Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

Today is the LAST DAY of this Mid-Year Campaign. This is our hour of need.
If you value independent journalism, please support Common Dreams.

TODAY is the last day to meet our goal -- Join the small group of generous readers who donate, keeping Common Dreams free for millions of people each year.

What have these justices of dubious legitimacy done with their power? They have repeatedly sought to tilt the electoral system toward Republicans. (Photo: Shutterstock)

We cannot afford a Supreme Court that has abandoned its constitutional duties to become a headquarters for Republican political partisans in black robes. (Photo: Shutterstock)

If Trump Fills RBG’s Seat, the Court’s Legitimacy Will Be in Crisis

We cannot afford a Supreme Court that has abandoned its constitutional duties to cement right-wing minority rule.

Mitchell Zimmerman

 by OtherWords

In 1832, President Andrew Jackson condemned a Supreme Court decision in words that are famous in judicial history, but today almost unthinkable in their disrespect for the highest court in the land: “Justice Marshall has made his decision; now let him enforce it.”

Jackson, a violent slave owner (and idol of President Trump) is best known for the ethnic cleansing of 120,000 Native Americans who were forcibly removed from the Southeastern United States in the 1830s.

When the state of Georgia tried to seize millions of acres of Cherokee land, the Supreme Court affirmed the rights of the Cherokee. But Jackson ignored the decision, and Native Americans eventually died by the thousands on the “Trail of Tears.”

What have these justices of dubious legitimacy done with their power? They have repeatedly sought to tilt the electoral system toward Republicans.

Nowadays, while people on the left and right both criticize the Supreme Court, the notion of simply ignoring a ruling is almost unimaginable. The court often has the last word on deeply political issues, but it’s generally seen as judicial, not “political.” That’s the key to its legitimacy.

But for the Supreme Court to have legitimacy, we must know the fix is not in.

The judges must have been fairly selected, and political leaders with different views must all have a fair opportunity to pick justices. For the court to be legitimate, it must be touched by democratic influence: justices must be selected by democratically elected presidents.

In a slow-moving and rough way, then, the presidential choices can reflect the moods of their times. And, optimistically viewed, the people who call themselves “justices” may be seen as a kind of composite of the priorities and values of our nation over a period of decades.

In this century, however, any claim the Supreme Court’s judges were fairly selected is fragile.

Four of the current nine justices were selected by Presidents George W. Bush and Donald Trump. Each lost the popular vote in their inaugural term, and each was put in office against the will of the majority of Americans. Meanwhile the majority-elected president, Barack Obama, was prevented from appointing a justice on what is now admitted to have been a phony excuse.

What have these justices of dubious legitimacy done with their power? They have repeatedly sought to tilt the electoral system toward Republicans.

In 2008, they approved voter ID requirements whose only function was to hinder voting rights. In 2013, they eviscerated the Voting Rights Act of 1965, unleashing an avalanche of new state laws to disenfranchise minority, elderly, and young voters. This April, they disallowed the votes of thousands of Wisconsinites who tried to vote by mail during the pandemic.

You could argue the Court was no bulwark even before. After all, George W. Bush was essentially appointed by a right-wing majority of the Supreme Court when they halted the Florida vote count in 2000. But it could get far, far worse.

If Trump is permitted to appoint yet another justice, that will make five—a majority of the Court—selected by men who became president despite being opposed by most voters. Any contention that a majority of the Court reflects the values of most Americans will be eradicated, and it will be time to end any pretense that the Supreme Court is a legitimate judicial institution.

There could no worse time for America to find itself without a judicial bulwark. The president wages war on American constitutional values, encourages violence, and refuses to accept that he should leave office if he loses the election.

We cannot afford a Supreme Court that has abandoned its constitutional duties to become a headquarters for Republican political partisans in black robes.


This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 License.
Mitchell Zimmerman

Mitchell Zimmerman

Mitchell Zimmerman is an attorney, longtime social activist, and author of the anti-racism thriller "Mississippi Reckoning" (2019).

TODAY is the last day of our crucial Mid-Year Campaign and we might not make it without your help.
Who funds our independent journalism? Readers like you who believe in our mission: To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. No corporate advertisers. No billionaire founder. Our non-partisan, nonprofit media model has only one source of revenue: The people who read and value this work and our mission. That's it.
And the model is simple: If everyone just gives whatever amount they can afford and think is reasonable—$3, $9, $29, or more—we can continue. If not enough do, we go dark.

All the small gifts add up to something otherwise impossible. Please join us today. Donate to Common Dreams. This is crunch time. We need you now.

Biden Urged to Embrace Windfall Tax as Exxon Says Profits Doubled in Second Quarter

"It's time for the president to demand that Congress pass a windfall profits tax on Big Oil and use the revenue to provide rebates to consumers NOW!" wrote Sen. Bernie Sanders.

Jake Johnson ·


Texas Supreme Court Allows Century-Old Abortion Ban to Take Effect

"Extremist politicians are on a crusade to force Texans into pregnancy and childbirth against their will, no matter how devastating the consequences."

Jake Johnson ·


'What's There to Even Discuss?' Omar Says Free, Universal School Meals Should Be Permanent

"We have an opportunity to prove that a government of the people, by the people, and for the people can still deliver big things. And we can feed tens of millions of hungry kids while we do it."

Jake Johnson ·


'Stark Betrayal': Biden Administration Floats New Offshore Oil and Gas Drilling

"This is the third time since November the Biden administration has announced new oil and gas leasing plans on the Friday before a holiday," said one climate advocate. "They're ashamed, and they should be."

Jake Johnson ·


As US Rolls Back Reproductive Rights, Sierra Leone Moves to Decriminalize Abortion

"I'm hopeful today's announcement gives activists in the U.S., and especially Black women given the shared history, a restored faith that change is possible and progress can be made."

Brett Wilkins ·

Common Dreams Logo