Support Common Dreams Today
Journalism that is independent, non-profit, ad-free, and 100% reader-supported.
To donate by check, phone, or other method, see our More Ways to Give page.
Matters for America called attention to the numerous Republican
operatives on Fox News' payroll and airwaves. Further demonstrating that Fox is
effectively a conservative political organization and not a legitimate news
outlet, a review of the network's coverage since September 1 reveals that these
individuals often use their airtime to advance false and misleading claims
about Democrats and progressives, as well as to fundraise.
"I can't imagine the transition from
politics to Fox News is a difficult one," said Eric Burns,
President of Media Matters. "Between fundraising, smearing progressives, and
promoting conservative talking points, GOP operatives must feel right at home."
Burns added: "The evidence clearly shows
that Fox operates as a strategic political operation, not a legitimate news
In the past nine months, Fox News has transformed into a strategic
political operation. Media Matters has
documented network personalities -- on both "opinion" and "news" shows -- raising money for
Republican political action committees on air, presenting GOP talking
points as news, promoting
partisan protests, advancing
falsehoods about Obama administration officials, airing deceptively doctored
video to smear progressives, and comparing President Obama and his policies
to Adolf Hitler, socialism, or the mafia.
If that weren't enough evidence that Fox News is not a
legitimate news channel,
Media Matters documented
today the revolving door that exists between the Republican Party and Fox News.
A number of former Bush administration officials, former and potentially future
GOP presidential candidates, and Republican strategists enjoy time on Fox's
payroll and airwaves. A review of Fox coverage since September 1 reveals that
these individuals, typically hosted alone or on unbalanced panels, often use
their airtime to advance false and misleading claims about Democrats and
progressives, as well as to fundraise, further demonstrating that Fox is
effectively a conservative political organization and not a legitimate news
- Karl Rove: Ubiquitous in Bush White House, on Fox News.
Karl Rove, who served as George W. Bush's senior adviser and deputy chief of
staff throughout most of his eight-year presidency, is a ubiquitous figure on
Fox News. Since September 1, for instance, he has appeared at least 17 times --
roughly twice a week -- on prime-time programs such as Hannity and The O'Reilly Factor in his capacity as
Fox News contributor and political analyst. In all but one of those instances, he
has appeared alone opposite Fox hosts. (On the October 18 edition of Fox News Sunday, he appeared opposite
former Democratic Party chairman Terry McAuliffe.) Moreover, Rove has
repeatedly misled and misinformed during these appearances, including falsely
claiming that Kevin Jennings, a Department of Education official, had
engaged in "high-profile, in-your-face advocacy of things like NAMBLA and
gay rights and queering elementary school curricula" and advancing the dubious
claim, contradicted by the Congressional Budget Office, that the House
health care bill will lead employers to "dump" coverage.
- Dana Perino: From Bush White House podium to Fox News
desk. After serving as Bush's press secretary, Perino became a Fox News contributor and Fox Forum columnist, appearing on Fox News' prime-time programs at
least nine times since September 1, most frequently on Hannity, according to a search of the
Nexis database. Perino typically appeared with other guests: She appeared with
a Fox Business Network reporter in four instances, she appeared twice with
Democrats or liberals (Bob Beckel and Julie Menin), and she appeared once on a Fox News Sunday panel with syndicated
columnist Charles Krauthammer, as well as Mara Liasson and Juan Williams of
NPR. She appeared alone twice. During these appearances, Perino has falsely
suggested that allowing federally subsidized health plans to cover abortion
is inconsistent with current law and suggested
that the White House is doing "like dictators do" by criticizing Fox.
- John Bolton: Bush ambassador to Fox Nation.
John Bolton, formerly Bush's ambassador to the United Nations, now serves as a Fox News contributor and has appeared alone opposite Fox
prime-time hosts nine times since September 1. During his appearances, he has
advanced misinformation, such as joining Fox host and conspiracy
Glenn Beck in suggesting that the Obama administration supports a
- Mike Huckabee: Former GOP presidential candidate uses
Fox perch to fundraise for his PAC.
