People cheer as U.S. President Donald Trump arrives for an indoor campaign rally at Xtreme Manufacturing in Henderson, a suburb of Las Vegas, Nevada, on September 13, 2020. (Photo: Brendan Smialowski / AFP via Getty Images)
Sep 14, 2020
A public health expert at George Washington University rebuked President Donald Trump's campaign after it argued that Trump had a right to host an estimated 25,000 people at an indoor campaign rally Sunday evening in Nevada because hundreds of thousands of Americans have taken part in racial justice protests in recent months.
After receiving harsh criticism for holding its first indoor rally since June in the Las Vegas suburb of Henderson, the campaign responded by saying, "If you can join tens of thousands of people protesting in the streets...or burn down small businesses in riots, you can gather peacefully under the 1st Amendment to hear from the president of the United States."
The campaign was essentially arguing in the middle of the coronavirus pandemic that "it's only fair that the president be allowed to kill some of his supporters by exposing them to superspreader events," tweeted Dr. Jonathan Reiner, a professor at GWU and a CNN analyst.
\u201cApparently Trump\u2019s campaign believes that since there were riots this summer it\u2019s only fair that the president be allowed to kill some of his supporters by exposing them to superspreader events.\u201d— Jonathan Reiner (@Jonathan Reiner) 1600034068
According to public health experts, the outdoor racial justice protests that have taken place across the country have not been linked to spikes in coronavirus transmission, likely because of high levels of compliance with mask-wearing guidelines. At the March on Washington anniversary rally in August, marchers were not permitted to attend without a face mask.
Reiner appeared on CNN Monday morning to accuse the president of "negligent homicide" at Sunday's rally, where a majority of attendees appeared to not wear face masks.
"That's what you'd call the actions of somebody who through their negligence causes the death of other people," Reiner said. "We're in a pandemic and Clark County, Nevada has a lot of virus. So with thousands of people, there's complete certainty that there are people in that crowd, probably asymptomatic carriers of the virus, who will spread the virus."
\u201cDr. @JReinerMD on Nevada rally: \u201cI would respectfully suggest to @realDonaldTrump that if he thinks it's safe to gather thousands of people in a pandemic without masks, then he should go down to the rope line and vigorously shake some hands.\u201d\u201d— Alisyn Camerota (@Alisyn Camerota) 1600082369
Clark County has one of Nevada's highest seven-day averages for coronavirus infections, with 62 out of every 100,000 people infected.
"If you were trying to somehow increase the amount of virus in the community, what you would do is gather thousands of people shoulder to shoulder without masks and have them scream and yell and laugh for a few hours," Reiner said of Trump's Nevada rally.
Trump's last indoor campaign rally in Tulsa, Oklahoma, was linked to a significant surge in Covid-19 cases, according to Tulsa City-County Health Department Director Dr. Bruce Dart.
"We're in a pandemic and Clark County, Nevada has a lot of virus. So with thousands of people, there's complete certainty that there are people in that crowd, probably asymptomatic carriers of the virus, who will spread the virus."
--Dr. Jonathan Reiner, GWU
Campaign staff at the Sunday rally in Nevada checked attendees' temperatures and provided access to hand sanitizer, but mask-wearing was not required--in defiance of Democratic Gov. Steve Sisolak's orders.
Sisolak has mandated that people cannot gather in groups larger than 50 and must observe public health officials' mask-wearing and social distancing guidelines.
The governor accused the president of being "reckless" and "selfish" by holding the event.
"Early on in this crisis, when it came time to exhibit real leadership and make difficult decisions to protect the American people, he failed to develop a unified national response strategy," Sisolak tweeted. "To put it bluntly: he didn't have the guts to make tough choices--he left that to governors and the states. Now he's decided he doesn't have to respect our state's laws. As usual, he doesn't believe the rules apply to him."
\u201cThis is an insult to every Nevadan who has followed the directives, made sacrifices, and put their neighbors before themselves. It\u2019s also a direct threat to all of the recent progress we\u2019ve made, and could potentially set us back.\u201d— Governor Sisolak (@Governor Sisolak) 1600048543
\u201cAs Governor, I have worked with public health and infectious disease specialists to create emergency directives to protect public health and get our economy back on track.\u201d— Governor Sisolak (@Governor Sisolak) 1600048543
\u201cThat means limiting gathering sizes, mandating face coverings and practicing social distancing. All of which the President recklessly disregarded for his own gain this weekend in Nevada.\u201d— Governor Sisolak (@Governor Sisolak) 1600048543
Last week, one epidemiologist raised similar alarm over the president's rally in Freeland, Michigan, where many attendees in a crowd of 5,000 were seen without face coverings.
