Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

Sen. Kamala Harris (D-Calif.), a 2020 Democratic presidential candidate, speaks during the second Democratic primary debate of the 2020 presidential campaign season at the Adrienne Arsht Center for the Performing Arts in Miami, June 27, 2019. (Photo: Saul Loed/AFP/Getty Images)

'Bad Policy and Bad Politics': Kamala Harris Accused of Hijacking Medicare for All Label to Push More Industry-Friendly Plan

"Harris calls her plan 'Medicare for All,' but it's not even close."

Jake Johnson

Single-payer advocates on Monday accused Sen. Kamala Harris of hijacking the Medicare for All label to push an alternative that would fail to fundamentally overhaul America's for-profit healthcare system.

Harris, a 2020 Democratic presidential candidate, outlined what she described as her "Medicare for All" plan in a Medium post on Monday. But the California Democrat's proposal differs significantly from the Medicare for All legislation that she co-sponsored in the Senate earlier this year.

Instead of the four-year transition proposed by that bill, introduced by 2020 Democratic contender Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), Harris's plan calls for a 10-year transition.

Matt Bruenig, founder of the left-wing think tank People's Policy Project, disputed the California senator's claim that extending the transition period by six years would "decrease the overall cost of the program compared to the Sanders proposal."

"In fact the opposite is true: the longer you take, the longer NHE remains unnecessarily elevated," Bruenig tweeted, referring to national health expenditures.

Harris's plan would also preserve a major role for private health insurance, which would be virtually eliminated under the Sanders legislation.

"Instead of completely replacing private coverage with a government-run, single-payer system based on traditional Medicare," the New York Times reported, "Ms. Harris would allow people to choose plans modeled on Medicare Advantage, which would be run not by the government but by private insurers."

Michael Lighty, a founding fellow at the Sanders Institute think tank and an activist with the Democratic Socialists of America's Medicare for All campaign, told Common Dreams that Harris's proposal would leave intact some of the harmful components of the profit-driven status quo.

"The alternatives put forth to single-payer Medicare for All—whether it's 'Medicare for America' or Medicare buy-ins, and now Senator Harris's alternative—rely on for-profit HMOs known as Medicare Advantage," said Lighty. "These plans restrict access to certain providers, charge seniors more for out of network care, and a receive an extra subsidy from the government."

"Hugely profitable and fast-growing, they keep insurers in charge," Lighty added. "Since under Senator Harris's plan an HMO, or other private commercial insurer, will continue to determine coverage and doctors for millions of people—and profit from denials of care—that's not healthcare as a human right."

Echoing Lighty's critique, Physicians for a National Health Program (PNHP) president Adam Gaffney called the reliance on private insurance the "major deficiency at the heart of Harris' healthcare plan."

RoseAnn DeMoro, a Sanders supporter and former executive director of National Nurses United, called Harris's plan "an insurance market masquerading as a health plan."

"Another market-based scheme to price gouge people and further enrich insurers," DeMoro tweeted. "You can't hijack the name Medicare for All while actually undermining it."

Harris introduced the plan just days before she is set to take the stage in Detroit Wednesday for the second round of Democratic presidential primary debates.

According to the Times, Harris appears to be positioning herself in the middle of Sanders and former Vice President Joe Biden, who unveiled his plan to build on the Affordable Care Act earlier this month.

"Ms. Harris's proposal seeks to straddle both camps," the Times reported, "using the 'Medicare for All' mantra as a long-term target while also seeking to keep a significant role for private insurers—which Mr. Sanders's plan would eliminate."

The Sanders campaign was quick to criticize Harris's plan.

"It's bad policy and bad politics," Faiz Shakir, Sanders's campaign manager, said in an interview with Bloomberg.

On Twitter, Shakir said the proposal represents another phase of Harris's "gradual backdown from Medicare for All."

"This is why you want a candidate with a lifetime of consistency and a track record on the big issues facing us," said Shakir.

Splinter's Libby Watson argued in an analysis of Harris's plan Monday that there "should be no role for profit in the healthcare system, and the level of profit that insurance companies currently enjoy—the top insurers raked in more than $7 billion in profits in just one quarter last year—is obscene."

"You can either take on the insurance industry and protect patients, or you can tiptoe around them and allow them to keep profiting off patients," Watson wrote. "There's no middle ground."


Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.

We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.

Because 'Publishing Is Not a Crime,' Major Newspapers Push US to Drop Assange Charges

"This indictment sets a dangerous precedent, and threatens to undermine America's First Amendment and the freedom of the press," The Guardian, The New York Times, and other media outlets warned.

Jake Johnson ·


Sanders Vows to 'Stand With Rail Workers' as Republican Says Congress Will Prevent Strike

"Last year, the rail industry made a record-breaking $20 billion in profits," Sen. Bernie Sanders noted. "Meanwhile, rail workers have ZERO guaranteed paid sick days."

Jake Johnson ·


Massive Demonstration of Support for Lopez Obrador in Mexico City

AMLO was elected in 2018 and heralded as the Bernie Sanders of Mexico.

Common Dreams staff ·


Scientists Revive ‘Zombie’ Virus After 50,000 Years Trapped in Siberian Permafrost

Researchers documented 13 never-before-seen viruses that have been lying dormant, frozen in thick ice, over tens of thousands of years.

Common Dreams staff ·


'Cleaner Air Is Coming' as London Expands Vehicle Pollution Fee to Entire Metro Area

"Around 4,000 Londoners die prematurely each year because of long-term exposure to air pollution, with the greatest number of deaths in outer London boroughs," noted Mayor Sadiq Khan in announcing the expansion.

Brett Wilkins ·

Common Dreams Logo