
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FREE NEWSLETTER
Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.
5
#000000
#FFFFFF
To donate by check, phone, or other method, see our More Ways to Give page.

Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.
"Schumer’s alignment with Republicans... in voting to advance this terrible pro-polluter, pro-data center permitting bill is all the reason needed to demand that Schumer step down as leader."
An environmental advocate is calling for Sen. Chuck Schumer to step down as Senate Democratic leader after he supported a permitting reform bill that critics say will empower polluters by weakening environmental regulations.
Schumer (D-NY), the Senate minority leader, was one of 14 Democrats who voted Wednesday to advance the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA), which cleared a procedural vote 65-31.
The bill would speed up the permitting process for energy and infrastructure projects by limiting environmental reviews and restricting the ability to challenge permitting decisions in court.
Democratic supporters of the bill celebrate it as a way to speed up the approval of clean energy infrastructure and drive down energy costs, pointing to projections that it will result in modest emissions reductions. But environmental groups warn the bill will also clear the way for much faster approval of fossil fuel infrastructure and artificial intelligence data centers, exposing communities on the front lines to the harms of industrial pollution.
Jim Walsh, the policy director at Food & Water Watch, said, "Sen. Schumer’s alignment with Republicans over a majority of his own Democratic caucus in voting to advance this terrible pro-polluter, pro-data center permitting bill is all the reason needed to demand that Schumer step down as leader of the Senate Democrats."
“Sadly, Schumer has failed to learn the primary lesson from last week’s midterm elections—that Americans are fed up with unchecked aggression from Big Tech and the out-of-control construction of AI data centers,” Walsh said. In virtually every local election in which data centers were on the ballot, voters opted to reject them in their communities.
“Time and again throughout this Congress, Schumer has supported the status quo. But the American people are loudly demanding real change," Walsh added. "Schumer must step down from party leadership for good."
Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.), who is challenging Schumer in the race for Senate majority leader, voted against the bill on Wednesday.
Like many Democrats who supported the legislation, Schumer framed his vote as a response to Americans’ concerns about high energy costs, an issue that helped fuel historic wins for the party nationwide.
“Americans are paying too much for energy, and we need to do something about it," Schumer said in a statement earlier this month. "For too long, our broken permitting system has held back cleaner, cheaper energy; driven up costs; and delayed good-paying jobs."
Erik Schlenker-Goodrich, executive director of the Western Environmental Law Center, has pushed back against this framing.
"This bill is being deceptively pushed as an ‘affordability’ bill when those benefits are at best meager, speculative, and won’t be felt for more than a decade while the harms to the people and places we love will start the moment this abomination of a bill is signed into law," he said.
According to an analysis by the Rhodium Group published earlier this month, BAAJA would reduce annual household electricity bills by just $41 to $66 by 2035, equivalent to about $3.42 to $5.50 per month.
Columbia University's Center on Global Energy Policy has projected that electricity costs may actually increase for Americans in the short term because construction costs could be passed along to consumers before savings are realized.
Meanwhile, many of the environmental effects from increased fossil fuel use and data center construction, such as water and air pollution, could be felt much sooner. Public health groups, including the American Public Health Association, have warned that BAAJA could increase rates of asthma, cardiovascular disease, certain cancers, and premature births by increasing exposure to polluting infrastructure.
"BAAJA may give us savings of a mere $15 a month in 15 years, while exponentially increasing asthma and cancer-causing pollution in our neighborhoods," said Mar Zepeda Salazar, legislative director at Climate Justice Alliance. "This is the ‘affordability win’ we are supposed to be grateful for?"
Though it appears on track to pass in the Senate, the bill has yet to get through the House of Representatives, where House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY), who is expected to become speaker in January, has raised some objections to its provisions on environmental protections and tribal sovereignty. If Congress doesn’t pass the bill before the new Congress begins in January, its backers would have to start over under Democratic majorities.
"The House has an opportunity now to acknowledge the clear will of the American people and rein in Big Tech’s data center attack," Walsh said. "It must start by rejecting this terrible pro-polluter, anti-environment permitting bill, and in so doing, demonstrate what political courage and common sense look like.”
"These shared lands should not be sacrificed to an unprecedented wave of industrial development without a national conversation about whether that development belongs there in the first place."
As the Trump administration and members of Congress on both sides of the aisle push to speed up data center development—against the wishes of the vast majority of Americans, according to recent polling—a coalition of more than 100 conservation and advocacy groups urged two top administration officials on Wednesday to impose an immediate moratorium on the facilities on public lands, arguing that "fundamental threshold issues" must be resolved before such development.
According to US Bureau of Land Management (BLM) records, at least 17 data center campuses and 13 related infrastructure projects—including transmission lines and access roads—have been proposed across more than 24,000 acres of federal land in Arizona, Idaho, Nevada, Oregon, Utah, and Wyoming.
Those projects have been proposed without determining "whether this new industrial use is legally authorized on public lands and, even if it is, whether large-scale data centers are an appropriate use of America’s public lands," wrote the coalition of 115 groups to Interior Secretary Doug Burgum and Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins on Wednesday.
"There is no comprehensive federal policy addressing these questions, no meaningful public process examining the consequences of this new use, and no adequate framework for addressing enormous demands on water and energy, impacts to wildlife and cultural resources, or effects on tribal nations and nearby communities," added the groups, including Defenders of Wildlife, the Sierra Club, Montana Conservation Voters, and Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility (PEER).
The letter follows recent reporting by ProPublica that showed Burgum has up to $64 million invested in artificial intelligence companies, many of which are pushing for the expansion of data centers to power their technology, while hundreds of President Donald Trump's political appointees also have significant financial ties to the industry.
More than 320 officials appointed by Trump have ties to Google parent company Alphabet, which plans to spend nearly $200 billion this year on the data center build-out. More than 240 of them have investments or other financial ties to Meta Platforms, which is also developing data centers.
