Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

No Order from Bush to Stop Torture

Never let it be said that the U.S. State Department lacks chutzpah.

The department recently issued its annual report on human rights practices of nations around the world, pointedly criticizing perennial violators as well as allies, including the U.S.-sponsored interim Iraqi government.

But the report doesn't discuss accusations of human rights abuses at the U.S. prisons in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba and Abu Gharib, Iraq, where prisoners of war and terrorism suspects are held.

Curtis Cooper, a State Department spokesman, explained that the report does not indulge in self-criticism. It leaves it to others to call the U.S. hand.

"We don't report on ourselves," Cooper said, but he noted that the United States does report on its allies as well as nations with chronic human rights transgressions.

For example, the report detailed torture, rape, arbitrary arrests and illegal detentions by the Iraqi government.

"There are countries we support and that are friends, and when they have practices that don't meet international standards, we don't hesitate to call a spade a spade," Cooper said. He added that the Iraqis accepted the criticism and didn't deny the charges.

Really now, what alternative do they have?

The report also listed the usual suspects, including Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Sudan, Pakistan, North Korea and Iran, among other humans rights violators.

Here are some of the critiques:

  • Saudi Arabia: torture by its security forces, arbitrary arrests and incommunicado detentions;
  • Egypt: mistreatment of prisoners leading to 10 deaths;
  • North Korea: brutal and repressive treatment of its people.

    Some nations were accused of torturing prisoners and inflicting them with sleep deprivation and blindfolding.

    If that sounds familiar, it's probably because similar criticism has been levied against U.S. interrogators who were accused of punitive methods to create anxiety and fear. The torture took many forms, including "water boarding" that simulates drowning.

    Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld approved a plan to allow "exceptional techniques" during 20-hour interrogations, including face slapping and stripping captives to create a feeling of helplessness and dependence and using dogs to create anxiety.

    The American Civil Liberties Union and Human Rights First -- made up of human rights lawyers -- have filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of eight men who claim they were tortured in Iraq and Afghanistan under Rumsfeld's command.

    The suit puts the blame on Rumsfeld and accuses him of violating the U.S. Constitution.

    Over the past several months, there also have been reports that the United States sends prisoners to countries where they will face tougher interrogation methods that would be outrageously illegal in the United States. It's euphemistically called "extraordinary rendition."

    So far, we have not heard a mea culpa from Rumsfeld. Despite all the shameful revelations, President Bush has yet to issue a ironclad executive order against torture or abusive treatment in military prisons.

    At a White House briefing last week, I asked press secretary Scott McClellan: "Has the president ever issued an order against torture of prisoners? And do we still send prisoners to Syria to be tortured?"

    McClellan replied: "The president has stated publicly that we do not condone torture and that he would never authorize the use of torture. He has made that (clear)."

    "But has he issued an order?"

    McClellan didn't give a clear response.

    The president made a "statement very publicly and he's made it very clear to everybody in the government that we do not condone torture," he replied.

    McClellan refused to say whether U.S. prisoners are shipped out to other countries for harsher treatment.

    So what is holding the president back from signing an executive order prohibiting torture?

    With no clear orders from the commander in chief, are prison guards still on their own?

    On his recent trip to Europe, Bush had a highly publicized meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin. Bush reportedly complained that Moscow had been backsliding on democracy and curbing individual liberties.

    Putin's public response was restrained -- apparently not wanting to ruffle Bush -- but he could have said: "Look who's talking."

  • © 2021 Seattle Post-Intelligencer
    Helen Thomas

    Helen Thomas

    Helen Thomas was an American author and former news service reporter, member of the White House Press Corps and columnist. She worked for the United Press International (UPI) for 57 years, first as a correspondent, and later as White House bureau chief. She was an opinion columnist for Hearst Newspapers from 2000 to 2010, writing on national affairs and the White House. Among other books, she was the author of "Front Row at The White House: My Life and Times" (2000) and "Watchdogs of Democracy?: The Waning Washington Press Corps and How It Has Failed the Public" (2007). Helen passed away on July 20, 2013.

    This is the world we live in. This is the world we cover.

    Because of people like you, another world is possible. There are many battles to be won, but we will battle them together—all of us. Common Dreams is not your normal news site. We don't survive on clicks. We don't want advertising dollars. We want the world to be a better place. But we can't do it alone. It doesn't work that way. We need you. If you can help today—because every gift of every size matters—please do. Without Your Support We Simply Don't Exist.

    Please select a donation method:

    3 Million People Have Died of Covid Since Rich Nations Began Obstructing Vaccine Patent Waiver

    "Every one of those deaths is a mark of shame for the governments of countries like the U.K. and Germany who have protected patents over human lives."

    Jake Johnson ·

    27 Groups Urge Congress to Close FBI 'Backdoor Search' Loophole

    "Ending this unconstitutional practice is imperative to ensure that foreign intelligence surveillance does not swallow Americans' privacy rights."

    Brett Wilkins ·

    300+ Civil Society Groups Counter-Mobilize Against UN Food Systems Summit

    "Repeating the agri-business-as-usual model to solve the food and climate crisis cannot deliver on the holistic and systemic transformation of our food systems we need today."

    Kenny Stancil ·

    House Dems Ask ExxonMobil Lobbyist to Testify About Climate Misinformation

    "For decades, the fossil fuel industry and its allies have used the same tactics as the tobacco industry to spread denial and doubt about the harm of its products," the letter states.

    Brett Wilkins ·