

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FREE NEWSLETTER
Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.
5
#000000
#FFFFFF
To donate by check, phone, or other method, see our More Ways to Give page.


Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.

Josh Chetwynd, Deputy Director, Media Relations, jchetwynd@
After a 2021 full of environmental victories, Environment America, the national network of 29 state organizations, has a slate of priorities ready for the new year that will ensure more renewable energy, zero carbon climate solutions, conservation, clean water and zero waste progress at the federal and state levels.
"From a ninth state committing to 100% renewable energy to new meaningful national conservation and clean transportation policies, 2021 was a great year of change - but 2022 needs to be even better," said Environment America President Wendy Wendlandt. "Our national and state advocates know that the challenges facing our planet continue to mount and that, no matter the victories, we must press forward until our air and water is clean, our energy is renewable, our climate safe, and our wild lands and the animals who inhabit them are fully protected. We look forward to working toward those goals in the coming year."
Here is a roundup of some of the other top issues that Environment America and its 29 state organizations will be working on across the country in 2022:
Dan Jacobson, Senior Advisor for Environment California, rallying to save rooftop solar. Photo credit: staff.
Environment America will continue its longstanding campaign to get states, cities, corporations and academic institutions to commit to powering all their operations with 100% renewable energy. We will continue our work on solar, which means pressing for expanded general solar goals, encouraging rooftop installation and defending pro-solar policies. We will also remain focused on offshore wind efforts. In addition, national advocates will increase their work on energy storage by asking states to set energy goals.
In addition, Environment America will continue to advocate for cutting energy waste by making our appliances and buildings more efficient. To that end, we will work to accelerate the adoption of electric heating, cooling and cooking technologies in buildings and will defend communities' freedom to choose clean energy.
At the federal level, the Build Back Better Act provides substantial tax incentives for wind and solar energy, clean transportation and energy efficiency.
At the state level, Environment California will work to protect solar incentive programs - as well as push to increase the use of solar panels on public roofs - from schools to fire stations - and make access to solar easier through programs like the free SolarAPP+. In addition, the group will push for the implementation of a million solar batteries to match the group's previously successful campaign to build more than a million solar roofs.
Environment Georgia, Environment Massachusetts, Environment North Carolina, Environment New Jersey, Environment VIrginia and Wisconsin Environment will all be calling on their states to commit to 100% clean renewable energy. In addition, Environment Georgia will advocate for fair compensation for using solar generation, and work to get the state to join the Atlantic offshore wind task force in order to increase its participation in utilizing this renewable energy. Environment Massachusetts will work to get the state to require all large buildings to replace fossil fuel heating with clean alternatives that meet efficiency standards -- including in office buildings, apartment buildings, hospitals and university campuses.
In North Carolina, advocates will also call for policies that increase solar storage and amplify efficient and gas-free homes. In Virginia, we will push the commonwealth to not only emerge as a national offshore wind leader but also embrace clean building codes that make where we work and live all-electric.
New Jersey organizers will press the state to codify its goal for 7,500 megawatts of offshore wind off the Jersey Shore by 2035 through legislation; to expand community solar projects; to adopt policies to turbocharge green financing for commercial projects to finance clean energy improvements; and to oppose legislation to ban state electrification mandates in the building sector. Wisconsin Environment will seek opportunities for households and major energy users to adopt renewables and energy storage. The Wisconsin group will also look to advance solar and wind energy incentives at the state and local level and develop solar farms to generate renewable energy in a responsible way.
Along with calling for more incentives for solar energy and an emphasis on making buildings all-electric, Environment Illinois will advocate for improved appliance efficiency standards and a transition from a gas infrastructure to renewable energy sources. Environment Maine will engage the public and stakeholders in the process of creating Maine's Offshore Wind Roadmap (to be finalized and released December 2022). Environment Missouri will work for an increase in the state's renewable energy standard from just 15% in 2021 to at least 50% in 2035. Other policies in Missouri include: incentives for expanding community rooftop solar; a banning of new gas infrastructure; and the construction of the Grain Belt Express, an 800-mile transmission line delivering abundant wind energy from Kansas, across Missouri, in order to assist in the renewable energy standard goals.
