Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

Much of the reporting on California's proposed plan for single-payer infers an outrageous price for universal healthcare, but doesn’t adequately mention the savings from scrapping the current for profit insurance system. (Photo: National Nurses United/flickr/cc)

Opponents of Single Payer Think You're Stupid... But Nothing Is Dumber Than a For-Profit Healthcare System

Pat LaMarche

Lack of critical thinking: it’s killing us. And if you get alarmed by the headline of a May 22, Sacramento Bee article, it will continue killing us.

One of the few reasonable opinions President Trump expressed recently – in the face of stark ridicule – is that healthcare reform shouldn’t be that difficult. “Nobody knew” He quipped.

I like boiling the healthcare discussion down to very few words – four in fact – live longer, pay less. When looked at with those four words in mind, the answer changes.

Nobody knew? Well some folks do.

Just look at whom lives longer and pays less. Why the Canadians, the Brits, the French, the Dutch, the Japanese, the Swiss, the Danes, the Italians, the South Koreans, the Israelis… They knew.

I could go on and on, but I don’t need to. ‘Cause if you’re still reading this and you favor our system of paying more and dying sooner – well forgive me – but perhaps you’re just too stupid to live.

And if the U.S. Healthcare system only caused the untimely and early demise of stupid people – like Paul Ryan – who prefer a profit drenched system, then it might be ok. But you and I pay for Speaker Ryan to have some of the best health insurance in the country, so no, it’s not working out that way.

Back to the article in the Sacramento Bee – and I’m not blaming the reporter because her editor likely wrote the headline, which reads, “The price tag on universal health care is in, and it’s bigger than California’s budget,” and while technically true, it’s still less then the price tag on our current system. And in the case of California’s newly proposed Universal Healthcare plan, everyone is covered.

“The price tag on universal health care is in, and it’s bigger than California’s budget,” is like saying, the price of a family’s new car is in and it’s more than the grocery budget. It’s just erroneous math compounded with irrelevance.

See using their comparison, the newspaper infers an outrageous price for universal healthcare, but doesn’t adequately mention the savings from scrapping the current for profit insurance system. When you read the article written by Angela Hart, you see that she did look into savings. She even accounted for $100 to $150 billion that employers pay in right now. Her article is far more scholarly than the scare-tactic headline implies. But she says the accounting still falls $50 billion short overall. That’s because there’s no mention of out-of-pocket cash payments (or those foisted onto overburdened credit cards) that also go to pay for our current for-profit system.

So let's do this differently.

Right now, Hart’s article says that the cost of California’s proposed single payer system would be $400 billion. But using statistical information released in 2016, the U.S. spends – on average - $10,345 per person for healthcare – and that’s counting the people who don’t even get it. California has – as of 2015 – 39.14 million people. The total cost for the current system is $404.903 billion. That’s nearly $5 billion more that Californians pay to – you guessed it – die sooner.

$5 billion that could be better spent teaching headline writers logic and math.


Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
Pat LaMarche

Pat LaMarche

Pat LaMarche is an author, activist and advocate. She is the author of "Left Out In America: The State of Homelessness in the United States" (Updated, 2020). Her novel, "The Magic Diary" (2019) is now available.

We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.

Dems Threaten to Subpoena FTI Consulting Over 'Blanket Refusal' to Provide Info on Fossil Fuel Work

"FTI's refusal to cooperate with this congressional inquiry shows that they have something to hide, which will reveal the dangerous ways agencies like theirs have promoted fossil fuel greenwash and misinformation," said the Clean Creatives campaign's leader.

Jessica Corbett ·


US Judge Says Mar-a-Lago Affidavit 'Can Be Unsealed' With Redactions

"This is going to be a considered, careful process, where everybody's rights, the government's and the media's, will be protected," declared U.S. Magistrate Judge Bruce Reinhart.

Jessica Corbett ·


Federal Judge Orders Starbucks to Rehire Fired Union Organizers in Memphis

"It was a ruling in favor of what's right," said one member of the Memphis Seven. "We knew from day one that we were going to win this, it just took time."

Brett Wilkins ·


Activists Arrested While Protesting 'Dirty Pipeline Deal' Outside Schumer's Office

"Sen. Schumer is sacrificing frontline communities and our clean energy future, all to placate a coal baron," said one organizer, referring to the majority leader's side agreement with Sen. Joe Manchin.

Kenny Stancil ·


Ex-CFO Allen Weisselberg Pleads Guilty to 15 Felonies, Set to Testify Against Trump Organization

The former executive will serve only five months on Rikers Island if he testifies in the upcoming criminal trial of the business.

Jessica Corbett ·

Common Dreams Logo