Published on

Don't Be Fooled, McKibben Says. On Climate, Trudeau's No Better Than Trump.

Environmentalist Bill McKibben calls BS on Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau in a new op-ed

Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, pictured here visiting an urban greenhouse in Montreal last month, "sure is cute, the planet's only sovereign leader who appears to have recently quit a boy band," writes Bill McKibben. But don't be fooled. (Photo: Lufa Farms/flickr/cc)

Environmentalist Bill McKibben is sick of people glossing over Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's climate record just because he's nice to look at.

To be sure, McKibben writes in a Guardian op-ed published Monday, Trudeau has "mastered so beautifully the politics of inclusion: compassionate to immigrants, insistent on including women at every level of government."

Combine those optics with his handsome appearance and reassuring rhetoric, and "in lots of ways he's the anti-Trump," McKibben says, making it "no wonder Canadians swooned when he took over."

"But when it comes to the defining issue of our day, climate change, he's a brother to the old orange guy in D.C.," the co-founder argues, referring to U.S. president and climate-destroyer-in-chief Donald Trump, whose administration is pushing dirty energy, waging a war on science, and threatening to withdraw from the Paris Agreement.

Meanwhile, Trudeau and his people say all the right things on climate—"[b]ut those words are meaningless if you keep digging up more carbon and selling it to people to burn, and that's exactly what Trudeau is doing," McKibben writes. 

For example, he continues:

Last month, speaking at a Houston petroleum industry gathering, [Trudeau] got a standing ovation from the oilmen for saying "No country would find 173bn barrels of oil in the ground and just leave them there."

Yes, 173bn barrels is indeed the estimate for recoverable oil in the tar sands. So let's do some math. If Canada digs up that oil and sells it to people to burn, it will produce, according to the math whizzes at Oil Change International, 30 percent of the carbon necessary to take us past the 1.5 degree target that Canada helped set in Paris.


Support Our People-Powered Media Model Today

If you believe the survival of independent media is vital to a healthy democracy, please step forward with a donation to nonprofit Common Dreams today:

That is to say, Canada, which represents one-half of 1 percent of the planet's population, is claiming the right to sell the oil that will use up a third of the earth's remaining carbon budget. That is to say, Trump is a creep and a danger and unpleasant to look at, but at least he's not a stunning hypocrite.

(At least, not on climate issues.)

McKibben is not the first to highlight Trudeau's mixed environmental messages.

"The federal government insists that it is committed to acting on climate change, but approving Kinder Morgan's project contradicts its promises and undermines the government's climate strategy and its international commitments," said Ecojustice lawyer Karen Campbell in November, when Trudeau announced the government's approval of the expansion of Kinder Morgan Trans Mountain pipeline and Enbridge's Line 3 pipeline project.

And in December, Trudeau touted Trump's support for the Keystone XL, which would transport tar sands oil from Alberta to Texas. When Trump gave the controversial project a green light in December, he garnered praise from Trudeau's cabinet. 

"The question for Canadians is: will the prime minister continue to align himself with a climate denying Trump administration, or will he stand with the people and with science and start living up to his own commitments to the climate and Indigenous rights?" asked (pdf) Greenpeace climate and energy campaigner Mike Hudema at the time. "The prime minister can't keep saying he will lead on climate while building three new tar sands pipelines. Alternative facts may work in the U.S. administration but they shouldn't be tolerated here."

For her part, Canadian author and activist Naomi Klein thanked McKibben for "telling the truth about the spin masters in the Trudeau government."

Of the Trudeau-as-savior narrative, she tweeted, "It's enough already."

This is the world we live in. This is the world we cover.

Because of people like you, another world is possible. There are many battles to be won, but we will battle them together—all of us. Common Dreams is not your normal news outlet. We don't survive on clicks. We don't want advertising dollars. We want the world to be a better place. But we can't do it alone. It doesn't work that way. We need you. If you can help today—because every gift of every size matters—please do. Without Your Support We Won't Exist.

Please select a donation method:

Share This Article