Rev. Dr. William Barber, president of Repairers of the Breach, speaks during a rally in Washington, D.C., on June 12, 2019. (Photo: Nicholas Kamm//AFP via Getty Images)
May 10, 2022
Rev. Dr. William Barber on Tuesday slammed the North Carolina Supreme Court for declining to hear his appeal of a conviction stemming from a May 2017 protest at the state Legislative Building in support of Medicaid expansion.
"In essence, we were arrested because someone said our message bothered them."
During a press conference about the high court's recent decision, Barber--a leader at Repairers of the Breach and the Poor People's Campaign--laid out how the case relates to free speech and the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.
"Even though the highest court won't hear us," he said, "we must continue to ask... 'Who determines whether the authorities are 'disturbed,' and that protestors are too loud, and that protestors have to cease their protest in a public building?'"
Detailing his encounter with police five years ago, Barber recalled that at the protest, for which he led call-and-response chants, "I asked the officers this question: 'How loud can we be? And we'll do that.'"
"The basic answer was, 'Somebody says it's disturbing them,'" Barber continued. "The Constitution says freedom of speech and the press are two of the great bulwarks of liberty and therefore shall never be restrained."
"The officers that day said they did not know how loud free speech could be, so we asked the court to decide," he explained. "In essence, we were arrested because someone said our message bothered them. The answer to the question of what was allowable was never answered. None of the work of the General Assembly suffered that day, but the rights of the people did."
\u201cWATCH NOW: Rev. Dr. Barber II, North Carolina Poor People\u2019s Campaign Address Importance of the Court Protecting Democracy and Freedom https://t.co/fOUz7L4a7i\u201d— Rev. Dr. William J. Barber II (@Rev. Dr. William J. Barber II) 1652206024
The North Carolina Supreme Court's decision last week follows a state Court of Appeals ruling from December which concluded that "the First Amendment is not implicated in the conduct" for which Barber was charged and "this is not a case about free speech--it is a case about loud speech."
Barber, the court said, "was not expelled from the General Assembly for the content of his words. He was removed for their volume."
The appellate court also determined that even if Barber's First Amendment rights were implicated, "his rights were not violated as a matter of law," adding that the building's rules--which state that visitors "may not disturb or act in a manner that will imminently disturb the General Assembly"--are "reasonable 'time, place, and manner' restrictions."
"If I'm charged and convicted with using my preaching voice to demand Medicaid expansion for thousands of poor and low-wage workers... it is an honor to stand and be named even in the courts of having done so."
In his speech Tuesday, Barber pointed out that half a decade after the protest in question, North Carolina's elected officials have still refused to expand Medicaid.
"If I'm charged and convicted with using my preaching voice to demand Medicaid expansion for thousands of poor and low-wage workers--regardless of their color, their sexuality, their gender--while Republican legislators block it, or if I'm charged and convicted for standing with others... speaking out with the poor and low-wage people and demanding a minimum living wage of $15 an hour, it is an honor to stand and be named even in the courts of having done so," said Barber, who was convicted of second-degree trespass.
"I will always, with others, fight for the right to stand for voting rights, to stand for immigrant rights, to stand for healthcare rights, to stand for living wages rights, to stand for LGBTQ rights, to stand for women's rights, to stand for equal protection under the law," Barber vowed, "and I'll even fight for the free speech of my opponents."
"The Bible actually tells us raise my voice with others like a trumpet--not like a harmonica, like a trumpet; not quiet, not whispering, but like a trumpet," he bellowed. "And if it means I'm charged and eventually have to even spend time in prison, it's a small price to pay. I cannot remain silent, I will not remain silent, while God's children suffer for no reason other than the poor choices of elected officials that hurt, destroy, and even cause the demise of poor and low-wealth people."
Barber and others are planning the Mass Poor People's & Low-Wage Workers' Assembly and Moral March on Washington and to the Polls for June 18, 2022. According to organizers, the event "will be a generationally transformative and disruptive gathering of poor and low-wealth people, state leaders, faith communities, moral allies, unions, and partnering organizations."
