"Are you, Rep. Smucker, consciously a mercenary for billionaires who are working to undermine our democracy and weaken the middle class?" Jonathan Smucker wrote on Twitter after he was ejected from a constituent meeting. (Photo: Rep. Lloyd Smucker)
Feb 21, 2018
During an RSVP-only meeting on "tax reform" organized by the Koch brothers-backed group Americans for Prosperity Wednesday morning, activist and author Jonathan Smucker demanded to know how much Pennsylvania Rep. Lloyd Smucker (no relation) has received in campaign contributions from Charles and David Koch.
Jonathan was quickly ejected from the event--but he caught part of it on video.
"This is my representative, and I want to know how much the Koch brothers are getting in tax cuts and how much they're contributing to your campaign," Jonathan said. "It's a fair question. We have a right...to get answers from you. You've been avoiding us and meeting with these private groups. And we want to know how much money they're getting in benefits from this [tax] bill."
Watch:
\u201cI just got ejected from a Koch brothers meeting with @RepSmucker.\n\nAnswer the questions, Congressman: How much $$ are the Koch brothers getting from this tax bill? And how much $$ are you getting in campaign contributions from the Koch Brothers?\u201d— Jonathan Smucker (@Jonathan Smucker) 1519223118
Jonathan was referring to the $1.5 trillion tax bill President Donald Trump signed into law last December. According to an analysis by Americans for Tax Fairness published last month, the Koch brothers "could save between $1 billion and $1.4 billion combined in income taxes each year" thanks to the new law.
Rep. Smucker voted for the bill and enthusiastically celebrated its passage.
In a Twitter thread following the meeting--which was officially titled "Unrigging the Economy: A Conversation with Congressman Lloyd Smucker"--Jonathan listed the questions he would have asked Rep. Smucker if he had been allowed to stay.
"Are you, Rep. Smucker, consciously a mercenary for billionaires who are working to undermine our democracy and weaken the middle class?" Jonathan wrote. "Are you consciously a mercenary because that's what it takes to get the campaign contributions you think you need to stay in office?"
\u201cMr. Congressman, you're here meeting with an organization founded and funded by the Koch brothers, billionaires whose organization's mission is to gut our nation's revenue so that they can cut then argue that we have to cut popular programs like Social Security and Medicare\u2026\u201d— Jonathan Smucker (@Jonathan Smucker) 1519223118
\u201cThe Koch brothers are pouring hundreds of millions of dollars into our political system to buy off our elected office holders\u2014people like you, @RepSmucker. You are bought, Mr. Congressman. You make time for them and you avoid the rest of us, your constituents.\u201d— Jonathan Smucker (@Jonathan Smucker) 1519223118
\u201cOR do you actually believe this load of horsecrap? Do you really believe in the snake oil you're selling? Do you genuinely think that working families will magically get a leg up when you give even more money to billionaires?\u201d— Jonathan Smucker (@Jonathan Smucker) 1519223118
After the meeting ended, Rep. Smucker tweeted that he "participated in a vibrant discussion this morning in Lancaster on the impacts of tax reform."
He did not address Jonathan's questions.
Why Your Ongoing Support Is Essential
Donald Trump’s attacks on democracy, justice, and a free press are escalating — putting everything we stand for at risk. We believe a better world is possible, but we can’t get there without your support. Common Dreams stands apart. We answer only to you — our readers, activists, and changemakers — not to billionaires or corporations. Our independence allows us to cover the vital stories that others won’t, spotlighting movements for peace, equality, and human rights. Right now, our work faces unprecedented challenges. Misinformation is spreading, journalists are under attack, and financial pressures are mounting. As a reader-supported, nonprofit newsroom, your support is crucial to keep this journalism alive. Whatever you can give — $10, $25, or $100 — helps us stay strong and responsive when the world needs us most. Together, we’ll continue to build the independent, courageous journalism our movement relies on. Thank you for being part of this community. |
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
During an RSVP-only meeting on "tax reform" organized by the Koch brothers-backed group Americans for Prosperity Wednesday morning, activist and author Jonathan Smucker demanded to know how much Pennsylvania Rep. Lloyd Smucker (no relation) has received in campaign contributions from Charles and David Koch.
Jonathan was quickly ejected from the event--but he caught part of it on video.
"This is my representative, and I want to know how much the Koch brothers are getting in tax cuts and how much they're contributing to your campaign," Jonathan said. "It's a fair question. We have a right...to get answers from you. You've been avoiding us and meeting with these private groups. And we want to know how much money they're getting in benefits from this [tax] bill."