Environment Washington will also be working toward clean, all-electric buildings and community solar. Environment Texas will work to protect renewable energy from discriminatory fees as state regulators redesign the electric market in the wake of the February blackouts. The group will also advocate to get Texas cities in the deregulated electric market to offer a public option for 100% renewable energy for their residents, and will support the development of offshore wind in the Gulf of Mexico (in particular, when the U.S. Department of the Interior begins offering leasing at the end of 2022).
Environment America staff fighting to protect the Arctic. Photo credit: staff.
Protecting our wild spaces and a cross-section of species is high on Environment America's agenda. This includes: Getting the federal government to finalize protections for the Tongass National Forest; continuing to move the tissue products market away from virgin wood toward such alternatives as recycled paper, bamboo and wheat straw (that includes particular focus on the likes of Costco and Procter & Gamble); ending oil leasing in the Arctic Refuge (as well as ending offshore drilling along the United States' contiguous 48 coast); permanently protecting land surrounding the Grand Canyon and Chaco Canyon; safeguarding Alaska's Bristol Bay from copper mining; and ending dangerous old-school lobster and fishing practices in New England Right whale ocean habitats.
The new year will also see new campaigns, including an effort to save mature trees in all natural forests as well as fresh efforts to expand ocean monuments and sanctuaries, where appropriate, off our coasts.
State partners will lean in on a number of nationwide priorities. For example, efforts to protect indispensable pollinators, in particular bees, will occur in such states as California, Illinois, Missouri, New Jersey, North Carolina, Oregon, Virginia and Wisconsin. Policies will vary by state, but banning bee-killing pesticides like neonicotinoids and chlorpyrifos for both agricultural and nonagricultural uses is a key in most places.
Erecting wildlife corridors that reconnect fragile species is also imperative. Environment California, Environment North Carolina, Environment Virginia and Environment Washington are among the groups that will be working on that issue.
There are also a number of state-specific priorities. For instance, Environment Maine will work to protect Frenchman Bay and Acadia National Park by stopping the development of a massive industrial salmon farm and pass legislation (LD 736) to expand and enhance Maine's ecological reserve system to protect additional ecosystems and wildlife habitat. Environment Georgia will advocate to preserve the Okefenokee National Wildlife Refuge from a proposed titanium mine close to the southeastern corner of the swamp.
In New Jersey, some specific plans include: ensuring constitutionally dedicated funds for open space increase; watchdogging state funding from the federal Land and Water Conservation Fund and the National Park Service to protect our natural lands and state and national parks; and pressing for the federal designation of the Delaware Water Gap National Recreational Area as the state's first national park. Environment Oregon will be working to reintroduce sea otters to the state after years of environmental degradation forced them out, and Environment Texas will press to get candidates for Texas governor to support the creation of one million additional acres of state parks.
Among its many conservation priorities, Environment Virginia will continue to call on protections for the Chesapeake Bay, while Environment Washington will press for the removal of dams along the Snake River as part of a statewide effort to promote salmon restoration and the elimination of pollution in the Salish region.
Environment America works to eliminate threats from fossil fuels and mining, industrial pollution, urban and agricultural runoff, and sewage systems. Photo credits: (from left) ILoveMountains.org/CC BY 2.0, Public Domain, Public Domain, Kate Boicourt / Integration and Application Network, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science
With the Clean Water Act celebrating its 50th anniversary in 2022, Environment America will spearhead a massive education effort to build public awareness and support for this bedrock environmental law. Our successful Get the Lead Out campaign will continue to press forward. At the federal level, the Environmental Protection Agency will be updating the Lead & Copper Rule, and we will call on the agency to require replacement of lead service lines within 10 years (with narrow exceptions for cities like Chicago to demonstrate they cannot meet that deadline).
State partners will also work on this issue. For example, Environment Georgia will advocate for the state to use funds from the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act and other federal sources to immediately start addressing this threat by replacing lead service lines, especially near child care centers and schools. This can be done by replacing fountains with filtered water bottle stations, and installing filters certified to remove lead at all other taps used for cooking and drinking. Similar efforts will take place in Illinois, where Environment Illinois found in 2018 that 78% of suburban Cook County schools detected lead in their water. Additional locales where advocates will push for policies to get rid of lead in our water system - particularly in schools - include Missouri, North Carolina, New Jersey, Texas, Virginia and Washington.