Join Us: News for people demanding a better world
Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place. We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference. Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. |
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
Rev. Dr. William Barber on Tuesday slammed the North Carolina Supreme Court for declining to hear his appeal of a conviction stemming from a May 2017 protest at the state Legislative Building in support of Medicaid expansion.
"In essence, we were arrested because someone said our message bothered them."
During a press conference about the high court's recent decision, Barber--a leader at Repairers of the Breach and the Poor People's Campaign--laid out how the case relates to free speech and the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.
"Even though the highest court won't hear us," he said, "we must continue to ask... 'Who determines whether the authorities are 'disturbed,' and that protestors are too loud, and that protestors have to cease their protest in a public building?'"
Detailing his encounter with police five years ago, Barber recalled that at the protest, for which he led call-and-response chants, "I asked the officers this question: 'How loud can we be? And we'll do that.'"
"The basic answer was, 'Somebody says it's disturbing them,'" Barber continued. "The Constitution says freedom of speech and the press are two of the great bulwarks of liberty and therefore shall never be restrained."
"The officers that day said they did not know how loud free speech could be, so we asked the court to decide," he explained. "In essence, we were arrested because someone said our message bothered them. The answer to the question of what was allowable was never answered. None of the work of the General Assembly suffered that day, but the rights of the people did."
\u201cWATCH NOW: Rev. Dr. Barber II, North Carolina Poor People\u2019s Campaign Address Importance of the Court Protecting Democracy and Freedom https://t.co/fOUz7L4a7i\u201d— Rev. Dr. William J. Barber II (@Rev. Dr. William J. Barber II) 1652206024
The North Carolina Supreme Court's decision last week follows a state Court of Appeals ruling from December which concluded that "the First Amendment is not implicated in the conduct" for which Barber was charged and "this is not a case about free speech--it is a case about loud speech."
Barber, the court said, "was not expelled from the General Assembly for the content of his words. He was removed for their volume."
The appellate court also determined that even if Barber's First Amendment rights were implicated, "his rights were not violated as a matter of law," adding that the building's rules--which state that visitors "may not disturb or act in a manner that will imminently disturb the General Assembly"--are "reasonable 'time, place, and manner' restrictions."
"If I'm charged and convicted with using my preaching voice to demand Medicaid expansion for thousands of poor and low-wage workers... it is an honor to stand and be named even in the courts of having done so."
In his speech Tuesday, Barber pointed out that half a decade after the protest in question, North Carolina's elected officials have still refused to expand Medicaid.
"If I'm charged and convicted with using my preaching voice to demand Medicaid expansion for thousands of poor and low-wage workers--regardless of their color, their sexuality, their gender--while Republican legislators block it, or if I'm charged and convicted for standing with others... speaking out with the poor and low-wage people and demanding a minimum living wage of $15 an hour, it is an honor to stand and be named even in the courts of having done so," said Barber, who was convicted of second-degree trespass.
"I will always, with others, fight for the right to stand for voting rights, to stand for immigrant rights, to stand for healthcare rights, to stand for living wages rights, to stand for LGBTQ rights, to stand for women's rights, to stand for equal protection under the law," Barber vowed, "and I'll even fight for the free speech of my opponents."
"The Bible actually tells us raise my voice with others like a trumpet--not like a harmonica, like a trumpet; not quiet, not whispering, but like a trumpet," he bellowed. "And if it means I'm charged and eventually have to even spend time in prison, it's a small price to pay. I cannot remain silent, I will not remain silent, while God's children suffer for no reason other than the poor choices of elected officials that hurt, destroy, and even cause the demise of poor and low-wealth people."
Barber and others are planning the Mass Poor People's & Low-Wage Workers' Assembly and Moral March on Washington and to the Polls for June 18, 2022. According to organizers, the event "will be a generationally transformative and disruptive gathering of poor and low-wealth people, state leaders, faith communities, moral allies, unions, and partnering organizations."
