The Justice League: A band of fictional superheroes. The Shadow Cabinet: A team of very real progressives. (Image: Warner Bros.)
Progressive 'Justice League' to Serve as Alt-Cabinet for Fact-Challenged Trump
"Please follow us," the group wrote, "unless you think our democracy is working just fine."
Dubbing itself an "online Justice League" of sorts, a progressive "Shadow Cabinet" launched Monday, filled with "citizen secretaries" tasked with debunking President Donald Trump's lies and putting forth substantive, democratic, and justice-based alternatives to his administration's right-wing agenda.
"Of course President Trump has legal legitimacy due to the Electoral College," the group wrote in a statement posted Monday morning on Twitter. "But he lacks moral legitimacy when he incessantly distorts, denounces, misdirects, cherry picks, and self-enriches in an almost Orwellian long con. Those engaging in daily disinformation deserve daily responses."
"Starting today," the statement continues, "we'll be a comprehensive, one-portal stop of 'citizen secretaries'--officials and scholars who will comment agency-by-agency not just on small 'lies' but especially on false narratives in the service of political ends."
A press statement identified the following "secretaries":
- Laurence Tribe, "Attorney General"--Constitutional law professor at Harvard Law School;
- Marielena Hincapie, "Immigration and Naturalization Services/Immigration and Customs Enforcement/Immigration"--Executive director, National Immigration Law Center;
- DeRay McKesson, "Justice Issues"--Civil rights activist and Black Lives Matter member;
- Robert Reich, "Labor/Commerce"--Former Labor Secretary and best-selling author;
- Laura Tyson, "Treasury/Trade"--American economist and former chair of the U.S. President's Council of Economic Advisers during the Clinton Administration; professor at Berkeley's Hass Business School;
- David Cay Johnston, "IRS"--Pulitzer prize-winning journalist and author; founder of the new DCReport;
- Diane Ravitch, "Education"--New York University professor and author/editor of 24 books on education;
- Joan Claybrook, "Transportation"--Ex-head of National Highway Traffic Safety Administration;
- Robert Weissman, "Consumer Agencies"--President of watchdog group Public Citizen;
- S. David Freeman, "Energy & EPA"--Ex-head of Tennessee Valley Authority under President Jimmy Carter and senior advisor to Friends of the Earth;
- David Himmelstein and Steffie Woolhandler, "Health and Human Services"--co-founders Physicians for National Health Program and distinguished professors at CUNY/Hunter's Shchool of Public Health;
- Colin Kahl, "National Security/Terrorism"--Former Vice President Joe Biden's National Security advisor;
- Rosa Brooks, "State Department"--Former Department of Defense counselor and State Department advisor; Foreign Policy columnist;
- Andrew Bacevich, "Defense Department"--Author and historian; Boston University Pardee School Global Affairs professor.
The group lists former New York City public advocate Mark Green as its "chief of staff," and Axios reports that it was Green who assembled the cabinet "in six weeks of frantic phoning, emailing, and fundraising."
Several of the secretaries tweeted about the effort upon its launch:
\u201cFollow @ShadowingTrump for excellent, no-holds-barred debunking of what Trump's Cabinet says, does, and doesn't do! https://t.co/DP7CrDYpl9\u201d— Laurence Tribe (@Laurence Tribe) 1488211653
\u201cCheck out the team at @ShadowingTrump. I have always wanted to be a cabinet secretary! Please follow @ShadowingTrump.\u201d— Rosa Brooks (@Rosa Brooks) 1488207131
And the group itself is tweeting as @ShadowingTrump. "Please follow us," the group wrote, "unless you think our democracy is working just fine."
An Urgent Message From Our Co-Founder
Dear Common Dreams reader, The U.S. is on a fast track to authoritarianism like nothing I've ever seen. Meanwhile, corporate news outlets are utterly capitulating to Trump, twisting their coverage to avoid drawing his ire while lining up to stuff cash in his pockets. That's why I believe that Common Dreams is doing the best and most consequential reporting that we've ever done. Our small but mighty team is a progressive reporting powerhouse, covering the news every day that the corporate media never will. Our mission has always been simple: To inform. To inspire. And to ignite change for the common good. Now here's the key piece that I want all our readers to understand: None of this would be possible without your financial support. That's not just some fundraising cliche. It's the absolute and literal truth. We don't accept corporate advertising and never will. We don't have a paywall because we don't think people should be blocked from critical news based on their ability to pay. Everything we do is funded by the donations of readers like you. Will you donate now to help power the nonprofit, independent reporting of Common Dreams? Thank you for being a vital member of our community. Together, we can keep independent journalism alive when it’s needed most. - Craig Brown, Co-founder |
Dubbing itself an "online Justice League" of sorts, a progressive "Shadow Cabinet" launched Monday, filled with "citizen secretaries" tasked with debunking President Donald Trump's lies and putting forth substantive, democratic, and justice-based alternatives to his administration's right-wing agenda.
"Of course President Trump has legal legitimacy due to the Electoral College," the group wrote in a statement posted Monday morning on Twitter. "But he lacks moral legitimacy when he incessantly distorts, denounces, misdirects, cherry picks, and self-enriches in an almost Orwellian long con. Those engaging in daily disinformation deserve daily responses."
"Starting today," the statement continues, "we'll be a comprehensive, one-portal stop of 'citizen secretaries'--officials and scholars who will comment agency-by-agency not just on small 'lies' but especially on false narratives in the service of political ends."
