Climate researcher James Hansen, who headed NASA's Goddard's Institute for Space Studies for more than 30 years, with his granddaughter, plaintiff Sophie Kivlehan.
(Photo: Our Children's Trust)
Aug 13, 2015
Claiming that the continued development and burning of fossil fuels violates their constitutional rights, 21 young plaintiffs--ranging in age from 8 to 19--filed a landmark climate change lawsuit against the federal government on Wednesday.
"The federal government has known for decades that CO2 pollution from burning fossil fuels was causing global warming and dangerous climate change," said one of the teenage plaintiffs and youth director of Earth Guardians, 15-year-old Xiuhtezcatl Tonatiuh Martinez of Colorado. "It also knew that continuing to burn fossil fuels would destabilize our climate system, significantly harming my generation and generations to come."
Despite that knowledge, the government "continued to authorize and promote fossil fuel extraction, production, consumption, and all their associated emissions--to the grave detriment of future generations," added attorney Philip Gregory of the California firm Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy, a counsel to the plaintiffs.
Lawyers working on the case say a win for the kids would be no less important, from a strictly legal basis, than Brown v. Board of Education, which established the right to equal educational opportunity, or Obergefell v. Hodges, which much more recently established the freedom to marry.
As MSNBC reports, the lawsuit "debuts a new legal framework to fight climate change, one that portrays federal support for the development and use of fossil fuels as a violation of the Fifth and Ninth Amendments, as well as the public trust doctrine."
The public trust doctrine ensures "the rights of present and future generations to those essential natural resources that are of public concern to the citizens of our nation," reads the complaint. "These vital natural resources include at least the air (atmosphere), water, seas, the shores of the sea, and wildlife. The overarching public trust resource is our country's life-sustaining climate system, encompassing our atmosphere, waters, oceans, and biosphere. Defendants must take affirmative steps to protect those trust resources."
The youth's legal complaint (pdf) was accompanied by an "expert declaration" (pdf) from former NASA scientist James Hansen, who first raised the alarm on climate change in 1988. Hansen's granddaughter, 17-year-old Sophie Kivlehan of Pennsylvania, is among the plaintiffs.
"In my opinion, this lawsuit is made necessary by the at-best schizophrenic, if not suicidal, nature of U.S. climate and energy policy," Hansen wrote.
"It is now clear, as the relevant scientific community has established for some time, that continued high CO2 emissions from fossil fuel burning will further disrupt Earth's climate system, and that, in turn, will impose profound and mounting risks of ecological, economic and social collapse," he continued. "In my view, our government's actions and inactions that cause or contribute to those emissions violate the fundamental rights of Sophie, other Youth, and future generations. Those violated rights include the right to life, the right to liberty, the right to property, the right to equal protection under the law, the right to government protection of public trust resources, and the right to retain a fighting chance to preserve a habitable climate system."
"In my opinion, this lawsuit is made necessary by the at-best schizophrenic, if not suicidal, nature of U.S. climate and energy policy."
--James Hansen, climate scientist
The complaint includes each plaintiff's individual story and how climate change harms them now and will harm them in the future if the court does not, as the lawsuit asks, order the federal government to decrease atmospheric concentrations of carbon dioxide to a safe level.
For example, 15-year-old Nathaniel Baring, of Alaska, is described as an "avid Nordic skier" who has been "harmed by the reduced snowfall in recent years."
Journey Zephier, a 15-year-old who lives with his family in Hawaii, has been adversely impacted by rising sea levels, beach erosion, and ocean acidification.
Eleven-year-old Sahara Valentine, an Oregon resident who has asthma, says her condition has been exacerbated by severe climate change.
And Victoria Barrett, a 16-year-old from New York, "has become emotionally distressed by the increase in superstorms in the Northeast," the complaint reads.
The case is part of a global legal campaign led by Our Children's Trust, a nonprofit organization coordinating federal, state, local, and global efforts to secure the legal right to a healthy atmosphere and stable climate.
There are signs that the strategy could be successful.