"This is the crap that makes grown epidemiologists cry," said Dr. Eric Feigl-Ding, a fellow at the Federation of American Scientists.
Join Us: News for people demanding a better world
Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place. We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference. Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. |
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
A public health expert at George Washington University rebuked President Donald Trump's campaign after it argued that Trump had a right to host an estimated 25,000 people at an indoor campaign rally Sunday evening in Nevada because hundreds of thousands of Americans have taken part in racial justice protests in recent months.
After receiving harsh criticism for holding its first indoor rally since June in the Las Vegas suburb of Henderson, the campaign responded by saying, "If you can join tens of thousands of people protesting in the streets...or burn down small businesses in riots, you can gather peacefully under the 1st Amendment to hear from the president of the United States."
The campaign was essentially arguing in the middle of the coronavirus pandemic that "it's only fair that the president be allowed to kill some of his supporters by exposing them to superspreader events," tweeted Dr. Jonathan Reiner, a professor at GWU and a CNN analyst.
\u201cApparently Trump\u2019s campaign believes that since there were riots this summer it\u2019s only fair that the president be allowed to kill some of his supporters by exposing them to superspreader events.\u201d— Jonathan Reiner (@Jonathan Reiner) 1600034068
According to public health experts, the outdoor racial justice protests that have taken place across the country have not been linked to spikes in coronavirus transmission, likely because of high levels of compliance with mask-wearing guidelines. At the March on Washington anniversary rally in August, marchers were not permitted to attend without a face mask.
Reiner appeared on CNN Monday morning to accuse the president of "negligent homicide" at Sunday's rally, where a majority of attendees appeared to not wear face masks.
"That's what you'd call the actions of somebody who through their negligence causes the death of other people," Reiner said. "We're in a pandemic and Clark County, Nevada has a lot of virus. So with thousands of people, there's complete certainty that there are people in that crowd, probably asymptomatic carriers of the virus, who will spread the virus."
\u201cDr. @JReinerMD on Nevada rally: \u201cI would respectfully suggest to @realDonaldTrump that if he thinks it's safe to gather thousands of people in a pandemic without masks, then he should go down to the rope line and vigorously shake some hands.\u201d\u201d— Alisyn Camerota (@Alisyn Camerota) 1600082369
Clark County has one of Nevada's highest seven-day averages for coronavirus infections, with 62 out of every 100,000 people infected.
"If you were trying to somehow increase the amount of virus in the community, what you would do is gather thousands of people shoulder to shoulder without masks and have them scream and yell and laugh for a few hours," Reiner said of Trump's Nevada rally.
Trump's last indoor campaign rally in Tulsa, Oklahoma, was linked to a significant surge in Covid-19 cases, according to Tulsa City-County Health Department Director Dr. Bruce Dart.
"We're in a pandemic and Clark County, Nevada has a lot of virus. So with thousands of people, there's complete certainty that there are people in that crowd, probably asymptomatic carriers of the virus, who will spread the virus."
--Dr. Jonathan Reiner, GWU
Campaign staff at the Sunday rally in Nevada checked attendees' temperatures and provided access to hand sanitizer, but mask-wearing was not required--in defiance of Democratic Gov. Steve Sisolak's orders.
Sisolak has mandated that people cannot gather in groups larger than 50 and must observe public health officials' mask-wearing and social distancing guidelines.
The governor accused the president of being "reckless" and "selfish" by holding the event.
"Early on in this crisis, when it came time to exhibit real leadership and make difficult decisions to protect the American people, he failed to develop a unified national response strategy," Sisolak tweeted. "To put it bluntly: he didn't have the guts to make tough choices--he left that to governors and the states. Now he's decided he doesn't have to respect our state's laws. As usual, he doesn't believe the rules apply to him."
\u201cThis is an insult to every Nevadan who has followed the directives, made sacrifices, and put their neighbors before themselves. It\u2019s also a direct threat to all of the recent progress we\u2019ve made, and could potentially set us back.\u201d— Governor Sisolak (@Governor Sisolak) 1600048543
\u201cAs Governor, I have worked with public health and infectious disease specialists to create emergency directives to protect public health and get our economy back on track.\u201d— Governor Sisolak (@Governor Sisolak) 1600048543
\u201cThat means limiting gathering sizes, mandating face coverings and practicing social distancing. All of which the President recklessly disregarded for his own gain this weekend in Nevada.\u201d— Governor Sisolak (@Governor Sisolak) 1600048543
Last week, one epidemiologist raised similar alarm over the president's rally in Freeland, Michigan, where many attendees in a crowd of 5,000 were seen without face coverings.
