

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FREE NEWSLETTER
Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.
5
#000000
#FFFFFF
To donate by check, phone, or other method, see our More Ways to Give page.


Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.

Derrick Robinson, drobinson@citizen.org
Ahead of the U.N. General Assembly (UNGA) heads of state summit, members of the U.S. Congress, a South African government official, and heads of labor, faith and health organizations today detailed why President Joe Biden's leadership in delivering a waiver of WTO intellectual property barriers, technology transfer to speed production by sharing vaccine recipes and funding for production of COVID medicines around the world is essential to ending the pandemic.
In the months since Biden's historic support for a waiver of World Trade Organization (WTO) monopoly barriers to greater COVID-19 vaccine production, little progress has been made. White House COVID Czar Jeffrey Zients has yet to unveil a global plan as the delta variant, first detected in India where vaccines are scarce, is now raging worldwide.
UNGA and Biden's global COVID-19 summit will be successful only if the president uses them to get the WTO waiver done, require vaccine recipes be shared via broad tech transfer to speed expansion of COVID-19 medicine supplies, and move funding for greatly expanded global production.
Video of today's event is available here. A transcript will be available shortly here.
Statements from speakers:
U.S. Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-Ill.)
"The delta-driven third wave of COVID-19 that is underway right now underscores the absolute urgent need to act to end the pandemic worldwide. And this is a moment of opportunity -- it actually can happen. And President Biden can act now at his special COVID-19 summit that is being held in conjunction with the UN General Assembly that started today. On May 5th, President Biden showed the courage and the incredible foresight in declaring his support for a temporary waiver of the World Trade Organization TRIPS rule, calling for the temporary pause of a complete monopoly power of the current vaccine makers, particularly Pfizer and Moderna. Intellectual property rights would be temporarily suspended and countries would have access to the recipe and the know-how to quickly manufacture millions of doses of vaccines and save millions and millions of lives... Numerous nations began asking for this TRIPS waiver in October of 2020, and yet today, there is a horrifying shortage of vaccine. We know that. The United States must at this time exert leadership now and save millions and millions of lives around the world, including lives that are at stake here at home in the United States. This is the moment. Please, President Biden, we are so grateful to you. The world was rejoicing when you said that you were in favor of a waiver, that you were willing to put people over the profits of the pharmaceutical companies and now is the moment."
U.S. Rep. Rosa DeLauro (D-Conn.)
"While we have made enormous strides vaccinating the United States population, that simply is not enough. We have a moral responsibility to step up and lead, to share what we have learned, and do everything we can to alleviate the suffering around the world and end this pandemic. That is why I will continue to support the decision made by President Biden to temporarily waive some of the world's intellectual property rules at the WTO to increase the global production and supply for coronavirus vaccines. Now it is time for him to act -- to deliver on his historic support. As the UNGA heads of state summit begins, President Biden's leadership is essential to help end this pandemic. That means prioritizing people over pharmaceutical profits and ensuring that a vaccine is a global common good."
Zane Dangor, Republic of South Africa, Special Advisor to the Foreign Minister
"We do know that the EU has expressed this week that they are not keen for an outcome on the TRIPS waiver proposal at the upcoming ministerial council and would like to kick this discussion further down the road, to way after the upcoming ministerial. The US in Geneva, at the WTO, has expressed support for an outcome at the upcoming ministerial so already we're seeing action by the US side, but we need out of next week's summit and the deliberations this week, commitment on a text from the US that can be tabled and negotiated with South Africa, India and other co-sponsors so we can have an outcome and get to the business of actually ensuring we get jabs in arms of those that need it most and we have equitable access. And in the long term, we change the asymmetrical nature of vaccine production and consumption globally."
