

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FREE NEWSLETTER
Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.
5
#000000
#FFFFFF
To donate by check, phone, or other method, see our More Ways to Give page.


Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.

A large fracking operation becomes a new part of the horizon with Mount Meeker and Longs Peak looming in the background on December 28, 2017 in Loveland, Colorado.
"We cannot afford to put support behind the next Theranos of climate solutions," said one campaigner.
The rapidly growing gas certification industry claims to accurately measure methane pollution and verify lower emissions from fracking operations.
But according to Earthworks and Oil Change International, so-called "certified gas" programs—an emerging frontier in the effort to greenwash fossil fuel production—are "likely highly unreliable and ineffective, resulting in increased threats to health and climate."
Certified Disaster: How Project Canary & Gas Certification are Misleading Gas Markets & Governments, a report the two groups published Monday, exposes "on-the-ground failures" to detect methane pollution by Project Canary—one of the largest certifiers of fracked gas in the United States—and implores policymakers to "avoid these follies and shift their time and energy toward facilitating a safe, managed decline in the production, distribution, and use of fossil fuels."
Given that methane traps 80 times as much heat as carbon dioxide during its first 20 years in the atmosphere, emissions of the potent greenhouse gas must be slashed substantially this decade to avert the worst effects of the climate crisis. The fossil fuel industry is the leading source of global methane pollution.
"History shows us that global problems attract snake oil salesmen, trying to make money pawning off false solutions... Gas certification is unproven, unregulated nonsense."
In an attempt to justify continued fossil fuel expansion despite mounting scientific evidence of the need to urgently phase out coal, oil, and gas extraction, the industry is pushing to label fracked gas as "responsibly sourced," by which it means less polluting.
To this end, fossil fuel producers are "increasingly hiring companies like Project Canary to certify their operations as meeting a certain standard," Earthworks and Oil Change International explain. "While no standards exist for the certification process, companies are racing ahead to charge a premium for certified gas and secure contracts and expand markets for a greenwashed product."
"Project Canary's marketing aggressively positions its certification services as a conduit to a 'net-zero' emissions world," the report notes. The Colorado-based firm's CEO, Chris Romer, "has openly discussed fixing the gas industry's 'brand problem,'" admitting that "Project Canary's 'goal' is to allow the oil and gas industry to maintain 'a social license to operate' and that 'clean' certified carbon will allow the industry to operate 'for many decades to come.'"
"We are going to be able to solve climate change with measurement," Romer asserted last year. And yet, as the report points out, "Project Canary monitors consistently fail to detect pollution events."
During a seven-month field investigation (May-November 2022) of 30 different oil and gas production sites along Colorado's Front Range where Project Canary and similar monitors are installed, Earthworks' trained thermographers recorded 22 significant pollution events using Optical Gas Imaging (OGI) cameras capable of detecting emissions invisible to the naked eye.
None of the 22 OGI-documented pollution events were detected by the Continuous Emissions Monitors (CEMs) used by Project Canary and other companies.
The following video shows how Project Canary and similar monitoring technologies fail to detect methane pollution.
"How can Project Canary measure and certify methane emissions if it can't even detect them?" the video asks.
Other key findings of the report include:
"History shows us that global problems attract snake oil salesmen, trying to make money pawning off false solutions," report co-author Josh Eisenfeld, corporate accountability campaign manager at Earthworks, said in a statement. "We cannot afford to put support behind the next Theranos of climate solutions."
"Over and over again we found that the monitors Project Canary uses to certify gas were failing to detect significant pollution events in the field, the very pollution that they claim to be monitoring," said Eisenfeld. "What we found in the field is just further evidence of what we have been hearing from industry insiders: Gas certification is unproven, unregulated nonsense."
Earthworks and Oil Change International call for "federal oversight for gas certification programs that ensure the protection of communities and the accuracy of emissions reductions." In addition, they demand "greater transparency and accountability for gas certification and a verifiable commitment to transition away from methane gas to truly clean and renewable energy sources in line with climate science."