“The Trump administration is treating America’s public lands like a line item in their own investment portfolio, and conflicted Data Center Doug Burgum, who has tens of millions invested in the speculative AI data center build-out, is leading the charge," said Jayson O'Neill, a spokesperson for Save Our Parks. "This administration and Burgum will continue to use their power to give away our public lands to AI data center developers unless Congress steps in to block it.”
The coalition called a moratorium on data centers on public lands "the minimum responsible step."
"It would give tribal nations, communities, lawmakers, and the public an opportunity to understand what is being proposed and to weigh in on whether commercial data centers are compatible with public land laws, purposes, and values. It would also allow for full examination of environmental impacts, cumulative demands on water and energy, and the consequences of transforming shared public lands into industrial sites."
Public support for data centers has plummeted amid reporting on their massive consumption of energy and water and their contributions to climate pollution.
Last week, the Interior Department released a five-year plan that includes potentially selling off public lands—a proposal, O'Neill told ProPublica on Tuesday, to "sell off what’s left to AI data center developers and [Burgum's] extractive resource buddies.”
According to More Than Just Parks, projects already proposed for public lands include:
A dozen Democrats in Congress are pushing to limit or ban data centers on or near public lands, according to reporting by ProPublica on Tuesday, with some citing the reports on Trump administration officials' ties to the AI industry.
Rep. Rashida Tlaib (D-Mich.) told the outlet she would "continue building the coalition" for the No AI Data Centers on Federal Lands Act, which she introduced in July in the Republican-controlled Congress. Democrats are set to take control of the US House of Representatives and the Senate in January.
“The American people expect public lands to be managed for the benefit of everyone, not a handful of corporations," said Jose Witt, Nevada state director for the Wilderness Society. "These are the places we hike, hunt, and connect with the natural world, yet the administration is poised to dramatically reshape how public lands are used to benefit big tech and the data center industry. The recent election made clear that Americans want a check on data center development, and we urge the administration and Congress to pause data center construction on public lands so we can fully assess the impacts and give the public a real say.”
The coalition wrote to Burgum and Rollins two days after 21 members of the Democratic caucus in the Senate voted to end debate on the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, which would speed up the federal permitting process for data centers and fossil fuel projects. Advocates have warned that the bill's changes to federal law would open up public lands for the facilities.
"America’s public lands belong to all of us," reads the Wednesday letter. "They provide places to hunt, fish, hike, camp, and connect with nature; protect clean water, wildlife habitat, cultural resources, and landscapes important to tribal nations; and preserve opportunities and experiences that cannot simply be recreated once they are lost. These shared lands should not be sacrificed to an unprecedented wave of industrial development without a national conversation about whether that development belongs there in the first place."
Large companies have rolled back efforts to protect the public as the federal government has "largely abandoned chemical safety as a priority," the report notes.
This year's Retailer Report Card, released on Wednesday by the research and advocacy group Toxic-Free Future, notes that consumers today are especially reliant on the corporate accountability efforts of large companies when it comes to staying safe from toxic materials in products they buy, as the Trump administration has "largely abandoned chemical safety as a priority."
Unfortunately for millions of families who shop and eat at major stores and restaurants like Walmart, Trader Joe's, and McDonald's, the report finds that nearly half of the companies included in the analysis are backsliding in efforts to remove toxic chemicals and plastics from their products and packaging.
Twenty-two of the 45 retailers saw their scores decline by at least two percentage points, as TFF rated them on whether they have a corporate safer chemicals policy, their transparency regarding ingredients, their bans on toxic chemicals and plastics, and whether they offer products that are Safer Choice Certified by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).
Walmart and Whole Foods saw the greatest declines in their grades, with both plummeting by at least 20 percentage points and earning "C" grades.
Whole Foods, which is owned by Amazon, has a list of banned or restricted substances—and widely publicizes its restricted components and ingredients on its shopping bags—but did not report progress on its goal of reducing its chemical footprint by 30% by 2025, in time for the Retailer Report Card's release. It also has not supported governmental policies to eliminate or reduce chemicals or plastics of high concern.
Walmart previously led the way in calculating and reporting its chemical footprint, said TFF, "but this year, while it released data about the percentage reduction of its chemical footprint for formulated products, it offered reduced transparency about the gross amount of toxic chemicals in these products."
“After a decade of growing retailer action, this backsliding should be a wake-up call,” said Cheri Peele, a co-author of the report and director of government and market policy at TFF. "Protecting people’s health must remain a priority.”
While significant backsliding was evident at companies like Whole Foods, Walmart, and retailers that dropped by 10 or more percentage points, including Amazon, Dick's Sporting Goods, and Walgreens, Peele emphasized that "companies know how to make products safer, and this year’s leaders show that progress is possible."
Apple, IKEA, Target, and Sephora, which all received "A" or "A-" grades, were credited with adopting comprehensive safer chemicals policies that apply to their products, manufacturing, private-label, and brand-name items.
IKEA also had the distinction of being one of the most improved retailers, jumping 11 percentage points. The furniture and home goods store "has made significant progress over many years in restricting chemicals and plastics of high concern including formaldehyde, PVC [polyvinyl chloride], PFAS [per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances], BPA [bisphenol A], and expanded polystyrene in a number of products."
In 2025, the company also introduced a total ban on PFAS—which are also called "forever chemicals" and have been linked to multiple cancers, reproductive harms, and other health problems—in all of its large materials. The policy came a year before President Donald Trump's EPA proposed rolling back limits on PFAS in drinking water.
Dollar Tree was the most improved store, increasing its score by 16 points after strengthening its reporting requirements, expanding its restricted substance list, and requiring private-label suppliers to use safer alternatives to restricted chemicals.
“Families shouldn’t have to choose between what they can afford and their health,” said José Bravo, national coordinator of the Campaign for Healthier Solutions. “It’s encouraging to see Dollar Tree restrict more harmful chemicals and require more transparency and accountability from suppliers at a time when other retailers are backsliding. Dollar stores tend to operate in communities that are overburdened by pollution and other stressors on health. Even small improvements to dollar store chemical policies make a real difference.”