Dr. Joia Mukherjee MD, MPH, Partners In Health, Chief Medical Officer
"Our ability to work in solidarity is a test. This is a test of our ability to collaborate as a globe and do things morally in the best interest of humanity. The big test looming before us is climate change. These things, like pandemics, hunger, unemployment, migration, these are all linked. It is really time to turn swords into plowshares. We cannot think of security in the 21st century as continuing a military build up, continuing endless wars. We need to take that money that we've spent, trillions of dollars - two billion a week for the war in Afghanistan alone - and put it into elevating the lives of all through medicine and science... In this crisis, the Biden administration has already led, and we are grateful for their [support for a] temporary waiver of TRIPS, but it's a meaningless act unless we put funding into transfer of technology and local production and expanding the production capabilities in Africa, in Asia, the Middle East, Latin America. These places can do it, it's a matter of financing, the procurement of raw materials and transfer of technology."
Father Charles Chilufya, Jesuit Conference of Africa and Madagascar, Director of Justice and Ecology
"While one in two or even more in the developed North are vaccinated, only one in 65 are vaccinated in Africa. There's a vast difference. Despite the promises we have made before to be better prepared and do better in the next pandemic, COVID-19 has demonstrated that no lessons have been learned, as we watch a deliberate repeat of past mistakes. We have seen how malaria, tuberculosis, and HIV/AIDS, which were once called global pandemics, have now become endemic to poorer regions like Africa. What is more disturbing in all of this is that this is about human life, this is about affront to human dignity. I know my fellow Catholic Joe Biden appreciates this. I'd like to thank him for his leadership for favoring the TRIPS waiver. That's a movement in the right direction. We believe that global leaders have power to do the right thing, but at present have chosen not to. But we believe that with his leadership, President Joe Biden can move other leaders for the first time to learn from history and respect life, respect human dignity, and understand the fact that this is about children dying, this is about children losing both of their parents and remaining vulnerable as orphans, this is about health workers who are left unprotected. It's human life at stake. We would like to appeal to President Biden to continue to show good example and mobilize the leaders to respect life, to respect human dignity."
Sara Nelson, Association of Flight Attendants-CWA, President
"This is a worker issue. Our workplace is the entire world. And so the world leaders who are standing in the way of making sure we are mobilizing every effort to remove all roadblocks to get this vaccine to every single person, to distribute that, to produce it, I would like to ask them: where to you think your flight attendants are going when they go to work? This cannot be centralized in a specific country, you cannot hide your face, you cannot put your head under the covers. I just spent the weekend going to 20-year remembrances of September 11th. What this reminds me of is that [flight attendants] went to work on the morning of September 11th. We were told up to that point that we needed to comply, we needed to keep everyone calm. We were given the exact wrong training to meet the crisis we were facing that day. It was flight attendants on the front line as first responders who got us some of the intelligence that day that made its way to Flight 93. On the flight there was a representation of every gender, race, culture and creed. On that plane, it looked like a representation of people from around the world. In a moment's time, they were just one force against a threat that was threatening their lives and the rest of ours on the ground. They immediately mobilized in an hour's time, with good information - and we have had good information for a good amount of time here, to take action against this major threat against all of us around the world: against our jobs, our economic security, our families, our communities, the threats that we face at work. In a moment's time they acted together and they saved the rest of our lives. That's the same thing that we can do now. Flight attendants around the world, President Biden, we want to inject back to you as you meet the rest of the leaders around the world, that we come with you with great respect to marshal a global response to end this pandemic. We need you to do this for workers, we need you to do this for every community, we need you to do this because this is what the human spirit does when it's up against a threat. We've seen it time and time again, we know you're the leader to do it, and we're with you all the way."
Lori Wallach, Public Citizen's Global Trade Watch, Director
"The mismatch to date between the crisis we face and world leaders' failure to deliver on the concrete actions needed to end the pandemic is disastrous and unacceptable. The delta variant foreshadows what a future of endless pandemic would look like, with the lack of vaccination causing outbreaks and breeding more dangerous variants in an endless cycle of death and economic hardship. That is a future that is entirely unacceptable. With the UN General Assembly starting today, President Biden has a powerful opportunity to change that and to end the pandemic. Ending the pandemic is a political choice. The world has the technical, the medical, the financial means to vaccinate the world and end the pandemic. There are three clear steps: getting intellectual property monopoly barriers out of the way through a temporary WTO TRIPS waiver, technology transfer through sharing the recipes that the current monopoly producers have, and funding for the necessary global production so that people around the world are not reliant on a few monopoly sources."
