Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

Harris’ plan overestimates the government’s ability to keep for-profit health insurance companies from driving up health care spending and denying people needed care. (Photo: Getty Images)

Harris’ plan overestimates the government’s ability to keep for-profit health insurance companies from driving up health care spending and denying people needed care. (Photo: Getty Images)

'KamalaCare' Fails to Address Big Problem: That We Cannot Trust Insurance Companies

Like other Democratic presidential candidates who propose a "public option," she never tells us what her plan will cost or why for-profit insurers will all of a sudden deliver good affordable health care. There’s a reason.

Diane ArcherWendell Potter

 by The Hill

It’s hard to disagree with Sen. Kamala Harris (D-Calif.) when she says: “Right now, the American health care system is a patchwork of plans, providers and costs that have left people frustrated, powerless and insurance companies in charge. And . . . health care just costs too much.” That makes it all the more confusing that Harris’ new health care plan would maintain the broken status quo -- one that leads thousands of Americans to die each year.

Like Sen. Bernie Sanders’ (I-Vt.) and Rep. Pramila Jayapal’s (D-Wash.) “Medicare for All” legislation, Harris would open up an improved, traditional Medicare public plan to all Americans. Unlike Sanders and Jayapal, Harris also would allow anyone who wants to opt into a commercial Medicare plan to do so.

Harris’ proposal would require all commercial health plans to operate under Medicare, which would provide greater oversight of health insurers. But it’s not clear how Harris’ plan would eliminate much, if any, of the $500 billion a year in administrative waste that private health insurers bring to the table.

Harris’ plan overestimates the government’s ability to keep for-profit health insurance companies from driving up health care spending and denying people needed care. It’s hard to see how it would rein in health care costs and guarantee health care to all Americans.

Harris’ tough talk on new rules of the road for private insurers sounds terrific. But President Barack Obama said the same thing 10 years ago -- and health insurers won out under the Affordable Care Act, making tens of billions of dollars in profits since the law passed. Insurers are in business to drive big profits and shareholder returns. How would Harris prevent insurers from gaming the system, as they always have?

It would be wonderful if Congress could enact a law that would turn our for-profit health insurance industry into the heavily regulated, largely non-profit insurers that offer better coverage at a lower cost in Germany, France and Japan. But with the health insurance trade association spending nearly $7 million on lobbyists in 2018 alone, thinking Congress would remove the profit motive of those companies is magical thinking. Harris underestimates the ability of for-profit insurers to corrupt our political system and health care regulators. 

Medicare Advantage plans, the commercial insurers that offer Medicare benefits, have overcharged the federal government—taxpayers—well over $100 billion dollars during the last decade, and the federal government has not been able to recoup even the cost of its audits. Many of these insurers have engaged in what the U.S. Office of the Inspector General calls “widespread and persistent” performance problems related to “denials of care and payment.” They have largely escaped public identification and accountability. Other Medicare Advantage plans have “threatened the health and safety of their members.” 

For several years now, Medicare Advantage plans have not disclosed complete and accurate data that reflects actual services their enrollees have received. This is necessary to ensure plans are providing them appropriate levels of care. The federal government has not even been able to get Medicare Advantage plans to provide their members with complete and accurate directories of which doctor they can see.

As Harris notes, 200 economists have united behind Medicare for All because it saves money and guarantees affordable health care to all. What she misses is that her plan is a far cry from the “single-payer” Medicare for All system these economists are referring to. Harris’ health care reform proposal introduces a new patchwork of private health plans with little evident cost savings and a high risk that enrollees will not get the affordable care they need. Like other Democratic presidential candidates who propose a “public option,” she never tells us what her plan will cost or why for-profit insurers will all of a sudden deliver good affordable health care. There’s a reason.


© 2021 The Hill

Diane Archer

Diane Archer is president of Just Care USA, an independent digital hub covering health and financial issues facing boomers and their families and promoting policy solutions. She is the past board chair of Consumer Reports and serves on the Brown University School of Public Health Advisory Board. Ms. Archer began her career in health advocacy in 1989 as founder and president of the Medicare Rights Center, a national organization dedicated to ensuring that older and disabled Americans get the health care they need. She served as director, Health Care for All Project, Institute for America’s Future, between 2005 and 2010.

Wendell Potter

Wendell Potter

Wendell Potter is the former vice president for corporate communications at Cigna. He is now president of Business for Medicare for All and author of bestselling books Deadly Spin and Nation on the Take.

We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.

Scientists Revive ‘Zombie’ Virus After 50,000 Years Trapped in Siberian Permafrost

Researchers documented 13 never-before-seen viruses that have been lying dormant, frozen in thick ice, over tens of thousands of years.

Common Dreams staff ·


'Cleaner Air Is Coming' as London Expands Vehicle Pollution Fee to Entire Metro Area

"Around 4,000 Londoners die prematurely each year because of long-term exposure to air pollution, with the greatest number of deaths in outer London boroughs," noted Mayor Sadiq Khan in announcing the expansion.

Brett Wilkins ·


'Amazing News': Historic Shark Protections Approved at Global Wildlife Convention

Up to 90% of sharks targeted by the lucrative fin trade will now be protected, said one advocate.

Julia Conley ·


'The Nightmare Materializes': Far-Right Extremist Itamar Ben-Gvir to Be Israel's National Security Minister

The Foreign Affairs Ministry of the Palestinian Authority said Ben-Gvir's elevation to national security minister could have a "catastrophic impact on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict."

Jake Johnson ·


Raging Wars, Soaring Hunger Put Women and Girls in Crosshairs, Warns UN

"A toxic mix of crises—conflicts, climate, skyrocketing costs, and the ripple effects of the Ukraine war—are inflicting a devastating toll on the forcibly displaced. This is being felt across the world, but women and girls are particularly suffering."

Brett Wilkins ·

Common Dreams Logo