In June, an organization partnered with Our Children's Trust won a similar case in the Netherlands. A Dutch court ruled that the government has a legal duty to reduce carbon emissions by 25 percent by 2020.
"The state must do more to avert the imminent danger caused by climate change, also because of its duty of care to protect and improve the living environment," read a statement from the Hague District Court at the time.
In June, a judge in Washington state handed a landmark win to a group of eight young petitioners backed by Our Children's Trust and Hansen. The judge ordered the Department of Ecology (ECY) to consider statewide reductions in carbon dioxide emissions based on the best available science.
"The court's decision brings a feeling of triumph," said 14-year-old petitioner Aji Piper in June. "But I know there is still much work to be done. We may have won a battle, but we're still fighting a bigger war."
An Urgent Message From Our Co-Founder
Dear Common Dreams reader, The U.S. is on a fast track to authoritarianism like nothing I've ever seen. Meanwhile, corporate news outlets are utterly capitulating to Trump, twisting their coverage to avoid drawing his ire while lining up to stuff cash in his pockets. That's why I believe that Common Dreams is doing the best and most consequential reporting that we've ever done. Our small but mighty team is a progressive reporting powerhouse, covering the news every day that the corporate media never will. Our mission has always been simple: To inform. To inspire. And to ignite change for the common good. Now here's the key piece that I want all our readers to understand: None of this would be possible without your financial support. That's not just some fundraising cliche. It's the absolute and literal truth. We don't accept corporate advertising and never will. We don't have a paywall because we don't think people should be blocked from critical news based on their ability to pay. Everything we do is funded by the donations of readers like you. The final deadline for our crucial Summer Campaign fundraising drive is just hours away, and we’re falling short of our must-hit goal. Will you donate now to help power the nonprofit, independent reporting of Common Dreams? Thank you for being a vital member of our community. Together, we can keep independent journalism alive when it’s needed most. - Craig Brown, Co-founder |
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
Deirdre Fulton
Deirdre Fulton is a former Common Dreams senior editor and staff writer. Previously she worked as an editor and writer for the Portland Phoenix and the Boston Phoenix, where she was honored by the New England Press Association and the Association of Alternative Newsweeklies. A Boston University graduate, Deirdre is a co-founder of the Maine-based Lorem Ipsum Theater Collective and the PortFringe theater festival. She writes young adult fiction in her spare time.
carbon dioxidecarbon emissionsconstitutional rightsearth guardiansenvironmentfossil fuelsglobal warmingjames hansenmsnbcocean acidificationclimate action
Claiming that the continued development and burning of fossil fuels violates their constitutional rights, 21 young plaintiffs--ranging in age from 8 to 19--filed a landmark climate change lawsuit against the federal government on Wednesday.
"The federal government has known for decades that CO2 pollution from burning fossil fuels was causing global warming and dangerous climate change," said one of the teenage plaintiffs and youth director of Earth Guardians, 15-year-old Xiuhtezcatl Tonatiuh Martinez of Colorado. "It also knew that continuing to burn fossil fuels would destabilize our climate system, significantly harming my generation and generations to come."
Despite that knowledge, the government "continued to authorize and promote fossil fuel extraction, production, consumption, and all their associated emissions--to the grave detriment of future generations," added attorney Philip Gregory of the California firm Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy, a counsel to the plaintiffs.
Lawyers working on the case say a win for the kids would be no less important, from a strictly legal basis, than Brown v. Board of Education, which established the right to equal educational opportunity, or Obergefell v. Hodges, which much more recently established the freedom to marry.
As MSNBC reports, the lawsuit "debuts a new legal framework to fight climate change, one that portrays federal support for the development and use of fossil fuels as a violation of the Fifth and Ninth Amendments, as well as the public trust doctrine."
The public trust doctrine ensures "the rights of present and future generations to those essential natural resources that are of public concern to the citizens of our nation," reads the complaint. "These vital natural resources include at least the air (atmosphere), water, seas, the shores of the sea, and wildlife. The overarching public trust resource is our country's life-sustaining climate system, encompassing our atmosphere, waters, oceans, and biosphere. Defendants must take affirmative steps to protect those trust resources."