Former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee became host of the Fox News program Huckabee after his failed bid for the
GOP's presidential candidate in 2008 and has guest-hosted The O'Reilly Factor at least three times
during 2009, according to a Nexis search. Moreover, in his capacity as Fox
host, Huckabee has directed viewers to "go to balancecutsave.com," which redirects visitors to a Web
page soliciting donations for Huckabee's political action committee, which financially
supports Republican candidates and also pays his daughter's salary.
Additionally, Huckabee has advanced falsehoods during his Fox appearances in
2009, including falsely suggesting that Vice President Joe Biden disclaimed
responsibility for the economy and that Bush did not claim to have
"inherited" a weakening economy.
- Newt Gingrich: From House speaker to Fox contributor to
... 2012 GOP pres. candidate?Fox News political contributor Newt Gingrich, who
"joined the network in 1999, marking his first television deal since
leaving Congress" that year as Republican speaker of the House of
Representatives, repeatedly appears on Fox News prime-time programs alone
opposite Fox's conservative hosts -- while considering
a run for president in 2012. Since September 1, Gingrich has appeared as a
contributor or analyst on Fox News at least 10 times, including four
appearances on Hannity and
two appearances on The O'Reilly Factor,
according to a Nexis search. In seven instances he appeared alone, he appeared
twice with his wife, Callista Gingrich, to promote their documentary and books,
and he appeared once on a Fox News Sunday panel
with Sen. Lamar Alexander (R-TN), former DNC chair Howard Dean, and Obama
transition team head John Podesta. During these and other appearances on Fox,
Gingrich advanced baseless and outrageous claims, including wondering
if White House communications director Anita Dunn wants to subject Fox
commentators to a "Cultural Revolution" and smearing
then-Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor by claiming that she "clearly
supported racial quotas" in the Ricci
v. DeStefano case.
- John Kasich: Fox host turned Ohio GOP gubernatorial candidate.
Former Ohio Republican congressman John Kasich, who hosted the now-defunct Fox
News program Heartland with John Kasich, guest-hosted The O'Reilly Factor at least twice in
2009 prior to announcing his bid for Ohio governor on June 1. Kasich
appeared on Hannity the day
that he announced his candidacy and three times thereafter, according to a
Nexis search. Additionally, Kasich's gubernatorial website features an article
in its news section that identifies him as "Fox News' Kasich." During
his Fox News tenure, Kasich has advanced misinformation, including forwarding
Republican talking point that Democrats, for all their criticism of the
Bush administration's Iraq war policy, had no plan of their own to deal with
Iraq, terrorism, and national security in general. Media Matters has also documented
that he claimed that the Rev. Jerry Falwell, founder and chairman of the Moral
Majority Coalition, is not "some sort of extremist."
- Dick Morris uses Fox appearances to smear Obama White
House, fundraise. Fox News political analyst and Republicanstrategist
Dick Morris is a ubiquitous presence on Fox News' prime-time programs,
appearing nearly three times a week every week since September 1, according to
a Nexis search. Morris has appeared alone opposite a Fox host since the
beginning of September at least 20 times, appearances that are fairly evenly
split among The O'Reilly Factor,
Hannity, and On the Record with Greta Van Susteren.
During the 2008 election cycle, Morris repeatedly urged
viewers to donate to an anti-Obama political action committee without
disclosing that that PAC had paid a firm connected to him; in recent days, he hasrepeatedly
his appearances to fundraise for a conservative group opposed to health care
reform for which he is chief strategist. Additionally, while on Fox, Morris has
smeared Obama and his administration, claiming,
for instance, that Secretary of State Hillary Clinton may challenge Obama in
the 2012 primary and that Obama "delay[ed] the decision to commit troops
to Afghanistan ... because he wanted this [Nobel] prize."