"This is the crap that makes grown epidemiologists cry," said Dr. Eric Feigl-Ding, a fellow at the Federation of American Scientists.
A public health expert at George Washington University rebuked President Donald Trump's campaign after it argued that Trump had a right to host an estimated 25,000 people at an indoor campaign rally Sunday evening in Nevada because hundreds of thousands of Americans have taken part in racial justice protests in recent months.
After receiving harsh criticism for holding its first indoor rally since June in the Las Vegas suburb of Henderson, the campaign responded by saying, "If you can join tens of thousands of people protesting in the streets...or burn down small businesses in riots, you can gather peacefully under the 1st Amendment to hear from the president of the United States."
The campaign was essentially arguing in the middle of the coronavirus pandemic that "it's only fair that the president be allowed to kill some of his supporters by exposing them to superspreader events," tweeted Dr. Jonathan Reiner, a professor at GWU and a CNN analyst.
\u201cApparently Trump\u2019s campaign believes that since there were riots this summer it\u2019s only fair that the president be allowed to kill some of his supporters by exposing them to superspreader events.\u201d— Jonathan Reiner (@Jonathan Reiner) 1600034068
According to public health experts, the outdoor racial justice protests that have taken place across the country have not been linked to spikes in coronavirus transmission, likely because of high levels of compliance with mask-wearing guidelines. At the March on Washington anniversary rally in August, marchers were not permitted to attend without a face mask.
Reiner appeared on CNN Monday morning to accuse the president of "negligent homicide" at Sunday's rally, where a majority of attendees appeared to not wear face masks.
"That's what you'd call the actions of somebody who through their negligence causes the death of other people," Reiner said. "We're in a pandemic and Clark County, Nevada has a lot of virus. So with thousands of people, there's complete certainty that there are people in that crowd, probably asymptomatic carriers of the virus, who will spread the virus."
\u201cDr. @JReinerMD on Nevada rally: \u201cI would respectfully suggest to @realDonaldTrump that if he thinks it's safe to gather thousands of people in a pandemic without masks, then he should go down to the rope line and vigorously shake some hands.\u201d\u201d— Alisyn Camerota (@Alisyn Camerota) 1600082369
Clark County has one of Nevada's highest seven-day averages for coronavirus infections, with 62 out of every 100,000 people infected.
"If you were trying to somehow increase the amount of virus in the community, what you would do is gather thousands of people shoulder to shoulder without masks and have them scream and yell and laugh for a few hours," Reiner said of Trump's Nevada rally.
Trump's last indoor campaign rally in Tulsa, Oklahoma, was linked to a significant surge in Covid-19 cases, according to Tulsa City-County Health Department Director Dr. Bruce Dart.
"We're in a pandemic and Clark County, Nevada has a lot of virus. So with thousands of people, there's complete certainty that there are people in that crowd, probably asymptomatic carriers of the virus, who will spread the virus."
--Dr. Jonathan Reiner, GWU
Campaign staff at the Sunday rally in Nevada checked attendees' temperatures and provided access to hand sanitizer, but mask-wearing was not required--in defiance of Democratic Gov. Steve Sisolak's orders.
Sisolak has mandated that people cannot gather in groups larger than 50 and must observe public health officials' mask-wearing and social distancing guidelines.
The governor accused the president of being "reckless" and "selfish" by holding the event.
"Early on in this crisis, when it came time to exhibit real leadership and make difficult decisions to protect the American people, he failed to develop a unified national response strategy," Sisolak tweeted. "To put it bluntly: he didn't have the guts to make tough choices--he left that to governors and the states. Now he's decided he doesn't have to respect our state's laws. As usual, he doesn't believe the rules apply to him."
\u201cThis is an insult to every Nevadan who has followed the directives, made sacrifices, and put their neighbors before themselves. It\u2019s also a direct threat to all of the recent progress we\u2019ve made, and could potentially set us back.\u201d— Governor Sisolak (@Governor Sisolak) 1600048543
\u201cAs Governor, I have worked with public health and infectious disease specialists to create emergency directives to protect public health and get our economy back on track.\u201d— Governor Sisolak (@Governor Sisolak) 1600048543
\u201cThat means limiting gathering sizes, mandating face coverings and practicing social distancing. All of which the President recklessly disregarded for his own gain this weekend in Nevada.\u201d— Governor Sisolak (@Governor Sisolak) 1600048543
Last week, one epidemiologist raised similar alarm over the president's rally in Freeland, Michigan, where many attendees in a crowd of 5,000 were seen without face coverings.
"This is the crap that makes grown epidemiologists cry," said Dr. Eric Feigl-Ding, a fellow at the Federation of American Scientists.
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.