As the groups note: "The report comes just as the European Parliament considers methane regulations requiring fossil fuel imports into the E.U., such as U.S. liquefied natural gas (LNG), to meet emissions criteria. This report makes clear that current efforts by U.S. gas producers and exporters to quantify and report the emissions associated with their cargoes cannot be trusted. It is imperative that the E.U. and other importers adopt the recommendations in this report as minimum criteria for documentation of methane emissions associated with gas imports."
"It's time to end the greenwashing of gas and focus on genuine climate solutions such as energy efficiency, electrification, and renewable energy."
Last year, the U.S. became the world's top exporter of LNG, which is methane gas that has been chilled and liquefied after being extracted through fracking or conventional drilling. Ahead of last week's G7 meeting, climate justice advocates told the Biden administration, which has helped Big Oil secure dozens of long-term fracked gas export contracts amid Russia's war on Ukraine, that "the global LNG boom must be stopped in its tracks"—a demand that went ignored.
On Monday, Lorne Stockman, co-director of research at Oil Change International and co-author of the new report, warned that "certified gas is being used to greenwash U.S. gas and LNG, creating a false narrative that expanded use of methane gas plays a role in the energy transition."
"This is simply not true," said Stockman. "Our report shows that Project Canary is misleading the public and investors about the true impacts of methane gas and must be held accountable."
"It's time," he added, "to end the greenwashing of gas and focus on genuine climate solutions such as energy efficiency, electrification, and renewable energy."
This country and this world are at a monumental crossroads. US voters have an opportunity to beat back the forces of fascism and confront the billionaires who are rigging the economy, our media system, and our democracy, making it increasingly impossible for ordinary people to get by. We’re not just talking about the election. We’re talking about what must be done once these fascist elements are vanquished from power. We need a bolder set of solutions than what either major party has so far been willing to offer and a working-class movement ready to fight like hell for it. Trump didn't emerge from nowhere. The conditions that fueled MAGA authoritarianism were created by decades of radical neoliberal economic policies and a corrupt political system dominated by corporate interests. They slashed taxes on the super-rich, promising that the benefits would trickle down. They said giveaways to the corporate titans would make life more affordable for the rest of us. It was all bullshit. And when a bitter, betrayed populace searches for someone to blame, right-wing demagogues have little trouble finding scapegoats. People know when they're being lied to, but you won't hear any of this from the corporate media. Only independent journalism—powered and funded by people who believe in building a better world—can deliver truly trustworthy daily news. If you share our vision, please contribute whatever you can to sustain our work. |
The rapidly growing gas certification industry claims to accurately measure methane pollution and verify lower emissions from fracking operations.
But according to Earthworks and Oil Change International, so-called "certified gas" programs—an emerging frontier in the effort to greenwash fossil fuel production—are "likely highly unreliable and ineffective, resulting in increased threats to health and climate."
Certified Disaster: How Project Canary & Gas Certification are Misleading Gas Markets & Governments, a report the two groups published Monday, exposes "on-the-ground failures" to detect methane pollution by Project Canary—one of the largest certifiers of fracked gas in the United States—and implores policymakers to "avoid these follies and shift their time and energy toward facilitating a safe, managed decline in the production, distribution, and use of fossil fuels."
Given that methane traps 80 times as much heat as carbon dioxide during its first 20 years in the atmosphere, emissions of the potent greenhouse gas must be slashed substantially this decade to avert the worst effects of the climate crisis. The fossil fuel industry is the leading source of global methane pollution.
"History shows us that global problems attract snake oil salesmen, trying to make money pawning off false solutions... Gas certification is unproven, unregulated nonsense."
In an attempt to justify continued fossil fuel expansion despite mounting scientific evidence of the need to urgently phase out coal, oil, and gas extraction, the industry is pushing to label fracked gas as "responsibly sourced," by which it means less polluting.
To this end, fossil fuel producers are "increasingly hiring companies like Project Canary to certify their operations as meeting a certain standard," Earthworks and Oil Change International explain. "While no standards exist for the certification process, companies are racing ahead to charge a premium for certified gas and secure contracts and expand markets for a greenwashed product."
"Project Canary's marketing aggressively positions its certification services as a conduit to a 'net-zero' emissions world," the report notes. The Colorado-based firm's CEO, Chris Romer, "has openly discussed fixing the gas industry's 'brand problem,'" admitting that "Project Canary's 'goal' is to allow the oil and gas industry to maintain 'a social license to operate' and that 'clean' certified carbon will allow the industry to operate 'for many decades to come.'"
