The Battle for Healthcare Begins

"If there is no public insurance option...then this is not reform at all."

That's what Governor Howard Dean said last night in a conference call with thousands of activists -- and he's absolutely right.

As Dr. Dean noted, the battle for real reform begins Tuesday morning, when Senator Max Baucus chairs a Senate Finance Committee hearing that will look into the public plan option. Activists are writing messages on why such a plan is critical and Senator John Kerry will read some of them into the record at the hearing.

The conference call -- organized by MoveOn and Democracy For America--
began with a story similar to that of too many citizens across the
nation. MoveOn member Lisa Hall said she was in a car accident -- hit
by a drunk driver -- and was laid off in the aftermath when she
couldn't work. She lost her insurance, COBRA ran out, and the bills
mounted as no insurance company would cover her due to pre-existing
"Ultimately," Small said, "[I went into] bankruptcy, like so many
others.... The healthcare in this country has to be accessible to
everyone. Not just the healthy people or the rich. We're just working
folks, trying to keep our jobs and what we've earned."

Dean said the outcome of this fight will be determined by activists.
We know what's coming -- charges of "socialized medicine", "you won't
be able to choose your doctor", "a bureaucrat in Washington will make
your healthcare decisions," etc. It will be up to the people to write
letters to the editor, call your congressman, talk to neighbors. Myths
will need to be debunked, front groups exposed,
and money trails followed. Already, special interest groups are making
robocalls and devoting millions of dollars to an anti-choice campaign.

"What we want to do is give people a choice," Dean said. "And stop
saying you've got to be in the private insurance market or have no
insurance whatsoever if you're under 65." (People over 65 are already
in a single-payer system -- Medicare.)

As Dean pointed out, the facts are on our side in this battle. For
starters, the proposal of a public plan option allows people to keep
their private insurance if they want to and even subsidizes it. It's
also cheaper than private insurance since a greater percentage of
premiums goes towards healthcare instead of CEO salaries, shareholder
dividends, swank offices, etc. (In Vermont, Governor Dean was able to
cut administrative costs by 1/3 when the state ran Medicaid instead of
a private company.)

But in Washington -- facts be damned -- real reform
that benefits ordinary citizens doesn't come without a tough fight.
"We're going to have an all out fight about this... and we're not going
to go down again," Dean said. "If members of Congress know how strongly
people feel about this they're going to think twice about voting
against it."

Dean said that Senator Baucus is the legislator who most needs
convincing since his committee is one of the two in the Senate that
will deal with the bill -- and he especially needs to hear from people
from his home state.

"He is nominally in favor of [the public option] but has also said
that he might trade it away," Dean said. "I don't think it's necessary
to trade it away -- we have a Democratic President, a Democratic
Senate, and a Democratic House, there's no reason to trade it away.... I
think we're going to get a good bill out of the House, the problem is
in the Senate."

Indeed, the Senate is a place that resists change and all too often kills needed reform. This time around, we can't let that happen. Tell your representatives
now that it's time to give people the option of a public plan.

Join Us: News for people demanding a better world

Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place.

We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference.

Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. Join with us today!

© 2023 The Nation