Look Who's Begging for Regulation

"Regulate the health insurance giants," chanted the reformers.

"Stop denying coverage to sick people," they demanded. "Stop jacking
up premiums," they cried. "Health coverage for all," they bellowed.

It was an impressive show that the health care reform movement put
on last week at a hearing before the Senate finance committee. It was
especially impressive because those doing the chanting, demanding,
crying and bellowing were not aggrieved outsiders, but the ultimate
insiders - the health insurance giants themselves!

When the dogs begin demanding leashes, you now that something unusual is afoot.

Indeed, two things are afoot. First, the public is fed up with our
country's insurance-dominated health care system, which cares first
about corporate profits and only secondarily about the health needs of
America's people. As a result, we pay more for health coverage than any
other country, yet the quality of care we get ranks 37th in the world
(below such countries as Malta, Morocco, Chile and Dominica).

Insurance companies maintain a massive money-sucking bureaucracy
that exists essentially to say "no" to policy-holders who need approval
for treatment and to say "hell no" to anyone who can't afford the
ever-escalating price for those policies. In the richest country in the
history of the world, 47 million Americans are uncovered, and many
millions more have "coverage" so thin that it leaves their families out
in the cold for most ailments. This is why 76 percent of the people
said in a March poll by the Pew Research Center that our health care
system either needs "fundamental changes" or needs to be "completely

Which brings us to the second factor in play: political change.
Americans have been angry about the insurance-run system for years, but
neither party produced results. Bill Clinton botched reform in the
early '90s, spooking Democrats so badly that, for years, they wouldn't
even attempt major reforms. George W. Bush and congressional
Republicans never met an insurance company they wouldn't hug, take
money from and serve faithfully, so they've simply ignored the people.

Last year, though, Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton, John Edwards,
Dennis Kucinich and other Democratic presidential contenders raised the
reform flag high, ultimately carrying it into the White House.

Today, redoing the health care system is on Washington's front burner, including plans for a public
insurance option to extend coverage to middle-class working families.
This public entity would provide a missing level of competition, lower
costs and instill some honesty in companies that had been gleefully
profiteering on the present system.

Like vampires, health insurance corporations shrink from sunlight,
so they have rushed an army of lobbyists to Washington in a desperate
attempt to stave off this public option. However, they recognize that
they are widely despised across the land and that even some Republican
members of Congress will no longer stand for the status quo (as one
Democratic leader noted, "Status quo is Latin for 'The Mess We're In'").

Thus, we're being treated to the delightfully dizzying sight of
insurance executives begging Congress to harness them with new
regulations. "We are comfortable with that," said the head of America's
Health Insurance Plans (AHIP), the industry's chief lobbying group,
which heretofore has ferociously opposed any and all protections for

Of course, AHIP members are wiley masters at slipping out of
regulatory harnesses - remember, these are the people who hire roving
packs of lawyers trained to write and enforce incomprehensible
insurance policies that boil down to this: "Thank you for paying us to
do our damnedest to stiff you."

In exchange for accepting such "regulation," AHIP wants Washington
to require everyone in the country to buy health insurance from Aetna,
Humana, United Health or its other members - with taxpayers covering
the annual premiums of those who can't afford the policies. In other
words, these private corporations would get a government-guaranteed
market. What industry wouldn't be "comfortable" with that?

In the interest of America's health, insurance giants should never
be made to feel comfortable. At the very least, real reform requires a
public insurance option to assure competitive integrity - and to put
some "care" back in health care.

Join Us: News for people demanding a better world

Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place.

We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference.

Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. Join with us today!

© 2023 Jim Hightower