"We are going to be able to solve climate change with measurement," Romer asserted last year. And yet, as the report points out, "Project Canary monitors consistently fail to detect pollution events."
During a seven-month field investigation (May-November 2022) of 30 different oil and gas production sites along Colorado's Front Range where Project Canary and similar monitors are installed, Earthworks' trained thermographers recorded 22 significant pollution events using Optical Gas Imaging (OGI) cameras capable of detecting emissions invisible to the naked eye.
None of the 22 OGI-documented pollution events were detected by the Continuous Emissions Monitors (CEMs) used by Project Canary and other companies.
The following video shows how Project Canary and similar monitoring technologies fail to detect methane pollution.
"How can Project Canary measure and certify methane emissions if it can't even detect them?" the video asks.
Other key findings of the report include:
"History shows us that global problems attract snake oil salesmen, trying to make money pawning off false solutions," report co-author Josh Eisenfeld, corporate accountability campaign manager at Earthworks, said in a statement. "We cannot afford to put support behind the next Theranos of climate solutions."
"Over and over again we found that the monitors Project Canary uses to certify gas were failing to detect significant pollution events in the field, the very pollution that they claim to be monitoring," said Eisenfeld. "What we found in the field is just further evidence of what we have been hearing from industry insiders: Gas certification is unproven, unregulated nonsense."
Earthworks and Oil Change International call for "federal oversight for gas certification programs that ensure the protection of communities and the accuracy of emissions reductions." In addition, they demand "greater transparency and accountability for gas certification and a verifiable commitment to transition away from methane gas to truly clean and renewable energy sources in line with climate science."
As the groups note: "The report comes just as the European Parliament considers methane regulations requiring fossil fuel imports into the E.U., such as U.S. liquefied natural gas (LNG), to meet emissions criteria. This report makes clear that current efforts by U.S. gas producers and exporters to quantify and report the emissions associated with their cargoes cannot be trusted. It is imperative that the E.U. and other importers adopt the recommendations in this report as minimum criteria for documentation of methane emissions associated with gas imports."
"It's time to end the greenwashing of gas and focus on genuine climate solutions such as energy efficiency, electrification, and renewable energy."
Last year, the U.S. became the world's top exporter of LNG, which is methane gas that has been chilled and liquefied after being extracted through fracking or conventional drilling. Ahead of last week's G7 meeting, climate justice advocates told the Biden administration, which has helped Big Oil secure dozens of long-term fracked gas export contracts amid Russia's war on Ukraine, that "the global LNG boom must be stopped in its tracks"—a demand that went ignored.
On Monday, Lorne Stockman, co-director of research at Oil Change International and co-author of the new report, warned that "certified gas is being used to greenwash U.S. gas and LNG, creating a false narrative that expanded use of methane gas plays a role in the energy transition."
"This is simply not true," said Stockman. "Our report shows that Project Canary is misleading the public and investors about the true impacts of methane gas and must be held accountable."
"It's time," he added, "to end the greenwashing of gas and focus on genuine climate solutions such as energy efficiency, electrification, and renewable energy."
The rapidly growing gas certification industry claims to accurately measure methane pollution and verify lower emissions from fracking operations.
But according to Earthworks and Oil Change International, so-called "certified gas" programs—an emerging frontier in the effort to greenwash fossil fuel production—are "likely highly unreliable and ineffective, resulting in increased threats to health and climate."
Certified Disaster: How Project Canary & Gas Certification are Misleading Gas Markets & Governments, a report the two groups published Monday, exposes "on-the-ground failures" to detect methane pollution by Project Canary—one of the largest certifiers of fracked gas in the United States—and implores policymakers to "avoid these follies and shift their time and energy toward facilitating a safe, managed decline in the production, distribution, and use of fossil fuels."
Given that methane traps 80 times as much heat as carbon dioxide during its first 20 years in the atmosphere, emissions of the potent greenhouse gas must be slashed substantially this decade to avert the worst effects of the climate crisis. The fossil fuel industry is the leading source of global methane pollution.
