Campaigning to Restore the Constitution

Two hundred and twenty-one years ago this week, the Constitutional
Convention that had gathered in the touchstone city of Philadelphia to
replace the Articles of Confederation with a more clearly drawn guiding
document for their revolutionary experiment agreed finally on a
framework to govern the new United States.

In so doing, Benjamin Franklin suggested, the framers established a
republican framework sturdy enough to outlast them - if, Franklin
warned, ensuing generations of Americans could keep faith with the

The document that was ratified September 17, 1787, though amended and interpreted, remains as Franklin knew it.

But the republic has not been well kept.

The United States of 2008 is stuck in the foreign entanglements
created when two wars were initiated without being declared by Congress
as required in Article 1 of the Constitution.

Warrantless wiretapping and data mining projects developed and
implemented by the current administration in violation of laws
explicitly designed to prevent abuses make a mockery of privacy
protections outlined in the 4th amendment.

Torture and extraordinary rendition, as practiced in U.S. operated
detention centers and carried out by U.S. authorities, in an aggressive
affront the 8th amendment bar on cruel and unusual punishment of those
in the country's custody.

Presidential signing statements and the refusal of current and
former White House aides to cooperate with congressional inquiries,
have created a dramatic imbalance between a super-powerful executive
branch and a disempowered legislative branch. This undermining of the
system of checks and balances that has been at the heart of the
constitutional project upsets the rule of law and creates a monarchical
circumstance similar to that against which the colonials revolted.

Yet, responses to the crisis have been tepid to the point of being
dysfunctional. The power to impeach has been taken off the table by
congressional leaders, and the mild option of censure has been
disregarded not for lack of necessity but for lack of political will.

So it is that America will on Wednesday mark a Constitution Day that cannot be a moment of celebration.

Rather, this Constitution Day requires of believers in the American
enterprise a renewed commitment to the ideals - and the radical spirit
- of the founders and essential document of the republic.

To that end, Wisconsin Senator Russ Feingold -- who with his lonely
vote against the Patriot act in 2001 and his consistent battles against
executive excess since then has established himself as the most
diligent defender of the Constitution in the current Congress -- will
be as busy this week as were James Madison, George Mason, Ben Franklin
and their fellow framers 221 years ago.

Feingold, who pondered seeking the Democratic nomination for the
presidency this year but instead decided to focus on his duties as
chairman of the Constitution Subcommittee of the Senate Judiciary
Committee, has taken it upon himself to use the run-up to this year's
Constitution Day to highlight the need to restore the rule of law to
the United States.

Feingold's constitutional renewal project has seen the senator
working with a bipartisan cross-section of concerned leaders and
activists that includes former U.S. Senator Lincoln Chaffee, R-Rhode
Island, and Common Cause President Bob Edgar - whose group has launched
a "Recapture the Flag" campaign "to restore public faith in the core
values of American democracy - freedom from tyranny, respect for
individual liberty and human rights, and government based on the rule
of law" -- to highlight "what the next president must do to fully
restore the rule of law after seven years of unprecedented Executive
Branch power grabs."

Kicked off with a national conference call featuring Edgar, Chafee and
Feingold, the Wisconsin senator was set Monday to deliver a major
address at Georgetown University, in which he intended to challenge
"the lofty and misdirected rhetoric of the Bush administration's
'Freedom Agenda'" and suggest that "(America's) true self-interest
(lies) in supporting democracy and the rule of law as essential to
fairness and stability globally."

On Tuesday, Feingold will chair a Constitution Subcommittee hearing
on "Restoring the Rule of Law." Legal scholars, historians and
advocates will testify as part of what Feingold's office describes as
"an effort to provide the next president with a full range of
recommendations for reestablishing appropriate checks and balances in a
variety of areas, including warrantless wiretapping, interrogation
standards, detention policy, abuse of executive privilege, excessive
government secrecy, violations of privacy and misleading Congress."
The point of this intensive activity by Feingold and his allies is to
get the media, the presidential candidates and Congress focused on the
work of reestablishing the rule of law.

To that end, a broad coalition of organizations from across the
ideological spectrum - ranging from the National Lawyers Guild and the
Center for Constitutional Rights to the Republican Liberty Caucus and
the American Conservative Defense Alliance, as well as Human Rights
Watch, Common Cause and the American Booksellers Foundation for Free
Expression -- has been urging the presidential candidates and the media
to dedicate Constitution Day (Wednesday) to discussing constitutional

In particular, the groups want Republican John McCain and Democrat
Barack Obama to explain what they think it means when they swear an
oath "to protect and defend the Constitution of the United States.

Noting that Obama and McCain had devoted September 11 to honoring
the victims of attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon, and
to expressing their commitment to promoting national service, the
American Freedom Campaign's Steve Fox says, "We hope that (the
Democratic and Republican nominees), along with other presidential
candidates, will see September 17 as a similar opportunity to join
together for an important anniversary. The Constitution is the
foundation of our nation and deserves a day a day of its own on the
campaign trail."

In particular, Fox and other organizers of the Constitution Day push are asking the candidates to address issues related to:

* Separation of powers and checks and balances

* Congressional oversight and executive branch accountability
(including the executive branch's responsibility to comply with
congressional subpoenas)

* The appropriate use of signing statements

* Torture and habeas corpus

* Electronic surveillance and Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA)

* Freedom of speech as it applies to potential whistleblowers in the next administration)

Noting that "presidents exercise a great deal of discretion and
flexibility in interpreting the Constitution and that abuse of
constitutional rights and safeguards can have significant harmful
effects on the American people's lives," the more than three dozen
groups that have endorsed the Constitution Day initiative have embraced
the argument that "it is therefore essential... to understand where
candidates stand on constitutional rights and separation of powers
prior to their election."

These are, as the founders would have said, self evident truths.

Unfortunately, with the exception of the rare Russ Feingold,
contemporary politicians tend to shy away from discussions about
constitutional duties and precise interpretations of what the executive
branch can and cannot do. If we are frank, we will acknowledge the ugly
reality that the men who would be president keep the discussion vague
because they want to maintain a flexibility to disregard the
Constitution at will, as President Bush and his predecessors have so
frequently done.

That is why it is so vital to raise constitutional questions now, when
the men who would be president are supposed to telling us how they will
govern -- and whether they will join the noble work of keeping the republic Ben Franklin and his comrades bequeathed to us.

Join Us: News for people demanding a better world

Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place.

We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference.

Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. Join with us today!

© 2023 The Nation