The report's "Hall of Shame," including 16 retailers that earned failing grades, was rife with companies that have failed to "take any steps toward reducing toxic chemicals." Ahold Delhaize—which owns major grocery chains including Hannaford, Food Lion, and Stop & Shop—Publix, Alberstons, and Trader Joe's were among the stores in the Hall of Shame.
While 22 retailers (44%) reported progress by phasing out PFAS in food packaging and textiles, bisphenols in receipt paper, and/or PVC in packaging, this was "a considerable reduction from 34 retailers (68%) reporting similar progress in 2024."
The report also found "insufficient" progress in ingredient transparency, with 21 companies (42%) failing to ask their suppliers for the chemical content of their products.
"This is an improvement from 2024, when 54% did not ask suppliers for chemical content," reads the report, while adding: "Retailers can’t manage chemicals they do not know are in their products."
The report notes that governmental policies have been shown to improve retailers' safety protocols.
"Before Washington state’s ban on toxic bisphenols in receipts took effect in January 2026, several retailers including Best Buy, Costco, CVS Health, REI, Target, TJX, Walgreens, Whole Foods Market, and others had already begun eliminating toxic bisphenols from receipts nationwide, demonstrating that safer alternatives were possible," reads the report. "Washington state’s ban was followed by California passing a similar law in September 2026, showing how retailer action and strong state policies can build on each other to drive safer practices across the marketplace."
Sarah Doll, national director of the environmental health alliance Safer States, said that "strong state policies that put health first, together with retailer action, help drive safer products across the marketplace."
“Families deserve the same protections wherever they shop," said Doll. "Retailers should build on this progress, not move backward.”
"It has never been clearer that agrochemical corporations have too much influence in government, and that unchecked pesticide use has created an urgent public health crisis."
The Take Down Pesticides coalition announced on Monday is calling for a global "agricultural shift away from petroleum-derived pesticides and towards proven organic and agroecological alternatives," with a particular focus on paraquat, a weedkiller "already banned in over 70 countries and linked to Parkinson's disease, thyroid cancer, and neurological harm to children."
The coalition—which includes Alianza Nacional de Campesinas, Coming Clean, Pesticide Action & Agroecology Network (PAN), and dozens of other organizations—wants policymakers worldwide to crack down on pesticides, but its first public statement highlights actions under US President Donald Trump, who has repeatedly betrayed his campaign promise to "Make America Healthy Again."
"This year, the Supreme Court sided with multibillion-dollar pesticide companies over people who have been harmed by their products," the groups said. "The Environmental Protection Agency continues to greenlight pesticides linked to cancer, Parkinson's disease, birth defects, and neurological harm to children. The US president has attempted to intervene in markets and boost the production of a pesticide linked to cancer, at the bidding of the company who makes it. And Congress has slashed food assistance for needy families, while incentivizing even more pesticide use."
"It has never been clearer that agrochemical corporations have too much influence in government, and that unchecked pesticide use has created an urgent public health crisis," the coalition continued, highlighting the heightened risks for farmers and farmworkers as well as public demand for outlawing dangerous pesticides. "States are starting to take back power, and protect their own residents from pesticides. More than 13 states have introduced legislation to ban or restrict paraquat, a toxic weedkiller that has shortened too many lives. One of those states, Vermont, became the first to ban it."
While recognizing that "banning one pesticide is not enough to protect the health of the farmworkers, farmers, and rural communities regularly exposed to multiple pesticides," the coalition explained that "ending paraquat use is an opportunity for farmers to get off the pesticide treadmill, and adopt organic and agroecological practices, instead of reaching for a replacement herbicide. Banning paraquat would send a powerful signal that agriculture cannot continue as usual."
PAN organizing lead Cristobal Lagunas said that "through our work, we meet people and hear stories of farmers and farmworkers who have been harmed by pesticides. People who sprayed pesticides for years and later developed cancer, Parkinson's, or other chronic conditions, people who were exposed while pregnant and whose children suffered developmental and neurological harm, and people who live near farms and experienced pesticide drift and are now afraid of what the future holds."
"Unfortunately these are not rare exceptions; these are regular occurrences in a system designed to take advantage of our most vulnerable communities," Lagunas stressed. "Our food system has let science, regulation, and compassion fall behind corporate profit. It’s time to foster a food system built on justice, transparency, and resiliency."
Hormis Bedolla, initiative coordinator for pesticides and environmental justice at Alianza Nacional de Campesinas, declared: "Pesticides are not combating insects and pests... They are poisoning and killing us. The idea of creating perfect fruit is not worth our health nor our lives."
Launched during the latest United Nations Climate Change Conference, the coalition also highlighted that "virtually all synthetic pesticides are derived from fossil fuels, and are manufactured in polluting facilities that harm community health. Fossil fuel-based pesticides contribute to the climate crisis—and should not be falsely marketed as a sustainability tool. Pesticides strip the soil of nutrients, reduce biological diversity, and inhibit soils from sequestering carbon."
The groups argued that "organic and agroecological practices of controlling weeds and other pests can be scaled up and widely adopted, if we have the political will to invest in them. We call on the public to continue to demand affordable food free from pesticides. We call on state lawmakers to prohibit paraquat and other toxic pesticides."
With Democrats set to take control of the US Senate and House of Representatives in January, after decisive wins against Trump's party in the midterms, "we call on members of Congress to resist agrochemical lobbying, reject campaign contributions from pesticide companies, and prioritize people’s health over corporate profits," the coalition continued.
"We call on state and local policymakers to prohibit the use of synthetic pesticides on lands that they manage," it added. "And we call on farmers to stand up to agrochemical companies, and demand federal, state, and local support for adopting organic and agroecological growing practices. Together, we can take down pesticides."
Other coalition members include Friends of the Earth US, Earthjustice, and the Center for Food Safety—whose legislative and policy coordinator, Reagan Ferris, noted that the group has long "championed the rights of farmworkers, consumers, endangered species, and the planet by challenging government policies permitting the overuse of toxic pesticides."
"Pesticides are a poisonous false promise that harm people, contaminate our food, and irreparably pollute the water, soil, and air," Ferris said. "A new agriculture for the 21st century is not only possible, but essential, to ensure a regenerative, healthful food system."
