Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

For Immediate Release

Contact

Press Release

Supreme Court's Commandments Lawsuit Should Have Been Litigated on Church-State Grounds, Says Americans United

Church-State Watchdog Group Urges Justices to Require Government Neutrality Toward Religion
WASHINGTON -

A Ten Commandments lawsuit to be heard this week by the U.S. Supreme
Court inappropriately focuses on free-speech rights rather than
church-state separation, says Americans United for Separation of Church
& State.

The justices will hear oral arguments Wednesday in Pleasant Grove City v. Summum. 

The case tests whether Pleasant Grove City, Utah, can accept a
Commandments monument for permanent display in a local park while
turning down a monument showing the tenets of another faith. The Summum
religion sued the local government after its display was rejected.

The 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Summum had a
free-speech right to display its monument next to the Commandments
monument.

Normally when the government discriminates against one faith while
preferring another, a lawsuit would be filed charging a violation of
church-state separation. In this situation, due to roadblocks in
pre-existing 10th Circuit law, attorneys for Summum made their argument
based on First Amendment free-speech principles, not Establishment
Clause grounds.

Americans United is sympathetic to Summum's plight, but is concerned
that Summum's free-speech argument could weaken church-state separation
legal doctrine.

The watchdog group filed an amicus brief
in support of neither Pleasant Grove City nor Summum and requests the
Supreme Court to reverse the lower court's decision. That way, Summum
can re-litigate this case under the framework of church-state
separation.

"Our Constitution requires the government to remain religiously
neutral," said the Rev. Barry W. Lynn, Americans United executive
director. "Government officials should never favor one faith over
others.

"Pleasant Grove City should never have approved the Commandments
display in the first place," said Lynn. "If the city had said no as it
should have done, we wouldn't be facing this mess at the Supreme Court."

Lynn, however, urged the justices to approach the case with great caution.

"If the Supreme Court lets Summum's free-speech argument stand," he
said, "it could open the door for government to use private speakers to
spread a particular religious belief.

"It would also mean if the government allows any group to erect a
permanent monument on its land, it must allow all proposed monuments to
be erected with no restrictions," he continued. "This could lead to
groups putting up permanent monuments promoting hateful messages on
public land throughout the country.

"Summum should have the chance to re-argue this case under the
correct legal doctrine of church-state separation," Lynn concluded.
"Let's hope the Supreme Court comes to the right conclusion here."

###

Americans United is a religious liberty watchdog group based in Washington, D.C. Founded in 1947, the organization educates Americans about the importance of church-state separation in safeguarding religious freedom.

'All He Has to Do Is Sign': Group Crafts Executive Order for Biden to Cancel All Student Loan Debt

"With the stroke of a pen, Biden could grant tens of millions of Americans a semblance of financial freedom."

Jake Johnson, staff writer ·


Rich Nations' Vaccine Pledge Includes Just 613 Million New Doses—Well Short of Promised 1 Billion

"A single factory could produce this number in a year if you waived patents."

Jake Johnson, staff writer ·


Ocasio-Cortez Says 'Elephant in the Room' Is Senate Democrats Blocking Their Own Party's Agenda

"The argument that we need to make here," the New York Democrat said of bipartisanship's dead end, "is that it's worth going it alone if we can do more for working people in this country."

Jon Queally, staff writer ·


On Climate and Covid-19 Emergencies, G7 Judged a 'Colossal Failure' for All the World to See

"Never in the history of the G7 has there been a bigger gap between their actions and the needs of the world. In the face of these challenges the G7 have chosen to cook the books on vaccines and continue to cook the planet."

Jon Queally, staff writer ·


NYC Mayoral Candidate Eric Adams Rebuked for 'Dangerous' 400-Students-to-1-Teacher Theory

"Defunding schools to the point that we have a 400:1 student-to-teacher ratio so we can bankroll another huge expansion in an already-multibillion dollar police budget," said Rep. Ocasio-Cortez, "is how you build a school-to-prison pipeline."

Jon Queally, staff writer ·