- Frank Luntz doctors words, facts while on Fox.
GOP consultant and pollster Frank Luntz has repeatedly
appeared during Fox News' prime-time shows since September 1, interviewed alone
a total of six times on Hannity and
The O'Reilly Factor and
appearing twice on Glenn Beck
with several 9-12 Moms. During his Fox News appearances, Luntz -- who authored
an anti-reform health-care
talking points memo intended to help conservatives defeat the Democrats'
health reform initiative -- has repeatedly misinformed about health care
reform. For instance, he has falsely
suggested that reform legislation reduces physician payments and spawned
another GOP talking point, asserting that the Democrats' proposed public
insurance plan is a "government option" not a "public option,
which is what the White House calls it." Beck also hosted Luntz to instruct
his audience on the signs "the tea party people should be carrying."
Media Matters for America is a Web-based, not-for-profit, 501(c)(3) progressive research and information center dedicated to comprehensively monitoring, analyzing, and correcting conservative misinformation in the U.S. media.
"Both countries show striking parallels in their attempts to harass and intimidate into silence all actual or perceived government critics and opponents."
As Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi welcomed Egyptian President Abdel Fattah El-Sisi as the chief guest at his nation's 74th Republic Day celebrations, Amnesty International on Thursday led calls for both right-wing leaders to "address the ongoing human rights and impunity crises" in their respective countries.
Meeting ahead of events commemorating the adoption of India's constitution—including a military parade in which members of the Egyptian army marched—Modi and El-Sisi agreed to elevate bilateral ties to a "strategic partnership," while calling for a "coordinated and concerted" effort to combat "terrorism."
Modi—who said Wednesday that he and El-Sisi "are in agreement that terrorism is the biggest threat to humanity"—has, like his Egyptian counterpart, been accused of using anti-terrorism laws to crush critics and silence dissent.
"The current human rights crises in India and Egypt are characterized by entrenched impunity and misuse of counterterrorism legislation to clamp down on civic space and peaceful dissent."
"The current human rights crises in India and Egypt are characterized by entrenched impunity and misuse of counterterrorism legislation to clamp down on civic space and peaceful dissent," Philip Luther, Middle East and North Africa research and advocacy director at Amnesty International, said in a statement.
"Both countries show striking parallels in their attempts to harass and intimidate into silence all actual or perceived government critics and opponents. This unrelenting assault on human rights must end," he added.
\u201cThe Indian and Egyptian authorities must address the ongoing human rights and impunity crises in the two countries. Both show striking parallels in their unrelenting assault on rights. https://t.co/gbmoAkMnXT\u201d— Amnesty India (@Amnesty India) 1674710907
As Amnesty noted:
In recent years, authorities in both countries have severely repressed the rights to freedom of expression, association, and peaceful assembly and failed to address entrenched discrimination against religious minorities.
Human rights defenders, lawyers, political opponents, peaceful protesters, academics, and students, face arbitrary arrests and detention, unjust prosecutions, and other forms of harassment and intimidation solely for their peaceful exercise of their human rights in both India and Egypt.
"India and Egypt seem to have taken their long-standing bilateral cooperation to a different level where they share tactics to increasingly repress rights and freedoms," Amnesty International India board chief Aakar Patel said in a statement. "As the leaders of the two countries take the center stage, celebrations of the adoption of India's constitution 74 years ago should not overshadow the grim reality that the human rights situations in both countries have been on a downward spiral."
\u201c\u201cThe current human rights crises in #India & #Egypt are characterized by entrenched impunity and misuse of counterterrorism legislation to clamp down on civic space & peaceful dissent\u201d, @amnesty said today, as India hosts President Sisi as the chief guest at its Republic Day.\u201d— Nuria Tes\u00f3n (@Nuria Tes\u00f3n) 1674743767
Leading an open letter from Egyptian and Indian diaspora members published Tuesday by the Canadian alternative news site rabble.ca, Ehab Lotayef, Samaa Elibyari, and Jooneed Jeeroburkhan noted that India's constitution "guarantees full equality and rights to all Indians and declares the country a secular, socialist republic."