"We are going backwards toward the goal of controlling CO2 emissions," said the author of a new study accounting for the electricity use and emissions of over 400 US data centers.
Just over 400 artificial intelligence data centers emitted as much climate pollution as Denmark does in a year, according to Harvard research published in Nature Sustainability on Monday.
The study found that a total of 403 hyperscale data centers released 28.3 million tons of carbon dioxide between May 2024 and April 2025, up to triple earlier estimates. And that number is likely to increase further as the rapid build-out continues.
"We are going backwards toward the goal of controlling CO2 emissions," Francesca Dominici, the study's senior author and Clarence James Gamble professor of biostatistics, population, and data science and director of the Harvard Data Science Initiative, told The Associated Press.
"What we're seeing is already striking, but it's only a snapshot of a rapidly expanding industry."
The researchers also looked at the overall electricity use of the data centers and found it was between 68 and 99 terawatt-hours, with higher estimates rivaling the annual electricity use of Michigan. All told, the centers accounted for 1.8% of US electricity consumption.
“We’re talking about just 403 facilities consuming approximately 82 terawatt-hours of electricity in a single year—approaching the annual electricity consumption of an entire mid-sized American state, including its homes, businesses, and industries,” lead author Gianluca Guidi, a postdoctoral fellow in the Harvard Department of Biostatistics, told Gizmodo.
The numbers, while high, are "nowhere near" the true greenhouse gas emissions of the industry, as Emily Atkin noted in Heated. The study did not count every data center active during the study period, did not look at the contribution of off-grid power plants like those used by Elon Musk's controversial Colossus data center in Memphis, and did not consider the climate pollution of refrigerants used to cool the centers.
The researchers also acknowledge that the build-out has only increased since the study period ended.
"What we're seeing is already striking, but it's only a snapshot of a rapidly expanding industry," Guidi said in a statement. "The data center boom hasn't slowed down since our study period ended in April 2025. New facilities have been built, existing campuses have expanded, and demand for AI computing continues to grow. That means the electricity use and carbon footprint we're reporting could already be substantially larger now in 2026."
This makes their findings all the more urgent for policymakers to consider.
“We already have over a thousand hyperscale facilities operating and another 2,000 planned,” Guidi told Gizmodo. “So, the data starts to raise a red flag about where we’re going, and whether we’re building these AI data centers in the most responsible way we can.”
The authors are also concerned about the impact of the data centers' fossil fuel use on public health. The researchers found that 54% of the data centers they studied were powered by fossil fuels, with 38% of them powered by gas and 15% by coal, but they were not able to dive into what that means for US residents' health and well-being.
"Quantifying health impacts is an important next step," Dominici said in a statement. "First, carbon dioxide drives climate change, which affects health through heatwaves, wildfire smoke, flooding, and other pathways."
Dominic continued:
Second, the fossil fuel power plants in the regional electricity systems associated with this demand also release other pollutants, such as fine particulate matter, nitrogen oxides, and sulfur dioxide, that are directly linked to heart and lung disease and premature death. So when data centers draw heavily on fossil fuel power, the people living near and downwind of those power plants may bear health costs, even if they're far from the data center itself.
The study authors also noted a lack of transparency and reliable information about data centers.
"Perhaps what surprised me most throughout the research was how little independently verified information is publicly available about infrastructure that’s already consuming electricity on this scale," Guidi told Gizmodo.
Atkin noted that the lack of transparency had made the researchers' task more difficult, and provided an opening for the new democratically controlled Congress to take action in January:
It’s supremely messed up that scientists have to work this hard just to get a partial picture of how much an immensely powerful, fast-growing industry is heating the planet we all have to live on—especially when voters just made it clear they want the industry reined in.
The public deserves to know exactly how many of these facilities exist, and how much they are polluting, so they can decide whether it’s worth trading the planet’s health for toothbrushes that tell us if we’re doing it right.
Come January, Democrats can show voters they were listening by making tech companies publish the data scientists actually need to figure out how many hyperscale data centers are running and how much they pollute. My bet is that once scientists get the full numbers, we’ll need a bigger country than Denmark for the comparison.
The research comes amid a nationwide backlash against the proliferation of AI data centers, with voters approving 43 of 44 anti-data center measures on the ballot in the midterm elections.
It also builds on growing evidence that the data center build-out is a worrying new contribution to the climate crisis. A Sierra Club analysis warned that the use of fossil fuels to power data centers could increase power sector emissions by 42% by 2030. Another study concluded that artificial intelligence is boosting climate emissions in another way: by helping facilitate the extraction and production of fossil fuels.
"With each passing day we’re learning more and more about the enormous greenhouse gas emissions and climate warming impacts that the AI data center industry is dumping on our planet," Seth Gladstone, the director of media and public relations for Food & Water Watch, told Common Dreams. "This comes on top of the skyrocketing electric bills and water security threats this industry brings wherever it lands. Now more than ever, we need Congress to act and pass a national moratorium on all new hyperscale data center construction, before it’s too late to halt Big Tech’s assault on our communities."
Update: This piece has been updated to include a quote from Seth Gladstone of Food & Water Watch.
The document was released after a week of negotiations that Greenpeace’s delegate to the climate summit described as “heavy on rhetoric but painfully short on ambition.”
Climate advocates are frustrated as the second week of the 31st United Nations Climate Change Conference begins in Antalya, Türkiye.
They argue that a draft proposal released Monday by the Turkish and Australian presidencies overseeing COP31 is short on concrete commitments for world leaders to phase out fossil fuels as global temperatures rise.
Monday's draft calls for "accelerated action to phase out fossil fuels, including through the immediate transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems," acknowledging a roadmap promised at last year's COP30 in Belém, Brazil. But it provides few specific details, said Andreas Sieber, head of political strategy for the international climate advocacy group 350.org.
"Türkiye and Australia seem to want to keep the transition away from fossil fuels in the diplomatic waiting room but drop any reference to the work going forward in the current draft text," Sieber said Monday. "Countries have repeatedly called on them to take the roadmaps forward, yet the presidencies have barely lifted a finger."
