In response to reports on Thursday that the Democratic leadership is taking steps to revive a defunct climate change panel, progressive groups and youth climate leaders warned that the move is an attempt by House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) and others to kill the surging demand for a Green New Deal Select Committee and called it a failure to fight for "solutions on the scale we need" to achieve "a livable future."
"Achieving the goals outlined in the resolution for a Select Committee on a Green New Deal are the bare minimum—anything less from our political leaders is a betrayal of young people around the world."
"Without a mandate to create a plan and a requirement that its members don't take fossil fuel money, we are deeply concerned that this committee will be just another of the many committees we've seen failing our generation our entire lives," Sunrise Movement co-founder Varshini Prakash declared after news broke that the Democratic leadership chose Rep. Kathy Castor (D-Fla.) to lead the revived climate committee.
As the Huffington Post reported, Green New Deal proponents were blindsided by the Democratic leadership's appointment of Castor, and it is unclear whether Rep.-elect Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.)—who led the push for a Green New Deal Select Committee—will even get a seat on the climate panel.
The Sunrise Movement said it has reached out to House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi's (D-Calif.) office for an explanation and vowed to keep fighting for a Green New Deal as if the planet depends on it—because it does.
"Achieving the goals outlined in the resolution for a Select Committee on a Green New Deal are the bare minimum we need to preserve life as we know it for our generation—anything less from our political leaders is a betrayal of young people around the world," the Sunrise Movement declared.
"Failing to advocate for the solutions on the scale we need to give our generation a livable future shows a deep lack of moral clarity and courage from our Democratic leadership," the group concluded on Twitter.
It’s obvious that there’s growing support for the #GreenNewDeal all across America. With tens of thousands urging Representatives to endorse the #GreenNewDeal and 81% of voters supporting it, Dem leaders must work to get us there if they want to be taken seriously by young people
— Sunrise Movement (@sunrisemvmt) December 21, 2018
In an interview with E&E News—which first reported that the Democratic leadership chose Castor to head the revived panel—the Florida congresswoman quickly got off to an inauspicious start.
"There's a big part of the Democratic Party that's basically indifferent about the end of human civilization but paying it some lip service. Every single one of them should face a primary challenger."
—Kate Aronoff, The Intercept
Echoing a talking point deployed by the likes of the Koch brothers and ExxonMobil, Castor suggested that it would be a violation of free speech to bar members who have accepted fossil fuel donations from serving on the climate committee.
"I don't think you can do that under the First Amendment, really," Castor said.
Though she later conceded in an interview with the Huffington Post that her comment was "inartful," the remark sparked fury from progressives, who viewed it as another sign that much of the Democratic Party and its leadership is woefully unprepared to take the ambitious steps science says are necessary to confront the climate crisis.
There's a big part of the Democratic Party that's basically indifferent about the end of human civilization but paying it some lip service. Every single one of them should face a primary challenger. https://t.co/6OIg8ywp4W
— Kate Aronoff (@KateAronoff) December 21, 2018
Pelosi to planet/people on it: Drop Dead https://t.co/nV6td6gD5P
— Ryan Grim (@ryangrim) December 20, 2018
"Loading a climate committee with fossil fuel money is akin to letting foxes in the henhouse," Ocasio-Cortez wrote on Twitter. "We shouldn't be afraid to lead."
We don’t have time to sit on our hands as our planet burns.
For young people, climate change is bigger than election or re-election. It’s life or death.
Loading a climate committee w/ fossil fuel is akin to letting foxes in the henhouse.
We shouldn’t be afraid to lead. https://t.co/JhqV2s2EVB
— Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (@Ocasio2018) December 20, 2018
"I honestly thought the Democratic Party leaders would see this opportunity," Waleed Shahid, communications director for Justice Democrats, added in a statement. "It's infuriating to see a fellow Democrat basically parrot the talking points of the Koch Brothers when it comes to the very common-sense idea that any politician who accepts donations from the fossil-fuel corporations should not be allowed to legislate on climate change."
Youth climate leaders in recent months have been urgently organizing, mobilizing, and getting arrested in droves to demand a bold and comprehensive action plan to save the planet, but critics said the Democratic leadership's move to revive an old climate panel is effectively a signal to the burgeoning grassroots movement to "buzz off."
Though the specific scope and mandate of the revived climate committee are not yet known, Castor told E&E News that while proponents of a Green New Deal "have some terrific ideas," the ambitious proposal supported by 81 percent of Americans will not be the "sole focus" of the panel.
Justice Democrats responded with alarm to Castor's comment, writing on Twitter, "Your sole focus won't be to propose solutions that match the urgency and scale recommended by the U.N.'s IPCC climate report?"
As Common Dreams reported, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) warned that carbon emissions must be cut in half by 2030 to avoid planetary catastrophe.
"I think they have some terrific ideas," Castor said of the Green New Deal advocates. "But that's not going to be our sole focus."
Your sole focus won’t be to propose solutions that match the urgency and scale recommended by the UN’s IPCC climate report?https://t.co/4FqHi5dD7j
— Justice Democrats (@justicedems) December 20, 2018
Though the Democratic leadership's move to revive a House climate change committee that was shut down by Republicans in 2011 was viewed as a significant blow to the momentum for a Green New Deal, the Huffington Post's Alexander Kaufman pointed out that the grassroots movement succeeded in making a previously fringe proposal mainstream in a remarkably short period of time.
Even in defeat, @Ocasio2018's Green New Deal push won.
The climate debate shifted.
40+ Democrats back policy that could *actually* end the oil age.
GND is now a 2020 issue.
81% of voters support it, including 57% of conservative Republicans. https://t.co/EO5LKM3fPi
— Alexander Kaufman (@AlexCKaufman) December 21, 2018
"The push forced a sea change in climate politics," Kaufman concluded, "pushing the policy debate from stagnant, wonky, and dubious solutions centered on market tweaks to sweeping, dramatic policies that scientists say could actually make a dent in surging greenhouse gas emissions."