"However today's India is led by a Hindu ethno-nationalist party committed to converting it into a Hindu nation," the authors continued, and "the government of India has been called out by domestic and international human rights organizations for unleashing and engendering violence and detentions against Muslim, Dalit, and Christian minorities as well as any human rights defenders."
"Meanwhile, January 25 marks the start of the 17 days in 2011 which forced one of the region's longest-serving and most influential leaders, Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak, from power," they continued. "We recall that moment of incredible exhilaration as all Egyptians aspired to more democracy and social justice. Unfortunately, on July 3, 2013, then-Gen. Abdel Fattah El-Sisi staged a coup d'état that toppled President Mohamed Morsi, the first democratically elected president of Egypt, and returned the country to dictatorial rule."
\u201c"What is happening in Egypt and India should be of interest to all Canadians, even if they are not of Egyptian or Indian origin. Support for governments that violate fundamental rights diminishes democracy everywhere." https://t.co/sXAmcQlOba\u201d— Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East (@Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East) 1674656645
"Since his ascent to power through dubious elections, El-Sisi has governed Egypt with an iron fist," the trio wrote. "Under his direct command, on August 14, 2013, two encampments of protesters in Rabaa and al-Nahda squares, demanding that President Morsi be reinstated, were dismantled by lethal force and more than 1,000 people were killed."
"To date, no one has been held accountable," the authors added. "Since then, all dissenting voices have been silenced and more than 60,000 political prisoners languish behind bars in abject conditions."
"It's high time for EPA to crack down on the toxic pollution from oil refineries that's threatening both wildlife and human health," said one environmental justice advocate.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency is failing to uphold its legal obligation to regulate the nearly half-billion gallons of toxic wastewater that petroleum refineries dump into the nation's waterways on a daily basis, according to an exhaustive study published Thursday.
The Environmental Integrity Project (EIP), a watchdog founded by former EPA enforcement attorneys, analyzed publicly available records and found that in 2021 alone, the 81 refineries across the U.S. that discharge into rivers, streams, and estuaries released 1.6 billion pounds of chlorides, sulfates, and other dissolved solids harmful to aquatic life; 15.7 million pounds of algae-feeding nitrogen; 60,000 pounds of selenium, which can cause mutations in fish; and other pollutants, including cyanide; heavy metals such as arsenic, chromium, copper, lead, mercury, nickel, and zinc; and petrochemicals like benzene.
"Much of the water pollution from refineries is legal," EIP's report explains, "because EPA and the states have failed to set any limits on certain pollutants and have failed to update and modernize permit limits for other pollutants" despite the Clean Water Act's mandate that EPA does so. "But a portion of the problem is also illegal. As it turns out, EPA and state enforcement of existing permit limits for refineries is lax and rarely results in penalties for violations."
"Almost 83% of refineries (67 of 81) exceeded their permitted limits on water pollutants at least once between 2019 to 2021, according to EPA enforcement and compliance records," the report notes. "But only about a quarter of the refineries with violations (15 of the 67) were penalized during this period."
Other key findings of the report, titled Oil's Unchecked Outfalls, include:
"Oil refineries are major sources of water pollution that have largely escaped public notice and accountability in the U.S., and too many release a witches' brew of contaminants to our rivers, lakes, and estuaries," EIP executive director Eric Schaeffer said in a statement. "This is because of lax federal standards based on wastewater treatment methods that are nearly forty years old."
"The Clean Water Act requires EPA to impose more stringent standards that reflect the advanced wastewater treatment methods available today," said Schaeffer, former director of civil enforcement at EPA. "After decades of neglect, EPA needs to comply with the law and set strong effluent limits for refineries that protect public health and environment. EPA and the states also need to start enforcing the limits that exist and penalizing polluters."