The draft follows a first week that Jasper Inventor, Greenpeace’s delegate at COP31, described as “heavy on rhetoric but painfully short on ambition.”
"We are seeing familiar dynamics play out," Inventor said. "Governments are largely repeating entrenched positions rather than finding ways to bridge their differences. Discussions are getting bogged down in procedural disputes and disagreements over what should even be on the negotiating table, instead of focusing on the urgent decisions needed to confront the climate crisis."
In a news release Monday, 350.org criticized the draft for continuing to promote “distractions” such as carbon removal technology. While the draft sets an ambitious goal for 35% of energy consumption to come from electricity by 2035, it lacks any requirement for that power to come from renewable sources.
350.org also said the draft’s proposal to provide at least $120 billion annually by 2035 to help developing nations—which have contributed disproportionately little to the climate crisis—adapt to worsening extreme weather events and repair climate damage they’ve already sustained falls far short of what is needed.
The proposal builds on a commitment made at last year’s COP30 summit in Belém to at least triple adaptation finance by 2035. Still, adjusted for inflation, that amount would be less than a third of what the United Nations Environment Program estimates developing countries will need annually.
“Across Africa, people are dying from drought and drowning from floods. Communities badly need the resources to adapt to the reality of a crisis they did little to cause," said Rukiya Khamis, 350.org's East Africa program manager. "But with debt and stretched public budgets, African governments can’t provide this on their own. Climate finance isn’t an extra at these talks: It’s the condition for everything else.”
According to an analysis published last week by Carbon Brief, public funding pledged to help developing countries fight the climate crisis has fallen by more than 70% in 2026, with President Donald Trump withdrawing the US from international climate efforts and wealthy European nations such as France and Germany slashing their aid budgets.
The negotiations also come amid a global energy crisis fueled by the US-Israeli war with Iran, which climate advocates have said underscores the need to transition away from volatile fossil fuel markets.
While consumers have been saddled with higher costs, oil companies in the US have raked in over $130 billion in profits between April and September 2026—nearly three times what they earned during that period last year, according to a New York Times investigation published in October.
"We have an unprecedented opportunity to secure an outcome at COP31 that can help us hold rich countries accountable to their legal obligations to provide climate finance," said Laurie van der Burg, public finance lead at Oil Change International. "Rich countries keep gaslighting us, saying we should trust them to put the money on the table, but meanwhile they cut their climate finance as they increase their military spending."
"By ending fossil fuel subsidies, making polluters pay, and changing unfair financial rules, rich countries can mobilize trillions, and both meet the needs of their own people and their climate finance obligations," she added. "This way, they can fund a just transition away from fossil fuels toward a more secure and affordable energy future. The money is there. What we need is political will.”
The Climate Action Network said a final draft should aim to deliver $120 billion in adaptation funds well before the 2035 deadline and include long-term funding commitments. It called for this support to come through grants rather than loans that can drive impoverished countries deeper into debt. It also said accountability mechanisms must be put in place to require wealthy nations to fulfill their promises.
"We came to Antalya to turn promises into protection for people. Halfway through, governments are gutting those promises instead," said Tasneem Essop, executive director of Climate Action Network International. "Workers facing the end of their industries are being offered a website to share their experiences. Families losing their homes to floods and droughts are being offered another workshop. And the countries hit hardest by a crisis they did not cause are being offered declarations instead of the finance they are owed."
“Australia asked to lead these negotiations, yet it is fighting the very commitment vulnerable countries need most: at least tripling adaptation finance," she added. "You cannot claim to lead a COP while working against the people it exists to protect."
The conference is set to close on Friday, leaving four more days for negotiators to turn broad ambitions into a substantive agreement.
"After the biggest fossil fuel crisis in history," Sieber said, "we cannot afford false solutions."
"Climate justice isn’t something to be talked about in closed rooms," said one Kenya-based group. "It’s people in the street saying: We are not asking for permission to be heard."
Thousands of people rallied in rainy Antalya, Türkiye on Saturday for the People's Climate March, lamenting the inadequate action of world leaders gathered in the city for the United Nations Climate Change Conference and calling for a just and rapid transition to the post-fossil fuel era.
Organizers said that more than 10,000 people took part in the demonstration, which brought together environmentalists, trade unionists, Indigenous campaigners, feminists, LGBTQ+ rights defenders, antiwar activists, and others from around the world.
The demonstration was part of a global day of action for climate justice, and was the opening event of the alternative People's Climate Summit, which runs through November 18.
"While world leaders meet behind closed doors at COP31, people are coming together on the streets to demand the real change our communities need," a spokesperson for the summit said ahead of the march.
"We cannot tackle the climate crisis while allowing fossil fuel corporations to keep expanding, communities to be exploited, and public money to flow into war and destruction," the spokesperson continued. "We need a just transition that puts people before profit, makes rich polluters pay, and protects the planet for future generations. Our message is simple: climate justice now."
Kirtana Chandrasekaran of summit participant Friends of the Earth International said Saturday:
“The Peoples’ Climate Summit and march have come at a critical time for climate justice. In a context of worsening climate impacts, wars, and genocide, our communities, especially in the Global South, are being pushed to the frontlines of the crisis. We’re coming together to build solidarity and advance real, community-based solutions. We’re demanding that these solutions be reflected at COP31 and that the big polluters blocking them and promoting false solutions be kicked out.”
Turkish activists took advantage of the international spotlight to draw attention to environmental destruction in their country, including expanding coal mines, deforestation, industrial pollution, and other threats.
“The government talks about protecting ecology at COP31, but they don’t protect anything but bad projects," Eser Öncel of the group Northern Forests Defense told The Irish Times.
Local protestors leading the climate march through the centre of Antalya at COP31
[image or embed]
— Leo Hickman (@leohickman.carbonbrief.org) November 14, 2026 at 3:25 AM
Ayşe Özdemir of the progressive People's Democratic Party—which has been targeted by the government of Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan through court action—said world leaders gathered at COP31 "are discussing their own interests."