Other clean water priorities include pressing state and local officials to use new federal infrastructure funding to adopt stronger local policies to make waterways safe for swimming - from Pittsburgh and Philadelphia to Austin, Texas. Enhancing factory farm pollution regulations will be on the agenda in Illinois and Wisconsin. Environment New Jersey is placing the implementation of a comprehensive clean-up plan for Barnegat Bay among its priorities and Environment Georgia will work to protect communities from the toxins in coal ash by ensuring that all coal ash is stored away from waterways in dry, lined and capped facilities.
Destination: Zero Carbon
With transportation continuing to be the number one source of greenhouse gas emissions in the U.S., reimagining our transportation system with a clean renewable roadmap remains high on Environment America's to-do list.
At the federal level, we will press for the next generation of clean car standards for model years 2027 and beyond to continue the trend toward stronger regulations in order to put us on the path to 100% EV sales by 2035 or sooner. Also, we will press for greater federal incentives for EV purchases and, as part of our Charge Across America campaign, we're supporting the Green Spaces, Green Vehicles Act to bring electric vehicle charging to national parks and forests.
In the states, Environment California will press for a commitment to build a network of a million electric vehicle charging stations statewide, and will support expanding such local programs as Clean Cars 4 All, which works to take the dirtiest cars off the roads, throughout California. Environment Georgia will advocate for tax credits for new EV owners and a removal of fees levied on EV owners. The group will also work to increase state support for mass transit and greater autonomy for counties to determine their own transit futures.
A number of our groups, including Environment Illinois, Environment Maine, Environment New Jersey, Environment Oregon, Environment Texas, Environment Virginia and Environment Washington will focus on increasing fleets of electric school buses. Improving EV charging infrastructure will be on the agenda for a number of these groups as well.
Beyond that, our Maine group will push for the Pine Tree State to adopt the Advanced Clean Truck rule as well as pass legislation (LD 1579) to establish targets and timetables for the state, counties and municipalities to transition to zero-emission light-, medium- and heavy-duty vehicle fleets. Environment Missouri will work to remove alternative fuel decal requirements for electric vehicles. In New Jersey, goals include fully funding consumer rebates at the point of EV purchase of up to $5,000; implementing NJ Transit electric bus pilot programs across the state (including in Camden and Newark); and instituting advanced clean truck regulations.
PennEnvironment will push for the Keystone State to join the Zero Emission Vehicle (ZEV) portion of the CA clean cars program. In Texas, Environment Texas will also work to get Austin and other cities to require new buildings be EV-ready. In addition, our Texas group will press to stop the expansion of I-35 through Austin. In Virginia, that will include advocating for the Transportation Climate Initiative (TCI), and, in Wisconsin, efforts will be made to increase the state's Transportation Alternatives Program (TAP) by $10 million per biennium.
Stamping out waste to protect not only people but also animals and our wild spaces is a longstanding goal for Environment America. Holding producers responsible for the cost of managing and cleaning up their wasteful packaging and products is a key part of that effort. Campaigns will occur in Colorado, Illinois, New Jersey, Oregon, Virginia and Washington, among other states.
We'll continue to both advance bans on single-use plastics and protect against preemptive statewide efforts to stop them. Action will take place on this issue in such states as California, Connecticut, Georgia, Illinois, Missouri, New Jersey, North Carolina, Oregon, Texas, Virginia, Washington and Wisconsin.
Advocates will also work to prevent chemical incineration and plastic-to-fuel conversion (wrongly called chemical or advanced "recycling"). This will happen at the state level, by opposing the permitting and building of these facilities - for example, stopping the construction of the Brightmark facility in Macon, Georgia. And, at the federal level, by urging the EPA to set rules to cover this currently unregulated and dangerous technology. We're also working with federal legislators to advance important bills, including banning the sale of polluting single-use plastics in national parks, and the strongest bill in U.S. history to reduce plastic waste, the Break Free from Plastic Pollution Act.
With Environment America, you protect the places that all of us love and promote core environmental values, such as clean air to breathe, clean water to drink, and clean energy to power our lives. We're a national network of 29 state environmental groups with members and supporters in every state. Together, we focus on timely, targeted action that wins tangible improvements in the quality of our environment and our lives.