EIP identified which refineries are the top dischargers of key pollutants. When it comes to selenium, the Chevron El Segundo Refinery in California and the Motiva Port Arthur Refinery in Texas are the worst offenders, each dumping more than 12 pounds per day into local waterways. The Phillips 66 Wood River Refinery in Illinois and the BP Cherry Point Refinery in Washington pour out more nickel than any other facility in the country. El Segundo is also the biggest discharger of nitrogen, at 4,351 pounds per day, followed by the PBF Delaware City Refinery’s 3,283 pounds per day. For total dissolved solids, the worst offenders are the ExxonMobil Baytown Refinery (347,345 pounds per day) and the Valero Corpus Christi Bill Greehey Refinery (291,527 pounds per day), both in Texas.
EIP also documented the worst refineries for permit violations from 2019 to 2021. The Hunt Southland Refinery in Mississippi exceeded its permitted pollution limits 144 times during that time period but faced just two Clean Water Act enforcement actions totaling $85,500. The Phillips 66 Sweeny Refinery in Texas, meanwhile, ran up 44 violations but was hit with just a single $30,000 fine.
"After decades of neglect, EPA needs to comply with the law and set strong effluent limits for refineries that protect public health and environment. EPA and the states also need to start enforcing the limits that exist and penalizing polluters."
"EPA's national discharge limits for refineries apply to just ten pollutants, including ammonia, chromium, and oil and grease," states the report. "These skeletal standards do not begin to address the variety and volume of dangerous contaminants found in the wastewater from refining processes."
For example, the report documents that refineries are "a notable source" of toxic "forever chemicals" (PFAS, or per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances), in part because they use firefighting foams that contain them. Even though PFAS have been linked to numerous adverse health impacts, EPA's newly released plan for regulating industrial discharges does not establish limits on these synthetic compounds in refinery wastewater.
"EPA's current rules for refineries are almost 40 years old, based on outdated treatment methods, and do not even apply to most of the pollutants that refineries discharge," says EIP's report. "EPA needs to waste no further time and move quickly to update these standards and impose the more stringent discharge limits the law requires."
"The states and the EPA also need to penalize permit violations more consistently so that refining companies have an economic incentive to clean up waterways," the report continues. "Currently, most violations by refineries are not penalized at all, and when they are, the amounts are paltry compared to the profitability of the industry. More stringent enforcement will provide a financial incentive for violators to update their pollution control systems and improve their operations to protect public health and the environment."
Bruze Reznick, executive director of Los Angeles Waterkeeper, lamented that "once again, the U.S. government has turned a blind eye while oil and gas companies pollute our environment, including our sensitive marine ecosystems, and disproportionately harm our frontline communities."
"We must now put the spotlight on oil refineries' essentially unregulated water pollution and demand that EPA fulfill its duty under the Clean Water Act by setting, updating, and actually enforcing discharge limits for these refineries," said Reznick.
He was echoed by Sejal Choksi-Chugh, executive director of San Francisco Baykeeper, who said that "it's high time for EPA to crack down on the toxic pollution from oil refineries that's threatening both wildlife and human health."
EIP researchers argued that "EPA's failure to require the cleanup of refinery wastewater is a part of a wider pattern."
"Most of the discharge limits in effect today for industries across the U.S. were established well before the end of the last century," the report points out. "According to the latest state water quality reports, about half of America's rivers, streams, and lakes, and a quarter of our estuaries are too polluted to support aquatic life, swimming, fishing, or to supply drinking water. The 1972 Clean Water Act promised to make all waters fishable and swimmable, but we are only halfway home to that goal more than fifty years later."
Without a "real, strong response" from the international community to Thursday's raid in the occupied West Bank, said one analyst, "Israel will continue to do what it wants without punishment."
An elderly woman was among at least nine Palestinian people killed in an early morning raid at a refugee camp in Jenin in the occupied West Bank on Thursday, in what President Mahmoud Abbas denounced as "a massacre from the Israeli occupation government, in the shadow of international silence."