Public Citizen is a nonprofit consumer advocacy organization that champions the public interest in the halls of power. We defend democracy, resist corporate power and work to ensure that government works for the people - not for big corporations. Founded in 1971, we now have 500,000 members and supporters throughout the country.
(202) 588-1000"Brendan Carr is threatening the media to cover the war the way the Trump regime wants. It’s one of the most anti-American messages ever posted by a government official," one news network said.
In a move one administration critic described as "fragrantly unconstitutional," Federal Communications Commission Chair Brendan Carr wrote a post on social media on Saturday that appeared to threaten the broadcast license of any media outlet that reported information concerning President Donald Trump's war on Iran that the president did not like.
"Broadcasters that are running hoaxes and news distortions—also known as the fake news—have a chance now to correct course before their license renewals come up. The law is clear. Broadcasters must operate in the public interest, and they will lose their licenses if they do not," Carr's message began.
Carr also shared a screenshot of a Trump post on Truth Social complaining about "Fake News Media" coverage of five US Air Force refueling planes that were reportedly hit and damaged in an Iranian missile strike on Prince Sultan air base in Saudi Arabia.
"The[is] is the federal government telling news stations to provide favorable coverage of the war or their licenses will be pulled," wrote Sen. Chris Murphy (D-Conn.) on social media in response to the post. "A truly extraordinary moment. We aren't on the verge of a totalitarian takeover. WE ARE IN THE MIDDLE OF IT. Act like it."
Several other media professionals, free speech advocates, and Democratic politicians understood Carr's post as a threat.
"The truth is this war has been a failure of historic proportions. They don’t want Americans to know that."
"The FCC is threatening the licenses of news stations that report on the effects of Iranian attacks on the American military," wrote journalist Séamus Malekafzali.
Bulwark economics editor Catherine Rampell wrote, "FCC Chair Brendan Carr threatens broadcast licenses over Iran War coverage."
Journalist Sam Stein posted, "The state doesn't like the war coverage, threatens the license of the broadcasters."
Independent news network MediasTouch wrote: "Brendan Carr is threatening the media to cover the war the way the Trump regime wants. It’s one of the most anti-American messages ever posted by a government official."
"The truth is this war has been a failure of historic proportions. They don’t want Americans to know that," the group continued.
"This is worse than the comedian stuff, and by a lot. The stakes here are much higher. He’s not talking about late night shows, he’s talking about how a war is covered."
Several pointed out that such a threat would be in violation of the First Amendment of the US Constitution, which guarantees freedom of speech and of the press.
"Constitutional law 101: It’s illegal for the government to censor free speech it just doesn’t like about Trump’s Iran war," Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) posted on social media. "This threat is straight out of the authoritarian playbook."
Sen. Mark Kelly (D-Ariz.), who has faced scrutiny from the administration for advising service members to disobey illegal orders, wrote: "When our nation is at war it is critical that the press is free to report without government interference. It is literally in the Constitution. This is overreach by the FCC because this administration doesn’t like the microscope and doesn’t want to be held accountable."
California Gov. Gavin Newsom wrote, "If Trump doesn't like your coverage of the war, his FCC will pull your broadcast license. That is flagrantly unconstitutional."
Aaron Terr, the director of public advocacy at the Foundation of Individual Rights and Expression, said: "The president's hand-picked misinformation czar is at it again, singling out 'fake news' that conflicts with his boss' political agenda. The First Amendment doesn't allow the government to censor information about the war it's waging."
Free Press senior director of strategy and communications Timothy Karr responded to Carr with a screenshot of the First Amendment and the words: "Here it is—as it seems you've forgotten what you swore an oath to 'support and defend.'"
This is not the first time that Carr has been accused of putting his loyalty to Trump over his duty to the Constitution. In September, he pressured ABC to take comedian Jimmy Kimmel off the air over remarks Kimmel had made following the murder of Charlie Kirk.
