For Immediate Release
Frontline Distorts Global Healthcare Options
PBS show treats mandatory for-profit insurance as the only alternative
WASHINGTON - The March 31 documentary by PBS's Frontline, Sick Around America,
treated mandatory for-profit insurance coverage as the only alternative
to the current U.S. healthcare system--even though the documentary was
a sequel to a 2008 Frontline special, Sick Around the World (4/15/08), that examined several publicly funded healthcare models, including Taiwan's single-payer system.
In a segment of Sick Around America subtitled "How to Get a Fairer System," Frontline
narrator Will Lyman asked Karen Ignati, a spokesperson from the
insurers' trade group America's Health Insurance Plans, why the U.S.
couldn't guarantee coverage for all like other developed countries do.
After Ignati responded that her industry could only guarantee universal
coverage if the government required all citizens to have insurance,
That's what other developed countries do. They
make insurers cover everyone and they make all citizens buy insurance.
And the poor are subsidized.
This generalization about other developed countries being places where
"people are mandated to buy" insurance is also repeated on Frontline's web page about Sick Around America, in a paragraph that contains a link to the Sick Around the World investigation. The only alternative to the current U.S. healthcare system that was examined in any depth in Sick Around America was Massachusetts' system of mandating that people buy insurance from for-profit health insurance companies.
But this exclusive focus on mandatory for-profit health insurance as a
solution to the healthcare problems facing the nation negated Frontline's earlier findings about the healthcare systems in developed countries. None of the healthcare systems featured in Sick Around the World is based on mandatory purchase of for-profit insurance; indeed, as a report by the Canadian government noted (5/97; revised 2/01), "The United States is the only OECD country that relies primarily on private insurance for healthcare financing."
Frontline's 2008 documentary actually highlighted Taiwan's single-payer model of healthcare system. As Frontline
correspondent T.R. Reid explained, when Taiwanese healthcare adopted
single-payer it went from being "worse than America's is today," with
high rates of uninsured, to a system that guarantees coverage for all
and "has the lowest administrative costs in the world, less than 2
percent." The U.K.'s system of public national health insurance was
And as Reid emphasized in the conclusion of the 2008 report, in
countries where there is some private-sector role in health financing,
one of the central lessons is that they "all impose limits," including
that insurance companies "can't make a profit on basic care." (This
point is made by one source in passing in Sick Around America, but it's easy to miss.)
Reid was supposed to be the correspondent for the new documentary, but he revealed in an interview with Corporate Crime Reporter (4/2/09) that he quit over concerns that the new documentary contradicted his earlier research:
"I said to them, mandating for-profit insurance
is not the lesson from other countries in the world," Reid said. "I
said, I'm not going to be in a film that contradicts my previous film
and my book. They said I had to be in the film because I was under
contract. I insisted that I couldn't be. And we parted ways.
"Doctors, hospitals, nurses, labs can all be for-profit," Reid said.
"But the payment system has to be non-profit. All the other countries
have agreed on that. We are the only one that allows health insurance
companies to make a profit. You can't allow a profit to be made on the
basic package of health insurance."
Frontline's new documentary
perpetuates the media's longstanding pattern of ignoring proposals for
single-payer health insurance (FAIR Media Advisory, 3/6/09),
despite the fact that this proposal polls well with the American public
and has been codified in a bill co-sponsored by 74 congressmembers.
While Sick Around America included several spokespeople from the health insurance industry, no single-payer advocate was featured in the documentary.
Ask Frontline why Sick Around America misrepresented the findings of Sick Around the World, treating mandatory for-profit insurance coverage as the only alternative to the current U.S. healthcare system.
Please share your letters to Frontline by posting them in the comments section on the FAIR Blog.
FAIR, the national media watch group, has been offering well-documented criticism of media bias and censorship since 1986. We work to invigorate the First Amendment by advocating for greater diversity in the press and by scrutinizing media practices that marginalize public interest, minority and dissenting viewpoints.