“They are talking about the situation in the Middle East and they are thinking about how much land they can take, how [many] guns they can sell each other,” she said. “That’s what they are discussing in the backrooms, so we don’t think it helps our climate; it will help the capitalists.”
Çiğdem Özbaş, a Turkish organizer of the summit, told Socialist Worker that people from the Global South were increasingly disillusioned with world leaders' inaction—especially those from the wealthier nations most responsible for the planetary emergency.
"They know they can’t win inside the UN meetings," she said of Global South activists. "So they need to organize outside [COP31] on an international level."
Özbaş also criticized climate financing agreements offered to developing countries.
"When they promise something, they don’t give it," she said. "Or they give it out, but they expect interest payments on their loans."
"That money should be public money rather than private companies exploiting the climate crisis," Özbaş added.
International solidarity was also on display at the People's Climate March. Friends of the Earth International argued that governments and corporations driving climate breakdown were also enabling Israel's genocidal war on Gaza.
“Corporations are not neutral actors. They are actively profiting from the destruction of Palestinian lives, land, and livelihoods," said Abeer Butmeh, coordinator of the Palestinian Environmental NGOs Network (PENGON)-Friends of the Earth Palestine.
"Those supplying weapons, financing the occupation, and enabling the systematic destruction of Palestinian land and livelihoods are not bystanders," Butmeh continued. "They are complicit in a system built on exploitation, violence, and impunity."
"There can be no climate justice while corporate profits are built on occupation, dispossession, and genocide," she added. "There can be no climate justice without holding these corporations accountable and ending their complicity."
Nairobi-based Power Shift Africa, which describes itself as a "pan-African climate and energy think- and do-tank," said on social media that "Antalya’s streets had a message for COP31 today. They didn’t whisper it. They marched it, chanted it, and carried it on banners."
"The demands were clear: Pay what is owed," the group continued. "Climate finance that arrives in grants, not just promises. Reparations for the harm already done. A just, fair transition away from fossil fuels. Real support for communities adapting to the climate impacts they are already living with."
"Give communities a seat at the table, because decisions about their future shouldn’t be made without them," Power Shift Africa added. "Because climate justice isn’t something to be talked about in closed rooms. It’s people in the street saying: We are not asking for permission to be heard."
“You can’t put out a fire while handing the matches to the arsonists. And you certainly can’t expect the arsonists to write the evacuation plan.”
A coalition of environmental organizations is warning that the COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Türkiye is in danger of being co-opted by big polluters.
An analysis released on Friday by the Kick Big Polluters Out (KBPO) coalition finds that more than 100 polluting corporations and trade associations—including from fossil fuel, Big Tech, and industrial agriculture—have sent delegations to COP31.
Among the largest delegations, the report says, are International Emissions Trading Association (IETA), which sent 29 delegates; BNP Paribas, which sent 22; HSBC, which sent 19; and Amazon, which sent 12.
The analysis also shows that banks "collectively representing more than $2.2 trillion in fossil fuel financing from 2021-2025" have a presence at COP31.
The KBPO report notes that these industries and associations "have demonstrated track records of being notably misaligned with or obstructing climate policy... indicating they can be a threat to the strong climate action COP31 must urgently deliver."
These polluters' delegations are so big that they vastly outnumber delegations sent by many nations that are most endangered by the climate emergency, including Niger, the Philippines, and Nepal.
Maikel Peuki, director of the Papua chapter of the Indonesian Forum for Living Environment (WALHI) and a KBPO partner, said allowing big polluters to have a seat at the COP31 table would have dire consequences for his country's environment.
“In Papua our forests and coastal areas are being targeted for fossil fuel and food estate projects and carbon-offsetting schemes by major corporate emitters,” said Maikel Peuki. “This is not a genuine solution to the climate crisis. Those who cause pollution should be the ones to pay for the damage they have created.”
Peuki's remarks were echoed by Lien Vandamme, senior campaigner for the Center for International Environmental Law's Climate and energy program.
"You can’t put out a fire while handing the matches to the arsonists," said Vandamme. "And you certainly can’t expect the arsonists to write the evacuation plan. It’s therefore no surprise that the UN climate talks continue to fail in delivering the climate action that is needed. It’s time to show Big Polluters the door and fundamentally change the rules that keep rolling out the red carpet for them."
Prakash Dalal, director of Friends of the Earth Nepal, accused big polluters of causing "loss of livelihood, emotional damage, trauma, and survival challenges" for people in his country, adding that "we cannot tolerate the disproportionate space given to them compared to civil society and our country delegations."
"We need to kick these big polluters out!" Dalal emphasizes. "This should be a moral and legal obligation for the COP."
The presence of polluters also drew the ire of climate activist Greta Thunberg, according to a Thursday report in Latin Times.
While protesting outside COP31, Thunberg decried the negotiations for being "filled with lobbyists" who are "paid by the very destructive industries" profiting from continued fossil fuel dependence.
Thunberg also accused governments attending COP31 of using the event to "whitewash themselves" without taking real action.
Deadlier flood disasters "are the foreseeable consequences of a fossil-fueled economy in which those who pollute most are also the best protected from its consequences," said one campaigner.
An analysis released Thursday by anti-poverty group Oxfam juxtaposed the soaring number of flood-related deaths worldwide with the ultrawealthy's ability to insulate themselves from the climate disasters that are growing more common and devastating as oil and gas emissions continue.
The group found that as monthly temperature records were shattered in more than 100 countries this year, flood deaths reached a 13-year high—driven largely by catastrophic flooding in Nepal and Tibet in August, when a glacier collapse sent a "wall of water more than 100 meters high, traveling at 180 kilometers per hour," which swept through a valley and killed more than 1,500 people, with 5,600 still missing.
The flooding disaster, which the chief of the United Nations Office for Project Services said last month should be a "defining moment" for an international community grappling with how to mitigate the impacts of the climate emergency, accounted for about three-quarters of the 8,000 people who died in floods this year.