While ABC eventually reinstated Kimmel's show following public backlash, free speech advocates warned at the time that the Trump administration would not stop trying to censor opposing views.
“The Trump regime’s war on free speech is no joke—and it’s not over," Free Press co-CEO Craig Aaron said at the time.
Indeed, Sen. Brian Schatz (D-Hawaii) wrote of Carr's Saturday statement: "This is worse than the comedian stuff, and by a lot. The stakes here are much higher. He’s not talking about late night shows, he’s talking about how a war is covered."
Carr's note comes at a particularly urgent time for independent media coverage in the US, as Paramount Skydance, which is run by the son of pro-Trump billionaire Larry Ellison, is set to acquire Warner Bros. Discovery, which owns CNN. The Trump administration has often criticized CNN's coverage, including of the war.
On Friday, Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth told reporters, “The sooner David Ellison takes over that network, the better,” as he complained about a CNN report on how the Pentagon underestimated the risk that Iran would close the Strait of Hormuz in response to US aggression.
Carr has already spoken out in favor of the merger, telling CNBC he thought it was a "good deal, and I think it should get through pretty quickly."
This piece has been updated with quotes from Sens. Chris Murphy, Elizabeth Warren, and Mark Kelly.
“Mandating a restart of these defective oil pipelines won’t curb high gas prices, but it will put coastal wildlife at huge risk of another oil spill," one advocate said.
State leaders and environmental advocates responded with outrage after the Trump administration on Friday ordered the restarting of a California pipeline that caused one of the largest oil spills in the state's history, a move that comes as oil prices have skyrocketed following President Donald Trump's launching of an illegal war against Iran and Iran's subsequent closure of the Strait of Hormuz.
After Trump issued an executive order on Friday authorizing the Department of Energy (DOE) to ramp up oil and gas development under the Defense Production Act, Energy Secretary Chris Wright ordered Sable Offshore Corp. to restart operations on the Santa Ynez Unit and Pipeline System, which include an offshore rig and a network of offshore and onshore pipelines along the Santa Barbara coast. Among them is a pipeline that ruptured in 2015, spilling around 450,000 gallons of oil into Refugio State Beach and killing hundreds of marine mammals and sea birds.
“Californians have repeatedly rejected dangerous drilling off our coast for decades," Sen. Alex Padilla (D-Calif.) said in a statement on Saturday. "Now, after dragging the US into a war with Iran and driving up oil prices, the Trump administration is trying to exploit this crisis to further enrich the oil industry at the expense of our communities and our environment."
In his statement, Wright emphasized the defense benefits of resuming drilling, arguing that "today’s order will strengthen America’s oil supply and restore a pipeline system vital to our national security and defense, ensuring that West Coast military installations have the reliable energy critical to military readiness.”
“Directing a private oil company to push its project through without safety checks and adherence to California laws that keep our coast safe is appalling and illegal."
The DOE added that "Sable's facility can produce approximately 50,000 barrels of oil per day, a 15% increase to California’s in-state oil production, that can replace nearly 1.5 million barrels of foreign crude each month."
Yet, far from a novel response to an unexpected emergency, the order is actually an escalation in a preexisting battle between California and the Trump administration over the future of the pipeline system. The state's Attorney General Rob Bonta sued to stop the administration from a federal takeover of two of the pipelines in January.
Sable also faces several lawsuits due to its attempts to restart the system after it purchased it from ExxonMobil in 2024, and has not yet cleared all of the state permitting requirements, according to the Center for Biological Diversity.
"In its latest brazen abuse of power, the Trump administration is attempting to seize exclusive federal control over two of California’s onshore pipelines," Bonta said on social media Friday evening. "We will not stand by as this administration continues their unlawful all-out assault on California and our coastlines, and we are reviewing all of our legal options."
California Gov. Gavin Newsom also spoke out against Wright's announcement.