The woman died of a gunshot wound in her neck, Middle East Eye (MEE) reported.
Heavily armed soldiers with the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) entered the refugee camp in a commercial truck and shot at residents who were trying to block them. The IDF also used bulldozers in the raid and targeted an area that was used as a meeting place for residents. According to Al Jazeera, "dozens of armored vehicles and snipers" were involved in the raid.
"The sounds of bullets and gunfights were intense, and clouds of smoke covered the sky," Anas Huwaisheh, a correspondent at a local channel, told MEE. "The Israeli occupation cut off the electricity, the internet, and the cell phone network during the storming. This shows that it was planned."
At least 20 people were injured as of this writing, including four who were in critical condition.
\u201cIsraeli forces shot dead nine Palestinians and wounded at least 16 others during a raid on Jenin refugee camp in the occupied West Bank. \n\nThe attack is one of the deadliest days since Israeli raids intensified at the start of last year, and has been described as a \u201cmassacre\u201d.\u201d— Middle East Eye (@Middle East Eye) 1674741232
The raid made Thursday one of the deadliest days in the occupied West Bank since the IDF intensified its attacks early last year in response to the Palestinian resistance.
At least 29 Palestinians have now been killed by Israeli forces in the occupied West Bank and East Jerusalem this month, including five children and 15 people from Jenin.
Palestinian Health Minister Mai al-Kaila accused the IDF of obstructing ambulances as emergency workers tried to take victims to a nearby public hospital and of "deliberately [firing] tear gas bombs at the hospital's children's department, choking children."
"There is an invasion that is unprecedented... in terms of how large it is and the number of injuries," Wissam Baker, the head of the public hospital, told Al Jazeera. "The ambulance driver tried to get to one of the martyrs who was on the floor, but the Israeli forces shot directly at the ambulance and prevented them from approaching him."
The IDF denied firing tear gas at the hospital deliberately but said soldiers fired the chemicals close enough to the hospital that it could have entered the children's ward.
Murad Khamayseh, a medic, told MEE that "it was almost impossible to go into the camp" to rescue victims.
"Israeli forces fired warning shots and signaled at the team to not approach the area," Khamayseh said. "As paramedics we have gotten used to this, but I honestly couldn't keep myself together after the things I have seen today."
Political analyst Aleef Sabbagh told Al Jazeera that the raid is likely "the first shot in a coming, larger Israeli operation" and warned that without a "real, strong response" to the attack and other incidents like the killing of Palestinian-American journalist Shireen Abu Akleh last year, "Israel will continue to do what it wants without punishment."
"The targeting of ambulances and hospitals, preventing aid to wounded people, the field executions—even the killing of Shireen Abu Akleh—there has been no accountability," Sabbagh said.
Abu Akleh was shot to death while covering an IDF raid in Jenin last May; multiple investigations have determined the Israelis were responsible for her killing, either intentionally or unintentionally, but Israel said in recent weeks it would not cooperate with a U.S. investigation into the matter.
Jewish Voice for Peace said Thursday that the Jenin raid was "the result of unrestrained violence by the Israeli military."
\u201cThe massacre in Jenin is the result of unrestrained violence by the Israeli military: 9 killed in one day, including 2 children. We support the calls for a national strike across all Palestine.\u201d— Jewish Voice for Peace (@Jewish Voice for Peace) 1674749525
The group also called on the U.S. to "end its complicity in Israel's brutal violence and apartheid."
"Over and over, the Biden administration has refused to take action in response to Israel's blatant war crimes against Palestinians, all while continuing to send billions of dollars to the Israeli military," said Beth Miller, the group's political director. "Next week, Secretary Blinken is visiting Israel to continue normalizing relations with its far-right extremist and violent government. Enough is enough."
A general strike was called across the West Bank on Thursday to protest the raid at the refugee camp.