(303) 801-0581The International Atomic Energy Agency warned of "the paramount importance of adhering to the seven pillars for ensuring nuclear safety and security during a conflict."
The director general of the International Atomic Energy Agency on Saturday demanded "maximum military restraint" from the US and Israel as it confirmed reports that strikes had targeted a location close to Iran's Bushehr Nuclear Power Plant, killing at least one person.
In a statement released via social media, the IAEA relayed a message from Director General Rafael Mariano Grossi, who expressed "deep concern about the reported incident."
Grossi warned that nuclear power plants or nearby areas "must never be attacked, noting that auxiliary site buildings may contain vital safety equipment" and stressed "the paramount importance of adhering to the seven pillars for ensuring nuclear safety and security during a conflict."
The IAEA said the attack near the Bushehr plant, Iran's only operational nuclear power facility, was the fourth such attack since Israel and the US began its invasion of Iran on February 28. The plant lies in a city inhabited by about 250,000 people.
A security staff member was killed by a projectile fragment and a building on the Bushehr site was impacted by shockwaves and fragments. Grossi said that no increase in radiation levels was reported.
Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi also condemned the Bushehr strike and issued a reminder of the "Western outrage about hostilities near Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Power Plant in Ukraine" when Russia attacked the site.
"Israel-US have bombed our Bushehr plant four times now. Radioactive fallout will end life in [Gulf Cooperation Council] capitals, not Tehran. Attacks on our petrochemicals also convey real objectives," said Araghchi.
Al Jazeera reported that at least two petrochemical facilities had been hit by the US and Israel in southern Iran’s Khuzestan province, an energy hub in the country. At least five people were injured in those attacks,
Iranian news agency Mehr reported that the state-run Bandar Imam petrochemical complex, which produces liquefied petroleum gas and chemicals as well as other products, sustained damage.
President Donald Trump said late last month that he would delay any attacks on Iran's energy infrastructure until April 6 and said the delay was "subject to the success of the ongoing meetings and discussions.”
He has threatened to destroy Iran's power plants and other civilian infrastructure if Iranian leaders don't end the blockade on the oil export waterway the Strait of Hormuz, which they began in retaliation for the US-Israeli strikes that started more than a month ago and which has fueled skyrocketing global energy prices.
The threat amounted to Trump warning that he could soon commit a war crime, said international law experts.
US President Donald Trump continued his "war on science" on Friday with his budget request for the 2027 fiscal year, which critics have denounced as "grossly irresponsible" for its proposed $1.5 trillion in military spending and "a moral obscenity" because of its cuts to social and scientific programs.
In the lead-up to Trump's request to the Republican-controlled Congress, as he and Israel waged war on Iran, Sean Manning, a Herbert Scoville Jr. Peace Fellow in the Union of Concerned Scientists' Global Security Program, wrote that "if this Bloody New Deal actually passes, it could give unparalleled increases in financial power to defense contractors and support for the political work they already do to influence Congress."
"Sane voices need to act now, building opposition to this unprecedented plan," Manning argued. "Progressives should be unflinching in defining this proposal as a blank check for the same contractors who cannot deliver ships on time, munitions at scale, or clean audits. Pouring funds into a defense sector that has repeatedly failed basic tests of accountability will not miraculously produce innovation."
In addition to railing against the budget for the Pentagon—the world's largest institutional climate polluter—after it was officially released on Friday, progressive voices directed attention to some particular proposed cuts and their consequences.
To fund the Pentagon's massive war-making budget, "the Trump administration is requesting the cancellation of billions of dollars in funds for renewable energy, environmental justice, carbon removal, space science, and climate change education," Emily Gardner reported Friday for Eos, the American Geophysical Union's news magazine.
As Katherine Tsantiris, Ocean Conservancy's director of government relations, pointed out, among the targeted federal agencies is the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). The proposed cuts, she said, "fly directly in the face of the clear bipartisan support Congress showed earlier this year by protecting funding for this critical agency."
"Slashing NOAA's budget would weaken weather forecasting, disrupt fisheries management, and stall ocean research—putting American lives, livelihoods, and global scientific leadership at risk," Tsantiris continued. "Congress should once again reject these cuts to ensure NOAA has the resources it needs to support our economy, protect our ocean, and keep Americans safe."