"Trump knew his war with Iran would raise gas prices," he wrote on social media. "Now he wants to illegally resurrect a pipeline shut down by courts and facing criminal charges. And it won't even cut prices. I refuse to let Trump sacrifice Californians, our environment, or our $51 billion coastal economy."
The Center for Biological Diversity noted that this order would mark the first time that the Defense Production Act was used to force an oil company to restart out-of-use Infrastructure and to disregard the state permitting process.
“This is a revolting power grab by an extremist president. Trump is misusing this Cold War-era law just to help a Texas oil company skirt vital state laws that protect our coastline, and Californians will pay the price,” Talia Nimmer, an attorney for the center, said. “Mandating a restart of these defective oil pipelines won’t curb high gas prices, but it will put coastal wildlife at huge risk of another oil spill. Overriding state law to let an oil company restart pipelines sets a radically dangerous precedent. It’s clear that no state is safe from Trump.”
The center also promised to push back against the order.
“Directing a private oil company to push its project through without safety checks and adherence to California laws that keep our coast safe is appalling and illegal,” Nimmer said. “We’re exploring all legal avenues. This dangerous action should be swiftly blocked by the courts.”
"He's a white supremacist," said one critic. "He doesn't hide it."
US President Donald Trump was accused Friday of espousing white supremacist ideology after he blamed the "genetics" of Muslim immigrants who commit crimes like Thursday's assault on a Michigan synagogue, while calling for their exclusion from the United States.
"Well, it's been going on for a long time. It's a disgrace. They're sick, they're really demented people," Trump said during a call-in interview with Fox News Radio host Brian Kilmeade. "They come into the country, they sneak in."
Trump was responding to a question about recent attacks by people who happen to be Muslims, including Mohamed Bailor Jalloh, who was stabbed to death by a cadet at Old Dominion University in Norfolk, Virginia after fatally shooting instructor Lt. Col. Brandon Shah, and Ayman Mohamad Ghazali, who was shot dead by security guards at the Temple Israel synagogue in West Bloomfield Township, Michigan after crashing his vehicle into the building.
Neither Jalloh nor Ghazali "snuck" into the country. Both were naturalized US citizens. Jalloh, originally from Sierra Leone, was a former National Guardsman. Ghazali had recently lost two of his brothers and other relatives to an Israeli airstrike in his native Lebanon.
"They’re sick people, and a lot of them were let in here. They shouldn’t have been let in," Trump told Kilmeade. "Others are just bad. They go bad. Something wrong—there’s something wrong there. The genetics are not exactly, they’re not exactly your genetics."
Trump has made many racist statements and has occasionally invoked what critics say is the language of eugenics, a debunked pseudoscience embraced by many white supremacists. He has also boasted about his own "much better blood."
While running for reelection, Trump echoed Nazi dictator Adolf Hitler's screed against "poisoning" by an "influx of foreign blood," declaring during a December 2023 campaign rally in New Hampshire that undocumented immigrants are "poisoning the blood" of the country.
"Trump is an old-school eugenicist nativist. He actually is fine with immigrants as long as they have the right 'genes,'" said David J. Bier, director of immigration studies at the libertarian Cato Institute, in response to Friday's interview. "This argument was the basis of the creation of the restrictive US immigration system 100 years ago."
Trump has previously said that he wants more immigrants from countries like Norway and not from what he called "shithole" nations in the Global South. His second administration has effectively ended refugee admissions—with the notable exception of white South Africans, the only people in the world allowed into the United States as refugees since last October, according to US Department of State data.
Progressive journalist Alex Cole said on X: "Imagine being the grandson of immigrants—who dyes his hair, paints his face orange, and wears lifts—lecturing the country about 'genetics.' The irony writes itself."
Trump's political rise began with his promotion of the racist "birther" conspiracy theory falsely positing that then-President Barack Obama was not born in the United States. He launched his 2016 presidential campaign by calling Mexican immigrants "rapists."
Once in office, Trump enacted a series of restrictions and outright bans on immigration from nations with Muslim majorities.
"He's a white supremacist," journalist Mehdi Hasan wrote Friday on X. "He doesn't hide it."