"Deaths from flooding are seven times higher in more unequal countries," noted Oxfam, while people in the Global South are far less likely to have contributed meaningfully to the carbon pollution that scientists say is heating the planet, putting the 1.5°C limit set by the Paris Agreement in 2015 out of reach, and causing the loss of glaciers and more extreme weather disasters.
"The carbon pollution of a person in the richest 1% has contributed 34 times more to today's extreme heatwaves than the average person, and 100 times more than someone in the poorest 50%," said Oxfam.
In September, the UN found that with countries contributing far too little to efforts to reduce carbon emissions, the planet is now expected to overshoot the 1.5°C threshold, and said policymakers must now focus on ensuring the overshoot is temporary.
But on Thursday, as world leaders gathered in Antalya, Türkiye for the United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP31), a report warned that the Earth could in fact be heading for an "irrevocable" breach of the 1.5°C limit.
"The carbon pollution of a person in the richest 1% has contributed 34 time more to today's extreme heatwaves than the average person, and 100 times more than someone in the poorest 50%."
The record number of flooding deaths this year, said Amitabh Behar, executive director of Oxfam International, "are not accidents of weather. They are the foreseeable consequences of a fossil-fueled economy in which those who pollute most are also the best protected from its consequences."
Oxfam also emphasized that while flooding deaths are soaring, one trend at COP31 demonstrated how the ultrarich are making devastating disasters in communities around the world more likely.
The group analyzed data from Polluterjet, finding that 87 private jets landed at Antalya Airport since November 7, just before COP31 began, emitting an estimated 777 tons of carbon dioxide.
"Nigerian billionaire Aliko Dangote’s private jet flew approximately 4,370 kilometers from Lagos to Antalya, emitting an estimated 30 tons of carbon, roughly as much as the average person emits in six years," said Oxfam. "During COP30 last year, 66 private jet journeys were recorded."
According to the Global Solidarity Levies Task Force, taxing private jets owned by about 250,000 people around the world could raise $45 billion per year, "nearly 12 times the amount rich countries gave to UN climate funds in 2025."
“While families mourn loved ones killed by floods and endure blistering heat, the ultrawealthy carry on flying in private jets, high above the devastating consequences,” said Behar. “Governments must stop treating the extraordinarily polluting luxuries of the superrich as an untouchable privilege. Taxing private jets is an obvious first step.”
“Fossil Free Zones are where the transition away from fossil fuels stops being a promise and starts happening on the ground.”
More than 40 advocacy groups on Thursday issued a declaration calling on the world's governments to establish permanent "Fossil Free Zones” to protect the climate, critical ecosystems, and Indigenous peoples and their lands from oil, gas, and coal exploration and extraction.
Unveiled at the United Nations Climate Change Conference—also known as COP31—in Antalya, Türkiye, the Fossil Free Zones Declaration urges governments to make the zones a central component of each nation's plans to transition away from oil, coal, and gas.
What is a Fossil Free Zone? As Cecilia Requena, a Bolivian senator and environmentalist, and Juan Pablo Osornio, the engagement and policy director at the nonprofit green group Earth Insight, explained:
A Fossil Free Zone is a defined area demarcated by its ecological, biodiversity, or cultural significance, where exploration, extraction, and development of fossil fuels are permanently prohibited. Think tropical rainforests, key biodiversity areas, Indigenous peoples’ territories, and critical marine ecosystems. They translate the abstract global commitment to transitioning away from fossil fuels into something tangible: a map, a boundary, a legal safeguard.
"Amid deep geopolitical fragmentation and weakening international cooperation, continued dependence on fossil fuels is further exacerbating existing vulnerabilities," the Fossil Free Zones Declarations states.
"Beyond its climate impacts, this dependence exposes countries and communities to volatile energy markets, supply disruptions, and economic instability, while undermining energy security and national sovereignty," the document continues. "Continued coal, oil, and gas extraction also causes unnecessary and avoidable harm to people and nature, including driving deforestation and biodiversity loss."
"Fossil fuel expansion continues to threaten ecosystems essential for biodiversity, climate stability, and the cultures and livelihoods of the peoples who protect them," the declaration adds. "Halting this expansion in critical territories such as forests or coral reefs is therefore an immediate, concrete step toward a just, orderly, and equitable transition, alongside plans to phase out existing fossil fuel production within key ecosystems."
The declaration—whose signatories include WWF International, Amazon Watch, the Science Panel for the Amazon, and Parliamentarians for a Fossil Free Future—calls for halting new fossil fuel exploration and expansion while prioritizing the responsible closure of existing projects in areas of climatic, ecological, and cultural importance.
“Fossil Free Zones are where the transition away from fossil fuels stops being a promise and starts happening on the ground," said Earth Insight senior associate for diplomacy Ignacio Arróniz Velasco. "When governments permanently close critical ecosystems and Indigenous territories to oil, gas, and coal extraction, they protect ecosystems, uphold the rights of the peoples who steward nature, and take a concrete first step towards a full, fair phaseout."
"This can be done with existing tools like nature protection laws or land tenure recognition," he stressed. "This is what implementation looks like. COP31 gives governments a real chance to work together on Fossil Free Zones and build them into their national roadmaps, so the just transition starts in the places that matter most for climate, nature, and people.”
Noting that "the Arctic is warming more than twice as fast as the rest of the globe, and should be the most obvious place to draw the line against new fossil fuel development," Susanne Waage, WWF Norway's fossil fuel transition lead, lamented that "Norway continues to explore aggressively for new oil and gas in one of the world's most vulnerable regions."
Waage added that the European Union, "Norway's largest oil and gas customer, has already said no to new Arctic oil and gas. Norway should listen, stop exploring for new oil and gas resources, and help make the Arctic a Fossil Free Zone."
Pascal Mirindi, Democratic Republic of Congo national coordinator of the group Our Land Without Oil, asserted: "We cannot claim to protect forests, peatlands, and vital ecosystems while opening the door to oil and gas within them. In the DRC, these projects threaten territories and the communities who depend on them for their livelihoods."
"Fossil Free Zones offer a concrete and immediate solution," Mirindi added. "Here at COP31, we are calling on governments to end all new exploration in critical ecosystems, to recognize these zones in their national roadmaps, and to guarantee a just transition centered on the rights of communities."