Quentin Scott, federal policy director at the Chesapeake Climate Action Network Action Fund, argued that "this proposed budget is exactly what America does NOT need when facing rising energy bills, more frequent extreme weather, and rising insurance rates."
"By gutting funds for climate science and innovation, the budget jeopardizes our ability to understand and respond to the accelerating climate crisis," Scott said. "Defunding climate research at NOAA doesn't make the problem go away—it makes those hazards more dangerous and more expensive. Families across the country are already paying the price through higher utility bills, flooding, and storm damage. This budget would only make those burdens worse."
Big Oil-backed Trump's budget proposal came on the heels of devastating flooding in Hawaii and as high temperatures hit the Western United States. It also followed an annual World Meteorological Organization report on the fossil fuel-driven climate emergency, which last month led UN Secretary-General António Guterres to declare that "every key climate indicator is flashing red."
Devastating.
[image or embed]
— Scott Kardel aka Palomar Skies (@palomarskies.bsky.social) April 3, 2026 at 12:29 PM
Trump also proposed slashing the Environmental Protection Agency's budget—amid calls to oust Administrator Lee Zeldin for "so brazenly" betraying the EPA's core mission to "protect human health and the environment." Trump also proposed cutting the agency's budget. Noting that attack, Climate Action Campaign director Margie Alt described the president's plan as "anything but a serious" one and "a declaration of who this administration is willing to let suffer."
In a nod to some of the rich executives whose campaign cash helped Trump return to power after promising to scrap his predecessor's climate policies and to enact a "drill, baby, drill" agenda, Alt also called it "a reiteration of this president's devotion to fossil fuel interests."
"This budget would slash the EPA budget by 52%, gutting the agency's ability to protect the air our children breathe, the water our families drink, and the communities that already bear the worst of extreme weather and climate change," she said. "It is a deliberately callous choice to remove the protections that keep families safe, healthy, and shielded from the impacts of pollution and climate change."
According to Alt:
This is not just a continuation of last year's rollbacks. It is an escalation of the Trump administration's Polluters First Agenda and their assault on public health safeguards. Since January 2025, among other abuses, this administration has fired 600 National Weather Service staff, proposed eliminating critical climate research institutions, waived mercury pollution standards for 60 dirty power plants, and gutted the Clean Air Act. This budget is the Trump administration's payback for their big oil, coal, and gas friends and contributors. It slashes resources for clean energy, it zeroes out environmental justice, and pushes oil, gas, and coal, at a time when prices for these energy sources are skyrocketing.
Never before have we had an administration that so blatantly treats American lives as expendable, as proven by this budget. Congress must reject this inhumane budget in full. The American people deserve a federal government that protects them, not one that trades their health, their safety, and their futures for big oil, coal, and gas profits.
As Gardner reported, Trump's budget also "proposes consolidating the Endangered Species Act and Marine Mammal Protection Act, but did not provide details outside noting the program would be housed at the Department of the Interior," among other changes and cuts.
Chris Westfall, senior government relations legislative counsel at Defenders of Wildlife, said that "the administration is yet again demanding that an overworked and grossly understaffed federal workforce do more with less. The proposed budget recklessly consolidates US Fish and Wildlife Service and National Marine Fisheries without the needed resources to preserve scientific expertise, opens our lands and waters to extractive industries, and hollows out the already strained workforce that provides crucial conservation work."
"This proposed budget pushes us further in the wrong direction—potentially triggering even more staff layoffs and providing less resources for wildlife conservation, which are pivotal to recovering America's imperiled species," Westfall warned. "Our nation's lands and the wildlife that depend on them for habitat deserve better than to be ignored by agencies that are shells of their former selves."
The president's proposed attack on endangered species came just days after the administration's so-called "God Squad" voted unanimously for an exemption allowing fossil fuel operations in the Gulf of Mexico to ignore policies intended to protect them. In response, Andrew Bowman, president and CEO of Defenders of Wildlife, said that "I cannot stress enough how unprecedented and unlawful this action is."
"There’s a chilling effect on not just my academic freedom, but that of my colleagues; anyone who dares to speak out against the war and against aggression," said UW professor Aria Fani.