"History shows us that global problems attract snake oil salesmen, trying to make money pawning off false solutions... Gas certification is unproven, unregulated nonsense."
In an attempt to justify continued fossil fuel expansion despite mounting scientific evidence of the need to urgently phase out coal, oil, and gas extraction, the industry is pushing to label fracked gas as "responsibly sourced," by which it means less polluting.
To this end, fossil fuel producers are "increasingly hiring companies like Project Canary to certify their operations as meeting a certain standard," Earthworks and Oil Change International explain. "While no standards exist for the certification process, companies are racing ahead to charge a premium for certified gas and secure contracts and expand markets for a greenwashed product."
"Project Canary's marketing aggressively positions its certification services as a conduit to a 'net-zero' emissions world," the report notes. The Colorado-based firm's CEO, Chris Romer, "has openly discussed fixing the gas industry's 'brand problem,'" admitting that "Project Canary's 'goal' is to allow the oil and gas industry to maintain 'a social license to operate' and that 'clean' certified carbon will allow the industry to operate 'for many decades to come.'"
"We are going to be able to solve climate change with measurement," Romer asserted last year. And yet, as the report points out, "Project Canary monitors consistently fail to detect pollution events."
During a seven-month field investigation (May-November 2022) of 30 different oil and gas production sites along Colorado's Front Range where Project Canary and similar monitors are installed, Earthworks' trained thermographers recorded 22 significant pollution events using Optical Gas Imaging (OGI) cameras capable of detecting emissions invisible to the naked eye.
None of the 22 OGI-documented pollution events were detected by the Continuous Emissions Monitors (CEMs) used by Project Canary and other companies.
The following video shows how Project Canary and similar monitoring technologies fail to detect methane pollution.
"How can Project Canary measure and certify methane emissions if it can't even detect them?" the video asks.
Other key findings of the report include:
"History shows us that global problems attract snake oil salesmen, trying to make money pawning off false solutions," report co-author Josh Eisenfeld, corporate accountability campaign manager at Earthworks, said in a statement. "We cannot afford to put support behind the next Theranos of climate solutions."
"Over and over again we found that the monitors Project Canary uses to certify gas were failing to detect significant pollution events in the field, the very pollution that they claim to be monitoring," said Eisenfeld. "What we found in the field is just further evidence of what we have been hearing from industry insiders: Gas certification is unproven, unregulated nonsense."
Earthworks and Oil Change International call for "federal oversight for gas certification programs that ensure the protection of communities and the accuracy of emissions reductions." In addition, they demand "greater transparency and accountability for gas certification and a verifiable commitment to transition away from methane gas to truly clean and renewable energy sources in line with climate science."
As the groups note: "The report comes just as the European Parliament considers methane regulations requiring fossil fuel imports into the E.U., such as U.S. liquefied natural gas (LNG), to meet emissions criteria. This report makes clear that current efforts by U.S. gas producers and exporters to quantify and report the emissions associated with their cargoes cannot be trusted. It is imperative that the E.U. and other importers adopt the recommendations in this report as minimum criteria for documentation of methane emissions associated with gas imports."
"It's time to end the greenwashing of gas and focus on genuine climate solutions such as energy efficiency, electrification, and renewable energy."
Last year, the U.S. became the world's top exporter of LNG, which is methane gas that has been chilled and liquefied after being extracted through fracking or conventional drilling. Ahead of last week's G7 meeting, climate justice advocates told the Biden administration, which has helped Big Oil secure dozens of long-term fracked gas export contracts amid Russia's war on Ukraine, that "the global LNG boom must be stopped in its tracks"—a demand that went ignored.
On Monday, Lorne Stockman, co-director of research at Oil Change International and co-author of the new report, warned that "certified gas is being used to greenwash U.S. gas and LNG, creating a false narrative that expanded use of methane gas plays a role in the energy transition."
"This is simply not true," said Stockman. "Our report shows that Project Canary is misleading the public and investors about the true impacts of methane gas and must be held accountable."
"It's time," he added, "to end the greenwashing of gas and focus on genuine climate solutions such as energy efficiency, electrification, and renewable energy."