U.S. Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-MN) (3rd L) listens during a news conference at the U.S. Capitol January 4, 2019 in Washington, DC. (Photo: Alex Wong/Getty Images)
Nov 18, 2019
After a man accused of threatening her life pled guilty to the crime in a U.S. District Court, Rep. Ilhan Omar on Tuesday released publicly a letter she wrote asking the federal judge presiding over the case to "show compassion" in his sentencing.
Patrick W. Carlineo Jr., a 55-year-old man from upstate New York, pled guilty on Monday on gun charges and for threatening to murder Omar in phone calls he made to her congressional office in March of this year. But in her letter to Judge Frank P. Geraci Jr., Omar said that while the charges were quite serious she did not think that an overly punitive sentence was the answer.
"The answer to hate is not more hate; it is compassion," Omar wrote.
"Who are we as a nation," her letter asks, "if we respond to threats of political retribution with retribution ourselves?"
The Minnesota Democrat posted the letter in its entirety on social media:
\u201cSharing my full letter on the the sentencing of Patrick W. Carlineo, a man convicted of threatening my life. \n\nWe must apply a system of compassion to criminal justice. \n\nWho are we as a nation if we respond to threats of political retribution with retribution ourselves?\u201d— Ilhan Omar (@Ilhan Omar) 1574191027
The formal complaint against Carlineo Jr. charged that he cited Omar being a Muslim before calling her a "terrorist" and threatening to "put a bullet in her [expletive] skull" when he called her office.
In her letter, Omar argues that punishing Carlineo "with a lengthy prison sentence or a burdensome financial fine would not rehabilitate him" or repair the harm he caused. Likely, Omar said, such a sentence "would only increase his anger and resentment."
Omar has been a vocal critic of mass incarceration during her first term in Congress, calling the system which locks up more than two million people "a scourge on this country."
In her letter, Omar said the U.S. must address the "systemic alienation" that victimizes people who often go on to commit acts of violence "through community reintegration and social services."
Carlineo's crime, Omar pointed out, is just a single example of the hate speech and political violence which "are an increasing feature in our public sphere."
"We will not defeat it with anger and exclusion," Omar wrote. "We will defeat it with compassion."
The congresswoman's letter garnered applause from progressives and critics of the U.S. prison system including Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.).
\u201cI agree with Representative Ilhan Omar: The answer to hate is not more hate; it is compassion. https://t.co/zHwTHAusVt\u201d— Bernie Sanders (@Bernie Sanders) 1574191973
"I'm amazed at this letter from Ilhan Omar, asking for mercy for the man who was just convicted of threatening to assassinate her," tweetedSlate writer and podcast host Aymann Ismail.
Join Us: News for people demanding a better world
Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place. We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference. Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. |
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
Jon Queally
Jon Queally is managing editor of Common Dreams.
Julia Conley
Julia Conley is a staff writer for Common Dreams.
After a man accused of threatening her life pled guilty to the crime in a U.S. District Court, Rep. Ilhan Omar on Tuesday released publicly a letter she wrote asking the federal judge presiding over the case to "show compassion" in his sentencing.
Patrick W. Carlineo Jr., a 55-year-old man from upstate New York, pled guilty on Monday on gun charges and for threatening to murder Omar in phone calls he made to her congressional office in March of this year. But in her letter to Judge Frank P. Geraci Jr., Omar said that while the charges were quite serious she did not think that an overly punitive sentence was the answer.
"The answer to hate is not more hate; it is compassion," Omar wrote.
"Who are we as a nation," her letter asks, "if we respond to threats of political retribution with retribution ourselves?"
The Minnesota Democrat posted the letter in its entirety on social media:
\u201cSharing my full letter on the the sentencing of Patrick W. Carlineo, a man convicted of threatening my life. \n\nWe must apply a system of compassion to criminal justice. \n\nWho are we as a nation if we respond to threats of political retribution with retribution ourselves?\u201d— Ilhan Omar (@Ilhan Omar) 1574191027
The formal complaint against Carlineo Jr. charged that he cited Omar being a Muslim before calling her a "terrorist" and threatening to "put a bullet in her [expletive] skull" when he called her office.
