be in violation of international humanitarian law, either when it comes to the conduct of the war or when it comes to the provision of humanitarian assistance, which are contradictory to those made by prominent experts and global institutions."
Keep ReadingShow Less
Most Popular