The youth's legal complaint (pdf) was accompanied by an "expert declaration" (pdf) from former NASA scientist James Hansen, who first raised the alarm on climate change in 1988. Hansen's granddaughter, 17-year-old Sophie Kivlehan of Pennsylvania, is among the plaintiffs.
"In my opinion, this lawsuit is made necessary by the at-best schizophrenic, if not suicidal, nature of U.S. climate and energy policy," Hansen wrote.
"It is now clear, as the relevant scientific community has established for some time, that continued high CO2 emissions from fossil fuel burning will further disrupt Earth's climate system, and that, in turn, will impose profound and mounting risks of ecological, economic and social collapse," he continued. "In my view, our government's actions and inactions that cause or contribute to those emissions violate the fundamental rights of Sophie, other Youth, and future generations. Those violated rights include the right to life, the right to liberty, the right to property, the right to equal protection under the law, the right to government protection of public trust resources, and the right to retain a fighting chance to preserve a habitable climate system."
"In my opinion, this lawsuit is made necessary by the at-best schizophrenic, if not suicidal, nature of U.S. climate and energy policy."
--James Hansen, climate scientist
The complaint includes each plaintiff's individual story and how climate change harms them now and will harm them in the future if the court does not, as the lawsuit asks, order the federal government to decrease atmospheric concentrations of carbon dioxide to a safe level.
For example, 15-year-old Nathaniel Baring, of Alaska, is described as an "avid Nordic skier" who has been "harmed by the reduced snowfall in recent years."
Journey Zephier, a 15-year-old who lives with his family in Hawaii, has been adversely impacted by rising sea levels, beach erosion, and ocean acidification.
Eleven-year-old Sahara Valentine, an Oregon resident who has asthma, says her condition has been exacerbated by severe climate change.
And Victoria Barrett, a 16-year-old from New York, "has become emotionally distressed by the increase in superstorms in the Northeast," the complaint reads.
The case is part of a global legal campaign led by Our Children's Trust, a nonprofit organization coordinating federal, state, local, and global efforts to secure the legal right to a healthy atmosphere and stable climate.
There are signs that the strategy could be successful.
In June, an organization partnered with Our Children's Trust won a similar case in the Netherlands. A Dutch court ruled that the government has a legal duty to reduce carbon emissions by 25 percent by 2020.
"The state must do more to avert the imminent danger caused by climate change, also because of its duty of care to protect and improve the living environment," read a statement from the Hague District Court at the time.
In June, a judge in Washington state handed a landmark win to a group of eight young petitioners backed by Our Children's Trust and Hansen. The judge ordered the Department of Ecology (ECY) to consider statewide reductions in carbon dioxide emissions based on the best available science.
"The court's decision brings a feeling of triumph," said 14-year-old petitioner Aji Piper in June. "But I know there is still much work to be done. We may have won a battle, but we're still fighting a bigger war."
Deirdre Fulton
Deirdre Fulton is a former Common Dreams senior editor and staff writer. Previously she worked as an editor and writer for the Portland Phoenix and the Boston Phoenix, where she was honored by the New England Press Association and the Association of Alternative Newsweeklies. A Boston University graduate, Deirdre is a co-founder of the Maine-based Lorem Ipsum Theater Collective and the PortFringe theater festival. She writes young adult fiction in her spare time.
Claiming that the continued development and burning of fossil fuels violates their constitutional rights, 21 young plaintiffs--ranging in age from 8 to 19--filed a landmark climate change lawsuit against the federal government on Wednesday.
"The federal government has known for decades that CO2 pollution from burning fossil fuels was causing global warming and dangerous climate change," said one of the teenage plaintiffs and youth director of Earth Guardians, 15-year-old Xiuhtezcatl Tonatiuh Martinez of Colorado. "It also knew that continuing to burn fossil fuels would destabilize our climate system, significantly harming my generation and generations to come."