"The imminence of breaching 1.5°C cannot be an excuse to open the door to defeatism—the focus has to be on accelerating action to limit the magnitude and duration of overshoot."
With world leaders, climate campaigners, scientists, and more gathered in Türkiye for the United Nations Climate Change Conference, an independent project that tracks government action warned Thursday that global warming is headed toward "an irrecoverable overshoot of 1.5°C" unless countries "rapidly reduce emissions to limit both the magnitude and duration of this overshoot."
A series of analyses released in the lead-up to the summit—including the United Nations Environment Program's "Limiting Overshoot" publication from September, the UNEP's "The Emissions Gap Report 2026: The Point of Return" from October, and the World Meteorological Organization's "State of the Climate: Update for COP31" from last week—have all sounded the alarm about at least temporarily surpassing 1.5°C, the Paris Agreement's global temperature rise limit for this century.
The new Climate Action Tracker (CAT) report, "Without Rapid Action, The World Is Heading to Irrecoverable Overshoot," lays out real-world action based on current policies; pledges and targets from the nationally determined contributions (NDCs) of countries that have signed on to the Paris Agreement; and the "optimistic scenario" based on all announced ambitions.
"Aggregated climate action has now essentially stalled for five consecutive years, with positive and negative actions canceling each other out," says the CAT briefing. "The warming outlook from current policies is leading to 2.7°C in 2100 (slightly up from 2.6°C) as it stood from 2021-2024."
"Our 2030 and 2035 targets scenario that assumes governments meet all their targets remains unchanged at 2.6°C in 2100," the report details. "The round of 2035 NDCs has closed: And it's clear governments have failed to meaningfully improve the outlook for end-of-century warming."
CAT's scenario that includes 2030 and 2035 NDCs as well as long-term targets projects "warming of 2.1°C in 2100, down from 2.2°C last year," the report continues. "Ambitious near- and long-term targets matter, but without credible policies and immediate implementation, they risk becoming empty promises rather than drivers of real-world emission reductions."
"Our optimistic scenario, assuming full implementation of all announced and net-zero targets, remains at 1.9°C in 2100," it stresses. "Even under our most optimistic assessment, if governments were to implement every single national pledge they have made—including the net-zero targets—we will still permanently overshoot the 1.5°C limit and get close to 2°C."
As both greenhouse gas concentrations and the profits of fossil fuel giants have soared while communities around the world face deadly heatwaves, rapidly intensifying hurricanes, rising sea levels, and destructive wildfires—like those that ravaged COP31 host Türkiye in September—scientists have reiterated warnings about the need for sweeping action to cut emissions.
"Continued warming from greenhouse gases emitted from human activities threatens to feed further warming as permafrost, wetlands, and wildfires destabilize and respond by releasing carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide," Ben Poulter, warming-induced emissions program director at Spark Climate Solutions, said in September, when a study he co-authored was published.
"This study provides a critical look at the magnitude of the temperature response," Poulter added, "and a call to action to accelerate the accounting and monitoring of warming-induced emissions to support pathways that phase out fossil emissions to stabilize the planet’s climate."
But the brutal truth is that the positive developments do not yet add up to bending the curve of emissions fast enough. Increasing energy demand and build-out of new fossil fuel infrastructure have led to still rising emissions.
[image or embed]
— Climate Action Tracker (@climateactiontracker.org) November 12, 2026 at 1:04 AM
Bill Hare, CEO of CAT partner organization Climate Analytics, emphasized Thursday that "the stark choice for governments is to either continue to support the fossil fuel industry, which would consign humanity to insurmountable economic damages, rising mortality from heat, and climate-driven diseases and disasters that they are unable to adapt to—or pivot to the solutions which are available and cheaper than ever."
"The imminence of breaching 1.5°C cannot be an excuse to open the door to defeatism—the focus has to be on accelerating action to limit the magnitude and duration of overshoot," he argued. "Every increment of warming above 1.5°C means even more significant consequences across climate, nature and human systems."
The report outlines "five key levers that could cut emissions at the speed and urgency needed to follow a Paris-aligned pathway, limiting the magnitude and duration of overshoot," which are:
"Governments collectively are simply not moving fast enough to adopt the policies that would enable us to escape from the emerging overshoot trap," said the lead author of CAT's report, Climate Analytics policy analyst Sarah Heck. "Worse, several are taking their foot off the accelerator and slowing their climate action—or in cases such as the USA, Canada, and New Zealand—rolling it back at a staggering level."
So far this week, Climate Action Network International has given its satirical "Fossil of the Day" award—long used to call out bad actors during climate summits—to New Zealand, for "dismantling its own climate commitments" under Prime Minister Christopher Luxon, as well as "absent leaders of wealthy countries," including Canada, Denmark, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Japan, the Netherlands, and Sweden.
The stark choice for governments is to either continue to support the fossil fuel industry – or pivot to the solutions which are available and cheaper than ever. The lack of decisive action means that long-term warming is expected to cross the 1.5°C limit around 2030.
[image or embed]
— Climate Action Tracker (@climateactiontracker.org) November 12, 2026 at 1:04 AM
While a key Democratic US senator is attending COP31, President Donald Trump is skipping the summit and has not sent a delegation, even though his country is the world's worst historical climate polluter. UNEP's report from last month highlights the dangers of the pro-fossil fuel agenda that the Republican leader has pursued since returning to power last year, including ditching the Paris Agreement, again.
Trump's ongoing illegal war on Iran has not only led to the deaths of thousands of people but also padded the pockets of those invested in the fossil fuel industry—including himself—while people around the world pay the price at the pump, due to Iran's restrictions on ship traffic through the Strait of Hormuz.
"With the closure of the Strait of Hormuz exposing our vulnerability to geopolitical shocks," said Niklas Höhne of CAT partner organization NewClimate Institute, "the case for renewables and electrification has never been stronger—and it does appear that global emissions could be on the verge of a peak and a much faster decline than we had previously thought."