Rev. Dr. William Barber on Tuesday slammed the North Carolina Supreme Court for declining to hear his appeal of a conviction stemming from a May 2017 protest at the state Legislative Building in support of Medicaid expansion.
"In essence, we were arrested because someone said our message bothered them."
During a press conference about the high court's recent decision, Barber--a leader at Repairers of the Breach and the Poor People's Campaign--laid out how the case relates to free speech and the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.
"Even though the highest court won't hear us," he said, "we must continue to ask... 'Who determines whether the authorities are 'disturbed,' and that protestors are too loud, and that protestors have to cease their protest in a public building?'"
Detailing his encounter with police five years ago, Barber recalled that at the protest, for which he led call-and-response chants, "I asked the officers this question: 'How loud can we be? And we'll do that.'"
"The basic answer was, 'Somebody says it's disturbing them,'" Barber continued. "The Constitution says freedom of speech and the press are two of the great bulwarks of liberty and therefore shall never be restrained."
"The officers that day said they did not know how loud free speech could be, so we asked the court to decide," he explained. "In essence, we were arrested because someone said our message bothered them. The answer to the question of what was allowable was never answered. None of the work of the General Assembly suffered that day, but the rights of the people did."
\u201cWATCH NOW: Rev. Dr. Barber II, North Carolina Poor People\u2019s Campaign Address Importance of the Court Protecting Democracy and Freedom https://t.co/fOUz7L4a7i\u201d— Rev. Dr. William J. Barber II (@Rev. Dr. William J. Barber II) 1652206024
The North Carolina Supreme Court's decision last week follows a state Court of Appeals ruling from December which concluded that "the First Amendment is not implicated in the conduct" for which Barber was charged and "this is not a case about free speech--it is a case about loud speech."
Barber, the court said, "was not expelled from the General Assembly for the content of his words. He was removed for their volume."
The appellate court also determined that even if Barber's First Amendment rights were implicated, "his rights were not violated as a matter of law," adding that the building's rules--which state that visitors "may not disturb or act in a manner that will imminently disturb the General Assembly"--are "reasonable 'time, place, and manner' restrictions."
"If I'm charged and convicted with using my preaching voice to demand Medicaid expansion for thousands of poor and low-wage workers... it is an honor to stand and be named even in the courts of having done so."
In his speech Tuesday, Barber pointed out that half a decade after the protest in question, North Carolina's elected officials have still refused to expand Medicaid.
"If I'm charged and convicted with using my preaching voice to demand Medicaid expansion for thousands of poor and low-wage workers--regardless of their color, their sexuality, their gender--while Republican legislators block it, or if I'm charged and convicted for standing with others... speaking out with the poor and low-wage people and demanding a minimum living wage of $15 an hour, it is an honor to stand and be named even in the courts of having done so," said Barber, who was convicted of second-degree trespass.
"I will always, with others, fight for the right to stand for voting rights, to stand for immigrant rights, to stand for healthcare rights, to stand for living wages rights, to stand for LGBTQ rights, to stand for women's rights, to stand for equal protection under the law," Barber vowed, "and I'll even fight for the free speech of my opponents."
"The Bible actually tells us raise my voice with others like a trumpet--not like a harmonica, like a trumpet; not quiet, not whispering, but like a trumpet," he bellowed. "And if it means I'm charged and eventually have to even spend time in prison, it's a small price to pay. I cannot remain silent, I will not remain silent, while God's children suffer for no reason other than the poor choices of elected officials that hurt, destroy, and even cause the demise of poor and low-wealth people."
Barber and others are planning the Mass Poor People's & Low-Wage Workers' Assembly and Moral March on Washington and to the Polls for June 18, 2022. According to organizers, the event "will be a generationally transformative and disruptive gathering of poor and low-wealth people, state leaders, faith communities, moral allies, unions, and partnering organizations."
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.