A press statement identified the following "secretaries":
- Laurence Tribe, "Attorney General"--Constitutional law professor at Harvard Law School;
- Marielena Hincapie, "Immigration and Naturalization Services/Immigration and Customs Enforcement/Immigration"--Executive director, National Immigration Law Center;
- DeRay McKesson, "Justice Issues"--Civil rights activist and Black Lives Matter member;
- Robert Reich, "Labor/Commerce"--Former Labor Secretary and best-selling author;
- Laura Tyson, "Treasury/Trade"--American economist and former chair of the U.S. President's Council of Economic Advisers during the Clinton Administration; professor at Berkeley's Hass Business School;
- David Cay Johnston, "IRS"--Pulitzer prize-winning journalist and author; founder of the new DCReport;
- Diane Ravitch, "Education"--New York University professor and author/editor of 24 books on education;
- Joan Claybrook, "Transportation"--Ex-head of National Highway Traffic Safety Administration;
- Robert Weissman, "Consumer Agencies"--President of watchdog group Public Citizen;
- S. David Freeman, "Energy & EPA"--Ex-head of Tennessee Valley Authority under President Jimmy Carter and senior advisor to Friends of the Earth;
- David Himmelstein and Steffie Woolhandler, "Health and Human Services"--co-founders Physicians for National Health Program and distinguished professors at CUNY/Hunter's Shchool of Public Health;
- Colin Kahl, "National Security/Terrorism"--Former Vice President Joe Biden's National Security advisor;
- Rosa Brooks, "State Department"--Former Department of Defense counselor and State Department advisor; Foreign Policy columnist;
- Andrew Bacevich, "Defense Department"--Author and historian; Boston University Pardee School Global Affairs professor.
The group lists former New York City public advocate Mark Green as its "chief of staff," and Axios reports that it was Green who assembled the cabinet "in six weeks of frantic phoning, emailing, and fundraising."
Several of the secretaries tweeted about the effort upon its launch:
\u201cFollow @ShadowingTrump for excellent, no-holds-barred debunking of what Trump's Cabinet says, does, and doesn't do! https://t.co/DP7CrDYpl9\u201d— Laurence Tribe (@Laurence Tribe) 1488211653
\u201cCheck out the team at @ShadowingTrump. I have always wanted to be a cabinet secretary! Please follow @ShadowingTrump.\u201d— Rosa Brooks (@Rosa Brooks) 1488207131
And the group itself is tweeting as @ShadowingTrump. "Please follow us," the group wrote, "unless you think our democracy is working just fine."
Dubbing itself an "online Justice League" of sorts, a progressive "Shadow Cabinet" launched Monday, filled with "citizen secretaries" tasked with debunking President Donald Trump's lies and putting forth substantive, democratic, and justice-based alternatives to his administration's right-wing agenda.
"Of course President Trump has legal legitimacy due to the Electoral College," the group wrote in a statement posted Monday morning on Twitter. "But he lacks moral legitimacy when he incessantly distorts, denounces, misdirects, cherry picks, and self-enriches in an almost Orwellian long con. Those engaging in daily disinformation deserve daily responses."
"Starting today," the statement continues, "we'll be a comprehensive, one-portal stop of 'citizen secretaries'--officials and scholars who will comment agency-by-agency not just on small 'lies' but especially on false narratives in the service of political ends."
A press statement identified the following "secretaries":
- Laurence Tribe, "Attorney General"--Constitutional law professor at Harvard Law School;
- Marielena Hincapie, "Immigration and Naturalization Services/Immigration and Customs Enforcement/Immigration"--Executive director, National Immigration Law Center;
- DeRay McKesson, "Justice Issues"--Civil rights activist and Black Lives Matter member;
- Robert Reich, "Labor/Commerce"--Former Labor Secretary and best-selling author;
- Laura Tyson, "Treasury/Trade"--American economist and former chair of the U.S. President's Council of Economic Advisers during the Clinton Administration; professor at Berkeley's Hass Business School;
- David Cay Johnston, "IRS"--Pulitzer prize-winning journalist and author; founder of the new DCReport;
- Diane Ravitch, "Education"--New York University professor and author/editor of 24 books on education;
- Joan Claybrook, "Transportation"--Ex-head of National Highway Traffic Safety Administration;
- Robert Weissman, "Consumer Agencies"--President of watchdog group Public Citizen;
- S. David Freeman, "Energy & EPA"--Ex-head of Tennessee Valley Authority under President Jimmy Carter and senior advisor to Friends of the Earth;
- David Himmelstein and Steffie Woolhandler, "Health and Human Services"--co-founders Physicians for National Health Program and distinguished professors at CUNY/Hunter's Shchool of Public Health;
- Colin Kahl, "National Security/Terrorism"--Former Vice President Joe Biden's National Security advisor;
- Rosa Brooks, "State Department"--Former Department of Defense counselor and State Department advisor; Foreign Policy columnist;
- Andrew Bacevich, "Defense Department"--Author and historian; Boston University Pardee School Global Affairs professor.
The group lists former New York City public advocate Mark Green as its "chief of staff," and Axios reports that it was Green who assembled the cabinet "in six weeks of frantic phoning, emailing, and fundraising."
Several of the secretaries tweeted about the effort upon its launch:
\u201cFollow @ShadowingTrump for excellent, no-holds-barred debunking of what Trump's Cabinet says, does, and doesn't do! https://t.co/DP7CrDYpl9\u201d— Laurence Tribe (@Laurence Tribe) 1488211653
\u201cCheck out the team at @ShadowingTrump. I have always wanted to be a cabinet secretary! Please follow @ShadowingTrump.\u201d— Rosa Brooks (@Rosa Brooks) 1488207131
And the group itself is tweeting as @ShadowingTrump. "Please follow us," the group wrote, "unless you think our democracy is working just fine."