Despite that knowledge, the government "continued to authorize and promote fossil fuel extraction, production, consumption, and all their associated emissions--to the grave detriment of future generations," added attorney Philip Gregory of the California firm Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy, a counsel to the plaintiffs.
Lawyers working on the case say a win for the kids would be no less important, from a strictly legal basis, than Brown v. Board of Education, which established the right to equal educational opportunity, or Obergefell v. Hodges, which much more recently established the freedom to marry.
As MSNBC reports, the lawsuit "debuts a new legal framework to fight climate change, one that portrays federal support for the development and use of fossil fuels as a violation of the Fifth and Ninth Amendments, as well as the public trust doctrine."
The public trust doctrine ensures "the rights of present and future generations to those essential natural resources that are of public concern to the citizens of our nation," reads the complaint. "These vital natural resources include at least the air (atmosphere), water, seas, the shores of the sea, and wildlife. The overarching public trust resource is our country's life-sustaining climate system, encompassing our atmosphere, waters, oceans, and biosphere. Defendants must take affirmative steps to protect those trust resources."
The youth's legal complaint (pdf) was accompanied by an "expert declaration" (pdf) from former NASA scientist James Hansen, who first raised the alarm on climate change in 1988. Hansen's granddaughter, 17-year-old Sophie Kivlehan of Pennsylvania, is among the plaintiffs.
"In my opinion, this lawsuit is made necessary by the at-best schizophrenic, if not suicidal, nature of U.S. climate and energy policy," Hansen wrote.
"It is now clear, as the relevant scientific community has established for some time, that continued high CO2 emissions from fossil fuel burning will further disrupt Earth's climate system, and that, in turn, will impose profound and mounting risks of ecological, economic and social collapse," he continued. "In my view, our government's actions and inactions that cause or contribute to those emissions violate the fundamental rights of Sophie, other Youth, and future generations. Those violated rights include the right to life, the right to liberty, the right to property, the right to equal protection under the law, the right to government protection of public trust resources, and the right to retain a fighting chance to preserve a habitable climate system."
"In my opinion, this lawsuit is made necessary by the at-best schizophrenic, if not suicidal, nature of U.S. climate and energy policy."
--James Hansen, climate scientist
The complaint includes each plaintiff's individual story and how climate change harms them now and will harm them in the future if the court does not, as the lawsuit asks, order the federal government to decrease atmospheric concentrations of carbon dioxide to a safe level.
For example, 15-year-old Nathaniel Baring, of Alaska, is described as an "avid Nordic skier" who has been "harmed by the reduced snowfall in recent years."
Journey Zephier, a 15-year-old who lives with his family in Hawaii, has been adversely impacted by rising sea levels, beach erosion, and ocean acidification.
Eleven-year-old Sahara Valentine, an Oregon resident who has asthma, says her condition has been exacerbated by severe climate change.
And Victoria Barrett, a 16-year-old from New York, "has become emotionally distressed by the increase in superstorms in the Northeast," the complaint reads.
The case is part of a global legal campaign led by Our Children's Trust, a nonprofit organization coordinating federal, state, local, and global efforts to secure the legal right to a healthy atmosphere and stable climate.
There are signs that the strategy could be successful.
In June, an organization partnered with Our Children's Trust won a similar case in the Netherlands. A Dutch court ruled that the government has a legal duty to reduce carbon emissions by 25 percent by 2020.
"The state must do more to avert the imminent danger caused by climate change, also because of its duty of care to protect and improve the living environment," read a statement from the Hague District Court at the time.
In June, a judge in Washington state handed a landmark win to a group of eight young petitioners backed by Our Children's Trust and Hansen. The judge ordered the Department of Ecology (ECY) to consider statewide reductions in carbon dioxide emissions based on the best available science.
"The court's decision brings a feeling of triumph," said 14-year-old petitioner Aji Piper in June. "But I know there is still much work to be done. We may have won a battle, but we're still fighting a bigger war."
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.