Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

Chicago Teachers Union members and supporters join a car caravan outside Chicago Public Schools headquarters on July 22, 2020. (Photo: Max Herman/NurPhoto via Getty Images)

Public Health Experts Denounce New CDC Document Pushing School Reopenings as 'Politically Driven' and 'Irresponsible'

"With outbreaks raging in the U.S., this can spell disaster."

Jake Johnson

Public health experts are warning that a new Centers for Disease Control and Prevention document strongly touting the benefits of reopening schools in the fall while downplaying the risks paints a politically motivated and misleading picture of the science that could put students, educators, and entire communities in danger of contracting Covid-19 as infections surge nationwide.

The document, titled "The Importance of Reopening America's Schools This Fall," was posted on the CDC's website Thursday as part of a broader set of resources and tools designed to help school administrators, teachers, parents, and others safely navigate the process of resuming in-person instruction.

Experts said much of the new material released by the CDC's is reasonable and helpful, discussing the importance of in-person learning for child development while also detailing the serious risks involved in reopening schools amid a global pandemic. (The full package of resources released by CDC Thursday can be viewed here.)

"CDC: you do not need to convince Americans about the importance of in-person schooling. We get it. We need you to guide us on the science and how we can safely reopen. Guidelines should be based on public health—not political considerations."
—Dr. Leana Wen, George Washington University

But the document openly advocating school reopenings drew condemnation from experts who characterized it as clearly driven by a political agenda rather than science and concern for the health of students, school faculty, and the broader public.

"This just seems irresponsible," tweeted Michael Mina, an epidemiologist and immunologist at the Harvard School of Public Health. "With outbreaks raging in the U.S., this can spell disaster."

The CDC document heavily emphasizes the significance of in-person instruction for children, particularly those "with heightened behavioral needs"—a point that neither public health experts nor educators dispute. What alarmed experts was the document's failure to discuss in detail the possible health impact reopenings could have on school faculty members and communities.

"There is almost no epidemiology in this," tweeted Caitlin Rivers, an epidemiologist at Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security. "There are only two paragraphs on the science, and one of those is mostly devoted to flu."

"There is no mention of the risk of severe disease for teachers and staff, who are also part of the school community," Rivers added. "There is only passing, vague mention of mitigation measures to reduce the risk of transmission. Same for community prevalence."

The document focuses largely on the potential health risks that Covid-19 poses to children, a topic of ongoing debate among scientists and medical professionals. "The best available evidence indicates if children become infected, they are far less likely to suffer severe symptoms," the document states. "Children appear to be at lower risk for contracting Covid-19 compared to adults."

Mina noted that even if it is true that children are at lower risk from Covid-19, that "does not translate into low risk of causing outbreaks and infecting adults and at-risk populations."

Dr. Leana Wen, visiting professor at George Washington University, tweeted that the CDC does "not need to convince Americans about the importance of in-person schooling."

"We get it," Wen wrote. "We need you to guide us on the science and how we can safely reopen. Guidelines should be based on public health—not political considerations."

The CDC's new resources come just over two weeks after President Donald Trump complained on Twitter that the agency's guidelines for reopening schools are too "tough" and "expensive." Trump and Education Secretary Betsy DeVos are aggressively pressuring schools to resume in-person classes in the fall and threatening to withhold federal funding from schools that remain closed due to Covid-19 fears.

Following the president's tweet, CDC Director Robert Redfield said his agency would release additional materials to assist schools with reopening but would not alter its existing guidelines, which recommend that students wear face coverings and remain six feet apart, among other precautions.

Julia Marcus, an infectious disease epidemiologist at Harvard Medical School, criticized the document pushing school reopenings as "likely politically driven" and highlighted the some of the more useful information posted by the CDC on Thursday:

"It sure would be easier if the CDC could speak directly to the public instead of just quietly posting things on their labyrinth of a website," Marcus tweeted.

Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.

This is the world we live in. This is the world we cover.

Because of people like you, another world is possible. There are many battles to be won, but we will battle them together—all of us. Common Dreams is not your normal news site. We don't survive on clicks. We don't want advertising dollars. We want the world to be a better place. But we can't do it alone. It doesn't work that way. We need you. If you can help today—because every gift of every size matters—please do. Without Your Support We Simply Don't Exist.

Please select a donation method:

With Election Days Away, Bernie Sanders Headlines Get-Out-the-Vote Rally for Nina Turner

In his keynote speech, Sanders said corporate interests are pulling out all the stops to defeat Turner because "they know that when she is elected, she is going to stand up and take them on in the fight for justice."

Jake Johnson ·

Bush, Pressley, and Omar Sleep Outside Capitol to Demand Extension of Eviction Moratorium

Rep. Cori Bush, who was formerly unhoused, slammed her Democratic colleagues who "chose to go on vacation early today rather than staying to vote to keep people in their homes."

Jake Johnson ·

As Progressives Call for End to Blockade, Biden Announces More Sanctions Against Cuba

The move comes after Democratic leadership in the House blocked an amendment to roll back limits on how much money people in the United States can send to family on the island nation.

Jessica Corbett ·

Progressives Issue Dire Warning as House Bill to Extend Eviction Moratorium Dies

"If Congress does not act now, the fallout of the eviction crisis will undoubtedly set us backwards as the Covid-19 pandemic continues to ravish our communities, needlessly contributing to more death and destruction."

Brett Wilkins ·

Citing Donziger Case, Dems Raise Alarm About Use of Private Prosecutors in Federal Court

Private prosecutions of criminal contempt charges, said a pair of senators, "are highly unusual and can raise concerning questions of fundamental fairness in our criminal justice system."

Jessica Corbett ·