Watch:
\u201cI just got ejected from a Koch brothers meeting with @RepSmucker.\n\nAnswer the questions, Congressman: How much $$ are the Koch brothers getting from this tax bill? And how much $$ are you getting in campaign contributions from the Koch Brothers?\u201d— Jonathan Smucker (@Jonathan Smucker) 1519223118
Jonathan was referring to the $1.5 trillion tax bill President Donald Trump signed into law last December. According to an analysis by Americans for Tax Fairness published last month, the Koch brothers "could save between $1 billion and $1.4 billion combined in income taxes each year" thanks to the new law.
Rep. Smucker voted for the bill and enthusiastically celebrated its passage.
In a Twitter thread following the meeting--which was officially titled "Unrigging the Economy: A Conversation with Congressman Lloyd Smucker"--Jonathan listed the questions he would have asked Rep. Smucker if he had been allowed to stay.
"Are you, Rep. Smucker, consciously a mercenary for billionaires who are working to undermine our democracy and weaken the middle class?" Jonathan wrote. "Are you consciously a mercenary because that's what it takes to get the campaign contributions you think you need to stay in office?"
\u201cMr. Congressman, you're here meeting with an organization founded and funded by the Koch brothers, billionaires whose organization's mission is to gut our nation's revenue so that they can cut then argue that we have to cut popular programs like Social Security and Medicare\u2026\u201d— Jonathan Smucker (@Jonathan Smucker) 1519223118
\u201cThe Koch brothers are pouring hundreds of millions of dollars into our political system to buy off our elected office holders\u2014people like you, @RepSmucker. You are bought, Mr. Congressman. You make time for them and you avoid the rest of us, your constituents.\u201d— Jonathan Smucker (@Jonathan Smucker) 1519223118
\u201cOR do you actually believe this load of horsecrap? Do you really believe in the snake oil you're selling? Do you genuinely think that working families will magically get a leg up when you give even more money to billionaires?\u201d— Jonathan Smucker (@Jonathan Smucker) 1519223118
After the meeting ended, Rep. Smucker tweeted that he "participated in a vibrant discussion this morning in Lancaster on the impacts of tax reform."
He did not address Jonathan's questions.
During an RSVP-only meeting on "tax reform" organized by the Koch brothers-backed group Americans for Prosperity Wednesday morning, activist and author Jonathan Smucker demanded to know how much Pennsylvania Rep. Lloyd Smucker (no relation) has received in campaign contributions from Charles and David Koch.
Jonathan was quickly ejected from the event--but he caught part of it on video.
"This is my representative, and I want to know how much the Koch brothers are getting in tax cuts and how much they're contributing to your campaign," Jonathan said. "It's a fair question. We have a right...to get answers from you. You've been avoiding us and meeting with these private groups. And we want to know how much money they're getting in benefits from this [tax] bill."
Watch:
\u201cI just got ejected from a Koch brothers meeting with @RepSmucker.\n\nAnswer the questions, Congressman: How much $$ are the Koch brothers getting from this tax bill? And how much $$ are you getting in campaign contributions from the Koch Brothers?\u201d— Jonathan Smucker (@Jonathan Smucker) 1519223118
Jonathan was referring to the $1.5 trillion tax bill President Donald Trump signed into law last December. According to an analysis by Americans for Tax Fairness published last month, the Koch brothers "could save between $1 billion and $1.4 billion combined in income taxes each year" thanks to the new law.
Rep. Smucker voted for the bill and enthusiastically celebrated its passage.
In a Twitter thread following the meeting--which was officially titled "Unrigging the Economy: A Conversation with Congressman Lloyd Smucker"--Jonathan listed the questions he would have asked Rep. Smucker if he had been allowed to stay.
"Are you, Rep. Smucker, consciously a mercenary for billionaires who are working to undermine our democracy and weaken the middle class?" Jonathan wrote. "Are you consciously a mercenary because that's what it takes to get the campaign contributions you think you need to stay in office?"
\u201cMr. Congressman, you're here meeting with an organization founded and funded by the Koch brothers, billionaires whose organization's mission is to gut our nation's revenue so that they can cut then argue that we have to cut popular programs like Social Security and Medicare\u2026\u201d— Jonathan Smucker (@Jonathan Smucker) 1519223118
\u201cThe Koch brothers are pouring hundreds of millions of dollars into our political system to buy off our elected office holders\u2014people like you, @RepSmucker. You are bought, Mr. Congressman. You make time for them and you avoid the rest of us, your constituents.\u201d— Jonathan Smucker (@Jonathan Smucker) 1519223118
\u201cOR do you actually believe this load of horsecrap? Do you really believe in the snake oil you're selling? Do you genuinely think that working families will magically get a leg up when you give even more money to billionaires?\u201d— Jonathan Smucker (@Jonathan Smucker) 1519223118
After the meeting ended, Rep. Smucker tweeted that he "participated in a vibrant discussion this morning in Lancaster on the impacts of tax reform."
He did not address Jonathan's questions.
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.