In her letter, Omar argues that punishing Carlineo "with a lengthy prison sentence or a burdensome financial fine would not rehabilitate him" or repair the harm he caused. Likely, Omar said, such a sentence "would only increase his anger and resentment."
Omar has been a vocal critic of mass incarceration during her first term in Congress, calling the system which locks up more than two million people "a scourge on this country."
In her letter, Omar said the U.S. must address the "systemic alienation" that victimizes people who often go on to commit acts of violence "through community reintegration and social services."
Carlineo's crime, Omar pointed out, is just a single example of the hate speech and political violence which "are an increasing feature in our public sphere."
"We will not defeat it with anger and exclusion," Omar wrote. "We will defeat it with compassion."
The congresswoman's letter garnered applause from progressives and critics of the U.S. prison system including Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.).
\u201cI agree with Representative Ilhan Omar: The answer to hate is not more hate; it is compassion. https://t.co/zHwTHAusVt\u201d— Bernie Sanders (@Bernie Sanders) 1574191973
"I'm amazed at this letter from Ilhan Omar, asking for mercy for the man who was just convicted of threatening to assassinate her," tweetedSlate writer and podcast host Aymann Ismail.
Jon Queally
Jon Queally is managing editor of Common Dreams.
Julia Conley
Julia Conley is a staff writer for Common Dreams.
After a man accused of threatening her life pled guilty to the crime in a U.S. District Court, Rep. Ilhan Omar on Tuesday released publicly a letter she wrote asking the federal judge presiding over the case to "show compassion" in his sentencing.
Patrick W. Carlineo Jr., a 55-year-old man from upstate New York, pled guilty on Monday on gun charges and for threatening to murder Omar in phone calls he made to her congressional office in March of this year. But in her letter to Judge Frank P. Geraci Jr., Omar said that while the charges were quite serious she did not think that an overly punitive sentence was the answer.
"The answer to hate is not more hate; it is compassion," Omar wrote.
"Who are we as a nation," her letter asks, "if we respond to threats of political retribution with retribution ourselves?"
The Minnesota Democrat posted the letter in its entirety on social media:
\u201cSharing my full letter on the the sentencing of Patrick W. Carlineo, a man convicted of threatening my life. \n\nWe must apply a system of compassion to criminal justice. \n\nWho are we as a nation if we respond to threats of political retribution with retribution ourselves?\u201d— Ilhan Omar (@Ilhan Omar) 1574191027
The formal complaint against Carlineo Jr. charged that he cited Omar being a Muslim before calling her a "terrorist" and threatening to "put a bullet in her [expletive] skull" when he called her office.
In her letter, Omar argues that punishing Carlineo "with a lengthy prison sentence or a burdensome financial fine would not rehabilitate him" or repair the harm he caused. Likely, Omar said, such a sentence "would only increase his anger and resentment."
Omar has been a vocal critic of mass incarceration during her first term in Congress, calling the system which locks up more than two million people "a scourge on this country."
In her letter, Omar said the U.S. must address the "systemic alienation" that victimizes people who often go on to commit acts of violence "through community reintegration and social services."
Carlineo's crime, Omar pointed out, is just a single example of the hate speech and political violence which "are an increasing feature in our public sphere."
"We will not defeat it with anger and exclusion," Omar wrote. "We will defeat it with compassion."
The congresswoman's letter garnered applause from progressives and critics of the U.S. prison system including Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.).
\u201cI agree with Representative Ilhan Omar: The answer to hate is not more hate; it is compassion. https://t.co/zHwTHAusVt\u201d— Bernie Sanders (@Bernie Sanders) 1574191973
"I'm amazed at this letter from Ilhan Omar, asking for mercy for the man who was just convicted of threatening to assassinate her," tweetedSlate writer and podcast host Aymann Ismail.
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.