The University of Washington has removed a professor from his role as director of its Middle East Center after he criticized the illegal US-Israeli war of choice on Iran and condemned Zionism, the settler-colonial movement for Jewish hegemony in Palestine.
Aria Fani, who will remain an associate professor at UW’s Jackson School of International Studies, told The Seattle Times on Friday that new interim widirector Daniel Hoffman told him last week he was fired from his leadership role at the Middle East Center.
Fani, who was born and raised in Iran and came to the US when he was 18 years old, said he was hired for his research on Iran. However, he told the Times that he now feels "profoundly hurt and betrayed" by his removal.
"There’s a chilling effect on not just my academic freedom, but that of my colleagues; anyone who dares to speak out against the war and against aggression," he said.
In a separate interview Friday with My Northwest, Fani said he was removed "for improper use" of the center's listserv, an email application.
"I sent out two memos about this atrocious war on Iran in which I offered historical analysis that’s lacking in the media,” Fani said. “I was told that my email made ‘certain constituents feel attacked.’ By certain constituents, I assume the university means Zionists who would like to keep bombing every Middle Eastern country and continue dehumanizing their people.”
Last July Fani told the The Daily UW, a student newspaper, that President Donald Trump's militaristic foreign policy—he's bombed 10 countries, more than any other US leader—is not making the world safer.
“If you tell the dozens of children that were killed in Israeli bombardment... in Iran, or the families of the nuclear scientists who were just wiped out, I hardly imagine they would say that the world is a more peaceful place," he said amid the first round of US and Israeli airstrikes on Iran.
Since then, many more Iranian children have been killed by US and Israeli bombing, including more than 100 students who were among around 175 people massacred in the February 28 US cruise missile strike on a girls' school in Minab.
“The [only] peace this secures is for weapons manufacturers, for oil companies, for drone companies," Fani said in an implicit rebuke of Trump's claim to be the "president of peace."
"It secures peace for them, fills their pockets with money, and makes them fully invincible," he added. "It’s creating a class of people that are living [on] an alternate planet."
Fani was a close friend and defender of Ayşenur Ezgi Eygi, the 26-year-old Turkish-American UW grad and International Solidarity Movement volunteer who was fatally shot in 2024 while peacefully protesting the expansion of Israel’s illegal settlements in the occupied West Bank. Witnesses said Israeli occupation forces deliberately shot Eygi in the head.
The professor also called Zionism—some of whose founders acknowledged the colonial nature of their endeavor—a "cancerous" ideology.
Fani noted that his removal from his position at the Middle East Center coincided with a recent town hall-style meeting attended by UW President Robert Jones and right-wing media personality Ari Hoffman. According to Fani, Hoffman "specifically asked Jones" about the professor's leadership at the center.
“All we can do is try to remind people of their responsibilities as members of the university community,” Jones said at meeting. “Not trying to tell them that they can’t have a discussion about Palestine or about Israel, but let’s be clear that those discussions need to be had in a way that doesn’t perpetuate an environment where people feel unsafe.”
According to its website, UW's Middle East Center seeks "to strengthen an understanding of the Middle East in all sectors of American society through training and research at the University of Washington, as well as through delivery of outreach programming across the nation."
Fani is one of dozens of US academics who have been fired, had their contracts terminated, lost job offers, or faced other punitive repercussions for advocating Palestinian rights or opposing Israeli policies and practices.
Earlier this week, Shirin Saeidi, who headed the Center for Middle East Studies at the University of Arkansas, Fayetteville, was terminated for social media posts deemed supportive of Iran's government, despite the fact that the school's Faculty Committee on Appointment, Promotion, and Tenure ruled unanimously in February that she should return to her position.
Late last month, Texas State University philosophy professor Idris Robinson sued school officials after he was fired for what he says was his 2024 off-campus lecture in North Carolina titled “Strategic Lessons from the Palestinian Resistance."
Israel's conduct in Gaza is the subject of an ongoing International Court of Justice (ICJ) genocide case filed by South Africa and formally supported by nearly 20 nations. The International Criminal Court has also issued arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defense Minister Yoav Gallant for alleged crimes against humanity and war crimes in Gaza.
The ICJ found in 2024 that Israel's occupation of Palestine is an illegal form of apartheid.