Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

hospital

A woman is treated at Mercy Hospital in Portland, Maine on August 16, 2017. (Photo: Carl D. Walsh/Portland Portland Press Herald via Getty Images)

Inspector General, AMA and AHA Agree: Some Medicare Advantage Plans Are Endangering Their Enrollees' Lives

Americans should demand that the government stop rewarding Medicare Advantage plans for denying care inappropriately.

Diane Archer

Medicare Advantage plans are endangering the lives of older adults and people with disabilities. The HHS Office of the Inspector General (OIG), which works to fight waste, fraud and abuse, recently issued a devastating report showing that these corporate health plans, which contract with the government to deliver Medicare benefits, are denying large amounts of care inappropriately. 

Everyone enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan should demand that the government prioritize the health and well-being of people with Medicare and let them know which plans are keeping people from getting needed care.

This is not the first time that the OIG has raised serious concerns about Medicare Advantage. But Medicare Advantage plans continue to engage in widespread wrongful denials of care with little accountability. What will it take for the administration and Congress to protect people with Medicare from these bad actors?

In a 2018 report, the OIG raised equally troubling concerns about the risks faced by older adults and people with disabilities in Medicare Advantage. The OIG recommended that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) act to protect people with Medicare and provide them “with clear, easily accessible information about serious [Medicare Advantage] violations.” Unfortunately, these recommendations seem to have fallen on deaf ears. 

Instead of calling out the bad Medicare Advantage actors and holding them to account, CMS is protecting corporate interests over the interests of older adults, people with disabilities, and their families. Protecting Wall Street over people with Medicare. 

The OIG report explains that because CMS pays Medicare Advantage plans a flat fee regardless of the amount they spend on care, they have a “potential incentive...to deny beneficiary access to services and deny payments to providers in an attempt to increase profits.” 

Anyone enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan offered by Humana, United HeathCare, Aetna, or another health insurance company should beware. These Medicare Advantage plans are requiring that our nation’s most vulnerable individuals navigate an obstacle course when they need critical care. Worse still, they are inappropriately denying potentially life-saving care to tens of thousands of older adults and people with disabilities —care that traditional Medicare covers. 

The OIG report finds that nearly one in seven Medicare Advantage plan denials of care are wrongful. It highlights inappropriate denials of costly tests, nursing home care, and rehabilitation services.

There’s more. The Kaiser Family Foundation found that a sizeable number of Medicare Advantage plans don’t include the best cancer specialists and cancer centers in their networks. We can only imagine the consequences for their enrollees with cancer and other costly health care needs. 

The OIG report doesn’t name names, even though some Medicare Advantage plans are clearly worse than others. For example, some plans are implementing prior authorization rules that are out of sync with standard medical practice. 

The American Hospital Association confirms that “Inappropriate and excessive denials for prior authorization and coverage of medically necessary services is a pervasive problem among certain plans in the MA program.” It urges CMS to hold Medicare Advantage plans accountable “for inappropriately and illegally restricting beneficiary access to medically necessary care.”

An American Medical Association poll found that one in four physicians believe that prior authorization rules for some tests and treatments are harming patients. But, there’s no way for people with Medicare to find out whether their Medicare Advantage plans are coming between doctors and patients to their detriment. 

The OIG report neither outs the bad Medicare Advantage plans nor highlights the good ones. And, CMS keeps paying the bad ones, leaving their enrollees in a dangerous situation. An NBER report found that Medicare would save “around ten thousand” lives a year if CMS canceled contracts with the bottom-ranking five percent of Medicare Advantage plans and randomly reassigned their enrollees to other Medicare Advantage plans.

Instead of meaningfully penalizing or cancelling contracts with Medicare Advantage plans for establishing procedures that withhold necessary care from people with Medicare, CMS is giving them an 8.5 percent rate increase next year. It’s continuing to pay them significantly more per enrollee than it spends on people in traditional Medicare. As a result, the corporations that administer Medicare Advantage plans are profiting wildly!

CMS leads our nation’s parents and grandparents to believe that they can pick a Medicare Advantage plan that’s right for them — and then allows them to pick one that could gravely harm them or cause their premature death.

Curiously, most members of Congress laud Medicare Advantage plans—notwithstanding the OIG report and a sea of other reports raising concerns about them. But, some members of Congress are speaking out about the serious risks Medicare Advantage plans present for older people and people with disabilities and the huge costs they impose on taxpayers and the Medicare Trust Fund.

Last month, Congresswomen Katie Porter, Rosa DeLauro, and Jan Schakowsky, along with Senator Elizabeth Warren, led a letter to CMS. Joined by 15 other members of Congress, they called on CMS to protect people with Medicare and highlighted some of their concerns with Medicare Advantage. Senator Sherrod Brown led a similar letter three years ago, and CMS did nothing.

Americans should demand that the government stop rewarding Medicare Advantage plans for denying care inappropriately. In the meantime, everyone enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan should demand that the government prioritize the health and well-being of people with Medicare and let them know which plans are keeping people from getting needed care.


Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.

Diane Archer

Diane Archer is president of Just Care USA, an independent digital hub covering health and financial issues facing boomers and their families and promoting policy solutions. She is the past board chair of Consumer Reports and serves on the Brown University School of Public Health Advisory Board. Ms. Archer began her career in health advocacy in 1989 as founder and president of the Medicare Rights Center, a national organization dedicated to ensuring that older and disabled Americans get the health care they need. She served as director, Health Care for All Project, Institute for America’s Future, between 2005 and 2010.

We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.

'Incredible': Omar and Khanna Staffers Join Levin's Office in Unionizing

"It is long past time the United States Congress became a unionized workplace, and that includes my own staff," said Rep. Ilhan Omar. "I am proud of all the people on my team who have played a leading role in the staff unionization effort. Solidarity forever."

Jessica Corbett ·


Destructive Hurricanes Fuel Calls for Biden to Declare Climate Emergency

"Mother Nature is not waiting for the president or Congress to declare a climate emergency. She's showing us in real-time here in the United States—with wildfires, floods, heatwaves, hurricanes, and drought."

Jessica Corbett ·


Spain Approves 'Solidarity' Tax to Make Nation's Top 0.1% Pay a Fairer Share

The country's finance minister said that looming changes are bound to make the tax code "more progressive, efficient, fair, and also enough to guarantee social justice and economic efficiency."

Kenny Stancil ·


'Time to Take to the Streets': Working Class Hold 'Enough Is Enough' Rallies Across UK

"Does a CEO need an extra zero at the end of their salary—or should nurses, posties, and teachers be able to heat their homes?" said one supporter ahead of the #EnoughIsEnough National Day of Action.

Julia Conley ·


Ukraine Responds to Putin Annexations With Fast-Track NATO Application

Lamenting the lack of any progress toward a diplomatic settlement, one anti-war campaigner asked: "Will the world stand idly by as we careen towards nuclear apocalypse?"

Jake Johnson ·

Common Dreams Logo